Don't Waste Your Money is supported by our readers. When you purchase an item through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

The Best Pillow Inserts - 2021

Last updated on October 19, 2020
Best Pillow Inserts

Why Trust The DWYM Score?

DWYM is focused on helping you make the best purchasing decision. Our team of experts spends hundreds of hours analyzing, testing, and researching products so you don't have to.Learn more.

Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in a category.

Our Picks For The Top Pillow Inserts

Show Contents
Our Take
  Best Classic

EDOW Down Alternative Throw Pillow Inserts, 2-Pack

Don't Waste Your Money Seal of Approval

EDOW

Down Alternative Throw Pillow Inserts, 2-Pack

Overall Take

Square, White and FluffyChoose these inserts for your square pillows and enjoy a luxurious lounging experience.

  Best Capacity

Utopia Bedding Throw Pillow Inserts, 4-Pack

Utopia

Bedding Throw Pillow Inserts, 4-Pack

Overall Take

Bulk Pack for DecorIf you need to fill several pillow covers, this set of four is an ideal choice.

  Most Comfortable

HOMESJUN Cotton Down Alternative Pillow Inserts, 2-Pack

HOMESJUN

Cotton Down Alternative Pillow Inserts, 2-Pack

Overall Take

Soft and Down-AlternativeThese inserts are a snap to clean, since they can handle the rigors of your washer.

  Best for Couches

HIPPIH Zipped Rectangle Pillow Inserts, 2-Pack

HIPPIH

Zipped Rectangle Pillow Inserts, 2-Pack

Overall Take

Rectangular and ZipperedGive your back some relief with these inserts, which are longer than they are tall.

Avatar
Guide written by Danielle Smyth
Last updated on October 19, 2020

It is important to buy the right-sized pillow insert for your pillow sham, otherwise it will look either too full or not full enough. To determine the ideal insert size for you, use a measuring tape to measure the pillow sham from one side seam to the other. To make the pillow feel plumper and firmer, you can choose an insert that is one size larger than your pillow cover.

Some people prefer down filling, but pillows of this type may be too soft for others. The ideal ratio is 75% to 90% feathers and 10% to 25% down, which provides a good balance between softness and firmness. Those who are allergic to feathers or down have plenty of other choices, like polyester filling.

If your pillow sham has a zipper, be careful when stuffing the pillow insert inside. When too much pressure is used, the zipper could break, or the stitches could come out. Some pillow shams are made of delicate materials like silk, and once damaged, they cannot be easily repaired.

The Best Pillow Inserts

1
  Best Classic

EDOW Down Alternative Throw Pillow Inserts, 2-Pack

These two throw-pillow inserts are 18 by 18 inches, plump and comfortable. They are filled with upgraded microfiber polyester and offer medium support. They fit perfectly inside of Euro-style square pillow shams.

Features


Specifications

Brand
EDOW
Model
2
  Best Capacity

Utopia Bedding Throw Pillow Inserts, 4-Pack

Sold in sets of four, these white polyester inserts are 16 by 16 inches. They have a siliconized fiber filling and white polyester cotton covers. You can clean them with mild detergent; spot cleaning and hand washing only is recommended.

Features


Specifications

Brand
Utopia
Model
3
  Most Comfortable

HOMESJUN Cotton Down Alternative Pillow Inserts, 2-Pack

This set of two 20-by-20-inch square throw pillows is made with soft, 100% cotton covers. They are also filled with a down alternative made from 100% polyester. They are easy to care for; the cover can be removed and tossed in the washing machine.

Features


Specifications

Brand
HOMESJUN
Model
4
  Best for Couches

HIPPIH Zipped Rectangle Pillow Inserts, 2-Pack

Designed for durability, these pillow inserts will stay firm and full for years and have zip-up covers for your convenience. They are ideal for lumbar support, with a 12-by-20-inch size. Place them inside your duvet covers, and they will plump it up from corner to corner.

Features


Specifications

Brand
HIPPIH
Model
6
  Best for Allergies

DOWNCOOL Down & Feather Rectangle Throw Pillow Inserts, 2-Pack

Treat yourself to a pair of these elegant pillow inserts that are filled with 95% duck down. Their 100% cotton covers also have special stitching, so you needn’t worry about feathers escaping. They measure 12 by 20 inches and work with both bed pillow shams and any other rectangular shams of this size.

Features


Specifications

Brand
DOWNCOOL
Model

Our Pillow Insert Buying Guide

It is important to buy the right-sized pillow insert for your pillow sham, otherwise it will look either too full or not full enough. To determine the ideal insert size for you, use a measuring tape to measure the pillow sham from one side seam to the other. To make the pillow feel plumper and firmer, you can choose an insert that is one size larger than your pillow cover.

Some people prefer down filling, but pillows of this type may be too soft for others. The ideal ratio is 75% to 90% feathers and 10% to 25% down, which provides a good balance between softness and firmness. Those who are allergic to feathers or down have plenty of other choices, like polyester filling.

If your pillow sham has a zipper, be careful when stuffing the pillow insert inside. When too much pressure is used, the zipper could break, or the stitches could come out. Some pillow shams are made of delicate materials like silk, and once damaged, they cannot be easily repaired.

DWYM Fun Fact

Saggy pillows are a no-no! Some decorators suggest making your pillows as full as possible, even to the extent that you order inserts up to 2 inches larger. This could make it harder to get a pillow into the sham, though, especially if it has a zipper. Always take your time when placing an insert into a sham.

The Pillow Insert Tips and Advice

  • Here is an example of how to buy your insert one size up: if the pillow cover measures 11 inches by 11 inches, buy a 12-inch-by-12-inch pillow insert.
  • If your inserts arrive in a vacuum-packed container, they will need time to fluff up. Open the packages and let them sit out for a few days. You can also put them in the sun for one day to aid with the expansion process.
  • Once you put an insert into your sham, keep your hands inside and gently tug the insert’s corners to meet the sham’s corners. Straighten out and fluff as needed.
  • When washing your pillow shams, note that you can remove the pillow inserts some of the time and not wash them to cut down on wear-and-tear. If you’ve spilled something on the pillow that has soaked through, however, or if it’s been awhile since you’ve washed the insert, you might wish to also launder them.