Rachael Ray Nonstick Cookie Pan Set

Last updated date: October 24, 2019

DWYM Score
9.0


Why Trust The DWYM Score?

DWYM is your trusted product review source. Along with our in-house experts, our team analyzes thousands of product reviews from the most trusted websites. We then create one easy-to-understand score. Learn more.

Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in the category.

We looked at the top Baking Set and dug through the reviews from some of the most popular review sites. Through this analysis, we've determined the best Baking Set you should buy.

Overall Take

In our analysis of 140 expert reviews, the Rachael Ray Rachael Ray Nonstick Cookie Pan Set placed 6th when we looked at the top 9 products in the category. For the full ranking, see below.

Editor's Note November 20, 2019:
Checkout The Best Baking Set for a detailed review of all the top baking set.

Expert Summarized Score
9.2
16 expert reviews
User Summarized Score
9.3
3,306 user reviews
Our Favorite Video Reviews
What experts liked
It’s durable carbon steel utilized in its construction, avoids warping. These items are also easy to clean and long-lasting.
- Listderful
February 14, 2017 | Full review
The pans have a long-lasting nonstick finish to provide excellent food release, making for easy cleanup.
- Foodal
January 13, 2019 | Full review
It is 100% easy to maintain and easy to clean and no tough time is given by it.
- Buy The Best 10
The pans have been made using carbon steel and hence warping resistant. The surfaces are nonstick to prevent food remains from holding, making cleanup a breeze. The handles have extra wide grips for a confident grasp. It is oven safe for all your baking needs. They are bold-colored for a hint of fun in your kitchen.
- All True Stuff
Pans are neither too thick nor too thin and the non-stick coating makes cleaning easy breezy.
-
September 19, 2019 | Full review
The pans themselves are made from a heavy-duty steel which resists warping.
- Kitchenistic
July 10, 2019 | Full review
The cookie pans feature bold-colored, extra-wide grippy handles that provide a confident grasp when pulling items from the oven and are oven safe to 500°F.
- My Classy Kitchen
It also has a durable carbon steel that resists warping and makes the bakeware set into a one which is long-lasting and durable.
- Top 5 Critic
They are designed from durable carbon steel material which is not only sturdy but coincidentally prevents warping. Furthermore, these cookie sheets are simple to clean and subsequently long lasting.
- Savant Magazine
Long-lasting sheet made from durable carbon steel. Resist warping. Non-stick. Set of Three, including 9" x 13", 10" x 15", and 11" x 17". Oven safe to 450 degrees Farenheit. Extra-wide grip handles. Easily cleanup. Nest together for storage.
- BestReviews
The ergonomic wide silicone handles are comfortable to hold and protect your hands from high heat. As well as featuring a super stylish dark gray color, the handles have Rachael Ray's signature bright orange color which adds a special splash of color to your kitchen. The cookie sheets are oven safe up to 450°.
- Morning Chores
The steel is highly durable, resists warping, and its long-lasting non-stick coating ensures great food release and easy cleanup. The bold-colored (agave blue), extra-wide silicone handles give you a confident grip, so you'll be able to effortlessly pull the sheets from the oven. Plus, they are oven safe to 500 degrees F.
- Best Advisor
July 25, 2019 | Full review
These non stick cookie pans are long lasting and will serve you palatable experience of cooking as gives best food release and can be easily cleaned as well. It can bear up to 450 Fahrenheit of heat. They are easily manageable and needs to be hand washed.
- Village Bakery
January 21, 2019 | Full review
The cookie pans are made of high grade carbon steel that prevents warping. On the other hand, the non-stick interior provides great food release and easy cleanup.
- BakingReview
August 31, 2016 | Full review
This masterpiece cookware from Rachael Ray features a nonstick design. It provides you with excellent food release and easy cleanup.
- Top Ten Product Review
August 23, 2019 | Full review
These cookie pans are made from long-lasting, food grade carbon steel that resists distort of shape and smoothness; long-lasting nonstick provides excellent food release and easy cleanup.
- Top Amazon Review
What experts didn't like
It does warp, but not too much to cause a concern.
-
September 19, 2019 | Full review
A bit expensive.
- My Classy Kitchen
Water can seep inside through the silicone handle pieces, causing the pan to rust. Do not use with cooking spray.
- BestReviews
It can rust if the sheets are not dried properly.
- Morning Chores
The housing loses its color over time.
- Best Advisor
July 25, 2019 | Full review

