Don't Waste Your Money is supported by our readers. When you purchase an item through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

The Best Black Sweater

Last updated on January 6, 2022
Best Black Sweater

Our Review Process

Don't Waste Your Money is focused on helping you make the best purchasing decision. Our team of experts spends hundreds of hours analyzing, testing, and researching products so you don't have to. Learn more.

Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in a category.

Our Picks For The Top Black Sweaters

View All Recommendations
Product Overview
Key Takeaway
 Top Pick

Amazon Essentials Crew Neckline Women’s Black Sweater

Don't Waste Your Money Seal of Approval

Amazon Essentials

Crew Neckline Women’s Black Sweater

This lightweight women’s sweater is made from 55% cotton, 25% modal and 20% polyester. It features a crew neckline, a comfortable yet close fit, and a ribbed collar, hem and cuffs. This Amazon-branded item is perfect for layering.

Overall Take

Beyond BasicsThis well-priced, lightweight black sweater deserves pride of place in your closet or dresser.

 Runner Up

Hanes Tagless Cotton Fleece Men’s Black Sweater


Tagless Cotton Fleece Men’s Black Sweater

Men appreciate quality-made sweaters that provide warmth and hold up to frequent wear. This 90% cotton, 10% polyester heavyweight fleece sweatshirt from Hanes does not disappoint. It's a perfect wardrobe staple for winter.

Overall Take

Keep Your Guy WarmThis sweatshirt makes a great addition to his casual wardrobe no matter where the day takes him.

 We Also Like

TownCat Large Pockets Women’s Black Sweater Cardigan


Large Pockets Women’s Black Sweater Cardigan

Designed to be worn often, this 60% polyester, 35% rayon and 5% Spandex open-front women’s cardigan looks great in black and the many other colors it comes in. It makes a cozy layer on those in-between days and pairs well with jeans.

Overall Take

So Lightweight and WearableIf you’re looking for a light cardigan for yourself or a friend, this flowy sweater is a great option.

 Strong Contender

VOIANLIMO Open Front Women’s Black Sweater Cardigan


Open Front Women’s Black Sweater Cardigan

Voianlimo’s lightweight women’s knit cardigan has a casual, relaxed design. It is made with 80% viscose and 20% nylon. It also features two front pockets, ribbed cuffs and a pretty ribbed shawl collar that runs all the way down its sides.

Overall Take

A Modern Look for HerThis cardigan with pockets is lightweight and finely knit. It can be dressed down or up with ease.

Buying Guide

Every wardrobe benefits from the versatility of basic black clothing, including tops, skirts, pants or sweaters. When it comes to black sweaters, you’ll find there is truly something for everyone.

Black sweaters can be worn anywhere, and styles can be dressed up or down as needed. It makes sense to have a selection of basic black sweaters so you’re always ready for any occasion.

One thing you’ll want to consider is the sweater’s style. Some people don’t like turtlenecks, crewnecks and other collars that sit up against the neck, but you have plenty of other choices. For example, cardigans are sweaters that have open fronts, either with or without buttons, snaps or zippers. They’re a good choice for dressing in layers.

It is also nice to have some black tops in different materials, to keep you as warm or as cool as you need to be. Coarse wool is the thickest and can feel too heavy if the weather is warm. Fine wool can be a better option but tends to be quite expensive. Alpaca and cashmere sweaters are also warm, but these can be quite pricey as well.

On the lighter side, you can choose linen, polyester, cotton or silk. Basic sweaters and sweatshirts are generally made from cotton/polyester blends, but you can also find ones made with acrylics, nylon and rayon (viscose).

Cotton, polyester, nylon and rayon sweaters are less expensive, but might not be as warm as wool and similar materials. If you see the word “fleece” in the product description, though, the sweater or sweatshirt should do a good job of keeping you toasty and warm.

A well-made and correctly-sized sweater should hug the body but not feel restrictive. To get the right size, have a friend help you measure the back of your collar to your waist for the length. To measure for sleeves, go from the shoulder blade down to the wrist bone.

Cardigans are more forgiving in width, but if the sleeves are too short or the body is not long enough, they may not look right. You may wish to size up with cardigans if you plan to wear thicker shirts underneath.

What to Look For

  • Most product pages include sizing guides, and manufacturer sizes vary by brand. Read carefully before you order.
  • You usually can’t go wrong buying someone a black sweater — unless, of course, they don’t like black.
  • To keep your black sweater looking its best, always follow the laundering directions. Some can only be hand-washed.
  • Use the right laundry detergent on your black sweaters to keep them from looking gray over time.
  • To avoid putting your black sweater in the washing machine by mistake, keep your hand-washables separated from your other clothes.

More to Explore

Black is known to be slimming, but many people wear it exclusively for other reasons. For example, someone may want to present a mysterious air or make a particular fashion statement.

One celebrity who always wore black was country singer Johnny Cash, both for practical and symbolic reasons. In his song, “The Man in Black,” he said, “I wear the black for the poor and the beaten down, livin’ in the hopeless, hungry side of town, I wear it for the prisoner who has long paid for his crime, but is there because he’s a victim of the times.”

Simon Cowell is also known for his unchanging fashion sense, but he does switch it up between black, white and gray shirts. He reportedly owns 30 black Armani T-shirts and prefers black because his white shirts get too dirty. In 2019, he wore a red shirt on an episode of “America’s Got Talent” — you can imagine the Internet chatter after that.

The “Matrix” movies, which continue to influence fashion, featured iconic all-black outfits. Comedian Richard Lewis and rock star Joan Jett were also known to only wear black most of the time.

From our partners