Palmer Classic Cast Aluminum Baking Plates Pizzelle Maker

Last updated: October 27, 2023

With a simple design free of controls and indicator lights, this iron makes a pair of cookies measuring around 4.25 inches. The durable build features iron and aluminum. It has a handle similar to manual models.

We looked at the top Pizzelle Makers and dug through the reviews from some of the most popular review sites. Through this analysis, we've determined the best Pizzelle Maker you should buy.

Product Details

Key Takeaway: This is a good option when you want something sturdy and don't want to have to deal with controls or lights.

In our analysis of 35 expert reviews, the Palmer Classic Cast Aluminum Baking Plates Pizzelle Maker placed 2nd when we looked at the top 7 products in the category. For the full ranking, see below.

From The Manufacturer

MAKES DELICIOUS CRISPY PIZZELLES – Palmer’s Pizzelle Maker Classic makes crispy, delicious pizzelles in half the time required by hand irons. QUALITY PRODUCT MADE IN THE USA – This product is manufactured in the USA in Palmer’s factory in West Newton, PA. 5 YEAR MANUFACTURER WARRANTY – Palmer offers a 5 year manufacturer warranty on the electrical components of this product. Palmer will repair the iron at no cost when shipped back to them directly (Palmer does not pay for return shipping). PRODUCT SPECIFICATIONS – Palmer’s Pizzelle Maker Classic makes two thin 4 ½”-¼” thick cookies. This product is 120 volts, 800 watts, UL listed, and is made with cast aluminum plates.

Expert Reviews

What reviewers liked

Makes very thin, crispy pizzelles. Heavy duty construction. Five-year warranty.
If you're looking for a completely sturdy, no-frills pizzelle maker, this one is your best bet. Featuring two different designs and a 5-inch cookie plate, you'll end up with seriously gorgeous cookies fit for the ~fanciest~ of parties!
Easy to use. Giftable. Durable. Premium material. Adjustable temperature control.
Simple design. Easy to operate. Yields a couple of light crip cookies at the same time. Best option for gluten-free batter.
Made in the USA, comes with a 5 year warranty, electric.
Cast aluminum body: Lightweight, durable, and easy to clean. 2 baking plates: Time-saving. 2 traditional patterns: Authentic and decorative results. Long handle: Ergonomic and heat-resistant. Fast cooking time: Cooks in 30 seconds.
Good temperature control and ease of use.

What reviewers didn't like

No indicator light. Not non-stick.
It doesn't have any special timers, so it'll take some time for you to get to know the tool.
The design is sub-par. The batter sticks on the pizzelle maker.
Make sure to measure the batter well because there is no space for overflow. Pizzelleare a bit thicker. Cast-iron is sticky whick means it's difficult to clean.
More expensive, more difficult to find.
Long heat-up time: Takes 15 minutes to reach baking temperature.
Fairly long preheat time (15 minutes) and challenging cleaning process. The batter shouldn’t stick if you follow the instructions, but if it does, the tight metal crevices are hard to clean.
View our Pizzelle Maker buying guide for in-depth advice and recommendations.

From our partners