Apple TV

Last updated date: December 19, 2019

DWYM Score


Apple TV

Why Trust DWYM?

DWYM is your trusted product review source. Along with our in-house experts, our team analyzes thousands of product reviews from the most trusted websites. We then create one easy-to-understand review. Learn more.

Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in the category.
Show Contents

We looked at the top Streaming Devices and dug through the reviews from some of the most popular review sites. Through this analysis, we've determined the best Streaming Device you should buy.

Editor's Note December 19, 2019:
Checkout The Best Streaming Device for a detailed review of all the top streaming devices.

Overall Take

If you're looking for the best streaming device for Apple devotees, Apple TV is it. It provides compatibility with iPads, iPhones, Macs, Apple Watch and iTunes content. Apple TV also offers a beautiful 4K HDR and immersive Dolby Atmos sound if you have a compatible TV and sound system.

In our analysis of 42 expert reviews, the Apple Apple TV 4K placed 2nd when we looked at the top 9 products in the category. For the full ranking, see below.

From The Manufacturer

4K for high quality video Dolby Digital Plus 7.1 surround sound. A10X chip. Voice search by asking the Siri Remote. View photos and videos from your iPhone and iPad on TV. Netflix, iTunes, Hulu, ESPN, and thousands more apps in the App Store*

Expert Reviews

Expert Summarized Score

7 expert reviews

User Summarized Score

421 user reviews

What experts liked

Navigation with the Siri Remote is fast and fluid thanks to the trackpad along the top, but the real hero is the more flexible layouts that require less drilling down into menu after menu to find something to watch.
- Macworld
November 2, 2015 | Full review
The new Apple TVs work best with iPads, iPhones and Macs thanks to Apple AirPlay and will allow you to easily stream content from your phone or tablet to the big screen.
- Tech Radar
December 5, 2017 | Full review
It combines the best streaming quality available today -- including Dolby Vision HDR video, which no other streamer offers, and Dolby Atmos audio -- with the smoothest, most polished feel.
September 18, 2018 | Full review
The Apple TV 4K recently greatly improved its sound quality, too, by adding support for Dolby Atmos.
- Trusted Reviews
August 17, 2018 | Full review
Unsurprisingly, movies and TV look gorgeous in 4K HDR as well.
- Tom's Guide
October 10, 2018 | Full review
On compatible sets, HDR lets you see more intense brightness, deeper blacks and a wider range of colors in between.
- Engadget
September 27, 2017 | Full review
Apple’s tvOS has the best user experience, and this model supports Dolby Vision, iTunes, and AirPlay.
- New York Times Wirecutter

What experts didn't like

The problem with the Apple TV’s App Store is discovery.
- Macworld
November 2, 2015 | Full review
Of course, as we mentioned earlier, the Apple TV is a bit limited in the resolution department.
- Tech Radar
December 5, 2017 | Full review
The new Apple TV does not support VP9 and therefore we can't deliver 4K resolution on this device.
September 18, 2018 | Full review
If you’re not an iPhone user, you may be better off opting for a different streaming box or stick, unless you’re prepared to devote yourself to iTunes.
- Trusted Reviews
August 17, 2018 | Full review
On the other hand, the new Apple TV doesn't do much more than streaming boxes that cost almost $100 less — and in some cases, it doesn't even do as much.
- Tom's Guide
October 10, 2018 | Full review
It's just a shame that we still have to wait for Apple to score more licensing deals, get more third-party support and fix curious omissions, like its lack of Atmos support.
- Engadget
September 27, 2017 | Full review
Most popular music-streaming services, like Spotify and Pandora, are missing from the Apple TV. You can send many of these channels to the box via AirPlay if you own an Apple device, but otherwise you’re missing some content you may find essential.
- New York Times Wirecutter

Overall Product Rankings

Roku Streaming Stick+

1. Roku Streaming Stick+

Overall Score: 9.0
Apple TV

2. Apple TV

Overall Score: 8.9
Amazon Fire Stick

3. Amazon Fire Stick

Overall Score: 8.7
Roku Express

4. Roku Express

Overall Score: 8.5

5. NVIDIA Shield TV

Overall Score: 8.4
Roku Premiere+

6. Roku Premiere+

Overall Score: 8.3
Roku Streaming Stick

7. Roku Streaming Stick

Overall Score: 8.0
Roku Ultra

8. Roku Ultra

Overall Score: 7.9

9. Mohu

Overall Score: 5.2

An Overview On Streaming Devices

These days, most streaming devices have the same key functions and apps. While it can be hard to tell them apart, there are features and compatibilities to consider based on how and where you plan to use them.  Is 4K important to you? Are you a Prime member or Apple devotee? How about voice search? These are important questions to ask yourself before buying a streaming device.

Streaming devices can be broken into two basic categories: smart TVs and digital media players (DMPs). With a smart TV, you will have access to preloaded and downloadable apps that can be used to stream media through the TV itself. If you have a smart TV, you don’t need a separate digital media player as long as you like the interface and everything functions well for you. However, smart TVs may not have as many apps as a digital media player, and new apps may not get added as often. You’ll also want to check to make sure you can access the apps you will use the most before expecting a smart TV will have everything you need.

