Safety 1st Baby Monitor

Last updated date: January 25, 2019

DWYM Score
7.7

Why Trust The DWYM Score?

DWYM is your trusted product review source. Along with our in-house experts, our team analyzes thousands of product reviews from the most trusted websites. We then create one easy-to-understand score. Learn more.

Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in the category.

We looked at the top 1 Baby Monitors and dug through the reviews from 6 of the most popular review sites including Tom's Guide, TechHive, PC Magazine, Best Reviews Guide and more. Through this analysis, we've determined the best Baby Monitor you should buy.

Overall Take

In our analysis of 40 expert reviews, the Safety 1st Safety 1st Baby Monitor placed 6th when we looked at the top 9 products in the category. For the full ranking, see below.

Editor's Note May 9, 2019:
Checkout The Best Baby Monitor for a detailed review of all the top baby monitors.

Expert Summarized Score
7.8
6 expert reviews
User Summarized Score
7.4
127 user reviews
Our Favorite Video Reviews
What experts liked
What's unique about this Safety 1st wifi baby monitor is that it also includes a wireless speaker pod that you can place anywhere in your house so you can listen in on your baby when you don't want to turn on your smart phone. This is nice during the night when you don't want to turn on your bright screen, or when your phone battery is low and you need to recharge. And the speaker pod has a battery that lasts for about 10-12 hours, so you can easily bring it into different rooms. So that's a nice added feature.
- Mommy Hood 101
Very easy to setup and very little delay for sound to stream to the two-way audio unit
- Tom's Guide
July 18, 2018 | Full review
The audio unit can run for 12 hours on a full charge. Once everything is powered up, the app guides you through a simple pairing process that in my testing worked without a hitch. The good news is it stays in quiet mode until the camera detects activity, so you don’t need to deal with ambient noise as you go about your day.
- TechHive
July 4, 2018 | Full review
Easy to install. The camera delivered sharp live video in testing, which played smoothly at 30fps. Daytime video contained rich colors, and night video appeared well lit with good contrast.
- PC Magazine
July 27, 2018 | Full review
Great video and audio quality, user-friendly, and free cloud storage.
- Best Review Guide
January 2, 2019 | Full review
What experts didn't like
So here are some things that we didn't like about this monitor: first, many times when we open the app on our phone, the live stream doesn't connect immediately - sometimes we would restart the app, and other times we'd just need to wait several seconds. That's frustrating when you just received an alert and go to see what's going on, but can't. Second, if your internet goes down you're basically screwed. Unlike the Nanit and Lollipop, it will not revert to streaming over your local area network in the event of an internet outage - so even if you're at home, you won't be able to use the app or otherwise view the video. Third, the camera has a bright little light on it, which we ended up covering with electrical tape. Finally, we found the speaker pod unusually difficult to use, and were disappointed that a charger wasn't even included with it.
- Mommy Hood 101
No humidity or temperature sensors and occasionally lost Wi-Fi connection.
- Tom's Guide
July 18, 2018 | Full review
The camera doesn’t play lullabies or soothing nature sounds, and it doesn’t include any environmental sensors for monitoring the temperature or humidity in your child’s room to help maintain their comfort.
- TechHive
July 4, 2018 | Full review
There was a trace of pincushion distortion around the edges, but it was minor. No lullabies or white noise. Lacks manual recording capabilities.
- PC Magazine
July 27, 2018 | Full review
Has no lullabies, no sensors for temperature/humidity. Not the most impressive battery life for the audio unit.
- Best Review Guide
January 2, 2019 | Full review

