Don't Waste Your Money is supported by our readers. When you purchase an item through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

The Best Cookie Cutter

Last updated on February 29, 2024
Best Cookie Cutter

Our Review Process

Don't Waste Your Money is focused on helping you make the best purchasing decision. Our team of experts spends hundreds of hours analyzing, testing, and researching products so you don't have to. Learn more.

Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in a category.

Our Picks For The Top Cookie Cutters

View All Recommendations
Product Overview
Key Takeaway
 Top Pick

BakingWorld Children’s Metal Cookie Cutters, 7-Piece

Don't Waste Your Money Seal of Approval

Children’s Metal Cookie Cutters, 7-Piece

With this cookie cutter set, you get seven cutters that feature your children's favorite characters. These include Mickey Mouse, a unicorn and a dinosaur. Each of the cutters are constructed from a durable stainless steel that is both strong and easy to clean.

Overall Take

Cute CharactersYou can use these cookie cutter for much more than creating delicious desserts. They also work for cutting sandwiches and biscuits.

 Runner Up

LAXIZAR Tiny Stainless Steel Cookie Cutters, 18-Piece

Tiny Stainless Steel Cookie Cutters, 18-Piece

Make vegetables, fruits and desserts much more appealing using this highly versatile cookie cutter set. The set includes 18 mini cutters and molds in a variety of shapes, including flowers, stars, airplanes and even dog bones. Once you cut the fruit and veggies out, you can arrange them to create an edible bouquet.

Overall Take

Most VersatileWith this cookie cutter center, you can place a heart-shaped carrot in the center of a cucumber slice.

 We Also Like

Wilton Assorted Cookie Cutter Pack, 101-Piece

Assorted Cookie Cutter Pack, 101-Piece

If you're in need of an affordable cookie cutter set, this model delivers. Each set comes with letters, numbers and a host of holiday cutters. The only downside to these stencils is that they aren't very deep, so you won't be able to use them on thick cookies or to cut shapes out of sandwiches.

Overall Take

Affordable CuttersSince this cookie cutter is made of plastic, it's a good set to use when having your children help with the baking.

 Strong Contender

MCIGICM Multi-Purpose Cookie Cutter Set, 12-Piece

Multi-Purpose Cookie Cutter Set, 12-Piece

Constructed from a durable stainless steel, these cookie cutters won't rust or lose their shape. The star, heart, flower and circular cutters feature rolled edges for safety. They can be used for everything from cookies to muffins to sandwiches to craft clay.

Overall Take

Four Fun ShapesThese cookie cutters are safe in temperatures up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit, which means you can clean them in a dishwasher.

Buying Guide

Did you know the average American eats 300 cookies a year? Multiply that by the number of people in your family and you’ll quickly learn it’s cheaper to make cookies yourself than to purchase them at the store. For that, you need a good set of cookie cutters.

Determine whether you’d like a starter set of cookie cutters made out of plastic or a more commercial set made out of stainless steel. Plastic cookie cutters are a good choice if your children enjoy baking with you, while the stainless steel are best when baking for a party or special event.

Choose your cookie cutter set based on the shapes available. Some sets are specific to the holidays, for example, while others have molds that are designed for a baby shower. There are even sets that have letters and numbers, so you can spell out “Happy Birthday” or make cookies that reveal the recipient’s age. Of course, if you go with a set of round cookie cutters, you can use them to make donuts, biscuits and even fondant circles.

Check to see if the cookie cutter set comes with any extras. Some offer a complimentary recipe book to give you a little inspiration, while others provide a few coffee stencils. These are used to decorate lattes and cappuccinos.

What to Look For

  • Always review the cleaning instructions for your cookie cutters on the product care label. Some are listed as hand wash only, while others specify use in a dishwasher on the top shelf only. Many quality stainless steel models are even safe enough to be washed in the dishwasher without restriction.
  • Make sure the cookie cutters are deep if you plan on cutting something thick, like a sandwich for your child’s lunch.
  • Look at the cookie cutter’s product label to determine if it is BPA-free or made from an FDA-approved food-grade material. You don’t want any toxins leaching into your cookies.
  • When comparing the price of cookie cutter sets, you must first look at the type of material used to construct the cookie cutters. Plastic models, like the Wilton Cookie Cutters Set, 101-Piece, are always the most affordable. Next, you need to take into consideration the number of cutters in the set. A set that has seven more cutters than other models will naturally cost more.

More to Explore

Cookie cutters have been in existence for quite a long time. In fact, the Ancient Egyptians used to use them to shape dough. At that time cookie cutters were called molds.

One of the most popular cookie cutter shapes is the gingerbread man. You may be surprised to discover that Queen Elizabeth I is thought to be the first person to have the shape of a man cut out of ginger dough.

There’s actually a National Cookie Cutter Historical Museum in Joplin, Missouri. It’s supported by the Cookie Cutter Collectors Club and doesn’t charge any entry fees. The museum is open Tuesday through Saturday and closed on Sunday and Monday.

From our partners