Don't Waste Your Money is supported by our readers. When you purchase an item through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

The Best Crib Mattress Cover

Last updated on September 17, 2020

We looked at the top 7 Crib Mattress Covers and dug through the reviews from 20 of the most popular review sites including Smart Parent Advice, Mattress Advisor, Healthy Baby Happy Earth, Sleep Standards, Sleep Advisor, The Sleep Judge and more. The result is a ranking of the best Crib Mattress Covers.

Best Crib Mattress Cover

Why Trust The DWYM Score?

DWYM is focused on helping you make the best purchasing decision. Our team of experts spends hundreds of hours analyzing, testing, and researching products so you don't have to.Learn more.

Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in a category.

Our Picks For The Top Crib Mattress Covers

Show Contents
Our Take
Experts Included
Pros
Cons
  The Best Overall

COZYCUDDLES Waterproof Zippered Quilted Crib Mattress Cover

COZYCUDDLES

Waterproof Zippered Crib Mattress Cover

Overall Take

Zipper Provides Full CoverageThis mattress cover is unique in that it zips on, giving complete coverage while also keeping it easy to put on and take off.

Experts Included
DWYM Baby and Kids Experts plus Mattress Advisor, The Sleep Judge, Reasons To Skip The Housework, Mom Loves Best, Inner Parents. Along with user reviews from Amazon and Walmart.
Pros
" Absorbs spills, sweat, and any liquid. Fabric is soft on a baby’s skin."
Cons
"Zipper can’t be tucked in the encasement."
  The Best Value

Carter’s Waterproof Fitted Quilted Crib Mattress Cover

Carter's

Waterproof Fitted Quilted Crib Mattress Cover

Overall Take

Stays in PlaceThe design of this mattress cover is specifically for standard crib mattresses, offering a snug fit so it won't move around.

Experts Included
DWYM Baby and Kids Experts plus Good Housekeeping, Baby Know How. Along with user reviews from Amazon and Walmart.
Pros
" The quilted polyester top has a cushiony, comfortable feel with a waterproof vinyl pad to keep the crib mattress protected."

American Baby Company Waterproof Fitted Crib Mattress Cover

American Baby

Waterproof Fitted Crib Mattress Cover

Overall Take

Quiet BuildThis mattress cover is filled with soft materials that resist that "crackling" sound that happens with movement on some mattress covers.

Experts Included
DWYM Baby and Kids Experts plus The Spruce, Safe Baby Reviews, The Babble Out and 1 more. Along with user reviews from Amazon and Walmart.
Pros
" Won’t shift no matter how much your little one moves around in their sleep. The mattress pad can be washed and dried in the machine."
Cons
"Pills up after washing. May melt on high dryer setting."

YOOFOSS Waterproof Fitted Crib Mattress Cover

YOOFOSS

Waterproof Fitted Crib Mattress Cover

Overall Take

Strong, Reinforced ThreadsThe threads on this mattress cover are reinforced to prevent wear and shrinking even with regular washing and drying.

Experts Included
DWYM Baby and Kids Experts plus Baby Know How. Along with user reviews from Amazon.
Pros
" Durably constructed. Soft and breathable. Waterproof and absorbent."
Don't just take for granted what one reviewer says. Along with our own experts, DWYM analyzes the top expert reviews of the leading products and generates a score you can actually trust.
14

Products Considered

We identified the majority of the crib mattress covers available to purchase.
7

Products Analyzed

We then selected the leading and most popular products for our team to review.

View All Product Rankings

20

Expert Reviews Included

In addition to our expert reviews, we also incorporate feedback and analysis of some of the most respected sources including: Smart Parent Advice, Mattress Advisor, Healthy Baby Happy Earth, Sleep Standards, Sleep Advisor.

48,945

User Opinions Analyzed

We also incorporate user reviews from the leading retailers including Amazon, Walmart.

Our experts reviewed the top 7 Crib Mattress Covers and also dug through the reviews from 20 of the most popular review sites including Smart Parent Advice, Mattress Advisor, Healthy Baby Happy Earth, Sleep Standards, Sleep Advisor, The Sleep Judge and more. The result is a ranking of the best of the best Crib Mattress Covers.

DWYM is your trusted roduct review source. Our team reviews thousands of product reviews from the trusted top experts and combines them into one easy-to-understand score. Learn more.

Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in their category.

The Best Overall

COZYCUDDLES Waterproof Zippered Quilted Crib Mattress Cover

Our Expert Score
9.0
5 expert reviews
User Summarized Score
9.4
759 user reviews
Our Take

This waterproof crib protector is designed to capably absorb any liquid, including spills and sweat. It has a quilted cotton top to keep babies comfortable as they sleep while also reducing noise during movement. The zipper ensures it fully covers the entire mattress to offer complete protection against dust mites and other allergens.

What other experts liked
Absorbs spills, sweat, and any liquid. Fabric is soft on a baby’s skin.
- Mattress Advisor
The cover is quiet and won’t make any noise as your baby moves while sleeping. The quilted cotton top allows good airflow for maximum breathability.
- The Sleep Judge
Made from skin-friendly fabrics.
- Reasons To Skip The Housework
Affordable. Waterproof. The materials are hypoallergenic for sensitive babies, and free of BPA, lead, vinyl, and latex.
- Mom Loves Best
Full Protection: this mattress pad zips closed over the entire crib mattress offering full protection from any type of accident that your baby may have.
- Inner Parents
What other experts didn't like
Can melt in a dryer – make sure and hang dry. The cover may be a tight fit.
- Mattress Advisor
Zipper can’t be tucked in the encasement.
- The Sleep Judge
Can only be air-dried.
- Reasons To Skip The Housework
Not dryer safe.
- Mom Loves Best
Drying: this mattress pad is not safe to put in the dryer. That means that you will need to consider air drying time when you are changing the mattress pad after an accident.
- Inner Parents

The Best Bang For Your Buck

Carter’s Waterproof Fitted Quilted Crib Mattress Cover

Our Expert Score
9.4
2 expert reviews
User Summarized Score
9.6
2,933 user reviews
Our Take

This mattress cover is built to fits a standard size crib mattress, 28" x 52", snugly. If fitted around the correct mattress size, it won't move around and will provide both comfort and protection to your baby during sleep. The cushiony quilted top will provide an extra layer of softness to ensure comfort throughout the night.