From The Manufacturer

Stay connected with your baby wherever you go with the Safety 1st HD Wi-Fi Baby Monitor Camera with Sound- and Movement-Detecting Audio Unit. Use your smartphone to see and hear your baby no matter where you are. Safety 1st's free app allows you to adjust sound and motion sensitivity levels, set custom alerts, and much more. The video baby monitor camera provides crystal-clear 720p HD video with minimal buffering and a 130-degree wide-angle view. A smart audio unit in the baby monitor camera is sound and motion activated and provides two-way talk with a 12-hour battery life. The baby monitor features a built-in security chip that creates a firewall between the camera and your home network for an added level of privacy and security. Record special moments from the Wi-Fi baby monitor using the app and share with family and friends via text or social media. Additional baby monitor features include 12 infrared lights for ultra-clear night vision, multi-camera expandability, and encrypted cloud storage for video and sound. Safety 1st believes parenting should have fewer worries and more joyful moments. As the first and only leader in child safety, Safety 1st is here to give you peace of mind so you can spend less time worrying and more time enjoying every first you experience with your child. Troubleshoot-check the wifi signal strength from your internet service provider. To avoid signal interference or echoes ensure that there is enough distance between your device and the camera. Use of other 2.4 ghz products such as bluetooth systems or microwave ovens may cause interference with this product. Avoid placement near major electrical equipment, large metal or concrete objects or walls. Keep the camera at least 5 feet away from these types of products or turn them off if they appear to be causing interference

Overall Product Rankings

1. Infant Optics Baby Monitor
Overall Score: 9.2
Expert Reviews: 7
2. Arlo Baby Monitor
Overall Score: 8.7
Expert Reviews: 5
3. Babysense Baby Monitor
Overall Score: 8.5
Expert Reviews: 4
4. VTech Baby Monitor
Overall Score: 8.2
Expert Reviews: 4
5. Philips Avant Baby Monitor
Overall Score: 8.1
Expert Reviews: 2
6. Safety 1st Baby Monitor
Overall Score: 7.7
Expert Reviews: 6
7. Angelcare Baby Monitor
Overall Score: 7.7
Expert Reviews: 2
8. Owlet Baby Monitor
Overall Score: 7.7
Expert Reviews: 3
9. Sony Baby Monitor
Overall Score: 7.1
Expert Reviews: 1

An Overview On Baby Monitors

As a parent or caregiver, your child’s safety is a No. 1 priority. When you can’t be in the room or are drifting off to sleep yourself, a baby monitor offers wonderful peace of mind. It allows you to be alerted as soon as your baby moves or makes a peep so you can decide if they’re just having a dream or you’re needed right away. Baby monitors today come with a variety of features and functions, but this guide will help you focus on what’s most important to you.

Baby monitors are available as three basic types: audio-only monitors, video and audio monitors and Wi-Fi-enabled video and audio monitors. There are also movement monitors, but they are usually used in addition to a video or audio monitor, not in place of one.

From a cost perspective, the more features you add, the more the price goes up. You will also usually pay more for a larger video screen or additional cameras or parent monitors. Digital monitors typically cost more but it may be worth it to you because they are also more secure as your signal is encrypted. Analog monitors can cross frequencies with nearby monitors. If you’re getting an audio-only digital monitor, look for monitors with DECT technology, which uses a lower frequency bandwidth that will give you clearer sound and more secure connection.

Audio-only monitors will pick up any sounds or noises your baby makes and alert you through a speaker. Some, like the VTech Baby Monitor, also have a sound-level indicator to let you know how much noise is coming from your baby’s room. The VTech Monitor also has an option which allows for two-way talk, so you can comfort your little one with your voice or call for help. Many times, audio monitors are more compact, have longer battery life, great range and are the most affordable. You are probably more likely to find analog options in this category so be sure to look for monitors that mention “secure transmission” or digital technology.

Audio and video monitors provide you with both a sound and visual view into what your baby is up to. No more sneaking into the room to check on noises that may be nothing! The parent monitor screen can range from small, like the Babysense Video Baby Monitor at 2.4 inches, all the way up to 5 inches. To transmit the video, you’ll set up a small camera near the baby’s crib. Some may offer mounting hardware as well. Both the InfantOptics Video Baby Monitor and the BabySense Video Baby Monitor give you the ability to zoom, tilt or pan the camera for a better view of your slumbering little one.

Most audio and video monitors also provide the two-way talk feature so you can communicate with your baby when you’re out of the room. They will also typically automatically switch from day to night mode. The BabySense has an ECO mode that switches the video monitoring off until it picks up sounds. This may also be a good option for anxious parents or those who find themselves woken up unnecessarily by the video screen.

Wi-Fi-enabled video monitors, like the Arlo Baby Monitor, are digital cameras that use your existing Wi-Fi network to send a high-quality video signal to your phone, tablet or other connected devices. You will likely get the highest quality video (Arlo boasts 1080p HD) with a Wi-Fi baby monitor. The Arlo Baby Monitor and others like it can also send alerts to your device when sound, movement or other environmental changes have occurred. This way, you don’t have to have video streaming constantly if you need to use your device for other things.

