Sams Creek Forest Products Winfield Red Oak Fireplace Mantel

Last updated: July 25, 2022

Sams Creek Forest Products Winfield Red Oak Fireplace Mantel

Our Review Process

Don't Waste Your Money is focused on helping you make the best purchasing decision. Our team of experts spends hundreds of hours analyzing, testing, and researching products so you don't have to. Learn more.

Don't Waste Your Money Seal of Approval
Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in the category.
Show Contents

We looked at the top Fireplace Mantels and dug through the reviews from some of the most popular review sites. Through this analysis, we've determined the best Fireplace Mantel you should buy.

Overall Take

You can stain or paint this fireplace mantel to match your décor. It is easy to install and comes with step-by-step instructions. Note that mounting hardware is not included.

In our analysis, the Sams Creek Forest Products Sams Creek Forest Products Winfield Red Oak Fireplace Mantel placed 4th when we looked at the top 8 products in the category. For the full ranking, see below.

From The Manufacturer

Our Winfield series of mantel shelves incorporates an elegant dentil crown moulding into a beautiful design certain to become the centerpiece of your room. Sams Creek mantel shelves are sold “Unfinished” and are available in either stain-grade Red Oak or paint-grade Hardwood. This Winfield mantel shelf will be delivered ready for your customization, stain or paint, to match your home. A Do-It-Yourself project, this easy to install mantel shelf is available in 2 sizes: 60-inch and 72-inch, as measured across the top of the mantel shelf. We take great pride in our Sams Creek craftsmanship! Our mantel shelves are handmade in Pennsylvania and use only North American hardwood – No MDF. These USA made mantel shelves are the ideal option for the Do-It-Yourself homeowner looking for that perfect finishing touch to your room. For a full mantel-surround look, consider adding the Frederick Leg and Skirt Full Surround Conversion kit, by Sams Creek, available unfinished in Red Oak or Hardwood.

Expert Reviews

User Summarized Score

273 user reviews

What experts liked

What experts didn't like


A fireplace mantel is a great way to create a focal point in your space, bringing all eyes to the fireplace. Not only are they decorative pieces for your home, but fireplace mantels can also play a functional role as well. With plenty of options to choose from, how do you know which fireplace mantel to get?

A good place to start is the material the fireplace mantel is made from. Wood is an option some people go with as it can be painted any color, providing a lot of flexibility. Plus, you can find wood in a number of budgets depending on the grade or quality you choose. However, this material can darken over time and also needs to have a minimum clearance from the fireplace for safety reasons.

Stone is a good option if you are looking for a custom-built mantel based on your dimensions and have a big budget. However, stone is limited in the styles and color options, so you are often left with something that is fairly neutral. Stone is also more difficult to install and can also be more difficult to clean.

In terms of size, you’ll want to check what the clearance requirements are for your particular fireplace as that will have an influence on the shape and size of mantel you can have. To determine how wide the fireplace mantel needs to be, measure the width of the fireplace and then add several inches to either size to get the size of mantel you need. However, don’t just focus on the size of the fireplace. The size of the room will also be a factor in getting the right size mantel as it should be proportional to the whole space.

Buying Advice

  • When it comes to the style of fireplace mantels, you have two main options: shelves and surrounds. For an easier, more convenient and less costly option, go with a mantel shelf. This sits only on top of the fireplace and doesn’t go around on the sides. It’s easy to relocate and install. A fireplace surround goes around three sides of the fireplace as the name suggests. You have more flexibility in terms of styles and designs, but they are more difficult to install and fit.
  • Consider the depth you need based on how you want to use the fireplace mantel. For example, do you want to use it as a shelf for small decorative items, such as picture frames and vases? If so, you will need to ensure the mantel is deep enough for your items. Or do you plan on keeping it clear of clutter and taking the minimalist approach? In that case, the mantel doesn’t need to be too deep. Most mantels are between six and seven inches deep.
  • Worried a wooden fireplace mantel may be a fire hazard? High-quality wooden mantels are designed to withstand the heat from the fireplace. However, you have to ensure you install them over the minimum clearance away from the fireplace to ensure everyone’s safety.
  • Deciding on the right color for your fireplace mantel can be difficult. Consider whether you want it to be a focal point of the room or not. If you do, choose a color that stands out against the rest of your fireplace area. If not, go for something that blends in.