Napoleon Prestige 500 Gas Grill

Last updated date: October 16, 2019

DWYM Score
8.3

Why Trust The DWYM Score?

DWYM is your trusted product review source. Along with our in-house experts, our team analyzes thousands of product reviews from the most trusted websites. We then create one easy-to-understand score. Learn more.

Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in the category.

We looked at the top 1 Gas Grills and dug through the reviews from 7 of the most popular review sites including The Spruce Eats, Consumer Reports, Top Ten Reviews, Best Reviews Guide, BestReviews, Amazing Ribs, Grills Zone and more. Through this analysis, we've determined the best Gas Grill you should buy.

Overall Take

Even cooking and extra burners make this a great choice for those who regularly grill for large groups. Four wheels make it easy to maneuver around, while three color choices let you customize it to fit your space. The high price though may put it out of range for many consumers. In our analysis of 55 expert reviews, the Napoleon Napoleon Prestige 500 Gas Grill placed 3rd when we looked at the top 10 products in the category. For the full ranking, see below.

Editor's Note October 21, 2019:
Checkout The Best Gas Grill for a detailed review of all the top gas grills.

Expert Summarized Score
8.9
7 expert reviews
User Summarized Score
7.1
44 user reviews
Our Favorite Video Reviews
What experts liked
The high-quality stainless steel burners produce a high, even temperature; while the porcelain coated cooking grates in the wave pattern give excellent heat contact.
- The Spruce Eats
November 3, 2018 | Full review
With a large cooking area and ample shelf space, this high-end midsize grill is a stand-out cooker, delivering impressively even heat, a wide range of high and low temperatures, and effective indirect heat for slow cooking.
- Consumer Reports
The Napoleon Prestige Pro has 8 main burners and an enormous amount of cooking space and power.
- Top Ten Reviews
Delivers a large cooking area for a built-in grill. Has 66,000 BTUs and five different gas burners. Stainless steel design looks great for a built-in grill area. Lighter works reliably over hundreds of uses. Includes an optional charcoal tray.
- BestReviews
The Napoleon Prestige P500RSIB is a very nice, high-end, cart-mounted, gas grill at an affordable price. The counterweight is a nice feature because it is hard to balance some foods and a counterweight is like balancing your tires.
- Amazing Ribs
Infrared side burner can reach over 1000 degrees Fahrenheit but can also be adjusted to a lower temperature for cooking sauces (a rarity among infrared burners). The rotisserie spear has a counterweight so your food remains balanced while on it
- Grills Zone
What experts didn't like
A basic grill for a relatively high cost
- The Spruce Eats
November 3, 2018 | Full review
Preheat time is middling, so prepare to wait at least 10 minutes to throw food on the grill.
- Consumer Reports
This gas grill burns through more fuel than the average grill.
- Top Ten Reviews
Not made as a standalone grill. May be too big for some people.
- BestReviews
The only assembly problem we encountered was the cabinet doors, which were a real pain to hang.
- Amazing Ribs
The warming rack needs to be removed when you use the rotisserie because it gets warped due to the heat
- Grills Zone

From The Manufacturer

This grill has everything. The Prestige Series P500RSIB-1 Gas Grill is the total package. A cart model grill by Napoleon with the capabilities of a full outdoor kitchen. The P500RSIB-1 has 4 main burners, 1 infrared rear burner and 1 infrared side burner. This gives the P500RSIB-1 the capacity to cook in at least 8 different ways. You can grill up to 30 burgers over the main burners, up to 8 burgers over the infrared side burner. Every P500RSIB-1 is test fired before packaging, ensuring that your grill will light as soon as it's out of the box. And the stainless steel construction means that this grill will last for years to come.

Overall Product Rankings

1. Weber Spirit Gas Grill
Overall Score: 9.2
Expert Reviews: 7
2. Weber Genesis II Gas Grill
Overall Score: 8.7
Expert Reviews: 7
3. Napoleon Prestige 500 Gas Grill
Overall Score: 8.3
Expert Reviews: 7
4. Dyna-Glo Gas Grill
Overall Score: 8.2
Expert Reviews: 6
5. Smoke Hollow Gas Grill
Overall Score: 8.2
Expert Reviews: 3
6. Coleman RoadTrip LXE Gas Grill
Overall Score: 8.0
Expert Reviews: 4
7. Napoleon Gas Grill
Overall Score: 7.8
Expert Reviews: 5
8. Even Embers Gas Grill
Overall Score: 7.7
Expert Reviews: 1
9. Nexgrill Gas Grill
Overall Score: 7.3
Expert Reviews: 3
10. Char-Broil Gas Grill
Overall Score: 7.3
Expert Reviews: 5

An Overview On Gas Grills

There’s no better way to enjoy warm weather than with a great backyard barbecue. Whether you’re cooking for your immediate family or a large group of friends, meat and vegetables taste a little better when cooked over a grill. Gas grills are the quickest and easiest way to cook outdoors since they fire right up in a couple of steps. However, great-tasting meals start with the grill you choose.

