Tempur-Pedic Supreme 3-Inch Medium Firm Mattress Topper

Last updated date: November 10, 2020

DWYM Score

9.1

Tempur-Pedic Supreme 3-Inch Medium Firm Mattress Topper

Why Trust DWYM?

DWYM is your trusted product review source. Along with our in-house experts, our team analyzes thousands of product reviews from the most trusted websites. We then create one easy-to-understand review. Learn more.

Don't Waste Your Money Seal of Approval
Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in the category.
Show Contents

We looked at the top Mattress Toppers and dug through the reviews from some of the most popular review sites. Through this analysis, we've determined the best Mattress Topper you should buy.

Update as November 10, 2020:
Checkout The Best Mattress Topper for a detailed review of all the top mattress toppers.

Overall Take

If you're searching for a mattress topper that adapts to your body, this model is your best bet. It's constructed using a thick memory foam that will provide lasting comfort. You'll also find the topper comes in traditional sizes, as well as a twin XL and a California king.


In our analysis of 87 expert reviews, the Tempur-Pedic Supreme 3-Inch Medium Firm Mattress Topper placed 6th when we looked at the top 18 products in the category. For the full ranking, see below.

From The Manufacturer

This twin 3 inch memory foam mattress topper features our proprietary TEMPUR material, so you get the same pressure-relieving comfort and support found in our mattresses. Whether you’re taking this topper on the road, or refreshing an old or uncomfortable mattress, you’ll be sleeping more deeply for years to come. Features a removable, machine-washable cover and a three inch thickness for ultimate comfort. Backed by a 10 year limited warranty.

Expert Reviews

Expert Summarized Score

9.4
9 expert reviews

User Summarized Score

8.8
2,533 user reviews

What experts liked

In fact, it offers more cushioning than any other memory-foam topper we tried, and unlike some other memory-foam models we tested, it never made us feel like we’d fallen into a crater.
- The New York Times
This topper is dense, durable, and feels like a mini-mattress. It’s about 30 lbs., three inches thick, and the folks at Tempur-pedic say it makes a great substitute for a mattress when you’re camping, or you have an overnight guest (and I have no trouble believing that!).
- Sleepopolis
The foam conforms well to the body without sinking too deeply and it has a nice medium-firm support overall (at least for my weight- it might be softer for a heavier body).
- The Sleep Judge
Its 3'' thick profile is ideal for those that want extra contour on their mattress or desire extra cushion while sleeping on the floor or hard surface.
- Slumber Search
Available in all major sizes, including twin XL and California king
- Slumber Yard
TEMPUR material is more durable compared to ordinary memory foam.
- SuperComfySleep.com
This three-inch memory foam topper is the best of both worlds: thick enough to support your back without causing you to completely sink to the bottom.
- Popular Mechanics
Another benefit is motion isolation. The TEMPUR-Topper Supreme absorbs motion transfer very well, which can cut down on sleep disruptions for couples.
- Tuck
Filled with the brand’s proprietary Tempur material, it offers enough comfort and support to justify the higher price tag.
- The Spruce

What experts didn't like

The Tempur-Pedic mattress topper weighs about 36 pounds, making it difficult to maneuver.
- The New York Times
While the cover is washable, the topper itself is not. In fact, you really shouldn’t get it wet at all.
- Sleepopolis
I do have one small complaint: it can sleep a little warm.
- The Sleep Judge
No straps or buttons to keep it in place
- Slumber Yard
The mattress topper may feel a little firm at first and needs to be broken in for a few nights for maximum comfort.
- SuperComfySleep.com
Expensive compared to other memory foam options
- Popular Mechanics
The TEMPUR-Topper Supreme has an above-average price-point compared to other memory foam toppers.
- Tuck

An Overview On Mattress Toppers

A mattress pad protects your mattress, but it doesn’t really make it more comfortable. For that job, you need a mattress topper, a relatively thin layer of material that rests atop your mattress to make it softer. But a mattress topper does more than simply offer a thin layer of cushioning. With the right one, you’ll also get a cooling effect that is far better than the unventilated toppers of previous generations.

If cooling is important to you, make sure you look for a topper that’s designed to keep you cool. Some use ventilation for that, but others use technology like cooling gel to provide even more assurance that you won’t wake up in the middle of the night in a pool of sweat. Often, it’s just simply the design of the topper itself that keeps sleepers cool.

Of course, overall, you’ll be looking for a topper that makes your mattress comfortable for sleeping. You’ll find with most mattress toppers, memory foam is the name of the game, but memory foam isn’t without its issues. Modern products are constructed to resolve the common problems that come with using the material.

Mattress toppers require chemicals during the manufacturing process and, unfortunately, this can lead to unpleasant odors when you bring them home. You won’t get away from that issue completely, but some toppers do cut down on this more than others. For best results, air your topper out for a few hours, preferably outside, before putting it on your bed and covering it with a fitted sheet. You can also set a bowl of vinegar in your bedroom for a few days to absorb the smell.

Lastly, there’s the price. It’s important to note that you can find very affordable mattress toppers on the market, but many of them have all the issues that higher-end toppers work to address. You’ll pay a little more for a comfortable, cooling sleeping experience, as well as avoiding the odor problem that comes with less expensive versions.

The Mattress Topper Buying Guide

  • Comfort starts with keeping you cool, especially if you tend to sweat while you sleep. With the EASELAND Queen Pillow Top Mattress Topper, you get the power of cooling gel to keep overheating at a minimum. With this mattress, the memory foam is infused with a cooling gel that prevents heat from being trapped in the layers. Other toppers use a breathable fabric for improved airflow.
  • Each mattress topper has its own unique way of making you more comfortable while you sleep. Some models have a 2-inch thick down-alternative layer attached to the cover, topped by a 2-inch thick layer of gel-infused memory foam. Others use memory foam to conform to your body. There are even toppers that have an open-cell technology to help prevent those body impressions that can make memory foam less comfortable.
  • You’ll always have at least a trace of odor when you unwrap a new mattress topper, mostly due to the chemicals injected into them. This problem is easily remedied by allowing the topper to air out for a short time.
  • Although you can find cheaper mattress toppers, you won’t get nearly the quality that you’ll find with a more expensive mattress topper. Either way, you’re sure to find a mattress topper that fits within your family’s budget.