Don't Waste Your Money is supported by our readers. When you purchase an item through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

The Best Plaid Pencil Skirt - 2021

Last updated on November 22, 2021
Best Plaid Pencil Skirt

Why Trust The DWYM Score?

DWYM is focused on helping you make the best purchasing decision. Our team of experts spends hundreds of hours analyzing, testing, and researching products so you don't have to.Learn more.

Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in a category.

Our Picks For The Top Plaid Pencil Skirts

Show Contents
Our Take
  Top Pick

Verdusa Stretch Waist Plaid Pencil Skirt

Don't Waste Your Money Seal of Approval

Verdusa

Stretch Waist Plaid Pencil Skirt

Overall Take

Versatile OptionThis calf-length plaid pencil skirt is both flattering and professional.

  Runner Up

Floerns Slim Fit Plaid Pencil Skirt

Floerns

Slim Fit Plaid Pencil Skirt

Overall Take

Classy LookThis skirt is great for work functions or special events, with a knee-length fit that’s both flattering and classy.

  We Also Like

SheIn Mid-Rise Waist Mini Plaid Pencil Skirt

Sheln

SheIn Mid-Rise Waist Mini Plaid Pencil Skirt

Overall Take

Great for DatesThis plaid skirt can be paired with a variety of colors and types of sweaters and blouses for a winning date night or an outing with friends.

  Strong Contender

Floerns Zippered Non-Stretch Plaid Pencil Skirt

Floerns

Zippered Non-Stretch Plaid Pencil Skirt

Overall Take

Great for TeensThe stylish design of this pencil skirt makes it a fun fit for a junior’s wardrobe.

Guide written by Stephanie Faris
Last updated on November 22, 2021

The pencil skirt never seems to go out of style, even as trends change when it comes to the waistline and fit of pants. With a pencil skirt, you get a tight fit from waist to hem for a flattering, slimming look.

In some cases, pencil skirts have a high waistline. This extends the torso, sometimes giving the illusion that someone is taller and slimmer. They can be paired with a suit jacket, a sweater, or a shirt, making pencil skirts a versatile wardrobe item.

One downside to the pencil skirt is its constrictive design. Traditional pencil skirts could make you feel like a mermaid, barely able to move your legs because they were so tightly bound together. Clothing designers typically built in slits in the back to create a little extra wiggle room. Without it, you might find yourself waddling around town all day.

But today’s pencil skirts use the latest design advancements to give you a little stretch without sacrificing the slimming effect pencil skirts have always had. Modern-day versions of the trend also vary in length. You’ll find pencil skirts in traditional calf lengths, as well as miniskirt and knee-length styles.

Perhaps the best thing about today’s pencil skirts, though, is the variety. You’ll find solids, as always, but you can also choose patterned options. Plaid is a classic fabric pattern that works both for the office and a night out, but the best thing about it is that there are different types of plaid. There’s tartan, gingham, checkered, houndstooth, tattersall and more, each with their own patterns.

When choosing a plaid pencil skirt, it’s important to look for a slight taper below the hips. This will give you the figure-flattering effect you want while also offering the room you need in the hip area.

The Best Plaid Pencil Skirts

1
  Top Pick

Verdusa Stretch Waist Plaid Pencil Skirt

This eye-catching pencil skirt is both flattering and comfortable. With a high waist and a hem stretching all the way to the calf, this skirt has a length of 34.6" to 37.2" and comes in sizes from XS to XXL. It also comes in dozens of colors.

Features


Specifications

Brand
Verdusa
Model
2
  Runner Up

Floerns Slim Fit Plaid Pencil Skirt

Made from a polyester material with 5% spandex, this skirt has the stretch you need to stay comfortable while also providing a slimming effect. It’s available in a variety of patterns and sizes, from XS to 4X.

Features


Specifications

Brand
Floerns
Model
3
  We Also Like

SheIn Mid-Rise Waist Mini Plaid Pencil Skirt

Available in sizes from XS to XL, this fun pencil skirt has stretchy material and elastic closure for a comfortable fit. You can choose from multiple patterns, many of which are neutral enough to match with blouses already in your closet.

Features


Specifications

Brand
Sheln
Model
4
  Strong Contender

Floerns Zippered Non-Stretch Plaid Pencil Skirt

Although the fabric in this plaid pencil skirt doesn’t have stretch built in, it’s soft for extra comfort while you’re wearing it. The zipper closure and high waist will make it look great with any tops in your wardrobe.

