Melissa & Doug Plastic Jenna Baby Doll, 12-Inch

Last updated date: February 22, 2021

DWYM Score

9.8

Melissa & Doug Plastic Jenna Baby Doll, 12-Inch

Why Trust DWYM?

DWYM is your trusted product review source. Along with our in-house experts, our team analyzes thousands of product reviews from the most trusted websites. We then create one easy-to-understand review. Learn more.

Don't Waste Your Money Seal of Approval
Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in the category.
Show Contents

We looked at the top Baby Dolls For 5 Year Old Girls and dug through the reviews from some of the most popular review sites. Through this analysis, we've determined the best Baby Doll For 5 Year Old Girls you should buy.

Editor's Note February 22, 2021:
Checkout The Best Baby Dolls For 5 Year Old Girls for a detailed review of all the top baby dolls for 5 year old girls.

Overall Take

This baby doll is not only soft to the touch, but she can open and close her eyes and suck her thumb or pacifier. The bonnet and onesie are removable for easy cleanup. The size is only 12 inches, making her perfect for 5-year-olds to maneuver.


In our analysis of 7 expert reviews, the Melissa & Doug Melissa & Doug Plastic Jenna Baby Doll, 12-Inch placed 1st when we looked at the top 11 products in the category. For the full ranking, see below.

From The Manufacturer

BEAUTIFUL BABY DOLL: The Melissa & Doug Mine to Love Jenna 12-Inch Soft Body Baby Doll features eyes that open and close and sweet baby cheeks; additionally, she can suck her thumb or pacifier. IDEAL SIZE FOR TODDLERS: Our Melissa & Doug Mine to Love baby is 12-inches long, which makes her a great size for toddlers 18 months and up to hug, cuddle, and care for. MULTIPLE HANDY FEATURES: Our Jenna baby doll features wipe-clean arms, a removable smocked romper and matching cap. She closes her bright blue eyes as she is rocked to sleep. GREAT GIFT FOR 18 MONTHS AND UP: The Mine to Love Jenna Soft Body Baby Doll makes a great gift for toddlers 18 months and up. Add the Melissa & Doug Baby Food and Bottle set to round out the hands-on, baby care experience. “THE GOLD STANDARD IN CHILDHOOD PLAY”: For more than 30 years, Melissa & Doug has created beautifully designed imagination- and creativity-sparking products that NBC News calls “the gold standard in early childhood play.” 100% HAPPINESS GUARANTEE: We design every toy to the highest-quality standards, and to nurture minds and hearts. If your child is not inspired, give us a call and we'll make it right. Our phone number is on every product.

Expert Reviews

Expert Summarized Score

9.7
5 expert reviews

User Summarized Score

9.4
7,657 user reviews

What experts liked

Closes eyes with rocking movements. Wipe clean hands. Made with a size of 12 inches. Added removable smocked romper.
- Little One Mag
Arms and legs are fully moveable, encouraging motor skill development. Bonnet and sleeper onesie are fully removable. This realistic baby doll toy will suck the thumb like a real baby. Arms and legs conveniently wipe clean when dirty.
- Net Parents
Very realistic; adorable eyes that can blink, sucks her thumb or pacifier as if the toddler can really feed the baby with Melissa & Doug Baby food and bottle set. Adorably cute, makes your baby fall in love at first sight. Made with highest-quality standards.
- Mom n Kids
At just 12 inches, this soft doll is easy for little hands to grasp and has realistic features that delight, like eyes that open and close when rocked to sleep and a mouth that can suck her thumb or a pacifier.
- The Spruce
The romper and cap are removable (dressing and undressing dolls are great ways to practice fine-motor skills). Plus, this baby doll is soft and snuggly — perfect for cuddling up with at bedtime.
- What To Expect

What experts didn't like

Mild baby powder smell.
- Little One Mag
Children need to be monitored while playing with the doll, as it contains small parts. All other accessories sold separately.
- Net Parents

An Overview On Baby Dolls For 5 Year Old Girls

Baby dolls have come a long way in recent years, with a lifelike look and feel. You can even find dolls with realistic animations like thumb sucking and eye opening and closing.

But before you buy a baby doll for your 5-year-old girl, it’s important to look at the benefits of playing with dolls in the first place. For children, it can help them develop their caretaking skills, giving them an early introduction to the joys of nurturing.

Parents may also find that lifelike baby dolls are a great way for a young child to get comfortable with the idea of having a younger brother or sister. But you have more options than ever when it comes to the type of doll. Some feature realistic skin creases and dimples while others even have that baby smell.

Ethnicities are also part of the choice. While most dolls are still white, there are now other options. You may also have to search a little harder to find a boy doll since girl dolls tend to rule store shelves.

Lastly, there are the accessories. Most baby dolls come with a onesie, but in some cases, you’ll get a matching hat, blanket and/or booties. If your doll comes with those items, make sure they’re machine washable and, in the case of clothing, that they can be removed.

The Baby Doll For 5 Year Old Girls Buying Guide

  • Baby dolls are likely to get dirty with excessive play. Make sure you choose one that can be easily cleaned with a wet cloth.
  • Skin texture is essential to getting that lifelike experience. Check the texture of the doll’s skin. Some have creases and dimples to really bring them to life.
  • You’ll find some baby dolls have limbs that bend. This comes in very handy when changing clothes.
  • Many baby dolls have neutral expressions for a reason. A defined expression makes it tougher for a child to interpret what they think the baby is feeling.
  • The size of the doll is important. Many are 11 or 12 inches, which is a great size for 5-year-olds.
  • Choosing a doll for a child relies heavily on the personal preferences of that particular person. Consider what you know about the child and use your natural instincts to choose one that’s the right fit.
  • At the age of 5, a child is getting a little more sophisticated in doll play. A realistic doll can be especially valuable to a child of that age.
  • Before you buy, check to see if you can buy extra clothing and accessories for the doll. Chances are, your child will eventually tire of the items included with the doll and want to change things up.