James Scott 5-Piece Crystal Bar Set

Last updated date: October 26, 2019

DWYM Score

Why Trust The DWYM Score?

DWYM is your trusted product review source. Along with our in-house experts, our team analyzes thousands of product reviews from the most trusted websites. We then create one easy-to-understand score. Learn more.

Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in the category.

We looked at the top Bar Serving Sets and dug through the reviews from some of the most popular review sites. Through this analysis, we've determined the best Bar Serving Set you should buy.

Overall Take

In our analysis of 48 expert reviews, the James Scott James Scott 5-Piece Crystal Bar Set placed 8th when we looked at the top 11 products in the category. For the full ranking, see below.

Editor's Note December 20, 2019:
Checkout The Best Bar Serving Set for a detailed review of all the top bar serving sets.

Expert Summarized Score
6 expert reviews
User Summarized Score
441 user reviews
Our Favorite Video Reviews
What experts liked
Classic diamond pattern catches the light, making the glass set shine. The all-glass stopper seals tightly to avoid alcohol evaporation. Black detailing on the stopper is aesthetically pleasing. Bottle is easy to grip and pours out smoothly.
- BestReviews
The James Scott Bar Set reflects the delicate, glowing splendor of magical farmland. This precious gemstone has been carefully crafted using the centuries-old tradition of glassblowers and cutters made from precious stones.
- My News 8
May 2, 2019 | Full review
The set is fairly priced and durable
- Top Best Product Reviews
It is made of crystal so it is better to be hand washed and requires delicate handling in order to ensure that it will remain beautiful throughout the years.
- Top Ten Collections
The James Scott 5 Piece Crystal Bar Set is one of the best crystal whiskey glasses for those who would appreciate a handcrafted set with 4 whiskey glasses and one 750 ml decanter.
- The Review Gurus
It is made with high-quality 24% lead crystal, and being crystal means it is delicate and requires special care, but if you take good care of it, it will remain a beautiful part of your bar ware for many years to come.
- Savored Sips
What experts didn't like
Glass arrives looking foggy, but clears up easily with a quick hand wash.
- BestReviews
It contains 24% lead
- Top Best Product Reviews

From The Manufacturer

This JAMES SCOTT 5 piece Crystal Bar Set makes the perfect gift for that classic gentlemen in your life. Designed to evoke 1920s charm, this 25 oz. decanter and 11 oz. glasses will be cherished for generations. Great groomsmen gift, best man gift, graduation gift, 21st birthday gift. Add a splash of panache to any affair with this Square Decanter Set with 4 Double Old Fashioned glasses. Serve a measure of Scotch or whiskey over ice in these elegant Double Old Fashions, which accentuate the rich amber hue of barrel-aged spirits perfectly. Whether you prefer traditional beauty or modern elegance, the JAMES SCOTT Bar Set of 5 will suit your style. Decanter is 10 tall and 3.25 wide and holds 25 oz. The glasses are 4" tall x 3 " diameter. CLICK "ADD TO CART" TO GET YOUR OWN JAMES SCOTT BAR SET VERY SOON - By buying this bar set you know that you made the right choice. With James Scott products you'll never regret your buying.

Overall Product Rankings

1. James Scott 7-Piece Decanter Set
Overall Score: 9.4
Expert Reviews: 1
2. Royal Decanters Whiskey Decanter Gift Set
Overall Score: 9.3
Expert Reviews: 8
3. Godinger Dublin Whiskey Bar Set
Overall Score: 9.2
Expert Reviews: 3
4. The Wine Savant Diamond Whiskey Decanter
Overall Score: 9.1
Expert Reviews: 1
6. The Wine Savant World Decanter with 2 Globe Glasses
Overall Score: 9.1
Expert Reviews: 2
8. James Scott 5-Piece Crystal Bar Set
Overall Score: 9.1
Expert Reviews: 6
9. Paksh Novelty Glass Decanter & Whisky Glasses Set
Overall Score: 9.1
Expert Reviews: 7
10. James Scott 6-Piece Crystal Whiskey Decanter Set
Overall Score: 8.8
Expert Reviews: 1
11. Bormioli Rocco Whiskey Gift Set
Overall Score: 8.8
Expert Reviews: 6

An Overview On Bar Serving Sets

If you keep liquor around the house, you need a good serving set. This is especially true if you regularly host guests. With a decorative set of glasses, you’ll immediately send the message that it’s time to relax and enjoy a good drink.