Arlo also lets you tap into other smart devices or technology you have in your house, such as Alexa or Google Home. You are usually also able to control the camera and any air or temperature sensors or features that it has from your phone or other devices. There is a slightly higher security risk with Wi-Fi-enabled video monitors, but as long as you take steps to secure your monitor and home network and don’t access the video feed remotely too often, you should be relatively safe.

Overall, the key areas you’ll want to focus on are: security, battery life, range, video and audio clarity, ease of use and set up and then decide what extras are important to you. Both the BabySense and the Arlo give you lullaby options, but Arlo lets you play your own music as well. Other added functions include things like night lights and room temperature monitoring. These features don’t make or break the usefulness of a monitor, so you’ll have to decide what you ultimately need and prefer.

DYWM Fun Fact

You may have seen news stories about baby monitors being hacked. No parent wants strangers looking in on their children, but how serious of a concern is it? The type of baby monitor really helps determine how easy it might be to hack. Digital baby monitors that are not Wi-Fi connected are certainly a better choice if hacking is a concern for you. The hacker would need to be in close proximity to the radio frequency, and many newer digital baby monitors use channel encryption, which would also need to be hacked into, making it on the whole, less likely.

Because Wi-Fi baby monitors are connected to the network in your home, which can be vulnerable, they are also more susceptible to hacking. Make sure your private network has remote access disabled, your router is updated frequently and has a strong password. It’s also a good idea to make sure your monitor is registered, able to receive security updates and can be password protected. When not in use, make sure your monitor is turned off.

Some Wi-Fi baby monitors also connect to the internet through an app that allows you to see and hear your child even when you’re not at home. In this case, the monitor manufacturer’s website could be hacked and your password could be stolen. If you really want to have remote access, just make sure your monitor is as secure as possible, as well as that you don’t broadcast the feed all the time and that you have a strong password that you change regularly.

The Baby Monitor Buying Guide

  • Even though recent American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) recommendations suggest that infants should sleep in their parents’ room for at least six months and ideally one year, you will still need a baby monitor if you want to have your own bedtime or monitor during naps.
  • Other studies suggest that babies actually sleep better and longer in their own rooms after four months. Ultimately, you’ll have to decide what is best for you and your family, but a monitor will be helpful no matter the sleep situation.
  • Always make sure your camera or speaker unit is safely placed where it will not fall into the crib or bassinet, preferably at least three feet away. Also be mindful of cords so they do not get tangled with the crib, blankets or baby. Once your child is old enough, make sure he or she knows the monitor isn’t a toy to be played with.
  • Never place your monitor near a spot where it could get wet to prevent electrocution.
  • A monitor does provide more peace of mind. However, it does not directly protect against sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS). You still need to follow the AAP guidelines, which recommends precautions such as always putting the baby to sleep on his or her back, keeping the crib free of pillows, blankets, and stuffed animals and using a one-piece sleeper.
  • When considering monitors, opt for models that include rechargeable batteries so the parent unit works when plugged in or not. The VTech baby monitor lasts for up to 18 hours. While you may not need quite that long, you’ll need at least 8 hours so the monitor can last through the night without being plugged in if need be.
  • In cases where you might need to have the volume low or muted, it’s a good idea to look for monitors that have a visual indicator that lights up when it detects sound like the InfantOptics sound-activated LED bar. Multiple levels, like the 5-bar graphic available on the VTech monitor, let you know if your baby is just sighing happily or crying.
  • Test your new monitor before the baby comes home to make sure it functions the way you expect it to. Your wireless network and the setup of your house may affect how it works in real life despite ranges the manufacturer promises. Keep your packaging and receipt just in case!
  • After you buy or a receive a new baby monitor, be sure you register it, so you will be notified of any recalls. It will also receive any necessary updates for safety and security purposes.
  • If you plan to have more children or would like monitors in more than one room, you may want to choose a monitor that can easily expand to multiple cameras that all feed into one parent unit. With the InfantOptics Baby Monitor, you can add up to four cameras to monitor with one parent unit using scan mode.