Nostalgia Iced Coffee Maker and Tea Brewing System

Last updated date: September 21, 2019

DWYM Score
7.7


Why Trust The DWYM Score?

DWYM is your trusted product review source. Along with our in-house experts, our team analyzes thousands of product reviews from the most trusted websites. We then create one easy-to-understand score. Learn more.

Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in the category.

We looked at the top Iced Tea Makers and dug through the reviews from some of the most popular review sites. Through this analysis, we've determined the best Iced Tea Maker you should buy.

Overall Take

In our analysis of 124 expert reviews, the Nostalgia Nostalgia Iced Coffee Maker and Tea Brewing System placed 9th when we looked at the top 9 products in the category. For the full ranking, see below.

Editor's Note November 7, 2019:
Checkout The Best Iced Tea Maker for a detailed review of all the top iced tea makers.

Expert Summarized Score
7.5
15 expert reviews
User Summarized Score
8.1
472 user reviews
Our Favorite Video Reviews
What experts liked
Designed with a stylish construction and shape, the Nostalgia CI3BK comes equipped with 2 coasters made of durable silicone that make it a great gift item. Thanks to its compact size, this tea and coffee maker can easily fit into your refrigerator door and is very space efficient. Made from top grade materials, this 4 in 1 device can be utilized as a coffee pot, a fruit infuser, and ice coffee and ice tea maker. Featuring a glass pitcher made from borosilicate with a robust grip made of silicone, it also features a coffee filter made from sturdy stainless steel and a nontoxic, plastic air tight lid.
- Savant Magazine
The pitcher that comes with the machine has a lid that can be set in three different ways according to your convenience. It can be set to allow pouring the contents into your glass including the ice cubes, to pour tea into your glass excluding the ice cubes, or to keep the lid tightly closed to prevent any spilling. The machine will turn itself off automatically when the brewing process is complete, which means you can go and focus and other things once the machine is on and have started making your iced tea. Another handy feature of this iced tea maker is that it has a built-in compartment for neatly storing the power cable inside the machine, which helps you to store the machine safely without any cables dangling out of it.
- Food Shark Marfa
A fine mesh filter in the brewing baasket is perfectly suitable for all types of tea and coffee grind sizes. You can be sure no tea leaves or coffee grains will get into the pitcher.
- Best Advisor
June 26, 2019 | Full review
This product is capable of brewing any of your favorite iced drinks, not just teas. Whether you like sweet tea or an iced latte, this is the machine for you. It has the ability to brew loose leaf, grounds or bags, and it will be chilled in minutes.
- Review Best Seller
It produces plentiful measure of frosted tea that is sufficient for everybody because of its three-quart glass pitcher with handle. This item includes three-position cover that turns for easy pouring, enabling you to pour even with the lid on.
- Village Bakery
June 1, 2019 | Full review
With the strength selector dial present, you get to dictate how good the quality of your beverage is going to be. Quite convenient if it's going to be used by a lot of people
- Homegearsreview
January 26, 2019 | Full review
This is one of the best iced tea makers to buy on a budget. From its versatility to its attractive design it does just about everything you would expect from and iced tea maker and more. It has a 3 quart glass pitcher, a reusable brew basket, and the ability to tuck the cord into the machine for storage. The strength selector is in the form of an easy to read dial ranging from 1-8 on the front of the machine, along with a power button. The pitcher lid is secure and has 3 settings, free pouring, ice guard and closed.
- Top N Best Reviews
It is very easy to use and even allows you to add lemon, herbs, and sweeteners in order to take the flavor of your iced tea to the next level. The brewing system also boasts a 3-position lid that turns to allow free pouring. Besides, it has a 3-quart glass pitcher, which comes with a large handle to make it easy to hold when pouring tea. Its strength selector dial ranges from 1 – 8, so you can easily choose the desired flavor strength for your favorite tea. The Nostalgia CI3BK Iced Coffee & Tea Brewing System is an innovative unit that will make your work easier.
- All Best Tops
The pitcher is very beautifully shaped and additionally includes a uniquely shaped handle to make serving your iced tea a delight every time. More of its impressive features include a brew strength selector, a reusable filter basket that makes it able to brew bagged tea, loose-leaf tea, and coffee. It also features a three-position lid that makes it one of the best iced-tea makers and allows either for free pouring, pouring with ice, or simply closed. Nostalgia backs it with a 1-year limited warranty.
- Home Gear X
The 3 quarts pitcher is made of glass, which keeps the flavor and ergonomically designed with a large handle and is dishwasher safe. Another feature is the three-positions you can do with the lid. You can choose free pouring, with ice or closed.
- EatrBox
June 2, 2019 | Full review
One of the great things about this machine is the fact that it is so versatile. The Nostalgia CI3BK Iced Coffee Maker and Tea Brewing System can also be used to create iced coffee. Latte lovers are also sure to be satisfied by this top of the range machine.
- Chef's Resource
July 25, 2019 | Full review
It has a shower head design that completely saturates everything in the filter basket and provides you with 3 quarts of your favorite cold beverage. It even has an auto shutoff feature when the brewing is complete and the cord can be stored away when not in use.
- Geek Wrapped
It’s so incredibly easy to use. Put your tea leaves, tea bags, or even ground coffee, plus enhancers, into the filter basket.
- Cooking Matt
June 6, 2019 | Full review
Smart and sleek design to complement your space
- Ah Joo
Brews gourmet Iced Coffee, Iced lattes, Iced tea and more. It comes with a strength selector dial
- Review Fantasy
April 9, 2019 | Full review
What experts didn't like
​The pitcher is made of glass and has to be handled carefully .
- Food Shark Marfa
There is no light indicator.
- Best Advisor
June 26, 2019 | Full review
The glass pitcher may be a little too thin hence cracks after a while.
- Homegearsreview
January 26, 2019 | Full review
It cant brew hot beverages, this machine is for iced or cold brewing only. The glass carafe is on the thin side and can not be replaced without buying a whole new iced tea maker. The carafe is hand wash only, the glass is not tempered and it is easy to crack, or shatter. The cord is shorter than you would expect on an iced tea maker, so outlet will have to be very close to where you’d like to place the iced tea maker. Finally, while the cord tucks away for easy storage, the overall shape of this device is awkward and causes it to be bulky when storing it.
- Top N Best Reviews
The system may arrive with a few defects, but the manufacturer always helps out.
- All Best Tops
It's costlier than most others. Glass will break if it falls
- Home Gear X
The glass pitcher is thin and cannot withstand the prolonged exposure to hot and cold liquid.. The lid is not secure; you have to hold it while pouring.
- EatrBox
June 2, 2019 | Full review
The glass pitcher is a little fragile.
- Chef's Resource
July 25, 2019 | Full review
The glass pitcher needs gentle care
- Cooking Matt
June 6, 2019 | Full review
Some parts are quite delicate. It requires a lot of ice to cool down.
- Ah Joo

