Robert Bryndza The Girl In the Ice

Last updated date: June 20, 2019

DWYM Score
8.6

Why Trust The DWYM Score?

DWYM is your trusted product review source. Along with our in-house experts, our team analyzes thousands of product reviews from the most trusted websites. We then create one easy-to-understand score. Learn more.

Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in the category.

We looked at the top 1 Thriller Novels and dug through the reviews from 8 of the most popular review sites including Publishers Weekly, Quick Book Reviews, Crime By The Book, Bookouture, Geeks, The Bookish Deer, The Book Review, One Readers Thoughts and more. Through this analysis, we've determined the best Thriller Novel you should buy.

Overall Take

They say you can't judge a book by its cover. But Robert Bryndza's "The Girl In the Ice" lives up to its stunning cover and title. This story follows a detective who lost her husband during a previous investigation. More of a suspense novel, this might not be the best fit for those who prefer police procedurals. In our analysis of 67 expert reviews, the Robert Bryndza Robert Bryndza The Girl In the Ice placed 2nd when we looked at the top 10 products in the category. For the full ranking, see below.

Editor's Note July 2, 2019:
Checkout The Best Thriller Novel for a detailed review of all the top thriller novels.

Expert Summarized Score
8.5
8 expert reviews
User Summarized Score
8.8
8,517 user reviews
Our Favorite Video Reviews
What experts liked
The Girl in the Ice is a fantastic murder mystery thriller, one that will grip from beginning to end anyone who enjoys this genre.
- Quick Book Reviews
June 12, 2016 | Full review
THE GIRL IN THE ICE is just plain fun to devour. THE GIRL IN THE ICE is that rare book that can genuinely be called “compulsively readable” - I read this book in two sittings, that’s how hooked I was.
- Crime By The Book
March 12, 2018 | Full review
A page-turning thriller packed with suspense.
- Bookouture
Story-line itself was fantastic. It was smooth-sailing, heart-wrenching and exciting.
- Geeks
Behold the first five-star read of 2019; The writing is incredibly compelling and addictive, and I was so engrossed in the story that I barely annotated the book like I usually do – all I wanted was to keep reading and to find out what would happen next.
- The Bookish Deer
February 21, 2019 | Full review
The story grabbed my attention immediately and from there the pacing was relentless and kept me glued to the pages from beginning to end.
- The Book Review
December 30, 2016 | Full review
The book itself is well-written and drew me in from the first.
- One Readers Thoughts
June 6, 2016 | Full review
What experts didn't like
Bryndza (the Coco Pinchard romantic comedy series) leaves no procedural serial killer cliché unused in this pallid series debut. The climax does nothing to reinforce Erika as a capable lead. Few will look forward to her further exploits.
- Publishers Weekly
April 2, 2018 | Full review
If you’re in the market for a crime book that digs deep into the details of a police investigation, this might not be the right choice for you - you're likely to find its portrayal of police work too “surface level.”
- Crime By The Book
March 12, 2018 | Full review
The twist at the end shocked me, however, I felt it was a little bit rushed.
- Geeks
While I do love quick pacing and hate deliberate filler, this one might have benefited from that tactic just a little, in order to build suspense and create a more sinister atmosphere.
- The Book Review
December 30, 2016 | Full review

From The Manufacturer

When a young boy discovers the body of a woman beneath a thick sheet of ice in a South London park, Detective Erika Foster is called in to lead the murder investigation. The victim, a beautiful young socialite, appeared to have the perfect life. Yet when Erika begins to dig deeper, she starts to connect the dots between the murder and the killings of three prostitutes, all found strangled, hands bound and dumped in water around London. What dark secrets is the girl in the ice hiding? As Erika inches closer to uncovering the truth, the killer is closing in on Erika. The last investigation Erika led went badly wrong… resulting in the death of her husband. With her career hanging by a thread, Erika must now battle her own personal demons as well as a killer more deadly than any she’s faced before. But will she get to him before he strikes again?

Overall Product Rankings

1. Robert Dugoni My Sister’s Grave
Overall Score: 8.8
Expert Reviews: 10
2. Robert Bryndza The Girl In the Ice
Overall Score: 8.6
Expert Reviews: 8
3. Mike Omer A Killer’s Mind
Overall Score: 8.5
Expert Reviews: 6
4. Michael Connelly The Wrong Side of Goodbye
Overall Score: 8.5
Expert Reviews: 9
5. Dustin Stevens The Boat Man
Overall Score: 8.4
Expert Reviews: 2
6. L.T. Vargus Dead End Girl
Overall Score: 8.2
Expert Reviews: 2
7. Allen Eskens The Life We Bury
Overall Score: 8.2
Expert Reviews: 9
8. Jeff Carson Foreign Deceit
Overall Score: 8.1
Expert Reviews: 2
9. Christopher Greyson The Girl Who Lived
Overall Score: 8.0
Expert Reviews: 7
10. Michael Crichton A Case of Need
Overall Score: 7.5
Expert Reviews: 4

