Hamilton Beach Electric Indoor Grill

Last updated date: January 13, 2020

DWYM Score
9.4


Why Trust The DWYM Score?

DWYM is your trusted product review source. Along with our in-house experts, our team analyzes thousands of product reviews from the most trusted websites. We then create one easy-to-understand score. Learn more.

Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in the category.

We looked at the top Indoor Electric Grills and dug through the reviews from some of the most popular review sites. Through this analysis, we've determined the best Indoor Electric Grill you should buy.

Overall Take

The Hamilton Beach Electric Indoor Grill allows high-heat searing, which gives you delicious, crisp outer surfaces while still maintaining the inner juicy core. You'll get an overall better taste, texture and appearance using this grill. You can remove both the grill plate and drip tray and slip them in the dishwasher for easy cleanup. In our analysis of 139 expert reviews, the Hamilton Beach Hamilton Beach Electric Indoor Grill placed 1st when we looked at the top 7 products in the category. For the full ranking, see below.

Editor's Note March 18, 2020:
Checkout The Best Indoor Electric Grill for a detailed review of all the top indoor electric grills.

Expert Summarized Score
8.3
19 expert reviews
User Summarized Score
8.8
3,335 user reviews
Our Favorite Video Reviews
What experts liked
Lack of smoke makes it a great option for those who live in areas that prohibited charcoal grills. Large grease catcher and dishwasher friendly, removable cooking plate make this grill a delight to clean.
- BestReviews
You can enjoy meat at its best quality because of the highest temperature soaring which helps lock the juice inside the meat. It is very easy to use, the indicator light helps to tell you when the grill is ready to use.
- Buy Me Top 10
The grill is pretty easy to clean and comes with a removable and dishwasher safe drip tray. It also features a removable grill plate which is also dishwasher safe.
- All Top Ratings
With an adjustable heat setting that includes an extra-high temperature ‘searing’ setting, this indoor grill promises to deliver outdoor grilling results, sealing in flavor and keeping your meat juicy and tender.
- Improb
The construction of the grill is such that it is removable. Moreover, it consists of a drip pan which will collect all the oil as well as the juices which flow through. You can remove and clean it whenever you want.
- Globo Grills
Thanks to the high-heat searing temperature, this little grill locks in all the juice and flavor, giving your meat a better taste, texture, and appearance.
- Healthy Kitchen 101
Capable of fitting up to 8 servings at once, the Hamilton Beach 25361 Electric Indoor Searing Grill is the best indoor electric grill we’ve had the joy of using.The 118 square inches of cooking area can fit around 6 burgers, up to 3 steaks, and even up to 6 large chicken breasts!
- Outside Pursuits
Comes with a convenient window that let you see the progress of food.
- The Best A-Z
The lift handle takes safety another step by protecting your hands from getting burnt under high temperatures.
- Trustorereview
This searing grill is very easy to use. You just need to turn the heat dial all the way up to sear. The preheat takes mere 2 minutes, and when the appliance reaches the highest temperature of 450 degrees F, the green indicator light informs you that the grill is ready to sear steaks or burgers to perfection.
- Best Advisor
Has the ability to catch spills and oil using the drip tray.
- BBQ Queens
Easy to use and easy to clean, the Hamilton Beach Electric Indoor Grill is a straightforward and user friendly model of indoor grill that allows easy control over cooking your food perfectly.
- Best of Machinery
This machine is made out of stainless steel, extending its possible life, and it only weighs 8 pounds, making it easy to move in and out of storage.
- Grill Guru
It comes with the removable grill plate for your convenience. Also, there is a drip tray with it. Whenever some juices or something release from the grill, it captures it to avoid the mess.
- Reviewprous
All parts are removable to enhance easy cleaning.
- Put Product Reviews
Its highest temperature is 450 degrees for fast grilling, and also you can adjust the temperature using the adjustable dial according to your need.
- TrustedHints
Its parts are removable, making it easy to clean and is dishwasher friendly.
- PProReviews
It is easy to clean. Both the grill surface and the trickle plate are removable and dishwasher safe. Likewise, the grill spread can also be ejected for washing hands.
- Best Product Buff
There will be no mess in the drip pan.
- BBQ Grills Reviews
What experts didn't like
Build quality is questionable. Its not a grill you can open and close multiple times while cooking without lowering the temparature.
- BestReviews
The window is not removable and a bit hard to clean.
- All Top Ratings
Not smokeless.
- Globo Grills
It has no handle.
- Healthy Kitchen 101
It requires a preheat before placing your food to cook.
- The Best A-Z
It would have been better if the window could be removed for cleaning.
- Trustorereview
Rather short power cord.
- Best Advisor
Needs preheating first before the actual cooking process.
- BBQ Queens
Can take a long time to cook meat.
- Grill Guru
The grill smokes a little bit which you wouldn’t like.
- Reviewprous
The Teflon does not stay in place.
- Put Product Reviews
Warranty is only for 1 year.
- BBQ Grills Reviews

From The Manufacturer

Hamilton Beach Indoor Grill makes healthy grilling at home a breeze. Temperature setting, dishwasher safe plates & drip tray. Adjustable temperature control ranges from 200 degree to high searing temperature of 450 degree