From The Manufacturer

Looking for an easy way to create your favorite Iced beverages? if so, the Nostalgia cafe ice Iced Coffee & tea brewing system is for you. This handy appliance will brew Iced Coffee, Iced lattes, ice teas, sweet teas and more! it has a removable filter basket that brews bags, Leaves or fresh ground Coffee and 3-quart glass pitcher. You will be chilling in minutes!.

Overall Product Rankings

1. Takeya Cold Brew Iced Coffee Maker
Overall Score: 9.2
Expert Reviews: 26
2. Mr. Coffee 2-Quart Iced Tea & Iced Coffee Maker
Overall Score: 8.9
Expert Reviews: 35
3. Mr. Coffee 3-Quart Iced Tea and Iced Coffee Maker
Overall Score: 8.8
Expert Reviews: 7
4. Ovalware Cold Brew Iced Tea & Coffee Maker
Overall Score: 8.7
Expert Reviews: 8
5. Tartek Large Cold Brew Iced Coffee & Tea Maker
Overall Score: 8.4
Expert Reviews: 2
6. Komax Iced Tea Maker
Overall Score: 8.0
Expert Reviews: 6
7. Mr. Coffee Adjustable Iced Tea Maker
Overall Score: 8.0
Expert Reviews: 4
8. Mr. Coffee 3-Quart Adjustable Brew Iced Tea Maker
Overall Score: 7.8
Expert Reviews: 6
9. Nostalgia Iced Coffee Maker and Tea Brewing System
Overall Score: 7.7
Expert Reviews: 15

An Overview On Iced Tea Makers

On a hot summer day, there is nothing quite like a freshly brewed glass of iced tea. This caffeinated beverage is simple to make with the right tools, and it can be tailored to the tastes and sweetness desired by the maker. Having an iced tea maker handy will allow you to brew up a large batch in a short time so that you can sip on it at your leisure.

