Don't Waste Your Money is supported by our readers. When you purchase an item through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

The Best Peanut Butter Candy - 2022

Last updated on February 15, 2022
Best Peanut Butter Candy

Why Trust The DWYM Score?

DWYM is focused on helping you make the best purchasing decision. Our team of experts spends hundreds of hours analyzing, testing, and researching products so you don't have to.Learn more.

Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in a category.

Our Picks For The Top Peanut Butter Candies

Show Contents
Our Take
  Top Pick

Reese’s 24-Count Peanut Butter Lovers Ultimate Candy Cups

Don't Waste Your Money Seal of Approval

Reese's

24-Count Peanut Butter Lovers Ultimate Candy Cups

Overall Take

Unique ChoiceThis treat features two kinds of peanut butter.

  Runner Up

M&M’s 55-Ounce Milk Chocolate & Peanut Butter Candy

M&M's

55-Ounce Milk Chocolate & Peanut Butter Candy

Overall Take

Perfect for EverydayEnjoy these peanut butter candies for desert or as an ice cream sundae topping.

  We Also Like

Cookie Dough Bites 3.1-Ounce Milk Chocolate & Peanut Butter Candy Bites, 12-Pack

3.1-Ounce Milk Chocolate & Peanut Butter Candy Bites, 12-Pack

Overall Take

Great ChilledTry these peanut butter candies frozen or refrigerated.

  Strong Contender

Justin’s Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups

Justin's

Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups

Overall Take

Classic CombinationThese peanut butter candies are combined with milk chocolate.

Guide written by Anam Ahmed
Last updated on February 15, 2022

Peanut butter candy is one of life’s little pleasures. It’s sweet and salty, often crunchy and chewy at the same time. An explosion of flavor and texture in your mouth, it’s the perfect way to end a meal or a great pick-me-up snack in the middle of the afternoon. Whether you enjoy it with friends and family or just by yourself, it’s a sweet treat that always feels like a reward. There are lots of different types of peanut butter candy available on the market today, so how do you pick the one you’ll like best?

Consider whether you prefer the taste of peanuts on their own or if you like combining them with other ingredients. Many types of peanut butter candy mix chocolate and peanut butter together for a two-in-one treat. This classic flavor combination combines the rich sweetness of milk chocolate with the salty and crunchy flavors of peanut butter. Together, this is a combination few can resist.

Another type of peanut butter candy puts more focus on the peanuts, and highlights them with just a few ingredients such as sugar syrup. These types of peanut butter candies may have whole roasted peanuts in addition to peanut butter for an added textural crunch.

In addition to the flavor of the peanut butter candy, don’t forget to think about what kind of texture you prefer. Do you want the whole peanut butter candy to just melt in your mouth as you eat it, with a soft and gooey texture? Or do you like the contrast of soft and crunchy and want to have whole pieces of peanuts in the candy as well so you get something hard to bite down on?

The Best Peanut Butter Candies

1
  Top Pick

Reese’s 24-Count Peanut Butter Lovers Ultimate Candy Cups

Get peanut butter on the outside and the inside with this candy. It makes a great treat or desert. There are 24 individually wrapped packs in this package.

Features


Specifications

Brand
Reese's
Model
2
  Runner Up

M&M’s 55-Ounce Milk Chocolate & Peanut Butter Candy

These peanut butter candies are perfect for any day. Have them on their own for desert or as a topping on a sundae. They have creamy peanut butter and chocolate in a crunchy candy shell.

Features


Specifications

Brand
M&M's
Model
3
  We Also Like

Enhance the flavors of this peanut butter candy by having them frozen or refrigerated. They are ideal for sharing with friends or eating on your own. There is no egg in the cookie dough.