From The Manufacturer

Offering three popular-sized baking pans, the Rachael Ray® Nonstick Bakeware 3-Piece Cookie Pan Set is ideal for making both savory and sweet treats. Rachael Ray® sure know how to make baking easy and fun. These cookie pans are made from durable steel that resists warping and feature long-lasting nonstick that provides excellent food release and easy cleanup. With a small, medium, and large cookie sheet, enjoy the convenience of three sizes to do everything from roasting stuffed eggplant, broiling cheesy garlic bread, or baking Rachael’s Ranch-Style Potato Skins and yummy Kahlua Chocolate Chunk Cookies. The cookie pans feature bold-colored, extra-wide grippy handles that provide a confident grasp when pulling items from the oven and are oven safe to 500°F. As an added bonus, a portion of the proceeds from this purchase goes to Yum-o!®, Rachael’s nonprofit organization that helps kids and their parents develop healthy relationships with food and cooking. These versatile cookie pans are the perfect complement to many other pieces in Rachael's bakeware and cookware collections that always spell fun in the kitchen. Hit a sweet or savory triple out of the park with the Rachael Ray® Nonstick Bakeware 3-Piece Cookie Pan Set that includes three durable pans for creating delish baked foods.

Overall Product Rankings

1. Rachael Ray Bakeware Set
Overall Score: 9.6
Expert Reviews: 21
2. Calphalon Nonstick Bakeware Set
Overall Score: 9.6
Expert Reviews: 35
3. FINEDINE Stainless Steel Mixing Bowls
Overall Score: 9.1
Expert Reviews: 18
4. Pyrex Glass Bakeware Set
Overall Score: 9.1
Expert Reviews: 0
5. AmazonBasics Nonstick Baking Set
Overall Score: 9.0
Expert Reviews: 15
6. Rachael Ray Nonstick Cookie Pan Set
Overall Score: 9.0
Expert Reviews: 16
7. Circulon Nonstick Bakeware Set
Overall Score: 8.8
Expert Reviews: 7
8. Good Cook Nonstick Cookie Sheets
Overall Score: 8.2
Expert Reviews: 12
9. GreenLife Ceramic Baking Set
Overall Score: 7.8
Expert Reviews: 0

An Overview On Baking Set

The scent of freshly baked cookies or a cooling pie is a friendly way to welcome people into your home (having tasty treats at the ready doesn’t hurt, either!). But buying a bakery-scented candle won’t cut it — the real deal always smells better. 

Simplemost Media

Whether you’re an all-star baker or you’re just getting started with your first batch of chocolate chip cookies, the job gets a lot easier if you’ve got the right tools. Bakeware like cookie sheets, cake pans, loaf pans and muffin pans will turn your raw dough into mouthwatering creations. Having a reliable set of mixing bowls and glass bakeware for oven cooking and food storage helps every step go smoothly.

First things first: learn the function of every piece of bakeware to determine what you need in your kitchen. Cookie sheets have many possibilities; it’s smart to buy several of them. You can obviously use them to bake up sweet and soft snickerdoodles or smiling gingerbread men, but cookie sheets have their place in the savory world as well.

Simplemost Media

You can spread veggies like brussels sprouts, beets and carrots across them, then toss the cookie sheet in the oven for warm roasted vegetables. Cookie sheets also serve as a platform for baked fish or chicken, and you can cook pizzas on them to save your oven from pesky crumbs.

The best cookie sheets (or baking sheets) are made from heavy-duty steel or aluminum. Nonstick baking pans are covered with Teflon or other coatings that prevent food from sticking. 

Round cake pans and square cake pans are designed for just that: creating round or square cakes. You can use more than one to create layered cakes for birthdays and other special events, or just stick to one layer for tasty simplicity. Cake pans are usually made from aluminum or another metal, and they’re often covered in nonstick coating. 