Simplemost Media

One of the most important features of a serving set is the decanter. Although decanters are great for holding your beverages for pouring later, they actually serve a very important purpose. A decanter is designed to help your liquor retain its flavor and consistency. They’re particularly popular for whiskey and wine, although the two beverages need very different types of decanters, so make sure you choose the one that fits your own needs.

Simplemost Media

A decanter allows the liquid inside to breathe, so in using it, you’ll find your drinks are more richly flavored than if you’d poured them directly from the bottle. But each decanter comes with a stopper that should create an airtight seal when in place. One of the biggest issues with decanters is that the included stopper allows air through, so make sure your chosen set has a decanter with a good seal.

Simplemost Media

When you consider bar serving sets, you probably think solely of your favorite after-work drink. But some serving sets are versatile enough to use with any type of beverage, from your morning glass of orange juice to that iced tea you like with lunch. If you prefer a multipurpose serving set, make sure you look for that while you’re shopping.

Simplemost Media

Many decanters are made using crystal, and that meant at one time, lead was found in the decanters people used. If you’ll be storing your beverages in your decanter for a period of time, this could become a problem, as the lead could leach into the liquid and create health concerns. Check for verbiage that indicates the bar set is lead-free.

DYWM Fun Fact

A decanter can come in handy for entertaining, but it likely isn’t necessary for storing your favorite liquors. Whiskey, in particular, won’t benefit much from being stored in a decanter. According to the Scotch Whisky Association, bottled whiskey is a finished product, which means it will pretty much taste the same whether decanted or not. But as your whiskey levels drop in that original bottle, the liquor will start to oxidize. One beverage that does benefit from decanting is wine, which does lose its quality with oxidation. Decanting also helps remove sediment in some wines, so wine drinkers may find a bar set brings even more value to an at-home happy hour.

The Bar Serving Set Buying Guide

  • Typically, with a bar set, you’ll get four glasses, a decanter and a serving tray. But the James Scott 7-Piece Decanter Set, Godinger Dublin Whiskey Bar Set and Paksh Novelty Glass Decanter & Whisky Glasses Set have six glasses each. The Royal Decanters Whiskey Decanter Gift Set comes with four glasses.
  • Decanter size is also worth taking into consideration. The James Scott 7-Piece Decanter Set and Paksh Novelty Glass Decanter & Whisky Glasses Set can hold around 33 ounces of liquid each. The Royal Decanters Whiskey Decanter Gift Set and Godinger Dublin Whiskey Bar Set are closer to 28 ounces.
  • When it comes to design, the Royal Decanters Whiskey Decanter Gift Set stands out, with a round decanter and nautical etchings that make it a perfect gift. If you prefer the more classic look, though, the James Scott 7-Piece Decanter Set and Paksh Novelty Glass Decanter & Whisky Glasses Set are very similar in design and both deliver that typical bar set look.
  • In addition to its standout design, the James Scott 7-Piece Decanter Set earns points for ease of storage. It has a wooden stand that you can use to slide it into a cabinet when you aren’t using it.
  • Not all decanters are created equal when it comes to storing liquid. The James Scott 7-Piece Decanter Set is great for rum, vodka and tequila, while the Royal Decanters Whiskey Decanter Gift Set works well for those who love whiskey, scotch and bourbon. The decanter on the Godinger Dublin Whiskey Bar Set not only accommodates whiskey, scotch, bourbon and vodka, but also wine. The Paksh Novelty Glass Decanter & Whisky Glasses Set’s decanter is ideal for whiskey, bourbon and scotch, but the diamond cut of the glasses makes them great for every type of beverage, including juices and water.
  • Today’s consumers have grown used to tumblers that keep their beverages cold for hours. Bar sets add that feature in by using a type of glass that reduces condensation and keeps coolness in. The James Scott 7-Piece Decanter Set uses ultra-clarity glass for this.
  • Getting your items to your front door undamaged can sometimes be a challenge, but you’ll find most manufacturers will replace any items that arrive damaged. The James Scott 7-Piece Decanter Set takes that a step further with a 100 percent delivery guarantee, sending a new set out free of charge if there are any issues. The Royal Decanters Whiskey Decanter Gift Set comes with a money-back guarantee and a lifetime warranty. If you don’t like the set, contact them and they’ll issue a full refund.
  • The hourglass design of the James Scott 7-Piece Decanter Set makes the decanter easy to hold while you’re pouring.
  • You have the option of dishwasher cleaning or handwashing with most bar sets. If that’s important to you, make sure your chosen decanter and glasses are dishwasher-safe.