Features


Specifications

Brand
Floerns
Model
5

Vfshow Pleated Waist Bowknot Detail Plaid Pencil Skirt

A fun accent bow makes this plaid pencil skirt stand out from others. It has a concealed back zipper and a slit in the back to give you freedom of movement. The skirt is knee-length with a high waist, and ranges in size from XS to XXXL.

Features


Specifications

Brand
Vfshow
Model

Our Plaid Pencil Skirt Buying Guide

The pencil skirt never seems to go out of style, even as trends change when it comes to the waistline and fit of pants. With a pencil skirt, you get a tight fit from waist to hem for a flattering, slimming look.

In some cases, pencil skirts have a high waistline. This extends the torso, sometimes giving the illusion that someone is taller and slimmer. They can be paired with a suit jacket, a sweater, or a shirt, making pencil skirts a versatile wardrobe item.

One downside to the pencil skirt is its constrictive design. Traditional pencil skirts could make you feel like a mermaid, barely able to move your legs because they were so tightly bound together. Clothing designers typically built in slits in the back to create a little extra wiggle room. Without it, you might find yourself waddling around town all day.

But today’s pencil skirts use the latest design advancements to give you a little stretch without sacrificing the slimming effect pencil skirts have always had. Modern-day versions of the trend also vary in length. You’ll find pencil skirts in traditional calf lengths, as well as miniskirt and knee-length styles.

Perhaps the best thing about today’s pencil skirts, though, is the variety. You’ll find solids, as always, but you can also choose patterned options. Plaid is a classic fabric pattern that works both for the office and a night out, but the best thing about it is that there are different types of plaid. There’s tartan, gingham, checkered, houndstooth, tattersall and more, each with their own patterns.

When choosing a plaid pencil skirt, it’s important to look for a slight taper below the hips. This will give you the figure-flattering effect you want while also offering the room you need in the hip area.

DWYM Fun Fact

A few decades before the pencil skirt came along in the 1940s, there was the hobble skirt, an ankle-length skirt that was popular between 1905 and 1910. The skirt was normal until it reached the calf area, at which point it narrowed so tightly that women could only take small steps to walk. Interestingly, hobble skirt designer Paul Poiret once commented that he had “freed the bust [but] shackled the legs.”

By the time Christian Dior introduced pencil skirts to the world, ankle-length skirts were no longer in style. This enabled him to create a below-the-knee tapered skirt that allowed women to walk somewhat normally. The timing of his skirt turned out to be perfect as it hit the market when World War II was coming to an end and people were looking for ways to save money. Full skirts were wasteful, the thinking went, and pencil skirts needed less fabric to create.

The Plaid Pencil Skirt Tips and Advice

  • No pencil skirt will fit two people quite the same. Pay attention to the measurements of any you choose. You’ll need to look at the length and the width in the waist and hip areas compared to measurements you can make yourself.
  • Pencil skirts are often associated with high waists, but this isn’t always the case. You can find pencil skirts that hang lower in the waist area if that is a better fit for your build.
  • Spandex is the key to getting the little bit of stretch you need in a pencil skirt. Look for a skirt that has at least a small amount of spandex built in.
  • Polyester is the most popular fabric in today’s dressy skirts. There’s a reason for that. Polyester is easy to care for and doesn’t wrinkle easily. It also creates a more lightweight fabric, making it more bearable in the hot summer months.
  • Some skirts can look deceptively thicker, especially online. Pay close attention to the design of the skirt. You might need to wear a slip beneath it.
  • A knee-length or calf-length skirt can give you versatility. You can wear it to work, lunch with colleagues or dinner with the family. But miniskirts can come in handy on date night or when you head out with a group of friends.
  • Pencil skirts are available in a wide range of sizes, including plus and junior sizes. If you typically wear petite sizes, you might find you need to look for a petite pencil skirt to have the hem land where it’s designed to.
  • If you’re looking for a plaid skirt that you can wear with a variety of tops and jackets, look for one in a neutral plaid like small black and white checkers or beige with subtle stripes of tan and brown. If your plaid is too bold, you might find yourself limited in the items you can wear with it.

About The Author

Stephanie Faris 

Stephanie Faris is a novelist and professional writer. She's also a wife and stepmom who lives in the Nashville, Tennessee, area. She has a passion for fashion and has been able to used that passion to write content for a variety of sites. She also writes books for young children, including the Piper Morgan series of chapter books published by Simon & Schuster's Aladdin imprint.