Presto CoolDaddy Locking Odor Reduction Electric Deep Fryer

Last updated date: April 29, 2022

DWYM Score


Presto CoolDaddy Locking Odor Reduction Electric Deep Fryer

Why Trust DWYM?

DWYM is your trusted product review source. Along with our in-house experts, our team analyzes thousands of product reviews from the most trusted websites. We then create one easy-to-understand review. Learn more.

Don't Waste Your Money Seal of Approval
Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in the category.
Show Contents

We looked at the top Electric Deep Fryers and dug through the reviews from some of the most popular review sites. Through this analysis, we've determined the best Electric Deep Fryer you should buy.

Update as April 29, 2022:
Checkout The Best Electric Deep Fryer for a detailed review of all the top electric deep fryers.

Overall Take

For smaller households, this electric deep fryer is the perfect choice. It holds only 1.9 liters of oil, making it easy to store in a cabinet when not in use. It also has a built-in indicator light that lets you know when the oil is hot and ready for food to be added. A viewing window lets you keep an eye on your food without lifting the lid. We like that this comes with a charcoal filter to absorb odor.

In our analysis of 58 expert reviews, the Presto CoolDaddy Locking Odor Reduction Electric Deep Fryer placed 11th when we looked at the top 15 products in the category. For the full ranking, see below.

From The Manufacturer

Delicious deep fried foods, fast and easy. Perfect for chicken, shrimp, french fries and more. Exterior handle lowers food into the oil with the cover closed to prevent spattering. Removable pot with nonstick cooking surface. assures quick and easy cleanups. Big six-serving capacity in a compact-size deep fryer. Adjustable thermostat permits easy selection of the desired frying temperature. Locking cover prevents spattering and reduces odor. Removable air filter absorbs odors. Handy indicator light lets you know when the oil is ready for frying. Extra large viewing window lets you supervise frying without opening the cover. Presto* CoolDaddy* cool-touch deep fryer (6-cup capacity) 120 volts AC, 1500 watts, 60 Hz. “

Expert Reviews

Expert Summarized Score

8 expert reviews

User Summarized Score

2,115 user reviews

What experts liked

Comes with multiple features for easy handling, including an adjustable thermostat, an indicator light and a locking cover designed to prevent spills and reduce odors.
- BestReviews
It reduces the greasy smells really well, the basket is helpful so that the user doesn’t get any splatter while frying.
- ratingle
It’s very safe to use. It’s designed not to even have a possibility of getting burned. The locking cover will keep all the oil from splattering.
- Home Kitchen Land
January 9, 2017 | Full review
Compact size with included basket.
- At Least We Fried
May 8, 2018 | Full review
The adjustable thermostat and indicator light make the fryer easy to operate for all. One simply sets the needed temperature and the light will let them know when the oil is ready.
- Top Fryer
You need not worry about oil splattering or smell with this deep fryer.
- Best Deep Fryer Reviews
February 26, 2018 | Full review
Safe to use as it has a large viewing window where the frying delicacies can be observed without opening the lid which makes the machine quite convenient.
- Deepfryerly
Features adjustable thermostat and cool-touch exterior
- The Deep Fryer Expert
January 8, 2019 | Full review

What experts didn't like

Slightly less power than some of the higher priced models.
- BestReviews
The Presto Fryer is not dishwasher-safe. It must be washed by hand which can make it somewhat tedious to use.
- ratingle
Presto 05442 deep fryer has no on/off switch.
- Home Kitchen Land
January 9, 2017 | Full review
Struggles to maintain temperature.
- At Least We Fried
May 8, 2018 | Full review
All parts of the fryer except for the basket which can be put in the dishwasher have to cleaned by hand.
- Top Fryer
Time to heat up is more in case of this presto cooldaddy fryer.
- Best Deep Fryer Reviews
February 26, 2018 | Full review
The user has to be keen since it does not switch itself off if left on for long or while it is frying
- Deepfryerly
The removable pot requires you to place it properly every time you cooking
- The Deep Fryer Expert
January 8, 2019 | Full review

An Overview On Electric Deep Fryers

If you’ve tried to make fried chicken, shrimp or even French fries at home, you’ve likely found pan frying doesn’t quite do the trick. Frying pans are shallow, not allowing you to completely immerse food in oil. You’ll also deal with grease spatter all over your stove unless you’re careful, which means extra cleanup time after dinner.

