Don't Waste Your Money is supported by our readers. When you purchase an item through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

The Best Eyeliners - 2022

Last updated on May 19, 2022

We looked at the top 10 and dug through the reviews from 23 of the most popular review sites including and more. The result is a ranking of the best .

Why Trust The DWYM Score?

DWYM is focused on helping you make the best purchasing decision. Our team of experts spends hundreds of hours analyzing, testing, and researching products so you don't have to.Learn more.

Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in a category.

Our Picks For The Top

Show Contents
Our Take
Experts Included
Pros
Cons
  Top Pick

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Retractable Smudge-Proof Creamy Eyeliner

Don't Waste Your Money Seal of Approval

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP

Retractable Smudge-Proof Creamy Eyeliner

Overall Take

Smudge ProofThis eyeliner lasts all day through heat and humidity.

Experts Included
DWYM Health & Wellness Experts plus BestReviews, Style Craze, Insider. Along with user reviews from Amazon, Target and Walmart.
Pros
" This smooth velvety matte shade has great staying power. Features intense pigmentation at an amazing price. Reviewers said it was easy to apply and lasted even through intense crying sessions."
Cons
"Not humidity proof. Causes allergic reaction."
  Runner Up

Maybelline Hyper Easy Smooth Liquid Waterproof Eyeliner

Maybelline

Hyper Easy Smooth Liquid Waterproof Eyeliner

Overall Take

Flexible TipThis eyeliner offers optimal control and grip.

Experts Included
DWYM Health & Wellness Experts plus Byrdie, Allure. Along with user reviews from Amazon, Best Views Reviews and Target.
Pros
" This popular waterproof eyeliner stayed mostly intact after a workout and when splashed with water."
  We Also Like

Stila Stay All Day Marker-Like Waterproof Eyeliner

Stila

Stay All Day Marker-Like Waterproof Eyeliner

Overall Take

Easy to UseThis eyeliner is smudge proof and transfer proof.

Experts Included
DWYM Health & Wellness Experts plus BestReviews, Good Housekeeping, Glamour. Along with user reviews from Amazon.
Pros
" Waterproof liner can be worn in the rain or while swimming. Liquid formula offers precision so you can perform a variety of looks. Glides on easily and does not smear."
  Also Great

e.l.f. Cruelty-Free & Vegan Highly-Pigmented Eyeliner

e.l.f.

Cruelty-Free & Vegan Highly-Pigmented Eyeliner

Overall Take

Intense LookThis eyeliner is ultra pigmented.

Experts Included
DWYM Health & Wellness Experts plus . Along with user reviews from Amazon, Target and Walmart.
Don't just take for granted what one reviewer says. Along with our own experts, DWYM analyzes the top expert reviews of the leading products and generates a score you can actually trust.
17

Products Considered

We identified the majority of the available to purchase.
10

Products Analyzed

We then selected the leading and most popular products for our team to review.

View All Product Rankings

23

Expert Reviews Included

In addition to our expert reviews, we also incorporate feedback and analysis of some of the most respected sources including: Beauty Over Fifty, Good Housekeeping, Allure, Byrdie, Musings of a Muse.

1,251,254

User Opinions Analyzed

We also incorporate user reviews from the leading retailers including

Our experts reviewed the top 10 and also dug through the reviews from 23 of the most popular review sites including and more. The result is a ranking of the best of the best .

DWYM is your trusted roduct review source. Our team reviews thousands of product reviews from the trusted top experts and combines them into one easy-to-understand score. Learn more.

Don't Waste Your Money Seal of Approval
Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in their category.

The Best Overall

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Retractable Smudge-Proof Creamy Eyeliner


Our Expert Score

9.0
3 expert reviews

User Summarized Score

9.0
75,064 user reviews

Our Take

This eyeliner is smudge proof and will last all day through heat and humidity. The pencil is retractable and easy to use. This eyeliner is available in both neutral and bright colors.

What other experts liked

This smooth velvety matte shade has great staying power. Features intense pigmentation at an amazing price. Reviewers said it was easy to apply and lasted even through intense crying sessions.
- BestReviews
This retractable eyeliner from NYX Professional makes drawing wings an effortless task. Its creamy formula and intense color off add a pop to your eyes. It glides effortlessly and stays put for a long time without smudging or bleeding. It...
- Style Craze
There's affordable and then there's cheap. At $5.49, NYX Retractable Eye Liner is definitely in the latter category. But don't the price tag fool you — the formula does not skimp on quality. It's highly pigmented and easy to apply,...
- Insider

What other experts didn't like

Review Quote (Negative)
- BestReviews
Not humidity proof. Causes allergic reaction.
- Style Craze
Pretty small color selection.
- Insider

The Best Bang For Your Buck

e.l.f. Cruelty-Free & Vegan Highly-Pigmented Eyeliner

User Summarized Score

8.9
6,728 user reviews

Our Take

This ultra-pigmented eyeliner will give you an intense look. It is waterproof with great staying power. The eyeliner can be used on your lash line, waterline or all over the lid.

