Don't Waste Your Money is supported by our readers. When you purchase an item through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

The Best Plastic Pitcher

Last updated on April 21, 2023

Our Review Process

Don't Waste Your Money is focused on helping you make the best purchasing decision. Our team of experts spends hundreds of hours analyzing, testing, and researching products so you don't have to. Learn more.

Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in a category.

Our Picks For The Top Plastic Pitchers

View All Recommendations
Product Overview
Key Takeaway
 Top Pick

New Star Foodservice Lightweight Anti-Break Plastic Pitcher, 60-Ounce

Don't Waste Your Money Seal of Approval

New Star Foodservice

Lightweight Anti-Break Plastic Pitcher, 60-Ounce

Whether you own a restaurant or you're simply looking for a reliable plastic pitcher that won't crack when dropped, this model has you covered. It's nice and lightweight and comes with a handle that is comfortable to hold. Since the pitcher has a translucent design, you'll always be able to identify the contents at a glance.

Overall Take

Indoor and Outdoor UseUse this plastic pitcher to serve everything from iced tea to your favorite beer.

 Runner Up

Amazing Abby Lead-Free Break-Resistant Plastic Pitcher, 72-Ounce

Amazing Abby

Lead-Free Break-Resistant Plastic Pitcher, 72-Ounce

Families will love that this plastic pitcher has a large 72-ounce capacity. It's perfect for adding milk to cereal at breakfast time or serving fresh lemonade out on the back deck. The pitcher is constructed using a food-grade plastic that is free of BPA and lead, so you can feel good about using it.

Overall Take

Large CapacityThanks to the included lid, you won't have to worry about losing liquid when transporting this plastic pitcher from fridge to table.

 We Also Like

Brita Easy Clean Water Filter Pitcher, 2.5-Quart


Easy Clean Water Filter Pitcher, 2.5-Quart

Save money on bottled water with this plastic pitcher, which filters tap water to give you pure results. The 10.47-inch height means it fits easily on most refrigerator shelves, and the pitcher holds 10 cups of water. You'll just need to replace the filter every six months.

Overall Take

Refreshing ChoiceThe built-in filter on this pitcher gives you clear water with each pour.

 Strong Contender

LOCK & LOCK Spout Secure Open Plastic Pitcher, 3-Quart


Spout Secure Open Plastic Pitcher, 3-Quart

Whether you love making freshly squeezed orange juice or a refreshing batch of iced tea, this plastic pitcher has you covered. It's constructed using a BPA-free plastic that is extremely durable. The pitcher is also outfitted with a flip-top lid for ease of use.

Overall Take

Most EconomicalYou'll love the budget-friendly price tag on this plastic pitcher.

Buying Guide

Whether you’re serving lemonade or margaritas, the right pitcher can make all the difference. Simply insert your ingredients, mix and pour.

But not all pitchers are the same. Some have some conveniences built in that you might miss at first glance. One of the most useful features is a lid that doubles as a strainer. You’ll notice most lids have a section cut out to help you with pouring. Simply move the lid to the closed position to block liquid from coming out. You can also find lids that have slots built in for straining liquid through ice or keeping pulp out of your glass of orange juice.

If water is your beverage of choice, consider a pitcher that has a water filter built in. You’ll simply have to change the filter periodically, but this type of pitcher allows you to get delicious water from your kitchen sink.

Many modern pitchers also feature measurement marks. These marks demonstrate exactly how much liquid to put in. This can come in handy if you regularly use recipes to make beverages.

Pitchers also come in various sizes, so make sure you pay attention to capacity before you buy. You may find your favorite beverage recipe makes two gallons, but your pitcher’s capacity is only one gallon.

What to Look For

  • Check the height of your pitcher if you’ll be storing it in your refrigerator. If you don’t have a shelf in your refrigerator that allows for taller items, you could find you have nowhere to store your pitcher.
  • Most pitchers are made from plastic. If BPA is a concern for you, search for a pitcher that promises it’s BPA-free.
  • If you’ll use your pitcher outdoors, consider one that’s made of shatterproof materials. Plastic that allows for drops without breaking can come in handy if you’re at a picnic or by the pool, or if kids will use your pitcher.
  • Most pitchers block liquid by having you simply rotate the lid. Pay attention to how easy it is to move the lid on the pitcher you choose. Some require you to lift the lid, rotate it, then push it down again while some can be moved without lifting. You’ll want to make sure your lid is designed to stay in place once you’ve moved it to its position.
  • You can liven up plain filtered water by adding a little fresh fruit to your water pitcher. Simply drop some sliced fruit in the bottom of the pitcher, then pour your water through the pitcher as usual.

More to Explore

Drinking vessels have been a part of the landscape throughout history. Early European drinking cups were initially carved out of wood, but as Rome colonized parts of Europe, residents learned pottery, allowing them to make drinkware from glazed clay. This trend continued throughout the Middle Ages, when poorer families drank from bowls while wealthier families had lead-glazed pitchers.

But in Spain, artisans revolutionized pottery with majolica. Majolica, which introduced patterns to pottery, spread throughout Europe. Soon Italians adopted the practice, adding their own unique designs to their creations. Artisans in other areas began to pick up the practice, leading to a wide variety of imaginative pottery designs that can now be seen in museums around the world.

From our partners