Kristin Forte/Simplemost Media

The art of brewing tea has been honed by humans for thousands of years. Though methods of steeping tea leaves in water vary slightly, the idea is the same. A simple glass carafe, like theTakeya 10310 Patented Deluxe Cold Brew Iced Coffee Maker with Airtight Lid & Silicone Handle, is an example of basic brewing methodology at work. There is a metal mesh filter that hangs down into the carafe and holds the tea leaves (or coffee grounds for those looking to make iced coffee). The entire volume of water slowly turns into the nice earthy brown color that you want. This process is similar to steeping a tea bag into a hot cup of water, only it’s done at a larger scale and doesn’t necessarily require heat. If you use hot water or cold, the time it takes to brew can be different, so be sure to find the recipe that suits your needs the best.

If you like the simplicity of the large carafe with a built-in filter, there are some similar products that have features that might be attractive. If you like having tea available but don’t drink it very fast, you could look at finding an iced tea maker that has a sealable lid, like the Takeya 10310 Patented Deluxe Cold Brew Iced Coffee Maker with Airtight Lid & Silicone Handle. This option will let you keep the tea fresh for up to two weeks, letting you take your sweet time in finishing it. It doesn’t hurt that this tea maker also looks like a beaker from your high school chemistry class, bringing a touch of modern design to your refrigerator contents.

Kristin Forte/Simplemost Media

Some of you might look at these smaller glass carafes and think that they’re not big enough for your needs. If you are making tea for a large group of family or friends, or maybe you just want to have a lot of tea for yourself, there are iced tea makers that focus on brewing a bigger quantity.  For a 2-quart option, the Mr. Coffee 2-Quart Iced Tea & Iced Coffee Maker works a lot like a countertop coffee maker. The pitcher has a built-in top section that holds a filter similar to a coffee filter, but the contents of the filter will be your loose tea leaves. Set this up to brew, and it heats up water before pouring it through the filtered leaves. For those who like to sweeten their tea, add your sugar or sweetener while the tea is still hot for good results. 

Is 2 quarts still not enough tea? Well, you might want to think bigger with the Mr. Coffee 3-Quart Iced Tea and Iced Coffee Maker, which works in a similar fashion to the smaller version. Size isn’t everything though, and this large pitcher also adds in useful features, like a wide, durable handle that lets you confidently lift the heavy pitcher.

Kristin Forte/Simplemost Media

Beyond the size of the carafe or pitcher used in these iced tea makers, look for some other features that appeal to you. It’s okay to use the plastic pitchers that come with the larger tea makers, but most of us like to store our tea in a glass container of some sort if we aren’t planning on consuming it right away. If you find yourself in this category, you’ll either want to think about purchasing a separate glass carafe to hold your leftover tea, or maybe purchase a tea maker that comes with that feature right from the start.

Hauling a large quantity of tea is easier to do when your carafe or pitcher has a solid handle that’s wide enough to distribute the weight comfortably in your hand. A large plastic handle on a  glass carafe can give you a comfortable grip, but a slender integrated glass handle might give you the sleek look you want. Figure out what works best for your needs and know that any of these iced tea makers are bound to leave you satisfied with your purchase.

Kristin Forte/Simplemost Media

DYWM Fun Fact

Behind water, tea is the number one most consumed beverage in the world. More tea is consumed than every other manufactured drink that is made today, including alcohol, coffee and soft drinks. That is quite a testament to the popularity of this East Asian drink, which dates back to the 3rd century AD.

The Iced Tea Maker Buying Guide

  • Iced tea and iced coffee are very similar products and almost identical in their brewing process. If you’re a cold-brewed coffee lover, in addition to being an iced-tea drinker, keep that in mind since this product will serve you well in both cases. If you like your new iced tea maker enough, you might even find yourself adding a second one to your cart so you can have both of these cold brews on hand at all times.
  • Cold-brewing tea and hot-brewing tea are going to yield generally similar results, but there are consumers out there who prefer one to the other. If you like cold-brewing your iced tea (which means you let the cold or room-temperature water brew more slowly in a cold setting), focus on products that don’t require heated water. A simple glass carafe with a filter gives you the most control over your final product.
  • Think about your storage requirements as well. A product like the Mr. Coffee tea brewing machines will take up a small amount of counter or cabinet space when not in use. This is just something to keep in mind for those who don’t have a lot of free space in their kitchen.