Our Findings


NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Retractable Smudge-Proof Creamy Eyeliner

Top Pick

What We Liked: This eyeliner is smudge proof and will last all day through heat and humidity. The pencil is retractable and easy to use. This eyeliner is available in both neutral and bright colors.


Maybelline Hyper Easy Smooth Liquid Waterproof Eyeliner

What We Liked: You get optimal control and grip with the flexible-tip brush. It glides on smooth without any slips or gaps. The eyeliner is a great way to explore your artistic creativity.


Stila Stay All Day Marker-Like Waterproof Eyeliner

We Also Like

What We Liked: This easy-to-use eyeliner is smudge proof and transfer proof. It is waterproof so you can wear it in humidity. The eyeliner is made with cruelty-free processes.


CoverGirl Perfect Point Plus Stay-Put Eyeliner, 2-Piece

What We Liked: This eyeliner is a convenient choice as it never needs to be sharpened. It is designed to last all day and will not smudge. The eyeliner is available in a rainbow of colors.


e.l.f. Cruelty-Free & Vegan Highly-Pigmented Eyeliner

What We Liked: This ultra-pigmented eyeliner will give you an intense look. It is waterproof with great staying power. The eyeliner can be used on your lash line, waterline or all over the lid.

Our Buying Guide

Eyeliner is a great way to express your creativity. However, there are so many different types of eyeliner – how do you know which one is right for your needs? A popular variety is liquid eyeliner, which allows you do draw with a sharp, precise brush to create defined lines. This is a good choice if you like the winged retro look and like making flicks or scoops at the sides of your eyes. Gel eyeliner is perfect for getting a satiny finish. It glides on smoothly and looks very professional. However, it can take a little while to get the hang of it.

For those who prefer a more subtle look, pencil eyeliner is a good choice. It can also be used to color on the waterlines of your eyes, which isn’t possible with liquid or gel eyeliner. Pen eyeliner is quick to apply thanks to the sharp tip. They don’t show up as dark as pencil eyeliner so you may need multiple coats to achieve the look you’re going for. A traditional style of eyeliner which has been used for centuries is kohl. It glides on smoothly but it is likely to smudge, so you have to be careful when wearing it. There are some smudge-resistant styles of kohl available as well. If you’re a beginner and new to makeup, cream eyeliners may be a good option. They are the easiest to rub off, so you can re-do the lines if you didn’t get them right the first time.

DWYM Fun Fact

Did you know that the history of eyeliner goes as far back as ancient Egypt? During this time, people used kohl to trace their eyes. This kind of eyeliner was made from a type of lead sulfide combined with other minerals and then mixed with water, oil and animal fat. Eyeliner saw a boom in the early 1900s when the bust of ancient Egyptian Queen Nefertiti was found in 1912. She was revered as a beauty and everyone was captivated by her look – including the lines of thick, black kohl which she used to outline her almond-shaped eyes.

The Tips and Advice

  • In addition to the type of eyeliner, you also need to think about the type of applicator – which is how you actually apply the eyeliner to your skin. Many types, such as liquids, come with a pen-like applicator, which is easy to hold and maneuver. There are also felt-tip applicators which are great for making thicker lines as well as thin ones. Keep in mind that they may dry out quickly. Another type is a brush applicator, which is similar to the type of brush you get with nail polish. It can be more difficult to control and maneuver this applicator, but you are able to create different line thicknesses with it. Pencil applicators are easy to use and a good choice for most beginners.
  • Waterproof eyeliner formula are designed for long-lasting wear. However, keep in mind that they are also difficult to take off. Another issue is if you live in a humid climate, your eyeliner may be more likely to run or drip. In this case, waterproof eyeliner is a necessity.
  • Opt for high pigment formula as this way you don’t need to put on multiple layers of liner in order to get a bold color. Plus, this type of eyeliner typically goes on smooth and clean and doesn’t damage the sensitive skin around your eyes.
  • Most styles of eyeliner are available in multiple colors. However, arguably black eyeliner is the most popular as it works with so many different types of makeup looks and fashion style. You can also find eyeliner in other colors such as brown, blue, green and red.

About The Author

Anam Ahmed 

Anam Ahmed is a professional copywriter and essayist based in Toronto. She has been writing on technology, travel, parenting, and business for over 10 years, and works with a number of high-profile organizations. Highly interested in personal health and wellness, she values finding the best products that help people regain their vitality. Anam earned a master's degree from the University of Toronto and a bachelor's degree from Queen's University.