Don't Waste Your Money is supported by our readers. When you purchase an item through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

The Best Pillow Protectors

Last updated on December 29, 2022
Best Pillow Protectors

Our Review Process

Don't Waste Your Money is focused on helping you make the best purchasing decision. Our team of experts spends hundreds of hours analyzing, testing, and researching products so you don't have to. Learn more.

Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in a category.

Our Picks For The Top Pillow Protectors

View All Recommendations
Product Overview
Key Takeaway
 Top Pick

AllerEase Allergen Barrier Zippered Pillow Protectors, 2-Pack

Don't Waste Your Money Seal of Approval


Allergen Barrier Zippered Pillow Protectors, 2-Pack

With these pillow protectors, you'll be breathing easy. They are designed to reduce allergens, while also keeping you cool and comfortable. Since they're made from 100% cotton, the pillow protectors are soft against skin.

Overall Take

Economical OptionYou'll love the budget-friendly price tag on these pillow protectors.

 Runner Up

Coop Home Goods Soft Noiseless Pillow Protectors, 2-Pack

Coop Home Goods

Soft Noiseless Pillow Protectors, 2-Pack

Much more than a plain case, this pillow protector is waterproof, hypoallergenic and made with luxurious Lulltra fabric. It is thick and durable, yet surprisingly soft to the touch. It guards your family from bed bugs, spills and sweat, and it does not contain vinyl or PVC.

Overall Take

Safeguard Your Favorite PillowsRest easy with this comfortable and natural pillow case.

 We Also Like

Niagara Sleep Solution Jersey Pillow Protectors, 4-Pack

Niagara Sleep Solution

Jersey Pillow Protectors, 4-Pack

Keep your pillows dry and free from odors, while letting air flow through. The strong zipper closure provides a full seal. They are machine washable for easy care.

Overall Take

Waterproof and Breathable FabricThese pillow protectors keep out liquids but let air flow through.

 Strong Contender

Everlasting Comfort Breathable Pillow Protectors, 2-Pack

Everlasting Comfort

Breathable Pillow Protectors, 2-Pack

Since these pillow protectors are 100% waterproof, you won't have to worry about sweat, drool or water spills soaking through to your pillow. The pillows are also hypoallergenic and able to block bed bugs. When the protectors become soiled, all you need to do is toss them in the washing machine for a quick cleaning.

Overall Take

Best for Allergy SufferersIn addition to being soft to the touch, these pillow protectors have a breathable membrane that allows for proper airflow.

Buying Guide

If you’ve invested in a high-quality pillow, it’s important to extend its life by using a pillow protector. This covering goes under the pillowcase, completely covering the pillow and zipping up on one side, to keep out dust mites, mold, mildew, pollen and other allergens, in addition to sweat, drool and other liquids.

There a few different types of pillow protectors. Hypoallergenic pillow protectors are designed to reduce irritants for those who suffer from allergies. Dust, pollen pet dander and even dead skin cells can cause some people to get itchy and watery eyes or a runny nose at night. Using a hypoallergenic pillow protector and washing it often ensures you have uninterrupted sleep.

A waterproof pillow protector has a soft outer layer and a waterproof inner layer. It’s used for preventing stains on your pillow and keeping it free of any odors from perspiration and saliva. If you sleep particularly warm, then a temperature-regulating pillow protector is right for you. The fabric is designed for optimal airflow and doesn’t trap in heat, keeping you cool at night.

What to Look For

  • When looking for a pillow protector, consider your main goal. Do you want to keep out allergens so you don’t end up sniffling and sneezing at night or are you more concerned about keeping sweat and saliva away from your pillow? Consider the main purpose of your pillow protector, which will help you choose the right materials.
  • Cotton is a common material for pillow protectors. It’s a natural, breathable and soft material that is ideal for people with skin sensitivities. However, cotton generally does not wick moisture and can build up allergens if not washed frequently. Polyester is a highly durable material that is fast drying, so it’s helpful if you sleep warm and sweaty. It’s also easy to keep clean and is budget-friendly. Tencel lyocell and bamboo materials are naturally hypoallergenic and wick away moisture.
  • Waterproof pillow protectors are either made from a thin polyurethane fabric or vinyl. When buying a waterproof pillow protector, it’s important to look for a breathable fabric that does not cause you to get hot at night. Sometimes, vinyl or plastic materials can retain heat.
  • Ensure that the pillow protector has a secure zipper. This will keep out all allergens and liquids. The pillow protector should also be machine-washable so you can easily keep it clean.

More to Explore

The biggest benefit of using a pillow protector is prolonging the life of your pillow. This is especially key for high-end pillows or specialty pillows. By keeping away all liquids, including perspiration and saliva, in addition to allergens, you can keep your pillow fresh and clean.

Keep in mind that some pillow protectors can be a bit noisy, especially ones made from vinyl material. This can disturb some sleepers. Some pillow protectors can also trap air inside, which makes the pillow protector balloon up. This can also be disruptive during sleep.

From our partners