What other experts liked
The quilted polyester top has a cushiony, comfortable feel with a waterproof vinyl pad to keep the crib mattress protected.
- Good Housekeeping
Secure fit. It goes on easily and won’t move out of place. When you’re ready to take it off, it removes easily as well.
- Baby Know How

Overall Product Rankings

Our Crib Mattress Cover Findings

COZYCUDDLES Waterproof Zippered Quilted Crib Mattress Cover

What We Liked: This waterproof crib protector is designed to capably absorb any liquid, including spills and sweat. It has a quilted cotton top to keep babies comfortable as they sleep while also reducing noise during movement. The zipper ensures it fully covers the entire mattress to offer complete protection against dust mites and other allergens.

Carter’s Waterproof Fitted Quilted Crib Mattress Cover

What We Liked: This mattress cover is built to fits a standard size crib mattress, 28″ x 52″, snugly. If fitted around the correct mattress size, it won’t move around and will provide both comfort and protection to your baby during sleep. The cushiony quilted top will provide an extra layer of softness to ensure comfort throughout the night.

American Baby Company Waterproof Fitted Crib Mattress Cover

What We Liked: Both waterproof and comfortable, this mattress cover fits snugly over a standard crib mattress. A waterproof layer lies beneath a polyester top layer to provide waterproofing and comfort. Although it’s tight enough to remain snugly in place throughout the night, it’s not so tight that you’ll have a tough time removing it to wash it.

YOOFOSS Waterproof Fitted Crib Mattress Cover

What We Liked: The soft, breathable fabric of this mattress cover ensures that it protects the mattress while also keeping your little one comfortable. Strong, reinforced threads provide durability while also ensuring you can wash and dry it as you would any other bedding. It’s built to fit over a standard crib mattress, with deep pockets to comfortably protect mattresses up to 6 feet in depth.

PlushDeluxe Waterproof & Hypoallergenic Crib Mattress Cover

What We Liked: This mattress pad features a durable terrycloth-like fabric that is comfortable against your baby’s skin. It not only offers full coverage, but it’s also free of vinyl, BPA, phthalate, latex, lead, flame retardants and other chemicals that could irritate sensitive skin. The 9-inch deep skirt will cover even thicker crib mattresses.

Our Crib Mattress Cover Buying Guide

As you’re setting up your baby’s nursery, one of the biggest purchases you’ll make is a crib. From birth to at least the first year of your child’s life, hours will be spent on that mattress, so you’ll want it to be as safe and comfortable as possible.

One issue most parents will face with crib mattresses is moisture. Moisture can come from a variety of sources, including diaper leaks, saliva, sweat and tears. You’ll want to not only keep your baby dry throughout the night but also prevent the bacteria that can build up over time with excessive moisture.

A good mattress cover will collect that moisture while also providing a protective layer that keeps the baby above it dry. But mattress covers also help keep irritants like dust mites tucked safely inside. Over time, mattresses collect dead skin and hair, even when a baby is resting atop one, and the dust mites that result can serve as allergens to babies that are sensitive.

When looking for a crib mattress, though, safety and waterproofing aren’t the only factors to consider. You can still get those features without sacrificing comfort. Many feature quilted tops that provide an extra layer of cushioning between the baby and the mattress. This will combine comfort and safety to give both baby and parents a better night’s sleep.

DWYM Fun Fact

Mattresses are very absorbent in nature, which means they tend to soak up things throughout the night. This starts with the moisture that emits from you as you sleep. Humans produce as much as 26 gallons of sweat each year, and your body heat only exacerbates the issue, creating an ideal breeding ground for bacteria.

But perhaps the biggest reason for a mattress cover is the skin you shed each night. On any given day, you shed about 500 million skin cells, and since you spend a good chunk of those hours in bed, many of those cells end up in your mattress. This leads to dust mites, which can aggravate your allergies.

The Crib Mattress Cover Tips and Advice

  • Pay close attention to the size of your crib mattress. Standard size is 28” x 52” but depth also matters. Many mattress covers are built to fit over a mattress that’s 6 inches thick, but you can find some with deeper pockets that can handle a mattress of up to 9 inches in height.
  • As with your other bedding, you’ll need to regularly wash your mattress pad. Look for one that’s machine washable and can also be tumble dried.
  • A tight mattress pad will resist moving around as your baby moves, but some can be tough to remove and put on. Look for one that has at least a little wiggle room so that you don’t have a struggle making the bed.
  • Some mattress covers have a zipper that ensures every inch of the mattress is fully covered. This also makes it easier to get on and off.
  • The waterproofing feature inside some mattress covers can cause it to rustle as the baby moves. That rustling can wake infants up as they sleep. Many mattress pads are labeled as “quiet” for that reason.
  • You may want to keep an extra set of sheets, along with a spare mattress cover, in case your baby has an accident during the night and you need to make a quick change.

About The Author

Avatar
Stephanie Faris 

Stephanie Faris is a novelist and professional writer. She's also a wife and stepmom who lives in the Nashville, Tennessee, area. Her work has appeared on popular parenting sites. She also writes books for young children, including the Piper Morgan series of chapter books published by Simon & Schuster's Aladdin imprint.