Overall Product Rankings

1. Hamilton Beach Electric Indoor Grill
Overall Score: 9.4
Expert Reviews: 19
2. Maxi-Matic Indoor Electric Nonstick Grill
Overall Score: 9.3
Expert Reviews: 14
3. George Foreman Indoor/Outdoor Electric Grill
Overall Score: 9.1
Expert Reviews: 22
4. Cuisinart 5-in-1 Griddler
Overall Score: 9.0
Expert Reviews: 21
5. Hot Shot Smokeless Grill Indoor Electric Grill
Overall Score: 8.9
Expert Reviews: 9
6. Simple Living Products Indoor BBQ Grill
Overall Score: 8.9
Expert Reviews: 8
7. Presto Cool Touch Electric Indoor Grill
Overall Score: 8.8
Expert Reviews: 27

An Overview On Indoor Electric Grills

Grilling out is great, but unless you live in an area of the world where the weather is always warm, you probably don’t even think about it during the chilly winter months. Even when temperatures are high, though, rain and heavy winds can keep you inside, hampering your plans for delicious burgers and steaks.

Electric grills have opened up the option of grilling indoors, allowing you to make delicious meals no matter what the weather outside is like. You can set up your grill on your counter and cook the same meats, poultry, kabobs and other items that you would make outdoors during nice weather. But the taste of your meat will vary based on the design of the grill, so it’s important to pay attention to that build while you’re shopping.

Getting the outdoor grill taste with an electric grill can be challenging, though. One of the best ways to achieve that smoky flavor is through the use of items like liquid smoke, which can help nature along. You’ll also find that the design of the grill itself plays an important factor in how your items taste. Look for a grill with technology that provides an even cooking surface to ensure consistency.

You’ll also find many indoor grills have cooking plates made from porcelain-enameled cast iron. Although this material packs plenty of benefits, it can take longer to heat up, sometimes forcing you to wait at least 10 minutes for the surface to get warm enough for you to start cooking. You may also find some indoor grills cut on and off while cooking, but this is simply a self-regulating feature that ensures the cooking is even.

Another important factor in an indoor grill is temperature control. If you cook using recipes or other instructions, you’ll want a grill that will let you set a specific temperature and leave it. You’ll often find that indoor grills have only a selection of temperatures rather than a range. So instead of being able to dial your grill to 425 degrees, you might find you have to choose either 355 or 445.

DYWM Fun Fact

If you enjoy throwing food on the grill, you’re in good company. Politicians have held outdoor barbecues as networking events since the Colonial Times. George Washington hosted a barbecue party while running for the House of Burgesses in the mid-1700s, and many other politicians followed. But it wasn’t until the 1960s that outdoor barbecues made their way to the White House. The first barbecue on the lawn of the White House was hosted by President Lyndon Johnson as a way to thank supporters, with a menu that included barbecue ribs. But perhaps the most notable White House barbecues were held by President Jimmy Carter, who held a State Dinner with Japan’s prime minister that involved grilling pigs, steak and chicken on the rooftop terrace off the State Dining Room.

The Indoor Electric Grill Buying Guide

  • Cleanup is an important consideration with any surface that will handle messy foods. You’ll find a nonstick surface is invaluable when it comes time to clean your grill after use. But many electric grills also let you remove the grill and other parts and clean them in the dishwasher.
  • Also take a close look at the drip capture tray that’s built into most electric grills. These catch all the excess liquids that come off your grill, so they’re very important. Make sure the drip tray is also dishwasher safe if you aren’t a fan of hand washing.
  • Temperature range is an important consideration in an electric grill. Many will top out in the 400- to 450-degree range, which should cover most recipes.
  • In addition to being able to cook inside, electric grills also typically use grill plates rather than grate-based grills, which means you can cook smaller items like shrimp without worrying about them falling through.
  • Pay attention to the lid on the grill you choose. You’ll want one that completely covers what you’re cooking to reduce spatter, but you’ll also find that it comes in handy to have at least a partial-glass lid. With glass, you can see your items cooking without lifting the lid and reducing the temperature inside.
  • Indoor grills are designed for countertop grilling, but there are some that can be used outdoors, as well. If you think you might have the need for an occasional backyard grill, consider that while you’re shopping.
  • Some indoor electric grills go beyond letting you cook steaks and burgers. They offer interchangeable grill plates that let you cook items like pancakes and paninis.
  • You buy an indoor grill for the convenience of cooking inside. However, some grills still put out an excessive amount of smoke, making them not quite as ideal. Look for a grill that’s designed to minimize smoke output.
  • Many indoor electric grills require preheating before you set your food on the surface. Look for a grill with an indicator light that lets you know when the surface has reached the desired temperature.
  • Safety is always a concern with any electric appliance. Your electric grill should have an easy way to lift the lid that doesn’t require using an oven mitt.
  • Don’t get so caught up in the build of the cooking plates that you forget about the rest of the grill. You’ll need to be able to easily wipe the exterior clean, as it will inevitably get a few spills.
  • The weight of the grill you choose will come into play every time you pull it out of the cabinet and put it back in. A lightweight grill is not only easier to maneuver around your kitchen, but you’ll also be able to take it with you when you go camping or head out to a family gathering at the park.
  • The length of the power cord is also important. Make sure the power cord will reach from a power outlet to the area where you plan to use the grill.