An electric deep fryer is a great way to fry the foods you love in the comfort of your home. Simply fill it up with oil, wait for it to heat and insert your items. In a matter of minutes, you’ll have a tasty snack or a great side item for your meal. Since many electric deep fryers have lids and other safety mechanisms, you’ll also have protection from dangerous, not to mention messy, spatters.

Before you buy, you’ll want to decide the capacity you’ll need. If you plan to deep fry the occasional turkey or hold parties where you’ll fry up large quantities of food, you’ll need a larger capacity fryer.  But keep in mind these come at a price. The bigger size means you’ll need to find somewhere in your kitchen to store your fryer. But the smaller-sized fryers limit the food you’ll be able to cook.

Clean-up is also an important factor. Some fryers feature removable parts that you can simply slip into the dishwasher, while many others require each part to be hand washed after use. You’ll also have oil to discard after each use, so make sure you have a plan for taking care of that. Some fryers even let you save the oil to use next time.

Of course, in the end, it’s all about cooking. Some fryers have temperature controls, which makes it easier to cook a wide variety of food. You’ll also find that an indicator light can come in handy. These lights let you know when your oil is hot and ready for you to begin inserting food.

Kristin Forte/Simplemost Media

The Electric Deep Fryer Buying Guide

  • One very important thing to look at when shopping for a deep fryer is capacity. If you plan to hold big parties or you have a big family, you may want to consider a deep fryer with a larger capacity.
  • The T-Fal Deep Fryer uses 3.5 liters of oil, while other brands have models with capacities of 1.1 liter, 2 quarts, 3.4 quarts, 4 quarts and 5 liters. The 5-liter version is perfect for deep frying large food items like turkeys.
  • For smaller households or just cooking up some side dishes, though, consider a model that holds around 1.9 liters. You’ll have all the capacity you need without taking up excessive counter space.
  • Temperature accuracy is important when you’re inserting food and trusting a device to cook it as needed. Look for a brand that sustains heat better than other deep fryers, even remaining hot as you add food directly from the freezer. Some models, on the other hand, have only one temperature, which doesn’t work for all foods
  • Cooking with oil can be messy, as you’ve likely found if you’ve fried foods on the stove. After you’ve finished cooking, you’ll want cleanup to be as quick and painless as possible. The T-Fal Deep Fryer has easily detachable, dishwasher-safe parts. If the model you’re interested in isn’t dishwasher safe, look for a nonstick finish to make it easy to scrub clean.
  • You can’t start frying without filling your fryer with oil, and all of that has to go somewhere once you’re finished. The T-Fal Deep Fryer stores all that oil in a container that you can then save for future use. That means every time you’re ready to start cooking, you’ll have the oil from your previous session, saving you the trouble of disposing of oil afterward. Best of all, the oil is automatically strained into a separate tank, so you won’t get larger food particles in your reusable oil.
  • Consider a deep fryer that collects oil in a removable container with a built-in pouring spout.
  • One concern with household deep frying is odor. You likely don’t want your home to smell like a hamburger joint for the next few days. Consider a model that is built to cut down on those scents to keep your home smelling great.
  • Look for a model with an indicator light that lets you know when the oil is at the perfect temperature for adding food.
  • Safety is an important feature in a deep fryer. This starts with the lid. The T-Fal Deep Fryer has a sealed cooking lid that will lock your contents inside to avoid grease spatter. It also has a magnetic attachment on the power cord that will ensure that the power shuts off immediately if the fryer tips over.
  • One benefit of certain cool-touch models is that they have a viewing window that lets you keep an eye on your food without lifting the lid.
  • Deep fryers can vary dramatically in size, so measure your available space before you buy. The high capacity of the T-Fal Deep Fryer makes it tough to tuck into a corner or squeeze into a cabinet. Models that are smaller in size don’t pose much difficulty when it comes to storage.
  • Deep fryers are relatively affordable, with even the highest-priced model retailing for less than $100. The T-Fal Deep Fryer is the most expensive. You’ll find that the smaller fryers are the most affordable.