Simplemost Media

Loaf pans are cake pans’ rectangular cousins. They’re handy for making quick breads, like banana bread or beer bread. They’re also made from metal and usually covered in Teflon. 

Muffin pans will help you create batches of six, nine or twelve delicious muffins or cupcakes. They have a similar construction to other types of baking pans. Muffin pans can also be used to whip up egg bites that you can grab on busy mornings and other savory treats. 

Simplemost Media

Of course, you can’t get started on your baking journey without some mixing bowls. Mixing bowls come in a variety of sizes, materials and colors. Stainless steel bowls, like FINEDINE Stainless Steel Mixing Bowls, are built to last, and you can use them to mix food at almost any temperature. Many are also refrigerator, freezer and dishwasher safe. You’ll want a mixing bowl set with a wide range of sizes, from ¾ quart to eight quarts. Bowls that nest inside of each other will save you cabinet space, and bowls with flat bottoms will keep your doughs and icings safe as you blend them. 

Glass bakeware, like the Pyrex Glass Bakeware Set, is great for cooking up brownies, casseroles and other oven-friendly treats. It’s extra handy because you can take it straight from the oven to the fridge for storage. Many glass bakeware sets also come with locking lids, which will keep your baked goods fresh for days or weeks. Look for heavier glass containers with microwave and freezer-safe lids if you want to take advantage of those benefits.

Now that you’ve got a handle on the basics of baking sets, you can read up on specifics in our Tips & Advice.

DYWM Fun Fact

The phrase “let them eat cake” is commonly attributed to Marie Antoinette, the last Queen of France before the French Revolution. She supposedly said it during a famine that happened when her husband, Louis XVI, was running the country. She was told that France’s poorer citizens were suffering from bread shortages, and said “let them eat cake.” This cemented the notion that the French upper class was completely oblivious to the needs of people in lower socioeconomic tiers.

The only problem with the story is that there’s no record of Marie Antionette actually saying that phrase. There were no famines during her husband’s reign. One biographer claims that it was said 100 years before by Louis XIV’s wife, Marie-Thérèse. Other historians note that the saying doesn’t line up with Antionette’s personality, since she was a generous donor to charitable causes and well aware of the plight of France’s poor citizens. 

Regardless of who said it, “let them eat cake” was an accurate summation of how most of France’s ruling class remained willfully ignorant or were outright hostile to the needs of the rest of the country’s citizens.

The Baking Set Buying Guide

  • Consider what type of baking you enjoy doing the most. Are you mad about muffins? Look for a set with a larger muffin pan. Do quickbreads make your heart sing? Check for bakeware sets with one or more loaf pans. 
  • Budget is always one of the first considerations. If you’re baking frequently, feel free to spend a little more on a comprehensive baking set that meets all of your needs. If you’re just getting started, a smaller set makes more sense. 
  • Many baking sets don’t include mixing bowls, so take that added cost into account when you’re shopping. 
  • If you love brownies, you’ll want to add some glass bakeware to your kitchen arsenal. This bakeware is also ideal for savory meals and storage.
  • Take care of your Teflon! If you don’t, your nonstick baking set will lose its nonstick qualities and some of the Teflon might chip off into your food. To keep your Teflon in tip-top shape, avoid using metal utensils. Silicone spatulas, whisks, turners, spoons and ladles are affordable and hold up better than plastic. The Rachael Ray Bakeware Set even boasts silicone grips. 
  • Wait for your nonstick bakeware to cool completely before washing them. Even if the bakeware is marked as dishwasher safe, like the Calphalon Nonstick Bakeware Set, it’s better to hand wash them to prevent wear and tear from high temperatures. Wash them with dish liquid and use scratch-proof scouring pads and sponges. 
  • Avoid using lots of acidic ingredients in your nonstick bakeware. Acidic ingredients promote flaking. 
  • Store your bakeware properly between uses. Avoid stacking nonstick bakeware directly on top of each other. Instead, store them with a layer of paper towel between each pan to prevent scratches. You’ll also want to keep them away from any sharp utensils like knives or tongs.