Igloo Cooler, 25 Quart

Last updated date: November 24, 2019

DWYM Score
8.0

Why Trust The DWYM Score?

DWYM is your trusted product review source. Along with our in-house experts, our team analyzes thousands of product reviews from the most trusted websites. We then create one easy-to-understand score. Learn more.

Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in the category.

We looked at the top 1 Small Hard Coolers and dug through the reviews from 11 of the most popular review sites including BestReviews, Reviews Right Now, Guide Options, Aalsum Reviews, Outdoor Gear Lab, 99 Boulders, SOutdoors, Food & Wine, Products 88, Improb, Beyond The Tent and more. Through this analysis, we've determined the best Small Hard Cooler you should buy.

Overall Take

In our analysis of 116 expert reviews, the Igloo Igloo Cooler, 25 Quart placed 6th when we looked at the top 10 products in the category. For the full ranking, see below.

Editor's Note December 9, 2019:
Checkout The Best Small Hard Cooler for a detailed review of all the top small hard coolers.

Expert Summarized Score
7.6
11 expert reviews
User Summarized Score
8.8
555 user reviews
Our Favorite Video Reviews
What experts liked
Durable everything. Features blow -molded construction, a reinforced base, stainless steel hardware, and rubberized T -grip latches. It is also lightweight. Extra thick insulation allows for 5 days of ice retention at 90 -degrees. Super solid, and you can sit on it.
- BestReviews
October 1, 2019 | Full review
This heavy duty blow-molded cooler has it all! Extra-thick foam walls and insulated lid for the best cooling performance proven to hold ice for 5 days at 90 Degrees. Convenient size for optimal performance.
- Reviews Right Now
Large storage capacity. Affordable. With a lot of steel in this roto-molded design, it is definitely solid but light enough.
- Guide Options
September 27, 2019 | Full review
The Igloo BMX 52 quart is your go-to cooler for any rugged or leisure adventure you find yourself in! with our heavy duty blow-molded construction not only will you have some serious durability but also ice retention for over 5 days! take it to the Beach, take it camping or take it to the tailgate because wherever you go you'll be prepared with the best.
- Aalsum Reviews
October 31, 2018 | Full review
A well-performing, personal-sized cooler for a fraction of the price of its competition.
- Outdoor Gear Lab
Overall, the BMX is a solid cooler at a great price. Even the 52-quart model can be found for a third of what our other award winners retail for. The Best Value award is well deserved.
- 99 Boulders
For the price, this is the best value in camping coolers today. There may be more affordable options but they lack the performance of the Igloo BMX. There are better brands that hold ice longer but they cost a fortune. This is simply one of the best dollar for dollar values out there that can compete on some level with more expensive brands.
- SOutdoors
April 5, 2019 | Full review
This cooler’s specific design features—like an elevated base and UV inhibitors—keep your ice cold for four to five days, while the stainless-steel hardware is rust and weather-resistant to ensure maximum performance. The compact size makes this cooler easy to pick up and carry, but the wheels on the bottom mean you don’t have to.
- Food & Wine
July 16, 2019 | Full review
The Igloo BMX Cooler is innovatively designed with a reinforced base to keep it strong and manage the weight with light side walls. The base is slightly curved to minimize the hot ground touching surface area. The lid is designed with a focus to withstand UV and Heating action of Infrared Radiations. The extra foam layer inside the lid ensures that inner contents stay protected. Its capable of providing ice retention for 5 days.
- Products 88
It has thick foam and an insulated lid to prevent cold air from escaping and, in turn, retaining ice for up to four days. The cooler has a molded base that keeps it away from hot surfaces and enhances its cooling performance. This cooler also has rubberized latches that keep its lid secure
- Improb
March 29, 2019 | Full review
It has thick walls and a thick lid. It’s able to hit around three days of ice retention. With a freezer-style rubber gasket (which it lacks), it would likely be able to hit up to four or even five days of ice life.
- Beyond The Tent
What experts didn't like
Some felt that this cooler was overpriced for what it does. Some buyers did their own ice test and report that this cooler only holds ice for about 1 to 2 days.
- BestReviews
October 1, 2019 | Full review
Less ice retention. Poor Latch D.
- Guide Options
September 27, 2019 | Full review
It lacks an air/watertight seal, which loses it some points on insulation, and the rubber latches can catch against your leg if you carry it the wrong way around.
- Outdoor Gear Lab
The BMX finished toward the bottom of the pack in our spill and durability testing. While the cooler’s body and latches felt solidly constructed and held up well, some of the plastic components weren’t quite as well-made. In particular, we felt like the hinges on the lid would be easy to break if the cooler were pushed open too far. The lack of a drain is also a bummer.
- 99 Boulders
Less Ice Retention. Poor Latch Design.
- SOutdoors
April 5, 2019 | Full review
The only notable setback is a slight lack of build quality in some of the individual components. In addition to the lack of a freezer-style rubber gasket, the hinges lack the durability the rest of the Igloo BMX is notable for
- Beyond The Tent

From The Manufacturer

This heavy duty blow-molded cooler has it all! Extra-thick foam walls and insulated lid for the best cooling performance proven to hold ice for 5 days at 90 Degrees. Convenient size for optimal performance.

