SureGuard Waterproof & Hypoallergenic Fitted Crib Mattress Cover

Last updated date: March 25, 2021

DWYM Score


SureGuard Waterproof & Hypoallergenic Fitted Crib Mattress Cover

Why Trust DWYM?

DWYM is your trusted product review source. Along with our in-house experts, our team analyzes thousands of product reviews from the most trusted websites. We then create one easy-to-understand review. Learn more.

Don't Waste Your Money Seal of Approval
Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in the category.
Show Contents

We looked at the top Crib Mattress Covers and dug through the reviews from some of the most popular review sites. Through this analysis, we've determined the best Crib Mattress Cover you should buy.

Update as September 13, 2021:
Checkout The Best Crib Mattress Cover for a detailed review of all the top crib mattress covers.

Overall Take

Babies tend to be more sensitive to their environment, which is why this crib mattress cover is designed to stop dust mites, pet dander and mildew in their tracks. The cover not only stops leaks from reaching your baby's mattress, but it also whisks moisture away from baby's skin. The 100% cotton terry surface is even noise-free, so you don't have to worry about any "crinkle" sounds waking your baby up at night.

In our analysis of 20 expert reviews, the SureGuard Waterproof & Hypoallergenic Fitted Crib Mattress Cover placed 1st when we looked at the top 8 products in the category. For the full ranking, see below.

From The Manufacturer

Cotton. 100% Waterproof – Top protection against everyday liquids and stains; 10-year quality guarantee – Great baby registry gift for expecting moms. (NOTE: For six-sided protection, buy a SureGuard Mattress Encasement). Hypoallergenic – Blocks dust mites, allergens, bacteria, mildew and mold – For bed bug protection, buy together with a SureGuard Mattress Encasement. Soft & Noiseless – 100% cotton terry surface; Wicks away moisture; Retains the feel of your child’s mattress – Free from Vinyl, PVC, Phthalates, fire retardants and other toxic chemicals. Durable & Easy to Clean – Machine wash & dry – For frequent accidents, buy 2 or more – while one is washed, the other protects the mattress. Crib / Toddler / Baby bed (28 in x 52 in) – Fitted Sheet Style; Stretchable skirt fits any depth mattress up to 6 inches deep. Independently lab tested and GREENGUARD Gold certified.

Expert Reviews

Expert Summarized Score

6 expert reviews

User Summarized Score

7,108 user reviews

What experts liked

Hypoallergenic. It’s soft and doesn’t make a plastic crinkly sound like some other protectors.
- Smart Parent Advice
It is durable and easy to clean by machine washing and drying, and this product is Greenguard Gold Certified.
- Mattress Advisor
Deep, fitted corners that stay put and machine washability. 100% waterproof, yet it's breathable. The cotton terry cover gives softness without taking away from the support of the mattress.
- Healthy Baby Happy Earth
Made of cotton and are hypoallergenic. The cotton-top also provides a soft surface. 100% waterproof and will make it easier to clean.
- Sleep Standards
The cotton surface is thin and lightweight with an expandable skirt, designed to fit under any size or style of fitted sheet. It is machine washable and has been tested and certified to be free from harmful toxins.
- Sleep Advisor
Thanks to the elastic band, it’s really easy to take the cover and off the bed and throw it inside the washing machine for cleaning. Since it’s hypoallergenic, it can block unwanted contaminants such as bacteria, dust mites, bed bugs or several allergy triggers.
- The Sleep Judge

What experts didn't like

Not totally waterproof
- Smart Parent Advice
Do not put them in the dryer alone without towels or other sheets or the waterproof lining will deteriorate. Reviews show reports of leakage.
- Mattress Advisor
Cover tends to slide off memory foam mattresses.
- The Sleep Judge

An Overview On Crib Mattress Covers

As you’re setting up your baby’s nursery, one of the biggest purchases you’ll make is a crib. From birth to at least the first year of your child’s life, hours will be spent on that mattress, so you’ll want it to be as safe and comfortable as possible.

One issue most parents will face with crib mattresses is moisture. Moisture can come from a variety of sources, including diaper leaks, saliva, sweat and tears. You’ll want to not only keep your baby dry throughout the night but also prevent the bacteria that can build up over time with excessive moisture.

A good mattress cover will collect that moisture while also providing a protective layer that keeps the baby above it dry. But mattress covers also help keep irritants like dust mites tucked safely inside. Over time, mattresses collect dead skin and hair, even when a baby is resting atop one, and the dust mites that result can serve as allergens to babies that are sensitive.

When looking for a crib mattress, though, safety and waterproofing aren’t the only factors to consider. You can still get those features without sacrificing comfort. Many feature quilted tops that provide an extra layer of cushioning between the baby and the mattress. This will combine comfort and safety to give both baby and parents a better night’s sleep.

The Crib Mattress Cover Buying Guide

  • Pay close attention to the size of your crib mattress. Standard size is 28” x 52” but depth also matters. Many mattress covers are built to fit over a mattress that’s 6 inches thick, but you can find some with deeper pockets that can handle a mattress of up to 9 inches in height.
  • As with your other bedding, you’ll need to regularly wash your mattress pad. Look for one that’s machine washable and can also be tumble dried.
  • A tight mattress pad will resist moving around as your baby moves, but some can be tough to remove and put on. Look for one that has at least a little wiggle room so that you don’t have a struggle making the bed.
  • Some mattress covers have a zipper that ensures every inch of the mattress is fully covered. This also makes it easier to get on and off.
  • The waterproofing feature inside some mattress covers can cause it to rustle as the baby moves. That rustling can wake infants up as they sleep. Many mattress pads are labeled as “quiet” for that reason.
  • You may want to keep an extra set of sheets, along with a spare mattress cover, in case your baby has an accident during the night and you need to make a quick change.