Rubbermaid Logo Swinging Lid Recycling Bin, 12.5-Gallon

Last updated date: July 19, 2022

DWYM Score


Rubbermaid Logo Swinging Lid Recycling Bin, 12.5-Gallon

Why Trust DWYM?

DWYM is your trusted product review source. Along with our in-house experts, our team analyzes thousands of product reviews from the most trusted websites. We then create one easy-to-understand review. Learn more.

Don't Waste Your Money Seal of Approval
Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in the category.
Show Contents

We looked at the top Recycling Bins and dug through the reviews from some of the most popular review sites. Through this analysis, we've determined the best Recycling Bin you should buy.

Update as September 8, 2022:
Checkout The Best Recycling Bin for a detailed review of all the top recycling bins.

Overall Take

In our analysis of 52 expert reviews, the Rubbermaid Logo Swinging Lid Recycling Bin, 12.5-Gallon placed 12th when we looked at the top 15 products in the category. For the full ranking, see below.

From The Manufacturer

The convenient and easy-to-use Rubbermaid Step-On Waste Can with Liner Lock is both functional and innovative. It features a Liner Lock, which contains wires that secure the trash bag to the rim of the can, preventing slide-down. Add a clean look to your space with a waste container that hides refuse from view.

Expert Reviews

Expert Summarized Score

10 expert reviews

User Summarized Score

4,552 user reviews

What experts liked

The low price point of this plastic trash can provides its biggest advantage versus steel cans.
- Business Insider
The Rubbermaid’s snap-in hinges ably hold down trash bags in the oval opening. The pedal/lid mechanism prevents you from flinging the lid open as fast as with the Slim Step Can, or most of the competition.
- New York Times Wirecutter
November 13, 2018 | Full review
The pedal is a nice shiny metal that is tucked in at the bottom, which makes it a very uniform shape and something you won’t potentially trip over.
- Your Best Digs
July 3, 2019 | Full review
Due to the Rubbermaid 1843029 Step-On Wastebasket’s innovative design, you can keep the lid open without holding down the pedal. This makes it potentially foot-free in operation and makes taking out the trash a breeze.
- The Grand Kitchen
With a plastic exterior and stainless steel pedal operation, this can — available in black or white — may be basic, but it’s an Amazon bestseller with nearly 3,000 positive reviews!
- The Kitchn
You'll be able to open this with the touch of the hand while the trash bag is hidden with its unique seal making it easier on the eyes.
- The Spruce
June 13, 2019 | Full review
Very light and easy to carry.
- Buy Kitchen Stuff
It is made of high-quality plastic and has a practical design for easy operation and maintenance.
- Top Review Pro
This is a pedal step in where you step on a pedal to open the lid. This is always a convenient feature as it allows hands-free operation. On this model, Rubbermaid has upgraded to a stainless steel step that is way more durable than the all-plastic step.
- Trash That

What experts didn't like

Plastic lid won't keep pets out of the garbage.
- Business Insider
There is no removable liner, it’s neither airtight nor dog-proof, the black or gray plastic design won’t win any awards, and stains require a spray solution to clean up.
- New York Times Wirecutter
November 13, 2018 | Full review
Is light and more prone to being knocked over if it is empty.
- Your Best Digs
July 3, 2019 | Full review
The snap-on top refused to stay in place during testing. So, not only were we regularly unable to use the foot pedal, but we had to refit the dirty lid by hand far too many times.
- Reviewed
January 9, 2019 | Full review
As the lid stays open for some time, pets or children can cause a mess by tripping the can over.
- Buy Kitchen Stuff

An Overview On Recycling Bins

It’s important that everyone does their part to protect the environment. One easy way to do this is to recycle glass, plastic, metal and paper using recycling bins. Some counties provide outdoor recycling bins, while others do not. Of course, you’ll still need indoor bins to keep the recyclables organized.

Find out whether your township requires you to separate plastic and paper products. If they don’t, you’ll only need one dedicated bin for your kitchen. If they do, look for a model like that has four compartments within one bin.

When it comes to outdoor recycling containers, you want a bin that is quality made and able to withstand all types of weather. Look for a model that is also constructed with a UV inhibitor that protects the container from fading or becoming cracked from constant sun exposure.

Should the outdoor recycling bin require a liner, check for integrated cinches that help hold the liner place. This feature will also make it easier to remove the liner when you’re ready to replace it with a new one.

Recycling bins that have a lid are ideal, as they keep critters from getting into your trash. Some models have a locking mechanism to keep the lids in place. Others have a feature that keeps the lid propped open while filling or emptying it.

Look for an outdoor recycling container with wheels if you have a long driveway and dragging the bin to the curb is unrealistic. It’s best if the wheels are durable and outfitted with performance treads that work well on multiple surfaces.

Another option is to go with recycling containers that can be stacked on top of each other. Some of these bins can also be used indoors to store toys or in a garage to hold tools.

While recycling containers are available in a wide range of colors, such as yellow, green, blue, gray and white, you’ll want to make sure they are outfitted with the universal symbol for recycling before you buy them. This is the only way the trash men will be able to distinguish your recycling cans from your regular trash cans.

The Recycling Bin Buying Guide

  • Since your recycling bins hold trash, they will become dirty and smelly over time. Use a garden hose to give the recycling cans an initial rinse. Next, fill the bin a quarter of the way up with warm water and a squirt of dish soap. Add a cup of distilled white vinegar to help clean and deodorize the bin and then scrub the inside and outside of the bin. Rinse clean and allow to air dry.
  • It’s always best to rinse cans and bottles out before tossing them in your outdoor recycling bin. This helps deter outdoor pests, like raccoons and possums from getting into your trash.
  • Take a few extra seconds to flatten any cardboard and food boxes before placing them in your recycling bin. You’ll be able to fit much more in that way, which means you won’t need as many bins.
  • Check to see if you live in one of the 10 states that pay for recycled cans. If you do, you may want to set these items aside and take them directly to the recycling center. Every penny adds up.
  • Believe it or not, not all plastics are recyclable. Your city’s website should list which plastics it accepts. If you can’t find a list, take a look at the plastic’s number. Most centers tend to shy away from numbers 3, 6 and 7. If you have a number 1 (soft), 4 or 5, call the city and ask whether they accept those plastics in their recycling program, as some cities take these, while others don’t.
  • When comparing recycling bin prices, you’ll need to take into consideration extra features and whether the can is meant for indoors or outdoors. Models made from a soft material are the most affordable. In the middle, you’ll find the Rubbermaid Slim Jim Plastic Recycling Bin and the Genuine Joe Rectangular Recycling Bin, as these have a more solid construction. On the higher end are the bins that are also stackable.