Neutrogena Alcohol-Free Makeup Remover & Foam Cleanser

Last updated: August 8, 2022

Neutrogena Alcohol-Free Makeup Remover & Foam Cleanser

Our Review Process

Don't Waste Your Money is focused on helping you make the best purchasing decision. Our team of experts spends hundreds of hours analyzing, testing, and researching products so you don't have to. Learn more.

Don't Waste Your Money Seal of Approval
Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in the category.
Show Contents

We looked at the top Foam Cleansers and dug through the reviews from some of the most popular review sites. Through this analysis, we've determined the best Foam Cleanser you should buy.

Overall Take

In our analysis of 18 expert reviews, the Neutrogena Alcohol-Free Makeup Remover & Foam Cleanser placed 7th when we looked at the top 8 products in the category. For the full ranking, see below.

From The Manufacturer

Cleanse and wash away makeup in one easy step with Neutrogena Fresh Facial Foaming Cleanser. Safe for sensitive eyes, this all-in-one makeup remover and facial cleanser helps remove even waterproof eye makeup and leaves skin feeling refreshingly clean. Dermatologist-tested, the daily face wash creates a foamy lather that easily washes away dirt and oil without over-drying skin or stinging and irritating the sensitive eye area. Its gentle oil-, soap- and alcohol-free formula rinses completely clean, with no pore-clogging residue. From a dermatologist-recommended skincare brand, this facial foaming cleanser is hypoallergenic and non-comedogenic, so it won’t clog pores.

Expert Reviews


What experts liked

Fit for all types of skin, this is a classic option that combines dermatologist-tested ingredients for safe and comfortable removal.
We were pleasantly surprised by how light and conditioning this formula feels. It's both gentle and effective in removing the day's grime, as well as our waterproof liner and mascara, without any aggressive rubbing or excessive rinsing. And our skin remained soft even after cleansing.
- Allure
Cleanses skin deep within. Removes all the dirt and excess oil. Removes almost all the makeup including waterproof version. Skin feels fresh and clean without any stretchy feeling or dryness. Works well for my sensitive skin without causing breakouts. Leaves behind no last traces. Price is reasonable one bottle will last fairly long. Convenient to use pump dispenser.

What experts didn't like

Foaming qualities may not be as dramtic as other products on the list.
Needs a bit of efforts to remove stubborn eye liner. Packaging is not travel friendly.

Overview

A foam facial cleanser can be great for your skin because it guards your face from drying out as well as abrasion caused by contact. This product can make deep cleaning seem effortless, since there’s no scrubbing required.

So how do you know that you need a foam cleanser in the first place? Long story short: If your skin tends to be oily or you suffer from skin conditions like acne or rosacea, foam will probably be your best option. Cream cleansers have a thicker consistency that’s best absorbed by dry skin, while gel cleansers generally have a milder formula that can work with a wide variety of skin types. But with foam cleansers, those bubbles and lather aren’t just for show. They help to pull excess oil away from the skin, leaving it rejuvenated without harming sensitive pores or removing helpful natural oils.

If you’re using a cleanser at night (and you should), it has to remove makeup, sunscreen and other impurities you’ve collected during the course of the day. That’s best done with oils, which may seem counterintuitive if you’ve already got oily skin. There are beneficial oils that can promote skin health, though, such as coconut or jojoba oil. Look for those and other natural ingredients that can help lift away the bad stuff (dirt, makeup) while leaving in the good.

There are plenty of other good ingredients you can look for, though some may help certain skin types better than others. Glycerin is always a good bet, and you’ll see it in most foam cleansers. This compound is a humectant, which means it works to draw moisture into the pores. It’s a substance that’s already found in healthy skin, so you can’t really go wrong. In cleansers, glycerin is most effective at concentrations around 10%, but any amount helps. Aloe vera is a plant-based topical that soothes damaged skin and can also help moisturize.

You may also see a lot of foam cleansers advertise themselves as “pH balanced” and wonder how that makes a difference. In fact,  maintaining your skin’s pH is crucial. For those who might be allergic to science: The pH scale is used to measure acidity or alkalinity, with the most acidic substances rated zero and the most alkaline at 14. When it’s healthy, your face should measure around a five. Here’s the problem: That pH rating can be thrown out of whack by the wrong makeup, allergens or even cleansers that might otherwise help your face. When they become more alkaline, your pores get dry and itchy. More acid means they may break out. A pH-balanced cleanser is one where all the ingredients are proportioned to keep that pH rating where it should be.

Finally, there are a few things you may not want to find in your cleanser. For example, you may wish to avoid sodium lauryl sulfate (SLS), which has been used in the past to help cleansers get their sudsy consistency. SLS can cause irritation for many skin types, but when used in small amounts and rinsed off quickly it has been shown to be safe in cosmetic formulations.

Also use caution around cleansers that use a fragrance. The smell may be nice, but it usually comes from a mix of ingredients (often unlisted) that can be allergens. Even natural ones like geranium oil can cause a reaction.

More to explore