Urban Decay Sulfate & Phthalate-Free Eyeshadow Compact

Last updated date: September 12, 2022

DWYM Score

6.3

Urban Decay Sulfate & Phthalate-Free Eyeshadow Compact

Why Trust DWYM?

DWYM is your trusted product review source. Along with our in-house experts, our team analyzes thousands of product reviews from the most trusted websites. We then create one easy-to-understand review. Learn more.

Don't Waste Your Money Seal of Approval
Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in the category.
Show Contents

We looked at the top Eyeshadow Compacts and dug through the reviews from some of the most popular review sites. Through this analysis, we've determined the best Eyeshadow Compact you should buy.

Update as September 30, 2022:
Checkout The Best Eyeshadow Compact for a detailed review of all the top eyeshadow compacts.

Overall Take

Urban Decay's amazing 0.17-ounce Moondust eyeshadow is packed with iridescent glitter that makes your eyes pop. It goes on like a cream, so you needn't worry about anything getting into your eyes. It is also cruelty-free and sulfate and phthalate-free.


In our analysis, the Urban Decay Urban Decay Sulfate & Phthalate-Free Eyeshadow Compact placed 4th when we looked at the top 6 products in the category. For the full ranking, see below.

From The Manufacturer

OUT OF THIS WORLD: Sulfate-free, phthalate-free, and cruelty-free Moondust Eyeshadow combines microfine, iridescent glitter with intense, dreamy colors for a refined, multidimensional sparkle that’s out of this world. SUPERNATURAL SHIMMER: You’ve never seen a glittery shadow like this. Moondust Eyeshadow is dazzlingly sparkly but with a super-refined, elevated feel (and not a single speck of chunky glitter). BRILLIANTLY REFLECTIVE: New technology gives Moondust an amazing effect not found in traditional pressed-powder shadows. It feels like a cream but goes on like a powder to create a smooth, brilliantly reflective look with minimum fallout. PRO TIP: For more precise application, use a tapered eyeshadow brush. Apply wet (or spray brush with All Nighter Makeup Setting Spray) for a foiled effect. Moondust also doubles as a highlighter, so use it to spotlight cheekbones and décolletage.

An Overview On Eyeshadow Compacts

Eyeshadow products are made from base fillers like mica or talc and are bound together with things like magnesium and zinc. Creamier formulas will have oils and wax, like shea butter and beeswax, but most eyeshadows also have preservatives like glycol to keep things fresh. Colored mica pigments give the shadow its different tones; as you likely know, the variety is endless. If you have an allergic reaction to a makeup product like eyeshadow, stop using it immediately because one or more of those ingredients could be causing the problem.

Eye shadow compacts can contain one, two or dozens of colors and can be fun to experiment with. If you find the perfect color, you will often use it, so it makes sense to buy a single. It is not wise to buy an extensive palette with only one color you love, so if you are getting a bigger one, be sure it has a good mix. It is also good to get palettes with various textures, like matte, shiny and shimmery. You will also want to look for light, dark, smoky and neutral shades.

Nude eyeshadow compacts should have a range of champagne, beige, taupe, brown and black tones, while smoky palettes need gray, black, other darker tones and a shimmery highlighter. Although one size doesn’t fit all, certain shades will bring out the colors of your eyes. You can deepen eyeshadows by adding a bit of water, and feel free to mix colors and blend to your heart’s content. If you have sensitive skin, many eyeshadows are hypoallergenic, cruelty-free or made without other potentially irritating ingredients.

The Eyeshadow Compact Buying Guide

  • To blend eyeshadows, try a bold shade on your lids and then blend it upwards and outwards into a neutral. Another option is to use a light matte shade on the corners of your eyes and brow bones.
  • You can also use eye shadows as eyeliners with the right brush.
  • If a shade seems too intense, mix it with a neutral. Adding white can make it look chalky.
  • Creamy eyeshadows with waxes and oils generally have better staying power.
  • An eye shadow primer can help prevent creasing.
  • As a guideline, golds and coppers look nice with blue eyes; warm grays and browns pair well with brown eyes and purple tones bring out green eyes.
  • Some compacts come with their brushes, but others do not. You can also buy empty, refillable compacts that you can put your products in.