Don't Waste Your Money is supported by our readers. When you purchase an item through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

The Best Weeding Knife

Last updated on August 7, 2020

We looked at the top 10 Weeding Knives and dug through the reviews from 45 of the most popular review sites including Oak Hills Gardens, Own The Yard, All Listings, Best Garden Product, Daily Gardener, BestReviews and more. The result is a ranking of the best Weeding Knives.

Best Weeding Knife

Why Trust The DWYM Score?

DWYM is focused on helping you make the best purchasing decision. Our team of experts spends hundreds of hours analyzing, testing, and researching products so you don't have to.Learn more.

Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in a category.

Our Picks For The Top Weeding Knives

Show Contents
Our Take
Experts Included
Pros
Cons
  The Best Overall

Nisaku NJP650 Hori-Hori Weeding Knife

Nisaku

NJP650 Hori-Hori Weeding Knife

Overall Take

Authentic Japanese SteelJapanese stainless steel makes this weeding knife great for tough jobs.

Experts Included
DWYM Outdoor and Garden Experts plus The Spruce, Epic Gardening, Oak Hills Gardens, Morning Chores, Knife Guides, Florgeous and 8 more. Along with user reviews from Amazon.
Pros
" The design offers excellent multipurpose function as a gardening, landscaping, and camping knife, all in one. As a bonus, it even comes with a leather sheath so you can protect the blade and attach it to your belt."
Cons
"Instead of three rivets on the handle, it only has two, which means that it’s more prone to pulling apart after months of use."
  The Best Value

Fiskars Big Grip Garden Weeding Knife

Fiskars

Big Grip Garden Weeding Knife

Overall Take

Cuts Through SoilThis lightweight weeding knife is great for loose soil.

Experts Included
DWYM Outdoor and Garden Experts plus Love Backyard, Gardener’s Path, Top 5 Reviews, North Coast Gardening, Bob Vila, Hogwired. Along with user reviews from Amazon, Home Depot and Walmart.
Pros
" I personally use this knife for slicing over sod, digging out weeds, plating, cutting threads and thick branches without worrying about hand fatigue. This is because this product is designed with ergonomics and hand comfort in mind."
Cons
"I would use this tool mostly for light-duty container or indoor gardening, as the cast aluminum blade is not especially sharp, and it suffers from “no tang.” The blade is welded onto the large, soft-molded grip, which gives it a..."

MLTOOLS Hori-Hori Weeding & Digging Knife

MLTOOLS

Hori-Hori Weeding & Digging Knife

Overall Take

All-Purpose KnifeThis durable weeding knife is equally useful for gardeners, hunters or fishermen.

Experts Included
DWYM Outdoor and Garden Experts plus Knife Guides, Daily Gardener, Pool Cleaner Blog, Top 5 Reviews, Morning Homestead, Hogwired and 2 more. Along with user reviews from Amazon.
Pros
" The blade is made using stainless steel with a mirror polish, which is resistant to rust and breaking, making it ultra-durable. The textured handle ensures a cozy, non-slip grip in any condition and ensures safe operations. Although made up of..."
Cons
"Some people do not like the hard plastic handle."

Garden Guru Hori Hori Garden Weeding Knife

Garden Guru

Hori Hori Garden Weeding Knife

Overall Take

Great GiftThe rust-resistant stainless steel full tang blade is strong and unlikely to break under pressure.

Experts Included
DWYM Outdoor and Garden Experts plus Oak Hills Gardens, Morning Chores, Florgeous. Along with user reviews from Amazon.
Pros
" Works very well as a gardening knife. Good quality and well balanced in one's hand. Great for transplanting plants, digging out dandelions, digging through clay, etc."
Cons
"No protection on the handle in case of any slippage"
Don't just take for granted what one reviewer says. Along with our own experts, DWYM analyzes the top expert reviews of the leading products and generates a score you can actually trust.
17

Products Considered

We identified the majority of the weeding knives available to purchase.
10

Products Analyzed

We then selected the leading and most popular products for our team to review.

View All Product Rankings

45

Expert Reviews Included

In addition to our expert reviews, we also incorporate feedback and analysis of some of the most respected sources including: Oak Hills Gardens, Own The Yard, All Listings, Best Garden Product, Daily Gardener.

14,088

User Opinions Analyzed

We also incorporate user reviews from the leading retailers including Amazon, Home Depot, Walmart and 6 others.

Our experts reviewed the top 10 Weeding Knives and also dug through the reviews from 45 of the most popular review sites including Oak Hills Gardens, Own The Yard, All Listings, Best Garden Product, Daily Gardener, BestReviews and more. The result is a ranking of the best of the best Weeding Knives.