Overall Product Rankings

1. Coleman Flip Lid Cooler, 5 Quarts
Overall Score: 9.3
Expert Reviews: 12
2. Stanley Cooler, 16 Quart
Overall Score: 9.1
Expert Reviews: 22
3. Klein Tools Work Cooler, 17 Quart
Overall Score: 9.0
Expert Reviews: 20
4. Igloo Cooler, 16 Quart
Overall Score: 9.0
Expert Reviews: 5
5. Igloo Cooler, 12 Quart
Overall Score: 8.9
Expert Reviews: 8
6. Igloo Cooler, 25 Quart
Overall Score: 8.0
Expert Reviews: 11
7. Igloo Mini Cooler, 4 Quart
Overall Score: 7.9
Expert Reviews: 1
8. Coleman Wheeled Cooler, 50-Quart
Overall Score: 7.8
Expert Reviews: 22
9. Coleman Cooler, 18 Quart
Overall Score: 7.5
Expert Reviews: 2
10. Igloo Personal Sized Cooler, 7 Quart
Overall Score: 7.5
Expert Reviews: 2

An Overview On Small Hard Coolers

Whether you’re heading out to the beach or going to work at a job site, a small cooler can keep you stocked in cool beverages, snacks and even lunch until you return home. But small coolers vary dramatically in build and features, so it’s important to research the many options before you buy.

One big variation between coolers is capacity. You’ll want a cooler that’s small enough to be portable while also being able to hold everything you plan to take along for your outing. Some coolers will only hold a six-pack, while others have the capacity for long-neck bottles, cases of canned beverages and snacks for a large group.

If you regularly need higher capacity, make sure your cooler has wheels and that the locations you’ll be visiting don’t include stairs or other difficult-to-navigate surfaces. For smaller coolers, a hinged lid can come in handy, as you’ll only need to open it partway to reach inside and retrieve items stored there.

Many hard coolers also have lids that serve multiple purposes. Some will flip over and become tables, for instance, making them perfect for picnics. Lid indentations can come in handy for setting your drinks in between sips. Others have features that serve as storage for items like your thermos or a couple of bottles of water.

Small coolers aren’t limited to lunches and snacks. In fact, a new trend has campers taking a set of coolers along with them on their excursions, similar to a set of luggage. You can find a small cooler that matches your much larger one and tote all of it along with you to your campsite, beach towel or picnic table.

Although many features are important, none are as vital as the cooling capacity of your chosen cooler. The build of the cooler itself influences this. Many of today’s coolers are built with insulated walls to keep outside temperatures out and ensure the inside retains its temperature for as long as possible. The lid of your cooler can be a leak hazard, though, so make sure you choose one that seals tightly.

DYWM Fun Fact

The key to success with today’s coolers is something called “rotational molding,” which is simply the process of molding plastics to take on a specific shape. This eliminates the need to bolt multiple pieces together, creating seams that can easily leak. When buying a cooler, you’ll likely find it’s one big, seamless unit, with the lid being the only separate piece. To create a roto-mold, manufacturers fill a mold with hot plastic, then rotate that mold until the plastic is evenly distributed. This rotating process creates consistent thickness throughout the entire cooler’s build, reducing the risk of leaks.

The Small Hard Cooler Buying Guide

  • Perhaps the biggest differentiator between coolers as a whole is size. If you’re looking for one that’s portable, make sure you choose a cooler that has a smaller build. Bulky coolers can be tough to tote around and store, especially if you’re using them for work.
  • There are a couple of features that can make a cooler easier to carry. One is the handle that you’ll use to tote it around. Some coolers feature molded handles to keep your hands comfortable even when they’re loaded down. Another useful feature, though, is a shoulder strap, which will help balance the weight across more of your body, rather than relying solely on your hands to transport it. As coolers get larger, they often include wheels that make even a big, heavy cooler portable.
  • You may want to invest in a few ice packs for a mess-free way to keep your items cool. Without them, you’ll be relying on ice, which can cause leaks and saturate items you want to keep dry, like sandwiches and chips.
  • As handy as a small, lightweight build can be, you may find that you sacrifice capacity. A cooler that will only hold a few cans won’t help if you’re trying to pack for a picnic or camping weekend. Still, in some cases, you may just need a small cooler to carry a few items around. Consider this when shopping and try to find a cooler that will fit your own lifestyle best.
  • As you’re shopping, take a close look at the lid. Some coolers come with lids that flip around so that you can use them as trays. If they have molded cupholders, you can even rest your drink. Other lids have a weight capacity that allows you to sit on them once you’ve retrieved your items, providing extra seating for your next adventure. You’ll also find coolers that include storage for keeping cutlery, napkins, thermoses or water bottles.
  • The big-name, vacuum-insulated coolers that have become popular have shown just how much consumers are willing to pay for a good cooler. But competitors have put similar insulating technology to use to keep your food and beverages ice cold without forcing you to shell out half your paycheck. Some well-known name brands have decades of history in the cooler market and have constantly tweaked their technology to provide the best cooling power available today at an affordable price.
  • Cooler manufacturers strive to outlast the competition when it comes to cooling power. Although you’ll find plenty of coolers that keep your items cold throughout the workday, there are still others that can go 24 hours or longer. Even if you’re only out for the day, though, these longer-enduring coolers may still be the better choice, as they can protect internal contents against extreme temperatures.
  • When you’re finished using your cooler, make sure cleanup is easy. With smaller coolers, this isn’t as much an issue as with larger ones. If you can’t easily tip your cooler and pour out the water, look for a drain plug that will let the water out from the bottom.