Grillaholics Multi-Purpose Non-Stick BBQ Grill Mats, Set Of 2

Last updated date: August 18, 2022

DWYM Score


Grillaholics Multi-Purpose Non-Stick BBQ Grill Mats, Set Of 2

Why Trust DWYM?

DWYM is your trusted product review source. Along with our in-house experts, our team analyzes thousands of product reviews from the most trusted websites. We then create one easy-to-understand review. Learn more.

Don't Waste Your Money Seal of Approval
Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in the category.
Show Contents

We looked at the top BBQ Grill Mats and dug through the reviews from some of the most popular review sites. Through this analysis, we've determined the best BBQ Grill Mat you should buy.

Update as September 14, 2021:
Checkout The Best BBQ Grill Mat for a detailed review of all the top bbq grill mats.

Overall Take

The Grillaholics Non-Stick BBQ Grill Mat, Set of 2 is thin enough to retain flavor and grill marks, but also thick enough to remain durable. Consumers can use the mat on grills or baking sheets and cut them to fit the desired cooking surface. They are safe in temperatures of up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit.

In our analysis of 73 expert reviews, the Grillaholics Multi-Purpose Non-Stick BBQ Grill Mats, Set Of 2 placed 4th when we looked at the top 12 products in the category. For the full ranking, see below.

From The Manufacturer

Grill mats (also called grilling sheets and bbq grill mats) are a revolutionary new way to get better results from your grill. Made from PFOA-free PTFE (more commonly known as Teflon, and the ingredient that makes our grill mats non stick); grill mats provide a non stick cooking surface for your grill that makes grilling easier and more enjoyable. The use of a grill mat allows meat to stay tender and juicy so the flavor sticks to your food, not to your grill. They’re also dishwasher safe, making cleanup a breeze!

Expert Reviews

Expert Summarized Score

14 expert reviews

User Summarized Score

4,995 user reviews

What experts liked

These nonstick mats are a great way to extend the life of a barbecue. Easy cleanup and dishwasher-safe. Built to handle up to 500 degrees. Lifetime warranty.
- BestReviews
It can be used on any type of charcoal, gas, or electric grill, and serves its purpose well when cooking smaller foods that may otherwise fall through the grates.
- Wiki EZ Vid
Use it with full assurance of the lifetime warranty from the manufacturer.
- Paramatan
These heavy duty mats are affordable, easy to use, and non-sticky.
- Top Review Pro
You can heat them to up to 500 degrees-Fahrenheit
- Top Home Review
A 25 mm thickness allows the mat to heat up fairly quickly while still retaining a fair amount of temperature resistance.
- Seriously Smoked
The decent dimension accommodates a good amount of food, and this reduces the cooking time and effort.
- The 10 Pro
They are neither thick nor thin grill mats, but they are durable enough for heat.
- Best Brand Reviews
Don’t be discouraged that there are only two in the set, the thin yet tough mats are backed by a lifetime replacement guarantee so you won’t be replacing them ever again.
- Do Best Products
If you’re using charcoal, electric or gas cooker then the most ideal place to place the mats is at the top of the grills and the most ideal temperature that is recommended is 500F.
- Ktchn Dad
With its overall quality and durability as well as its great price, this BBQ mat deserves to be part of your top and best choices.
- Top 10 Focus
Being reversible and reusable as well as easy dishwashing cleaning are quite the features!
- Top 10 Buddy
It is thin enough to leave grill marks and flavor intact. It is designed in a way that it is also thick enough to generate ultimate heat resistance and heat durability.
- Dotbeasts
This model is also free of PFOA, silicone, or other harmful chemicals.
- Smokey Steak Ranch

What experts didn't like

Not ideal for searing or charring.
- BestReviews
Surprisingly, they are not as thick as most of the others out there.
- Top Review Pro
Your juices puddle on them and leave a mess
- Top Home Review
Less heat resistant than the Kona grill mats.
- Seriously Smoked
Consumers claim the juices puddle up on the mat and make a mess when cleaning up
- Smokey Steak Ranch

An Overview On BBQ Grill Mats

Since 75% of the individuals living in the United States own a grill or smoker, there’s a good chance that most households could benefit from a BBQ grill mat.

When shopping for a grill mat, stick with a model that is FDA certified with a nonstick surface. You want the mat to be free of harmful chemicals, BPAs and PFOAs. Otherwise, the chemicals from the mat could seep into the foods you’re grilling. A nonstick surface is also important, as it makes flipping and serving meats and vegetables a breeze.

Check the BBQ grill mat’s durability and heat resistance. Most mats are able to accommodate temperatures between 500 and 600-degrees Fahrenheit.

Review the size of the grill mat and determine whether the size can be altered. For example, you could purchase a large grill mat that can be cut to fit your grill rack. You could also purchase two small grill mats and lay them side by side to accommodate a four-burner grill.

Versatility is also important. Most grill mats can be used to line cookie sheets, cover the area around your stove burners, top the glass plate in your microwave and replace parchment paper for desserts that need to be chilled in a refrigerator or freezer.

Look for product protection in the form of a satisfaction guarantee or a product warranty. Some companies offer something as simple as a 2-year quality guarantee, while others provide an extensive 7-year no-hassle warranty.

The BBQ Grill Mat Buying Guide

  • Smaller grill mats won’t fit a two or three burner gas or kettle-style grill.
  • Thicker construction is not always better, as they take longer to heat up.
  • Don’t overlap your grill mats when using more than one, as they have a tendency to stick together.
  • Some BBQ grill mat owners report problems with flareups along the mat’s edges.
  • Never place the grill mat directly on a bed of charcoal. Grill mats should always be between 5 and 7 inches above the heat source.
  • BBQ grill mats are not the best choice if you’re looking to sear or char your food.
  • Reviewers report that some grill mats allow juices to puddle, which can create a bit of a mess.
  • While most grill mats can simply be wiped clean using a soapy dish rag, they are dishwasher safe if you don’t want to wash them by hand.
  • You can store your grill mats flat in a cabinet or rolled up in a drawer.
  • Thickness plays the biggest part in the overall price of BBQ grill mats. The Vremi Heavy Duty Grill BBQ Mat, Set of 5 costs less than the Kona 600 Degree Non-Stick BBQ Grill Mat, Set of 2, the Grillaholics Non-Stick BBQ Grill Mat, Set of 2 and the RENOOK 600 Degree Non-Stick Grill Mat, Set of 2, as it is just .2 mm thick.