Don't Waste Your Money is supported by our readers. When you purchase an item through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

The Best Cookie Tins - 2021

Last updated on May 7, 2021
Best Cookie Tins

Why Trust The DWYM Score?

DWYM is focused on helping you make the best purchasing decision. Our team of experts spends hundreds of hours analyzing, testing, and researching products so you don't have to.Learn more.

Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in a category.

Our Picks For The Top Cookie Tins

Show Contents
Our Take
  Best Overall

StarPack Home Festive Cookie Tins, 3-Pack

Don't Waste Your Money Seal of Approval

Festive Cookie Tins, 3-Pack

Overall Take

Holiday CheerThese cookie tins come with a complimentary bonus ebook that's filled with helpful cooking tips.

  Stylish Set

Cornucopia Brands Round Cookie Tins, 2-Pack

Round Cookie Tins, 2-Pack

Overall Take

Great for CakesIn addition to holding baked goods, these cookie tins can be used to store everything from bath bombs to craft supplies.

  Classic Butter Cookies

Royal Dansk Butter Danish Cookies Tin, 24 Oz

Butter Danish Cookies Tin, 24 Oz

Overall Take

Shortbread GoodnessA three-pack of these cookies makes a great and affordable gift for your friends and family around the holidays, or just because.

  Gingerbread Pick

Nyakers Gingerbread Snaps Cookie Tin, 26.45 oz

Gingerbread Snaps Cookie Tin, 26.45 oz

Overall Take

Traditional Crispy, Sweet BiscuitsThis treat is an ideal choice for the cookie fan who enjoys truly fresh flavors and crisp snaps.

Avatar
Guide written by Danielle Smyth
Last updated on May 7, 2021

Who doesn’t love cookies? Perfect for care packages or a treat to bring to the office, cookie tins are always a welcome gift. There are so many cookies and assortments on the market, there truly is something for everyone.

While the sweet treats themselves are the star attraction when you’re buying a cookie tin, the design of the tin is part of the appeal. Look for a pretty tin that will be a nice addition to a table — or a familiar classic that everyone will recognize.

Speaking of classics, cookie tins are a great way to order a batch of your favorite cookies, such as shortbread or butter cookies.

Food products are not usually eligible for returns, so look into reviews of the seller’s packaging and shipping record. While flaky, buttery cookies are delicious, they also tend to crumble easily if they aren’t packaged carefully. The same product could be available from a different vendor who may have a better track record with packing and shipping the product carefully.

Be sure to take a moment to carefully review your final order before confirming its purchase. This is especially important if you or someone who will be partaking in the sweet treats has food allergies.

The Best Cookie Tins

1
  Best Overall

High-quality is what you'll get when you go with these cookie tins. They're constructed using a thick steel and decorated with a festive pattern that screams Christmas. The set includes a large, medium and small tin to fit everything from cakes to muffins to homemade chocolates.

Features


Specifications

Brand
StarPack Home
Model
2
  Stylish Set

If you enjoy gifting homemade goodies to friends and family, you'll want to pick up these cookie tins. Each set includes two round tins that work well for cakes, cookies and candies. The first tin has an attractive ocean blue color, while the second features a rainbow design.

Features


Specifications

Brand
Cornucopia Brands
Model
3
  Classic Butter Cookies

These classic butter cookies are made with the same ingredients and have the same great taste as they have for the last 30 years. Packaged in an iconic tin, often repurposed to store sewing supplies, these treats will transport you back to childhood.

Features


Specifications

Brand
Royal Dansk
Model
4
  Gingerbread Pick

Made with real ginger, fresh spices and lots of care, these ginger snaps are thin and delicious, just as they should be. The intricately decorated commemorative tin is a stylish way to store the dozens of cookies that are carefully packaged inside.

Features


Specifications

Brand
Nyakers
Model
5
  Cute Scottie Dogs

You'll love these traditional shortbread cookies, baked in memorable Scottie dog shapes. They come in a decorative tin perfect for gifts or personal enjoyment. These tasty, flaky treats are available in a variety of combination packs and flavors, such as traditional, chocolate and chocolate chip, as well as a new gluten-free version.

Features


Specifications

Brand
Walkers
Model
6

This set boasts a variety of gourmet cookies topped with Belgian chocolate. The genuine ingredients and high-quality craftsmanship is sure to delight your guests.

Features


Specifications

Brand
Kirkland
Model
7

Coming in a decorative tin suitable for display or reuse, these Italian cookies are made with apricot kernels, egg whites and sugar. These are a traditional and iconic snack, mysteriously rich with the flavors of almonds and cherries, despite containing neither as ingredients.

Features


Specifications

Brand
Lazzaroni
Model

Our Cookie Tin Buying Guide

Who doesn’t love cookies? Perfect for care packages or a treat to bring to the office, cookie tins are always a welcome gift. There are so many cookies and assortments on the market, there truly is something for everyone.

While the sweet treats themselves are the star attraction when you’re buying a cookie tin, the design of the tin is part of the appeal. Look for a pretty tin that will be a nice addition to a table — or a familiar classic that everyone will recognize.

Speaking of classics, cookie tins are a great way to order a batch of your favorite cookies, such as shortbread or butter cookies.

Food products are not usually eligible for returns, so look into reviews of the seller’s packaging and shipping record. While flaky, buttery cookies are delicious, they also tend to crumble easily if they aren’t packaged carefully. The same product could be available from a different vendor who may have a better track record with packing and shipping the product carefully.

Be sure to take a moment to carefully review your final order before confirming its purchase. This is especially important if you or someone who will be partaking in the sweet treats has food allergies.

DWYM Fun Fact

The biscuit tin originated in England as part of the 1861 Licensed Grocer Act, which allowed groceries to be packaged and sold individually. The first decorated cookie tin was used by Huntley & Palmer in 1868 and resembled a small table.

While printing directly on the tin-plated steel had become commonplace, the real breakthrough in decorated cookie tin production was the discovery of offset lithographic printing. The offset lithographic process involves using a sheet of rubber to transfer a pattern painted on an ink stone to other surfaces, such as metal or porcelain.

The Cookie Tin Tips and Advice

  • Keep in mind that high-quality chocolate melts at a lower temperature than most American milk chocolate, and as such, cookies with this ingredient could melt in shipping.
  • While some cookies don’t have any gluten or nuts in their ingredients, there is still a chance the manufacturing facility had trace amounts in their assembly lines. Check this if you’re buying for someone with a nut allergy or celiac disease.

About The Author

Avatar
Danielle Smyth 

Danielle Smyth is a writer and content marketing expert based in New York. She has been writing on business and finance, home and garden, DIY, travel and tourism, and a variety of other topics for over a decade, and she holds a Master of Science in Publishing from Pace University. Danielle loves working on product reviews and helping others find the highest quality items and the best values. A self-proclaimed foodie, Danielle loves cooking, baking, and finding just the right products to make the kitchen a more enjoyable and efficient place.