The Best Baby Dolls For 5-Year-Old Girls - 2021
We looked at the top 11 Baby Dolls For 5 Year Old Girls and dug through the reviews from 7 of the most popular review sites including and more. The result is a ranking of the best Baby Dolls For 5 Year Old Girls.
Why Trust The DWYM Score?
DWYM is focused on helping you make the best purchasing decision. Our team of experts spends hundreds of hours analyzing, testing, and researching products so you don't have to.Learn more.
Our Picks For The Top Baby Dolls For 5 Year Old Girls
- The Best Baby Doll For 5 Year Old Girls
- 1. Melissa & Doug Plastic Jenna Baby Doll, 12-Inch
- 2. JC Toys Twin 13-Inch Realistic Soft Body Baby Dolls
- 3. JC Toys Anatomically Correct Vinyl Baby Doll, 15-Inch
- 4. Adora Open & Close Eyes Baby Doll, 13-Inch
- 5. Dolls To Play Soft Baby Doll & Backpack Carrier, 13-Inch
- 6. Dolls To Play Baby Doll Car Seat With Toy Accessories
- 7. Baby Alive Step ‘N Giggle Baby Black Hair Doll
- 8. Aori Lifelike Reborn African American Baby Doll
- 9. New York Doll Collection African American Newborn Baby Doll
- 10. Adora Playtime Collection Pink Baby Doll With Bottle
- 11. Dolls To Play Soft Body Baby Doll & Accessories, 14-Inch
Great for SnugglingThis doll is soft to the touch, making her perfect for hugging and snuggling during naptime.
Twin DollsYou'll get a set of twins in this baby doll set, each wearing different but a matching outfit.
Lifelike Dimples and CreasesThe dimples and creases in this doll's skin make it incredibly realistic.
Baby Powder ScentA pleasant baby odor scent makes this doll like holding a real baby.
Why we recommend these baby dolls for 5 year old girls?
Products Considered
Products Analyzed
Expert Reviews Included
User Opinions Analyzed
Our experts reviewed the top 11 Baby Dolls For 5 Year Old Girls and also dug through the reviews from 7 of the most popular review sites including and more. The result is a ranking of the best of the best Baby Dolls For 5 Year Old Girls.
DWYM is your trusted roduct review source. Our team reviews thousands of product reviews from the trusted top experts and combines them into one easy-to-understand score. Learn more.
The Best Overall
Melissa & Doug Plastic Jenna Baby Doll, 12-Inch
Our Take
This baby doll is not only soft to the touch, but she can open and close her eyes and suck her thumb or pacifier. The bonnet and onesie are removable for easy cleanup. The size is only 12 inches, making her perfect for 5-year-olds to maneuver.
What other experts liked
What other experts didn't like
The Best Bang For Your Buck
JC Toys Twin 13-Inch Realistic Soft Body Baby Dolls
Our Take
Two babies in one make this doll set stand out. You can choose between white and African American dolls, each in 13-inch sizes with soft, realistic skin. You'll also get a removable, washable outfit with each doll, as well as a bottle and pacifier.
Overall Product Rankings
9. New York Doll Collection African American Newborn Baby Doll
Our Baby Doll For 5 Year Old Girls Findings
Melissa & Doug Plastic Jenna Baby Doll, 12-Inch
What We Liked: This baby doll is not only soft to the touch, but she can open and close her eyes and suck her thumb or pacifier. The bonnet and onesie are removable for easy cleanup. The size is only 12 inches, making her perfect for 5-year-olds to maneuver.
JC Toys Twin 13-Inch Realistic Soft Body Baby Dolls
What We Liked: Two babies in one make this doll set stand out. You can choose between white and African American dolls, each in 13-inch sizes with soft, realistic skin. You’ll also get a removable, washable outfit with each doll, as well as a bottle and pacifier.
JC Toys Anatomically Correct Vinyl Baby Doll, 15-Inch
What We Liked: This 15-inch doll is impressively realistic, with lifelike dimples, wrinkles and folds. Posable arms, legs and head make it easy to take off and put on clothing. The doll comes with a hand-sewn knit outfit with matching hat and booties, along with a bottle and pacifier.
Adora Open & Close Eyes Baby Doll, 13-Inch
What We Liked: With a 13-inch design, this doll is recommended for children ages 1 and up. The doll’s body feels satiny soft and a beanbag bottom provides a pleasant holding experience. Adding to the realism, she can both open and close her eyes and suck her thumb.
New York Doll Collection African American Newborn Baby Doll
What We Liked: You’ll get an 11-inch doll in a gift box with this option. The doll is easy to clean by simply wiping it with a wet cloth. The onesie and matching hat are also machine washable for easy cleanup.
Our Baby Doll For 5 Year Old Girls Buying Guide
Baby dolls have come a long way in recent years, with a lifelike look and feel. You can even find dolls with realistic animations like thumb sucking and eye opening and closing.
But before you buy a baby doll for your 5-year-old girl, it’s important to look at the benefits of playing with dolls in the first place. For children, it can help them develop their caretaking skills, giving them an early introduction to the joys of nurturing.
Parents may also find that lifelike baby dolls are a great way for a young child to get comfortable with the idea of having a younger brother or sister. But you have more options than ever when it comes to the type of doll. Some feature realistic skin creases and dimples while others even have that baby smell.
Ethnicities are also part of the choice. While most dolls are still white, there are now other options. You may also have to search a little harder to find a boy doll since girl dolls tend to rule store shelves.
Lastly, there are the accessories. Most baby dolls come with a onesie, but in some cases, you’ll get a matching hat, blanket and/or booties. If your doll comes with those items, make sure they’re machine washable and, in the case of clothing, that they can be removed.
DWYM Fun Fact
Baby dolls give children hours of entertainment, but they also serve a developmental purpose. A team of researchers found that it activates certain brain regions. Using neuroscience, researchers at Cardiff University found that even when they played alone, doll play helped children develop empathy and social information processing skills.
For the study, the researchers had 33 children aged from 4 to 8 play with Barbie dolls. They monitored brain activity while the children played. The research found that a brain region called the posterior superior temporal sulcus was activated while the children played with the dolls. This is the part of the brain that humans use while considering other people’s thoughts and feelings.
The Baby Doll For 5 Year Old Girls Tips and Advice
- Baby dolls are likely to get dirty with excessive play. Make sure you choose one that can be easily cleaned with a wet cloth.
- Skin texture is essential to getting that lifelike experience. Check the texture of the doll’s skin. Some have creases and dimples to really bring them to life.
- You’ll find some baby dolls have limbs that bend. This comes in very handy when changing clothes.
- Many baby dolls have neutral expressions for a reason. A defined expression makes it tougher for a child to interpret what they think the baby is feeling.
- The size of the doll is important. Many are 11 or 12 inches, which is a great size for 5-year-olds.
- Choosing a doll for a child relies heavily on the personal preferences of that particular person. Consider what you know about the child and use your natural instincts to choose one that’s the right fit.
- At the age of 5, a child is getting a little more sophisticated in doll play. A realistic doll can be especially valuable to a child of that age.
- Before you buy, check to see if you can buy extra clothing and accessories for the doll. Chances are, your child will eventually tire of the items included with the doll and want to change things up.
About The Author
Stephanie Faris is a novelist and professional writer. She's also a wife and stepmom who lives in the Nashville, Tennessee, area. Her work has appeared on popular parenting sites. She also writes books for young children, including the Piper Morgan series of chapter books published by Simon & Schuster's Aladdin imprint.