Proctor Silex Nonstick Deluxe Hot Sandwich Maker

Last updated date: March 23, 2023

DWYM Score

8.7

Proctor Silex Nonstick Deluxe Hot Sandwich Maker

Why Trust DWYM?

DWYM is your trusted product review source. Along with our in-house experts, our team analyzes thousands of product reviews from the most trusted websites. We then create one easy-to-understand review. Learn more.

Don't Waste Your Money Seal of Approval
Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in the category.
Show Contents

We looked at the top Sandwich Makers and dug through the reviews from some of the most popular review sites. Through this analysis, we've determined the best Sandwich Maker you should buy.

Update as March 23, 2023:
Checkout The Best Sandwich Maker for a detailed review of all the top sandwich makers.

Overall Take

This maker has flat plates that offer versatility for a long sandwich or multiple smaller ones. It's spacious enough for thick sandwiches and can cook them within five minutes. Choose from stainless steel or white colors.


In our analysis of 27 expert reviews, the Proctor Silex Nonstick Deluxe Hot Sandwich Maker placed 3rd when we looked at the top 10 products in the category. For the full ranking, see below.

From The Manufacturer

Fast and Easy to Use: Just Load Lightly Buttered or Oiled Bread With Your Favorite Ingredients, Place It in the Sandwich Toaster and Close the Lid. in Under 5 Minutes, You’ll Have a Hot, Perfectly Toasted Sandwich. Toasts Two Thick Sandwiches: The Cooking Surface Accomodates Either Two Toasted Sandwiches or One Long Sandwich. a Floating Lid Means You Can Pile Them High in the Sandwich Press and They’ll Still Cook Evenly on Both Sides. Stainless Steel: The Hot Sandwich Maker Has Stainless Steel Housing That Is Durable, Easy to Clean and Looks Great on Countertops. Easy-Clean Plates: Durable, Nonstick Ceramic Plates Are Simple to Clean. Just Wipe Them Down With a Damp Cloth Once They’ve Cooled. Compact, Upright Storage: A Lid Lock Keeps the Sandwich Maker Shut Between Uses, so You Can Store It However Is Most Convenient.

Expert Reviews

User Summarized Score

9.0
9,054 user reviews

What experts liked

Its sizable nonstick plates feature cooking plates so smooth so you’re guaranteed to get evenly toasted sandwiches every time.
- Easy Kitchen Appliances
The compact, stainless steel grill fits two regular bread slices, side by side, and thanks to a floating lid it can press sandwiches up to 3-inches thick.
- Bustle
Thanks to a floating lid design, this model can easily accomodate even thicker sandwiches.
- Best Advisor

What experts didn't like

The nonstick, ceramic plates are not removable
- Bustle
The cooking plates are prone to scratches
- Best Advisor

An Overview On Sandwich Makers

If you enjoy toasted sandwiches, using a sandwich maker is a convenient alternative to cooking them by hand. You can simply prepare a sandwich with bread and your desired fillings, put it in the sandwich maker, close the lid and have your meal ready within around five minutes. This appliance is compact enough to have in your kitchen, dorm or camper, and its versatility makes it possible to create other treats such as pizza pockets, French toast and omelets.

Sandwich makers come in various styles with different types of plates. It helps to know how many sandwiches you’ll cook, which types you prefer and how much versatility you need. You’ll also want to pay attention to the size of the machine’s plates and the maximum height your sandwiches can be, especially if you like thick bread and many fillings. The cooking time is another important consideration.

Many sandwich makers have special indented plates that make two or four triangular sandwiches. However, others have a long plate that is flat and can accommodate a few full-sized sandwiches or even one long sandwich. The flat plates offer more versatility since you can use them for other types of foods easily. You can also consider sandwich makers with swappable plates to make various types of sandwiches and even waffles.

While less common, special-purpose sandwich makers exist for cooking breakfast sandwiches such as croissants and English muffins. These have multiple plates so you cook an egg separately from the bread, meats and other fillings. The downside of these, though, is that they’re not as versatile as traditional sandwich makers.

Regardless of which sandwich maker you choose, you’ll notice some common features such as nonstick plates, automatic temperature controls and clear indicator lights. The plates are also designed to keep your sandwich fillings from leaking out and causing a mess. In addition, you can expect your sandwich maker to cook both sides of your food evenly so you don’t have the hassle of flipping your sandwich over.

The Sandwich Maker Buying Guide

  • Unless your sandwich maker is marked otherwise, only use it indoors. You should also stick with using a grounded outlet for safety.
  • Always check the sandwich maker’s plug for any defects and avoid plugging it in if you see any.
  • Place the sandwich maker on a stable and heat-safe surface and avoid locations where the maker could get wet or come in contact with something flammable. Plus, make sure that it’s out of the reach of children who could touch it and get burned.
  • When you plug in the sandwich maker, a red indicator light should show that there’s power. After a few minutes, a green indicator light usually comes on to indicate that the maker has warmed up and is ready to cook your sandwich.
  • Make sure you properly prepare your sandwich so that it cooks well. This means avoiding overstuffing it and knowing the limitations of your sandwich maker.  You can also add some butter to your sandwich’s sides if desired.
  • Most sandwich makers don’t require oiling the plates beforehand, but you can still do this if you’re concerned about your sandwich sticking.
  • To use the appliance, place your sandwich on the bottom plate, press the lid down tightly and apply the latch. Make sure you remove the sandwich once it has finished cooking so that it doesn’t get burned. Some makers will automatically shut off to prevent this.
  • It’s best to remove your cooked sandwich using a spatula instead of your hands.
  • Always unplug your sandwich maker and let it cool off before you either clean it or store it for later use.
  • Thanks to the nonstick surface most sandwich makers have, cleaning the plates is usually as simple as using a damp cloth. However, you should avoid using chemicals on it since this can cause damage. Some products make things even more convenient with parts you can remove and safely put in the dishwasher. 
  • When you’re ready to store your sandwich maker, make sure to lock the lid’s latch. This gives you the option to store it upright in a cabinet if desired.