Features


Specifications

Brand
Cookie Dough Bites
Model
4
  Strong Contender

Justin’s Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups

These high-quality organic peanut butter candies are mixed with fair-trade chocolate. There are two peanut butter cups in the package

Features


Specifications

Brand
Justin's
Model
5
  Also Great

SweetGourmet Atkinson’s Crispy Peanut Butter Bar, 16-Ounce Bag

Try this peanut butter candy with a fun texture. The candy is crispy and crunchy and melts in your mouth. The candy is made with roasted peanuts and sweet syrup.

Features


Specifications

Brand
SweetGourmet
Model

Our Peanut Butter Candy Buying Guide

Peanut butter candy is one of life’s little pleasures. It’s sweet and salty, often crunchy and chewy at the same time. An explosion of flavor and texture in your mouth, it’s the perfect way to end a meal or a great pick-me-up snack in the middle of the afternoon. Whether you enjoy it with friends and family or just by yourself, it’s a sweet treat that always feels like a reward. There are lots of different types of peanut butter candy available on the market today, so how do you pick the one you’ll like best?

Consider whether you prefer the taste of peanuts on their own or if you like combining them with other ingredients. Many types of peanut butter candy mix chocolate and peanut butter together for a two-in-one treat. This classic flavor combination combines the rich sweetness of milk chocolate with the salty and crunchy flavors of peanut butter. Together, this is a combination few can resist.

Another type of peanut butter candy puts more focus on the peanuts, and highlights them with just a few ingredients such as sugar syrup. These types of peanut butter candies may have whole roasted peanuts in addition to peanut butter for an added textural crunch.

In addition to the flavor of the peanut butter candy, don’t forget to think about what kind of texture you prefer. Do you want the whole peanut butter candy to just melt in your mouth as you eat it, with a soft and gooey texture? Or do you like the contrast of soft and crunchy and want to have whole pieces of peanuts in the candy as well so you get something hard to bite down on?

DWYM Fun Fact

Grinding peanuts to eat has been around for hundreds of years, but when did it start to become commercially available in the modern world? The creator of peanut butter as we know it is actually nutritionist John Harvey Kellogg, the cereal pioneer. In 1985, Kellogg filed a patent for “food compound,” which consisted of ground up boiled nuts. This edible paste was designed for patients of a sanitarium and was meant to be easily digestible. The original food compound wasn’t limited to just peanuts, and Kellogg used different nuts including almonds. However, peanuts were the cheapest nut at the time.

Kellogg endorsed a plant-based diet, and suggested peanut butter as a meat alternative. At the time, peanut butter was considered a delicacy with an elite clientele. By the early 1900s, peanut butter was commercially available to the masses, and was an economical way to easily deal with rationed meat as a result of World War 1.

The Peanut Butter Candy Tips and Advice

  • For many shoppers, peanut butter candy is a once-in-a-while treat that is to be enjoyed in moderation. In order to help with portion control, some people prefer to get individually wrapped single-serving peanut butter candies. This way, they can just take one whenever they have a hankering for something sweet. Others prefer bulk packaging of peanut butter candy, which is especially helpful to have if you’re sharing it with friends. This way, everyone can have as much as they like. Keep in mind that individually wrapped candies often stay fresher longer.
  • Pay special attention to the ingredients list when buying peanut butter candy so you know what is in there. Keep in mind that ingredients are listed by the amount of quantity that is in the food, so the first couple of ingredients are crucial.
  • If you’re giving peanut butter candy out to others, especially young children, be sure to ask about any potential allergies. If someone is allergic to peanuts, they will not be able to eat any peanut butter candy.
  • If you find yourself always craving the combination of peanut butter and chocolate, know that it is actually rooted in biology. As a result of dynamic sensory contrast is why people love this duo. The meltiness of the chocolate combined with the crunchiness of the peanuts can be addictive!

About The Author

Anam Ahmed 

Anam Ahmed is a copywriter and essayist based in Toronto. She has been writing on technology, travel, parenting, and business for over 10 years, and works with a number of high-profile organizations. She values finding the best products to make people's lives easier. Anam earned an M.A. from the University of Toronto and a B.A.H. from Queen's University. Learn more at www.anamahmed.ca.