DWYM is your trusted roduct review source. Our team reviews thousands of product reviews from the trusted top experts and combines them into one easy-to-understand score. Learn more.

Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in their category.

The Best Overall

Nisaku NJP650 Hori-Hori Weeding Knife

Our Expert Score
8.8
14 expert reviews
User Summarized Score
9.6
1,502 user reviews
Our Take

This weeding knife is made of genuine Japanese stainless steel which is both durable and resistant to corrosion. The wooden handle is equally sturdy, and easy to grip. The included sheath allows you to carry it on the go.

What other experts liked
The design offers excellent multipurpose function as a gardening, landscaping, and camping knife, all in one. As a bonus, it even comes with a leather sheath so you can protect the blade and attach it to your belt.
- The Spruce
It does come with a sheath and loop.
- Epic Gardening
This knife is durable and easy to use. It makes light work of weeds with long taproots, and loosens soil and earth with little effort. The stainless steel blade is sharp, make sure you don’t cut yourself when cleaning it.
- Oak Hills Gardens
Forged by master blade craftsmen from the finest Japanese stainless steel that is famous for durability, precision, and control, and it has high rust and corrosion resistant abilities, so it can withstand intense use and harsh conditions.
- Morning Chores
A solid tool designed for all types of gardening and any other outdoor tasks such as digging a hole while camping. This is perhaps due to the mix of straight and serrated edges.
- Knife Guides
One of the most authentic and sought-after digging knives, the Nisaku NJP650 is considered the standard for hori hori knives. The company promises that the knife blade was made from the finest stainless steel using Japanese trademark manufacturing techniques.
- Florgeous
Made of finest stainless steel, this knife is perfect for all kind of gardening use and also makes it super durable since this one is not open to rusting and corrosion.
- Wood Working Toolkit
The blade itself is made of genuine Japanese steel and is designed to be durable. There are inch markers on the blade and the material is easy to clean.
- Outside Modern
The blade’s grind and polish of the blade is superior and the wood handle is sturdy. It’s become an indispensable garden tool- especially when diging up weeds, digging holes in the garden, splitting perennials and cutting up sod.
- Top 5 Reviews
Comes with a plastic sheath for storage and a sturdy wooden handle, which is easy to grip.
- Popular Mechanics
It features top quality stainless steel that is corrosion and abrasion resistant to enhance on the durability of the blade and its functionality.
- Morning Homestead
Blade length of 7.25 inches which provides a good depth when digging as well as a good thickness when cutting. This product also comes with the traditional wooden handle for better and more convenient grip with using the knife.
- Love Backyard
The blade is made of Japanese stainless steel, and it’s sharper than sharp. It’s easy to clean, resistant to scratches and rust, and keeps its edge. It’s light too, making it easy to maneuver without straining your hands or wrists....
- Daily Gardener
Very solid and well-made knife that’s been forged by some of the best blade craftsmen in Japan. With its 7.25-inch Japanese stainless steel blade, that’s serrated on one side and smooth on the other, you should have no problem at...
- Organic Garden Tips
What other experts didn't like
The one drawback of this knife, discomfort during use, is probably due to the rectangular shape of the wooden handle. The flat sides and edges (yes, they are slightly rounded, but still essentially made up of four flat planes) made...
- The Spruce
Instead of three rivets on the handle, it only has two, which means that it’s more prone to pulling apart after months of use.
- Epic Gardening
Maybe adding a finger guard at the bottom the handle would stop your hands slipping towards the blade. A more ergonomic handle would also allow for longer usage.
- Oak Hills Gardens
Not very durable wooden handle. Small serrations.
- Morning Chores
Uncomfortable feel on small hands.
- Knife Guides
Does not have a safety guard or sheath protecting the hand from the blade, so be cautious and don’t let your hand slip. Also, Nisaku is only giving 2-year warranty for this product.
- Florgeous
Handle may be a little uncomfortable for people with smaller hands.
- Wood Working Toolkit
Some people report the knife is heavy or that the square wooden handle can be difficult to hold for extended periods of time, but this depends on the size of the user’s hand and their strength.
- Outside Modern
The handle is too big and feels uncomfortable on small hands
- Morning Homestead
Not very durable wooden handle. Small serrations.
- Love Backyard
The handle isn’t cushioned, so best used with gardening gloves.
- Daily Gardener
Serrations are quite small. The handle is a little uncomfortable.
- Organic Garden Tips

The Best Bang For Your Buck

Fiskars Big Grip Garden Weeding Knife

Our Expert Score
8.4
6 expert reviews
User Summarized Score
8.2
1,124 user reviews
Our Take

The dual-pointed tip makes this knife ideal for digging into weeds in loose soil. The lightweight construction makes it easy to handle in any situation. Those who suffer from sore hands will find it comfortable and sturdy.