When shopping for grills, it can be easy to get caught up in the quality of the construction: make sure the grill’s cook box has thick and solid walls to keep the heat inside, especially if you prefer to grill year-round. Generally, heavy stainless steel is a good option because it doesn’t rust.

But while it is important to choose a sturdy, durable grill — since it will be exposed to the elements 24 hours a day,— you should put far more effort into weighing the grill’s cooking ability. Weber’s Genesis II model has burners that put the perfect sear marks on your meat, if that’s important.

Primarily, you’ll need to look for a grill that offers even heat from front to back, which provides consistency. This will let you use every square inch of burner space while cooking rather than confining all your items to the area of the grill that gets hottest.

Also, look for heavy cooking grids and full coverage from cooking elements. You don’t want hot or cold spots on your grilling surface!

The need for rapid, even heating means that you should consider size.

“With gas grills, size does matter,” says our resident kitchen expert Julie Chernoff, member of Les Dames d’Escoffier, dining editor of Better magazine and food journalist. “You shouldn’t buy more grill than you need, although it’s always tempting to buy the sexy unit with all the bells and whistles.”

She advises taking into account how much room you have for your grill and how many people you’re feeding.

“If you regularly host barbecues or friends and family, a larger-capacity grill is in order,” she says.

Ease of use may also be something you want to take note of before you buy.

“Make sure that the ignition works well — and if it is a propane system versus a dedicated natural gas line, make sure there is some sort of gauge to tell when the gas is running low,” Chernoff says. “No one wants to run out of propane halfway through a barbecue!”

One of the biggest challenges you’ll face is in knowing when your meat is cooked to the perfect temperature. Although many grills come with thermometers, these are built into the hood, which makes them inadequate for accurately measuring the internal temperature of your steaks and burgers. For that reason, you’ll probably need to stand close by with a meat thermometer in hand.

However, you don’t have to completely make cooking a guessing game. Newer models from Weber connect to an app that monitors the grill’s temperature and alerts you when your meat is done. You’ll still need to keep an eye on your grill, but this can at least let you wander away for a few minutes here and there without worrying about forgetting about your food.

As you’re shopping for a grill, also keep portability in mind. The Smoke Hollow 205 is designed for a tabletop, making it perfect for taking on camping trips. Even having a grill with wheels for moving it around can make a difference if you’re concerned about an approaching hail storm or a winter filled with ice and snow.

You’ll likely be able to choose from some exciting extras, including side burners, tool hooks, a rotisserie or a smoker box. When deciding on these, consider how likely you are to use them and for what purpose.

“I find the side burner useful for reducing marinades and melting butter to brush on corn, and tool hooks keep utensils handy,” Chernoff says.

Fortunately, there are a few grills on the market that will provide all of the extras you want while also helping you cook delicious meals. Simply outline the feature set you want and your budget, and you’ll quickly find the right grill for you.

DYWM Fun Fact

It’s likely no surprise that summertime is the most popular season for grilling, but one holiday beats all others for grilling out: Independence Day. Memorial Day and Labor Day are also popular for outdoor barbecues. But the good news is that thanks to outdoor fire pits and heaters, it’s becoming easier to cook outdoors year-round. You can grill anything from steaks to asparagus. However, hamburgers rank as the most popular, although children rank hot dogs at the top of the list. When cooking for a large group, hot dogs and hamburgers are an inexpensive option, especially if you have everyone bring side items like potato salad and baked beans.

