Don't Waste Your Money is supported by our readers. When you purchase an item through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

The Best Peanut Butter - 2022

Last updated on February 21, 2022

Why Trust The DWYM Score?

DWYM is focused on helping you make the best purchasing decision. Our team of experts spends hundreds of hours analyzing, testing, and researching products so you don't have to.Learn more.

Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in a category.

Our Picks For The Top Peanut Butters

Show Contents
Our Take
  Top Pick

Crazy Richard’s Non-GMO & Gluten Free Peanut Butter, 6-Count

Don't Waste Your Money Seal of Approval

Crazy Richard's

Non-GMO & Gluten Free Peanut Butter, 6-Count

Overall Take

Only One IngredientThis peanut butter is made from 100 percent peanuts.

  Runner Up

Justin’s Squeeze Pack Honey Peanut Butter, 10-Count

Justin's

Squeeze Pack Honey Peanut Butter, 10-Count

Overall Take

Portable SnackThese peanut butter squeeze packs are perfect for on the go.

  We Also Like

Jif Creamy Gluten Free Peanut Butter, 3-Count

Jif

Creamy Gluten Free Peanut Butter, 3-Count

Overall Take

Smooth ChoiceThis peanut butter is smooth and creamy.

  Also Great

SKIPPY Certified Kosher Creamy Peanut Butter

SKIPPY

Certified Kosher Creamy Peanut Butter

Overall Take

Classic PickThis peanut butter has a sweet and savory taste.

Guide written by Anam Ahmed
Last updated on February 21, 2022

Whether you’re the kind of person who likes to slather it on toast, mix it into a smoothie or just eat it straight out of the jar with a spoon, you know peanut butter is an important staple to have in your home. High in fiber and protein and a host of nutrients, peanut butter nourishes the body and provides you with plenty of energy to fuel your day.

There are many different types of peanut butter available, so how do you know which one to get? For many people, the decision starts with the ultimate question: smooth or crunchy? Smooth peanut butter, as the name suggests, has been blended until smooth so there are no chunks of peanuts floating around in there. It has a creamy and luxurious mouth feel. Crunchy peanut butter, on the other hand, has much more of a bite because there are small chunks of peanuts mixed in with smooth peanut butter.

Checking the ingredients list is important when buying peanut butter because this is a situation when less is more. Some people prefer peanut butter with just one or two ingredients because this means there aren’t any preservatives added. Some people like to have some added sugar to the peanut butter for a sweeter taste. Either way, ensure that no starchy fillers have been added to the peanut butter and there are as few ingredients as possible. If you want to ensure your peanut butter has healthy fats, opt for a variety that doesn’t contain palm oil or uses a healthier oil like coconut oil as a substitute.

The Best Peanut Butters

1
  Top Pick

Crazy Richard’s Non-GMO & Gluten Free Peanut Butter, 6-Count

There is only one ingredient in this peanut butter. It does not contain any added palm oil, sugar or salt. When the oil separates, it’s easy to stir back in with a spoon.

Features


Specifications

Brand
Crazy Richard's
Model
2
  Runner Up

Justin’s Squeeze Pack Honey Peanut Butter, 10-Count

If you want a nutritious snack on the go, these peanut butter squeeze packs are perfect. They contain organic honey for a sweet taste. The peanut butter is gluten free and kosher.

Features


Specifications

Brand
Justin's
Model
3
  We Also Like

Jif Creamy Gluten Free Peanut Butter, 3-Count

This peanut butter has a smooth consistency. It is made from fresh roasted peanuts. There are no artificial preservatives in the peanut butter.

Features


Specifications

Brand
Jif
Model
4
  Strong Contender

Santa Cruz Organic Dark Roast Crunchy Peanut Butter

This peanut butter has a robust and complex flavor thanks to the dark roasted peanuts. It doesn’t contain any artificial ingredients or added sugar. The peanut butter is non-GMO project verified.

Features


Specifications

Brand
Santa Cruz Organic
Model
5
  Also Great

SKIPPY Certified Kosher Creamy Peanut Butter

This classic peanut butter has a sweet and savory flavor. It is made with just four ingredients. There are no added preservatives or artificial flavors.

Features


Specifications

Brand
SKIPPY
Model

Our Peanut Butter Buying Guide

Whether you’re the kind of person who likes to slather it on toast, mix it into a smoothie or just eat it straight out of the jar with a spoon, you know peanut butter is an important staple to have in your home. High in fiber and protein and a host of nutrients, peanut butter nourishes the body and provides you with plenty of energy to fuel your day.

There are many different types of peanut butter available, so how do you know which one to get? For many people, the decision starts with the ultimate question: smooth or crunchy? Smooth peanut butter, as the name suggests, has been blended until smooth so there are no chunks of peanuts floating around in there. It has a creamy and luxurious mouth feel. Crunchy peanut butter, on the other hand, has much more of a bite because there are small chunks of peanuts mixed in with smooth peanut butter.

Checking the ingredients list is important when buying peanut butter because this is a situation when less is more. Some people prefer peanut butter with just one or two ingredients because this means there aren’t any preservatives added. Some people like to have some added sugar to the peanut butter for a sweeter taste. Either way, ensure that no starchy fillers have been added to the peanut butter and there are as few ingredients as possible. If you want to ensure your peanut butter has healthy fats, opt for a variety that doesn’t contain palm oil or uses a healthier oil like coconut oil as a substitute.

DWYM Fun Fact

Besides on toast, how can you enjoy peanut butter? It makes an excellent dip for celery sticks or apply slices – you can even dip lightly salted pretzels in peanut butter for a savory snack. For a main dish, you can stir peanut butter into a sauce for stir-frys or noodles, especially when mixed with sesame oil, soy sauce and a hot sauce. It creates a unique and complex flavor. For those who love peanut butter for breakfast, consider spreading some over warm pancakes in place of maple syrup.

The Peanut Butter Tips and Advice

  • If you frequently have breakfast on the go and like to enjoy some peanut butter to start your day, look for small individual servings of peanut butter that you can take with you. These are often squeezable packages so no utensils are necessary: simply tear open the pack and use your fingers to push out the peanut butter on to your toast.
  • If you want a more complex taste, try peanut butter that is made with dark roasted peanuts. This is a change from regular peanut butter as dark roasting the peanuts makes them taste stronger and more nutty.
  • In some varieties of peanut butter, especially those made from just peanuts, the oil will rise to the top of the jar. This peanut butter is fine to use – all you have to do is use a spoon and mix the oil back in with the solids to create a velvety texture. You can also flip the jar upside down for a few minutes to encourage the oil to mix back in with the solids.
  • Peanut butter that has been made with just nuts can be stored in an air-tight container in the fridge or cupboard for about six months. Peanut butter that has added oil can last longer, especially if unopened, for about two years. Once a jar has been opened, it should be used within three months.
  • Peanut butter can be a choking hazard for small children because it is so thick. When giving it to young kids, be sure to spread out the peanut butter in a very thin layer to limit the risk of choking, and give them something to drink along with it so they can easily wash it down.

About The Author

Anam Ahmed 

Anam Ahmed is a copywriter and essayist based in Toronto. She has been writing on technology, travel, parenting, and business for over 10 years, and works with a number of high-profile organizations. She values finding the best products to make people's lives easier. Anam earned an M.A. from the University of Toronto and a B.A.H. from Queen's University. Learn more at www.anamahmed.ca.