Digital media players are separate devices that connect to a TV through an HDMI or USB port. They may also be called a streaming device, media player, stick or box. You’re usually much better off getting a digital media player for each of the TVs in your household, as streaming apps are usually made specifically for these devices and will be updated more frequently than with a smart TV. Gaming systems, like Play Station and Xbox, can also be used for streaming.

Most digital media players or streaming devices plug into your TV and play directly from the device. Some, like Chromecast, play content from your computer or phone by using a “casting” function that communicates with your TV. Apple TV 4K also has this ability using AirPlay, but you can just play directly from the streaming device as well.

All standalone streaming device options are fairly similar, and your choice really depends on the type of media you want to access and what kind of devices you already have and use in your household. The Roku Express and Roku Streaming Stick+ are the most open devices, meaning they aren’t tied to a particular service or suite of devices like Amazon or Apple. While the Amazon Fire Stick offers you all of the same apps as a device like Roku, the experience is greatly improved and has more features if you are Prime member.

If you’re a real movie buff, with a new 4K TV and a separate sound system, you’ll want to get a streaming device that is compatible with these upgraded experiences, such as the Roku Streaming Stick+ or the newest version of the Amazon Fire Stick.  If you also have lots of digital content through iTunes, you should highly consider Apple TV 4K.  If you use other Apple products, you can also view photos and videos through the streaming device.

Despite all of the talk around “cord-cutting,” you may need a cord or two to start streaming. You will need a TV with an available HDMI port, a strong Wi-Fi connection, a nearby power outlet and adapter. Depending on the device you may need an HDMI cord or extender. The Amazon Fire Stick and Roku Streaming Stick+ can connect directly into the TV HDMI port. If you don’t have Wi-Fi you’ll need to connect directly with an ethernet cord. Apple TV 4K has an ethernet port and so does Chromecast, but many other streaming devices do not.

Every streaming device comes with a remote. They usually have far fewer buttons than the remotes you may be used to, but a lot of the same functions can be found on screen or aren’t necessary. Several streaming devices offer voice remotes that allow you to search, control and call up specific content with your voice commands. The Amazon Fire Stick uses an Alexa for it’s remote, while Apple TV 4K uses Siri and Roku Streaming Stick+ uses their own voice functionality.

You actually have a lot of options for what you use as a remote with streaming devices. If you’d rather not use the small, basic remote most of these devices come with, you can also typically use your phone as a remote if you download a compatible app. Apple TV 4K can be controlled with an iPhone, iPad and even Apple Watch. To get rid of multiple remotes, there are universal and smart remote options that can control streaming devices and sometimes other smart home technology as well.

Streaming devices are relatively affordable. Other expenses involved in streaming include your Wi-Fi cost and any additional cords or connectors needed (although most come with everything you need). Some streaming apps are free, but others require a paid subscription to the app itself, a service like Prime or to a cable or satellite provider to use. Overall, many find streaming attractive because of the wide variety of content available, as well as the lack of big, expensive equipment and generally lower costs.

The Streaming Device Buying Guide

  • To stream successfully, there are certain internet speed requirements that will make your experience better. Internet speed is measured in megabits per second or Mbps (also Mb/s). For standard definition viewing, 1.5-2.5 Mbps is recommended, while 6-8 Mbps is required for HD video. If you have a 4K TV, you can stream with 15-25 Mbps, but 25 Mbps is generally preferred.
  • If you choose to get an Amazon Fire Stick, you may want to consider a Prime membership to get more out of your device.  In addition to easily adding extra channels, having access to exclusive Prime content and Prime Music, you can also control  Amazon Echo, Tap or other compatible smart home devices with your Alexa voice remote.
  • Streaming devices do not come with antennas for watching over-the-air TV. If you don’t plan on signing up for an app with live TV options you will need to buy an HDTV antenna to receive over-the-air channels. If you do opt for an app with live TV, make sure it has the local channels you want, not all services have all channels.
  • Most streaming players don’t have built-in DVR. You may be able to add it to your services with certain apps, like DirectvNow, or buy an additional device, such as TiVO. Or you can wait for the show to become available on demand. Make sure you check to see what kind of storage space you have and how long you’re able to keep your shows. Some offer unlimited time while others will only give you 30 days.
  • If you’re not ready to cut cable or satellite, but still want to try streaming, you can start with a budget-friendly option like the Roku Express. Then, if you find yourself using streaming services more often than not, you can always upgrade to a more full-featured device like the Roku Streaming Stick+ or Amazon Fire TV Stick.
  • One of the best features of a compact streaming device is being able to easily move it or bring it with you. All you need is an HDTV with an HDMI port, a power outlet, and a Wi-Fi connection. You don’t have to worry about not having access to your favorite shows or movies while staying in a hotel or on vacation.