What other experts liked
I personally use this knife for slicing over sod, digging out weeds, plating, cutting threads and thick branches without worrying about hand fatigue. This is because this product is designed with ergonomics and hand comfort in mind.
- Love Backyard
It still has the concave blade with a serrated edge on one side and a beveled edge on the other, but it tapers down with two points at the end instead of a single tip. The two-pronged tip works extremely well for weeding in soft soil.
- Gardener's Path
Handy, light, and an excellent choice for digging, planting or transplanting. Users love that the knife is sharp and easy to use, but some do note that the handle is not durable.
- Top 5 Reviews
This is the cheapest soil knife available and works well for the price.
- North Coast Gardening
Not only is the Fiskars Big Grip Garden Knife a weeder, but it also has several added features that make it a great multipurpose tool for raised beds and smaller spaces with loose soil.
- Bob Vila
What other experts didn't like
Not very sharp. Too large handle.
- Love Backyard
I would use this tool mostly for light-duty container or indoor gardening, as the cast aluminum blade is not especially sharp, and it suffers from “no tang.” The blade is welded onto the large, soft-molded grip, which gives it a weak point if you’re doing heavy duty work
- Gardener's Path
Some customers have complained that the knife snapped in two within a week at the handle and that the metal bends. Few users also note that the garden knife is not as sharp as they expected.
- Top 5 Reviews

Overall Product Rankings

Nisaku NJP650 Hori-Hori Weeding Knife

1. Nisaku NJP650 Hori-Hori Weeding Knife

Overall Score: 9.6
Reviews Included: 15

Fiskars Big Grip Garden Weeding Knife

2. Fiskars Big Grip Garden Weeding Knife

Overall Score: 9.4
Reviews Included: 12

MLTOOLS Hori-Hori Weeding & Digging Knife

3. MLTOOLS Hori-Hori Weeding & Digging Knife

Overall Score: 9.2
Reviews Included: 9

Garden Guru Hori Hori Garden Weeding Knife

4. Garden Guru Hori Hori Garden Weeding Knife

Overall Score: 9.2
Reviews Included: 5

Radius Garden 102 Ergonomic Aluminum Weeding Knife

5. Radius Garden 102 Ergonomic Aluminum Weeding Knife

Overall Score: 9.1
Reviews Included: 9

Wolf-Garten Ks2K Fixed Hand Tool Weeding Knife

6. Wolf-Garten Ks2K Fixed Hand Tool Weeding Knife

Overall Score: 9.1
Reviews Included: 4

Wilcox All Pro Stainless Lawn & Weeding Knife

7. Wilcox All Pro Stainless Lawn & Weeding Knife

Overall Score: 9.0
Reviews Included: 7

Dig Dig Japanese Hori Hori Garden Weeding Knife

8. Dig Dig Japanese Hori Hori Garden Weeding Knife

Overall Score: 8.9
Reviews Included: 2

ARS KNK-MT211 Weeding Sickle Knife

9. ARS KNK-MT211 Weeding Sickle Knife

Overall Score: 8.9
Reviews Included: 2

Corona CT 3254 ComfortGEL Weeding Knife

10. Corona CT 3254 ComfortGEL Weeding Knife

Overall Score: 8.3
Reviews Included: 4

Our Weeding Knife Findings

Nisaku NJP650 Hori-Hori Weeding Knife

What We Liked: This weeding knife is made of genuine Japanese stainless steel which is both durable and resistant to corrosion. The wooden handle is equally sturdy, and easy to grip. The included sheath allows you to carry it on the go.

Fiskars Big Grip Garden Weeding Knife

What We Liked: The dual-pointed tip makes this knife ideal for digging into weeds in loose soil. The lightweight construction makes it easy to handle in any situation. Those who suffer from sore hands will find it comfortable and sturdy.

MLTOOLS Hori-Hori Weeding & Digging Knife

What We Liked: Several features make this weeding knife well-suited for a variety of tasks. Gardeners, hunters or fishermen will find the sharp serrated edge useful for sawing or digging. The non-slip grip is well made and the markings on the side allow it to be used for measuring.

