Legend Tilted Handles Cast Iron Pizza Pan

Last updated date: November 22, 2021

DWYM Score

9.8

Legend Tilted Handles Cast Iron Pizza Pan

Why Trust DWYM?

DWYM is your trusted product review source. Along with our in-house experts, our team analyzes thousands of product reviews from the most trusted websites. We then create one easy-to-understand review. Learn more.

Don't Waste Your Money Seal of Approval
Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in the category.
Show Contents

We looked at the top Cast Iron Pizza Pans and dug through the reviews from some of the most popular review sites. Through this analysis, we've determined the best Cast Iron Pizza Pan you should buy.

Update as November 22, 2021:
Checkout The Best Cast Iron Pizza Pans for a detailed review of all the top cast iron pizza pans.

Overall Take

This 14-inch pan arrives seasoned with 100% vegetable oil to get you started baking delicious pizzas. As you cook, the pan builds on that seasoning, forming crusts that are packed with flavors. Deeper walls and large, tilted handles mean you can create everything from thin-crust pizza to the deep dish style that’s popular in Detroit.


In our analysis of 21 expert reviews, the Legend Tilted Handles Cast Iron Pizza Pan placed 1st when we looked at the top 6 products in the category. For the full ranking, see below.

From The Manufacturer

THE PAN. THE MYTH. THE LEGEND: Legend cast iron pizza pan combines a rich heritage with modern cooking needs. Famous for lifelong durability and workhorse versatility, Legend cast iron cast from solid, pure steel and iron, this healthy nonstick pizza pan is THE master of heat distribution. LARGER, TILTED HANDLES FOR EASY LIFTING: 14 inch round pizza maker features large, heavy duty side handles and deeper walls for everything from NY thin to Detroit deep dish. Also perfect as griddle for fajitas, quesadillas, eggs, omelets, bacon, pancakes, steaks and more. IMPROVES WITH EVERY USE: The more you cook, the better they perform. Your Legend skillets arrive with a foundational seasoning of 100% vegetable oil (no synthetics/chemicals). As you build up your own seasoning, you write your story into pans worth passing down. LEGEND’S “FOREVER WARRANTY”: Legend Cast Iron pots and pans last a lifetime and then some. Nothing beats cast iron durability; just try putting a dent in these! If our craftsmanship or cooking performance ever fail, you’ll get your money back. Some things do last forever.

Expert Reviews

User Summarized Score

9.2
1,190 user reviews

What experts liked

Extremely durable. Heavy-duty side handles. Distributes heat evenly. Easy to clean.
- Did You Know Homes
Efficient aeration and heating. Durable design. Handles allow easy use.
- Dinners and Dreams
Durable cast iron lasts indefinitely. Cast iron is a versatile material usable for almost any cooking purpose. Affordable price is excellent to see for good cast iron. Good handles for easy removal from oven or stove heat.
- Grill Baby Grill

What experts didn't like

Can become rusty if not stored properly. Seasoning the pan can be time-consuming. Very heavy.
- Did You Know Homes
Cleaning is difficult as it is not dishwasher friendly.
- Dinners and Dreams
Cast iron has very specific care and use instructions that should be followed, making it sometimes a hassle to deal with.
- Grill Baby Grill

An Overview On Cast Iron Pizza Pans

There’s an art to making a good pizza. If you’ve ever tried to create your own at home, you probably know that pizzerias have mastered that art, and it can be tough to duplicate just the right taste and texture using a cookie sheet. A good pan can make a big difference, though.

A cast iron pizza pan can produce that crisp, flavorful crust that takes your pizza to the next level. The material simply interacts with dough in a way that steel and aluminum can’t. Whether you’re making your pizza from scratch or cooking frozen pizzas, a cast iron pizza pan will improve upon the final product.

In addition to offering even heat distribution and excellent heat retention properties, cast iron absorbs the flavors of the items you cook. Over time, your crusts and other items will be tastier simply because you used your favorite pizza pan.

But before you buy a cast iron pan of any type, you’ll first need to be aware of how high maintenance they can be.

Unless your cast iron pan specifies otherwise, you won’t want to put your pan in the dishwasher. You’ll need to hand-wash it very carefully to ensure it retains its seasoning. Although you can use detergent, it should be mild and used sparingly, and you should scrub with a cleaning brush specifically made for use with cast iron pans. If food is caked or burned on, you can use a spatula and extremely hot water to remove it.

Drying a cast iron pan can be even trickier. Unlike steel or aluminum, cast iron can rust if left to air dry. The best way to dry a cast iron pan is simply to turn your stove burner on high, set the pan on it and wait for the water to boil off.

Once it’s dry, you’ll need to heat your dry pan on the stove at an extremely high temperature and rub a small amount of canola oil or flaxseed oil on the pan’s surface using a napkin or paper towel. Be careful not to touch the hot pan as you do! You can then store your pan until the next time you want to use it.

The Cast Iron Pizza Pan Buying Guide

  • Cast iron pizza pans can be useful for reheating leftover pizza, as well as breads and other dough-based items. It helps the dough retain its crispness while it’s being warmed up.
  • If you like pizzas with a thicker crust, like Detroit-style deep dish, look for a pan that has lifted edges.
  • Most cast iron pizza pans aren’t limited to making pizza. You can use them to cook fajitas, eggs, sausage and more.
  • Many of today’s cast iron pans come pre-seasoned, allowing you to use them immediately. Check the type of oil the manufacturer used for seasoning to make sure it’s compatible with your diet.
  • Take a look at the handles on any cast iron pans you buy. They get extremely hot, and this heat typically extends to the handles as well, so you’ll probably need potholders. Easy-to-grab handles can make a big difference as you’re removing your pan from the oven.
  • Cast iron pizza pans aren’t limited to the oven, either. You can often use them on the stove or on campfires and backyard grills. If you want to use your pan on a campfire, make sure it can withstand extreme temperatures.
  • If you have a glass cooktop stove, keep in mind that cast iron cookware is heavy and tough. You can easily scratch the glass with your cookware if you aren’t careful.
  • Cast iron cookware is naturally nonstick, so you won’t need to treat it with cooking spray or oils right before you add your food.  Those oils are applied and baked on after you’ve washed and dried it, in order to season it for the next use.