The Best Pickle Pops
We looked at the top 3 Pickle Pops and dug through the reviews from 8 of the most popular review sites including and more. The result is a ranking of the best Pickle Pops.
Why Trust The DWYM Score?
DWYM is focused on helping you make the best purchasing decision. Our team of experts spends hundreds of hours analyzing, testing, and researching products so you don't have to.Learn more.
Our Picks For The Top Pickle Pops
Great Sour TasteIf you want that authentic sour flavor, you'll love BOB'S PICKLE POPS Original Dill Flavor.
Electrolytes for HydrationVan Holtens Pickle Ice Freeze Pops are packed full of electrolytes to keep you hydrated and reduce the risk of cramping.
Make Your Own PopsBest Maid Products Dill Juice helps you save money by delivering your pickle juice in large jugs that you can use to make your own freezer pops.
Why we recommend these pickle pops?
Products Considered
Products Analyzed
Expert Reviews Included
User Opinions Analyzed
Our experts reviewed the top 3 Pickle Pops and also dug through the reviews from 8 of the most popular review sites including and more. The result is a ranking of the best of the best Pickle Pops.
DWYM is your trusted roduct review source. Our team reviews thousands of product reviews from the trusted top experts and combines them into one easy-to-understand score. Learn more.
The Best Overall
BOB’S PICKLE POPS Original Dill Flavor
Our Take
With a 3-pack of 6 pops per pack for a total of 18, BOB'S PICKLE POPS Original Dill Flavor offers a great way to try it out without the large quantities you often get with freezer pops. It's also a great alternative to the sugary flavors always found with freezer pops, with a sour, briny taste similar to a pickle out of a jar. The compact size provides a portable treat when you're on the way out the door on a hot summer day.
What other experts liked
What other experts didn't like
The Best Bang For Your Buck
Van Holtens Pickle Ice Freeze Pops
Our Take
The Van Holtens Pickle Ice Freeze Pops come in two sizes, allowing you to try out the 8-pack before making the full commitment to a 48 pack. You'll get a delicious taste reminiscent of pickle juice in 2-ounce pops that you can take on the go. The one thing that sets these pops apart is that they contain electrolytes, which are ideal for keeping you hydrated on a hot summer day.
What other experts liked
Our Pickle Pop Findings
BOB’S PICKLE POPS Original Dill Flavor
What We Liked: With a 3-pack of 6 pops per pack for a total of 18, BOB’S PICKLE POPS Original Dill Flavor offers a great way to try it out without the large quantities you often get with freezer pops. It’s also a great alternative to the sugary flavors always found with freezer pops, with a sour, briny taste similar to a pickle out of a jar. The compact size provides a portable treat when you’re on the way out the door on a hot summer day.
Van Holtens Pickle Ice Freeze Pops
What We Liked: The Van Holtens Pickle Ice Freeze Pops come in two sizes, allowing you to try out the 8-pack before making the full commitment to a 48 pack. You’ll get a delicious taste reminiscent of pickle juice in 2-ounce pops that you can take on the go. The one thing that sets these pops apart is that they contain electrolytes, which are ideal for keeping you hydrated on a hot summer day.
Best Maid Products Dill Juice
What We Liked: For true pickle juice enthusiasts, there’s the Best Maid Products Dill Juice, which provides a full gallon jug of authentic flavor. You can use this jug to make your own freezer pops, which will save you money over buying pickle pops already packaged. Best of all, if you find the taste a little strong, you can dilute it or mix it with other ingredients to make your very own freezer pop flavors.
Our Pickle Pop Buying Guide
For many, freezer pops were a staple of childhood. There’s a good reason for that. Parents can buy these tasty treats, then stick them in the freezer to grab any time kids want a snack. On a hot summer day, they can be a great way to keep kids hydrated without trying to get them to stop and drink water.
But not everyone has a sweet tooth. Pickle pops take a savory approach to traditional freezer pops, with a sour, authentic dill taste that can be addictive. If someone in your household is a pickle lover, these pops are a great alternative to regular pickles, which are high in sodium, making them not ideal for situations where you may become dehydrated.
If you haven’t purchased freezer pops for a while, you may have forgotten that you don’t have to refrigerate them. You can store them in your pantry and put just as many as you need in the freezer to save space. You can even buy some molds and make your own pickle pops using pickle juice and some of the recipes available online. If you do, you’ll need to buy a mold and some popsicle sticks. For best results, turn your freezer to the highest setting. The faster you reach freezing temperatures, the fewer ice crystals you’ll accumulate, helping create a creamier consistency.
DWYM Fun Fact
Pickle-flavored treats may be showing up everywhere, but pickle juice is nothing new. In fact, athletes have been drinking pickle juice for years as a treatment for after-exercise cramping. One study found that pickle juice was more effective than water for muscle cramps, which could be another reason for the surge in popularity. But athletes aren’t the only ones who can benefit from pickle juice. In fact, a study found that pickle juice helps lower blood sugar in adults who are healthy. You’ll also benefit from a hefty dose of vitamins C and E when you enjoy a pickle pop or a glass of pickle juice.
The Pickle Pop Tips and Advice
- With pickle pops, taste is everything. Most will have a taste similar to the juice in your pickle jar. If you’ve never tried pickle-based products, you may want to try a smaller order first. But don’t rule it out completely if you don’t like the first brand you try. As with any food product, taste can vary dramatically from one brand to another.
- You may not realize it, but pickle pops can actually help keep you hydrated. If someone in your household plays sports or spends time outdoors during the hot months, look for a brand that includes electrolytes. This will not only help prevent dehydration, but it also reduces the risk of cramping.
- Some consumers make their own pickle pops using the leftover juice in their pickle jars. For that reason, you can now buy pickle juice by the gallon. You can then pour the juice directly into a mold, insert a popsicle stick and enjoy. It can save you money long term but, most importantly, it frees you up to be creative and fun. Let your kids pick out some molds they like and help you with the project.
- In addition to do-it-yourself pickle pops, you can use pickle juice for making Bloody Marys, potato salad and other recipes you want to have that extra pickle taste.
About The Author
Stephanie Faris is a novelist and business writer whose work has appeared on numerous blogs. She worked for the State of Tennessee for 19 years, the latter six of which were spent as a supervisor. She has written content for entrepreneurs and marketing firms since 2011. In addition to her online content, she is also the author of eight novels for Simon & Schuster, including the Piper Morgan chapter book series.