Radius Garden 102 Ergonomic Aluminum Weeding Knife

What We Liked: The curved handle of this weeding knife gives users extra leverage when digging into hard soil or tough weeds. The die-cast aluminum blade is thick and up to most any task. A thermoplastic coating makes for a comfortable grip.

Wilcox All Pro Stainless Lawn & Weeding Knife

What We Liked: This compact weeding knife is made of stainless steel that can stand up to even the toughest jobs without bending. It comes with a V-shaped tip which is sharp enough to handle stubborn weeds like dandelions. The grip is made out of a heavy-duty rubber that is easy to grip.

Garden Guru Hori Hori Garden Weeding Knife

What We Liked: A Japanese gardening knife is one of the best gardening gifts for gardeners. This weeding knife is also great for cutting, digging, sawing, planting, probing, transplanting and slicing.
The rust-resistant stainless steel full-tang blade is strong and less likely to break under pressure.

Our Weeding Knife Buying Guide

When you picture someone gardening, you typically imagine the easy, pastoral parts: planting the seeds, watering the plants. The truth is that the bulk of a gardener’s time is spent on their knees, fighting back against that persistent enemy of a healthy plant: Weeds.

That makes the right tools essential not only for the health of a garden but for the gardener’s back. And when it comes to especially tough weeds that need to be tackled at close range, there’s no tool like a good, solid weeding knife.

There are a surprising amount of tools for weeding, and not all of them are handheld knives. If you’re able to stand up and don’t need a lot of precision, there are long-handled weeders, hoes and even torches that can take care of weeds with a variety of different methods. But the weeding knife is ideally suited for plants in most household gardens, perennials and harvest plants that need a more personal touch. And as you’ll see, they are good for a lot more than just pulling weeds.

Weeding knives come in a variety of different configurations, each one shaped to tackle a variety of different tasks. The most common is the Japanese farmer’s knife, also known as a Hori Hori. From the side, this looks like any standard hunting knife, with one edge smooth and one serrated. But the blade itself is slightly concave, which makes it great for shoveling out deep-rooted weeds and digging holes for planting. And of course, it can still be used as an actual hunting knife, with all the applications that tool is used for (and more). Make sure the blade is especially sturdy since you’ll be using this one for plenty of intensive work.

While the Hori Hori is versatile, the blade is relatively short. Some common weeds like dandelions have root systems that go a bit deeper, and that’s where you’ll need an asparagus knife, also called a fishtail weeder. This tool is longer, with a V-shaped blade at the end. The tip may also be angled to allow you a little leverage when pulling up weeds. Just stick it deep into the soil beside the weed and pull back to remove the entire thing, roots and all.

If you need to do detail work on weeds that are closely entwined with your plants, consider a Cape Cod weeder. This type of tool is easy to spot, with an L-shaped blade that allows you to get in close when working in crowded gardens.

Need to pull up stubborn clumps of grass or weeds with a wider root foundation? Cobrahead weeders are less common, but they are made for this kind of grunt work. They feature a U-shaped head with a smaller blade on the end, made as much for pulling as for cutting. As with the Hori Hori knife, make sure the blade metal is durable and waterproof. Once this one starts to bend, it becomes significantly less useful.

In any of these tools, keep in mind that you’ll be using plenty of force and working in sweaty or wet conditions (and possibly both). That means the grip on the handle is just as important as the durability of the blade. If it’s a Hori Hori or other weeding tool with a long edge, check to see that it can be sharpened. Maintain your tools with the same care that you maintain that garden, and you’ll make far fewer trips to the department store.

DWYM Fun Fact

When most people hear the name Jethro Tull, they think of flute solos on classic rock radio. But some history-minded gardeners might know that he was a real person, an agricultural pioneer in 17th century England who popularized the use of the horse-drawn seed drill in the western world. Tull’s simple tool made it possible to plant in neat rows, making it far easier to weed in between the plants.

The Weeding Knife Tips and Advice

  • Hori Hori knives are one of the few gardening tools that are just as much at home in a camping kit as in a gardening shed. They can whittle or saw branches, remove small stumps and do other everyday hunting tasks, but they’re also useful around the campfire.
  • The shoveled blade is great for digging out hot coals or otherwise stoking small fires. Just make sure your handle is made of wood and not rubber, or you could damage the knife (not to mention your hand).

About The Author

Avatar
Tod Caviness 

As a professional writer for the past couple decades and a homeowner for the last seven, Tod Caviness has learned the hard way what vacuum cleaners will actually pick up dog hair and which plants will survive on a Florida patio. His favorite room: The office, with the kitchen a close second.