An Overview On Thriller Novels

  • The thriller genre includes a wide range of subgenres, so it’s important to consider the type of thriller you like. Robert Dugoni’s “My Sister’s Grave” is a combination mystery, police procedural and legal thriller, with a strong emphasis on the crime and legal elements. Robert Bryndza’s “The Girl In the Ice” isn’t the right fit for police procedural lovers. It’s more of a suspenseful thriller, following a detective as she attempts to track down a serial killer. With Mike Omer’s “A Killer’s Mind,” you get another chase after a serial killer, with a mystery element that will catch even the most seasoned reader off guard. If you’re familiar with Michael Connelly’s Bosch series, you likely already know he writes mystery thrillers with a strong emphasis on the characters.
  • The goal of any thriller reader is to find a book they can’t quite put down. Robert Dugoni’s “My Sister’s Grave” is one of those books. You’ll get smooth writing that pulls you in from the start. Even though the book does feature some flashbacks, they don’t overwhelm the story. Robert Dugoni, a New York Times bestselling author, introduces us to Tracy Crosswhite, a homicide detective with the Seattle Police Department, who is motivated to track down serial killers due to her sister’s disappearance 20 years prior.
  • Robert Bryndza’s “The Girl In the Ice” features not only an attention-grabbing title and cover, but it also hooks you from page one. You’ll enter the world of Erika Foster, a detective who lost her husband during her last investigation. She’s on the trail of a serial killer possibly responsible for a series of murders in London. There are a few clichés, but you’ll probably be too caught up in the compelling storyline to notice.
  • With Mike Omer’s “A Killer’s Mind,” you get a plot full of twists as it follows Zoe Bentley, a forensic psychologist chasing down a serial killer. Three women have been found embalmed and posed and Zoe has to track down the culprit before he tracks her down.
  • The name Harry Bosch is no stranger to thriller fans, and Michael Connelly’s “The Wrong Side of Goodbye” introduces readers to the 19th book in the series. In this book, Bosch is hired to find the former lover of a dying reclusive billionaire. This book comes across as fresh, even though it’s part of a long-running series.
  • When a thriller fails, it’s often because it simply isn’t “thrilling” enough. That has a great deal to do with pacing. Robert Bryndza’s “The Girl In the Ice” features a relentless pace that keeps you turning the pages. Mike Omer’s “A Killer’s Mind” maintains a steady pace throughout, tossing in some humor where necessary to ease the tension. With Robert Dugoni’s “My Sister’s Grave,” the pace can tend to lag at various points. Be prepared to be patient at first, as the pace gradually builds, drawing you in more slowly than with other thrillers.
  • When it comes down to it, though, the most memorable books are those with characters you truly love. This is no more evident than with the success of the Harry Bosch series, which showcases a hero who is fearless but still very likable. In Robert Dugoni’s “My Sister’s Grave,” Tracy Crosswhite is a well-developed lead, and the secondary characters jump off the page as well. However, the antagonist is a bit one-dimensional, which takes away from the story. On the other hand, Mike Omer’s “A Killer’s Mind” excels with its bad guys, painting them as truly human, which adds to the believability of the plot.
  • Although you don’t want any spoilers, it is helpful to know if an ending is worth the hours you’re about to put into reading a book. You’ll find Robert Dugoni’s “My Sister’s Grave” has a very satisfying conclusion, as does Robert Bryndza’s “The Girl In the Ice.”

DYWM Fun Fact

Thrillers have a long history, dating all the way back to Homer’s “Odyssey,” which features a protagonist overcoming numerous obstacles to find his way home. You’ll also see thriller elements in fairy tales like “Little Red Robin Hood,” which has a young girl dealing with a stalker in the form of a “big, bad wolf.” Although contemporary experts often consider Alfred Hitchcock the master of thrillers, today’s authors often look to books like Robert Ludlum’s “The Bourne Identity” and Dan Brown’s “The Da Vinci Code” for inspiration. The popularity of Gillian Flynn’s “Gone Girl” created a new trend of twist-filled mystery-thrillers with unreliable protagonists, many written by women.

The Thriller Novel Buying Guide

There’s nothing like a thriller that pulls you in from the start and won’t let you go. But finding that book you just can’t put down can be difficult, especially with the unlimited number of books available today. It can help to start with a New York Times bestseller, but even those can be hit or miss.

Before you choose a thriller novel, it can help to narrow down exactly the type of book that interests you. Do you prefer a book that goes in-depth into police work, or do you like a story told from the criminal’s perspective? There are crime thrillers, disaster thrillers, legal thrillers, medical thrillers, spy thrillers and more. As you begin to narrow the list of subgenres you enjoy most, the list of books to add to your to-read pile will shrink considerably.

Then there are the known names. Authors like Michael Connelly have become fan favorites due to their consistent delivery of compelling stories. Readers know exactly what they’re getting when they pick up a favorite author’s book, and unless the author lets them down, they’ll stay loyal. It also helps when an author’s books land a movie or TV deal, further helping readers know exactly what to expect.

But as with any genre of fiction, it’s all about the writing itself. It’s especially important for thriller novels to maintain a fast pace, prompting readers to turn the page to see what happens next. Many of today’s thrillers also pack in plenty of twists, thanks to the large group of readers who like to try to solve a mystery. But as valuable as those twists are, it won’t help if the reader is left disappointed at the end, so the payoff of those twists is essential.

In many cases, though, it all comes down to characters. If you look back at some of your favorite novels, chances are you think of the characters first. The ability to make the fictional people in a story jump off the page is what makes some authors more successful than others. When you’re reading book reviews, pay close attention to mention of characters since you’ll likely toss the book in the trash if they’re too unredeemable.