My First Crib Mattress

Last updated date: April 9, 2019

Review Melt Score

Why Trust The Review Melt Score?

Review Melt is the #1 product review aggregator. Our team analyzes thousands of product reviews from the most trusted websites. We then "melt" them into one easy-to-understand score. Learn more.

Look for the Review Melt seal for products that are the best in the category.

We looked at the top 1 Crib Mattresses and dug through the reviews from 4 of the most popular review sites including The Sleep Judge, BestReviews, The Bump, Sleep Reports and more. Through this analysis, we've determined the best Crib Mattress you should buy.

Overall Take

In our analysis of 40 expert reviews, the Kittrich Bedding My First Crib Mattress placed 5th when we looked at the top 9 products in the category. For the full ranking, see below.

Editor's Note April 15, 2019:
Checkout The Best Crib Mattress for a detailed review of all the top crib mattresses.

Expert Summarized Score
4 expert reviews
User Summarized Score
750 user reviews
Our Favorite Video Reviews
What experts liked
They have created this mattress with the child in mind, not the profits.
- The Sleep Judge
Boasts a 10 year warranty.
- BestReviews
Its cover is both waterproof and washable, and parents rave about how well their babies are sleeping on it.
- The Bump
Babies inevitably come with spills and leaks, so it’s great that you can wash the cover easily to keep it fresh and sanitary.
- Sleep Reports
What experts didn't like
May be too firm for baby.
- The Sleep Judge
Not as thick as some customers expected and they also found it to be slightly too short for some cribs.
- BestReviews
Too firm for toddlers.
- Sleep Reports

From The Manufacturer

My First was created to help promote restful sleep while understanding that your child is not the same size as an adult. They need the proper size to achieve the same good nights sleep to promote growth and learning. We utilize space age technology of Memory Foam to provide the head and neck support and align the body in a natural position. All of our memory foam pillows are made of the highest quality materials and meet or exceed all current codes and standards.Size: 51 5/8” x 27 1/4” x 5”. 5” memory foam crib mattress. Waterproof cover. Designed with square corners for a snug fit in the crib. Hypoallergenic, mite-proof. Phthalate and lead free. Removable and washable cover.

Overall Product Rankings

1. Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Crib Mattress
Overall Score: 9.6
Expert Reviews: 7
2. Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Crib Mattress
Overall Score: 8.6
Expert Reviews: 6
3. Sealy Soybean Foam Crib Mattress
Overall Score: 8.5
Expert Reviews: 4
4. Naturepedic No Compromise Organic Crib Mattress
Overall Score: 8.2
Expert Reviews: 4
5. My First Crib Mattress
Overall Score: 8.1
Expert Reviews: 4
6. American Baby Company Crib Mattress
Overall Score: 8.0
Expert Reviews: 3
7. Graco Premium Foam Crib Mattress
Overall Score: 8.0
Expert Reviews: 3
9. Milliard Crib Mattress
Overall Score: 7.7
Expert Reviews: 2

An Overview On Crib Mattresses

Review Melt Fun Fact

The Crib Mattress Buying Guide