The Gas Grill Buying Guide

  • There’s nothing more frustrating than marinating your steaks or patting out your burgers, only to get to the grill and learn you’re out of propane. The Weber Spirit II helps you out with a gauge that tells you approximately how much gas is left.
  • One ongoing issue with grills is cooking consistency. You’ll likely find no matter what grill you choose, some areas burn warmer than others. The Weber Spirit II runs hotter on the back than on the front, while the Weber Genesis II impresses with the evenness of its heat. The Napoleon Prestige 500 includes high-quality stainless-steel burners that provide an even temperature throughout.
  • Pay close attention to the location of the thermometer. The vast majority of grills place it on the hood, where it can’t accurately gauge the temperature of the meat cooking inside. You’ll likely still need to use a meat thermometer even with this to make sure the internal temperature of your meat is within a safe range.
  • If you plan to cook for large groups, capacity is a must. The Weber Spirit II has three burners, making it ideal for cooking for five to seven people. The tabletop Smoke Hollow model can fit up to eight burgers. The two-burner grill on the Weber Genesis II can seem cramped at times, especially if you have people over for a summertime party.
  • A side burner can make a big difference if you’re trying to cook multiple items. The Napoleon Prestige 500 includes four main burners, one infrared rear burner and one infrared side burner, giving you extra space if you’re cooking for groups or simply want to separate out what you’re cooking.
  • The Weber Genesis II features an externally-mounted propane tank, which is easier to maneuver than the traditional under grill storage setup you’ll usually get with a propane tank. Best of all, the area under your grill stays free for storing tools, platters and whatever else you need to set aside while you’re cooking.
  • When you’re grilling, it can be tough to keep up with all the tools you’ll need. The Weber Spirit II comes with six hooks to make it easy to store your tools where they’re always handy.
  • The Weber Spirit II and Genesis II have a unique Infinity ignition system that helps you fire up the grill quickly every time.
  • If you cook small items like shrimp, you’ll spend most of your time trying to keep them from falling into the fire. To prevent that, choose a grill like the Weber Spirit II that has tightly-spaced grates.
  • One major benefit to the Weber grills is that they’re iGrill3 ready. They feature a thermometer that connects to an app, notifying you on your device when your items are ready. This functionality currently works on their Spirit II, Genesis II and Genesis II LX grills.
  • The shape of Weber Genesis II’s burners sets it apart from others. Instead of the tube burners traditionally seen with grills, this model has tapered quadrangle-shaped burners.
  • The makeup of the Genesis II’s grates promotes sear marks on meats.
  • Occasionally, you may need to move the grill around, especially if your area gets rough weather and you need to roll your grill to a sheltered area. One disadvantage to the Weber Spirit II is that it only has two wheels, making it a little tougher to maneuver around. Both the Weber Genesis II and Napoleon Prestige 500 have four wheels.
  • If you’re interested in a fully portable model, consider the Smoke Hollow 205, which is designed to be set up on a table. This means you can take it along on camping trips.
  • Unlike other grills, which operate on a propane tank, the Smoke Hollow 205 uses small, disposable propane cylinders. Although this is convenient for transport and storage, it’s important to note that you may have a slightly harder time finding them. They’re sold as a camping accessory. It’s also important to note that they don’t ship with the grill, so you may want to purchase them so you’ll have them on hand when your grill arrives.
  • Although it’s probably going to be easier to find than the Smoke Hollow’s canisters, any grill you buy will need a propane tank. You can find them at home improvement retailers and gas stations. Best of all, once you’ve purchased a tank or canister, you should be able to get them refilled at a variety of locations for a fraction of the price you spent originally.
  • If you’re looking for a grill that’s built to withstand years of outdoor rigors, consider the Weber Genesis II. It has a frame made from welded beams, rather than sheet metal. The Smoke Hollow is also durable, with sturdy stainless-steel construction.
  • If something does go wrong with your grill, it’s important to know that you can get help. Weber offers the longest and most complete warranty in the industry at 10 years.
  • Although appearance isn’t always the top priority in finding a grill, it will become a part of your backyard aesthetics. The Weber Spirit II offers the most options, giving you a choice of black, ivory, red or sapphire. The Napoleon Prestige 500 is available in black, blue or stainless steel.
  • Once the grilling is done, you’ll have to clean things up. The Weber Genesis II is easy to clean. In addition to its unique tapered grill bars, it also has a grease management system under the firebox. To make cleanup even easier, you can insert a disposable aluminum pan in the slide-out tray and simply toss the tray when you’re finished.
  • If you don’t already have a grill, don’t forget the tools you’ll need to get started. You can buy stainless-steel grilling sets that usually include a storage case. At the very least, you’ll need a spatula and tongs. But you may also want to invest in a grill-specific cleaning brush, basting brush and corn holders.
  • If your grill is going to be exposed to the elements, you may also want to invest in a heavy-duty, weatherproof cover to help it last longer.