Screen Gems Dear John

Last updated date: July 7, 2019

DWYM Score


Screen Gems Dear John

Why Trust DWYM?

DWYM is your trusted product review source. Along with our in-house experts, our team analyzes thousands of product reviews from the most trusted websites. We then create one easy-to-understand review. Learn more.

Don't Waste Your Money Seal of Approval
Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in the category.
Show Contents

We looked at the top Romance Movies and dug through the reviews from some of the most popular review sites. Through this analysis, we've determined the best Romance Movie you should buy.

Update as August 12, 2019:
Checkout The Best Romance Movie for a detailed review of all the top romance movies.

Overall Take

In our analysis of 87 expert reviews, the Screen Gems Dear John placed 6th when we looked at the top 10 products in the category. For the full ranking, see below.

From The Manufacturer

From the author of “The Notebook” comes DEAR JOHN a story of destiny that pushes young soldier, John Tyree and idealistic college student, Savannah Curtis together. When war tears them apart, will their endless stream of love letters be enough to keep them united?

Expert Reviews

Expert Summarized Score

10 expert reviews

User Summarized Score

865 user reviews

What experts liked

That's the note Sparks aims for: the sad smile. First love is not to be, but the moon still looks so large when it rises, and people treat each other gently, and if someone should die, that is very sad, but perhaps it will provide an opportunity for someone else to live a little longer before they, too, must travel to that undiscovered country from whose bourn no traveler ever returns
- Roger Ebert
February 3, 2010 | Full review
"Dear John" does center on a Dear John letter, but it takes a few unexpected paths. That's the good news.
- The Hollywood Reporter
October 14, 2010 | Full review
One plus for the film is that it didn’t cross the line with regards to fidelity in marriage. When two of the characters are tempted to commit adultery, they resist it.
In an era of technology when the art of the hand-penned correspondence has been reduced to texting and email, Dear John is a compelling reminder of a letter’s power to connect people.
- Parent Previews
The scene between John and his dying father was especially touching and was probably the scene in which Channing Tatum did his best acting.
- Hub Pages
July 1, 2015 | Full review
The nature of love is that it must be reciprocal and committed. A “Dear John letter” by definition is about a love that is neither reciprocated nor committed. This film tells a story that speaks to those moments in all of our lives where we experienced the loss of love.
- Cinema In Focus
Dear John is as conventional and unworldly as the décor in your dad’s onscreen house. It’s the cinematic equivalent of a plastic-covered couch under a “Bless This House” sampler. And that’s not a bad thing, for audiences who have a high threshold for sentiment and a low one for dramatic conflict.
- Slate
February 4, 2010 | Full review

What experts didn't like

The film takes itself much too seriously, yet its characters exist in a realm of fiction, never coming alive as actual human beings. The production is decent but nothing really inspired. The film disappoints on most levels but most of all as a romance.
- The Hollywood Reporter
October 14, 2010 | Full review
At 1 hour and 42 minutes, Dear John isn't that long compared to other films we've seen come out of Hollywood recently. However, it does seem to drag. The ending -- with the resolution of John and Savannah's relationship -- also is rushed.
Fans of the book or any of Sparks's work know what they're in for, though, and may not mind being talked down to and forced to spend time with some of history's least inspired lovers. But fans of Lasse Hallstrom, who once made delectable guilty pleasures like Chocolat or the truly great What's Eating Gilbert Grape, will wonder how he lost his touch so severely
- Cinema Blend
And I must say, I was extremely disappointed by how the movie ended
- Hub Pages
July 1, 2015 | Full review

Overall Product Rankings

An Overview On Romance Movies

At the end of a long week, the best decompression is to cozy up on your couch and push play on an awesome romance movie. Unfortunately, there are so many romance movies that are just cheesy or are just plain boring. That’s why you should consider only the best romance movies as suggested by countless viewers. You will save time, and as a result, you will love the movie you choose.

What makes a great romance movie anyway? Although the genre has been around for so long, every generation seems to have a blockbuster movie that just touches countless souls. There are several things that all the best romance movies have as common denominators that make them out-of-this-world incredible. And you will know when you’ve found that perfect romance movie.

There are quite a few limitations placed on the romance movie genre, which makes it difficult for directors and actors to really impress their viewers. This calls for a very creative approach. With a bit of creativity, audiences will find that it isn’t just the same old story played by different actors. This could even mean a different angle of the same old love story, but with incredible details and imagination.

The characters must be likable. Whether they are witty, charming, sweet or funny, the characters should have something that diverges from the usual suspects of a romance movie.

Clichés in a romance movie can also be a huge turn-off. Directors try extremely hard to stay away from common romance scripts and scenes and put their best imagination towards spinning the scenes to an unexpected event.

Realistic plots are another must-have for a great romance movie. People want to be able to see the real reason for the attraction and the events unfolding in a somewhat natural way. This is another aspect that needs to reflect creativity from the directors. If the intriguing plot isn’t there, it is just on par with the other average romance movies.

One of the most notable characteristics of all the greatest romance movies is the chemistry between the actors. Audiences will always comment on the spark between the lead actors in a romance movie. That connection must be believable, or the movie won’t be as fun to watch.

An unexpected finale is something that tops off the most romantic of movies. So many times, in romance movies, the audience can predict the happily ever after ending. When a movie doesn’t have that predictable ending, you know you’ve happened upon a great romance movie.

With countless choices, you will surely find it hard to choose. There are several that stand out to audiences in particular. “A Walk To Remember” by Warner Bros. is definitely one for the records. This romance movie has all the elements to make it the best, including a beautiful ending that just tugs at the heart. Right alongside it, CBS Films delivered “The Words.” This romance movie gives the audience something to think about in the moral realm all while displaying well-developed and surprising characters.

At its heels stands the beloved Warner Bros. film, “The Notebook.” A whirlwind of emotions that are realistically portrayed, intense on-screen chemistry between the actors and an unexpected ending combine to give audiences one of the best romance movies of modern cinema.

Also suggested as one of the best romance movies is an Amazon Studios Original, “Life Itself.” This movie definitely gives audiences a roller coaster ride of emotions throughout the storyline. Any one of these flicks will give you a great romance movie experience.

The Romance Movie Buying Guide

  • Browse through different film production companies to find the best romance movies. Warner Bros., CBS Films and Amazon Studios are all great places to start.
  • Find a subgenre you love. There are drama romance movies, sci-fi romance movies, action romance movies, comedy romance movies and classic romance movies, among other varieties.
  • Be thoughtful of who you are watching the movie with. Some romance movies can hit home for some people. Others prefer to actively avoid the genre altogether.
  • There is an appropriate romance movie for every stage of your relationship (and every kind of relationship, even long-distance relationships) if you like watching them with your partner.