Graco 4Ever

Last updated date: December 13, 2018

DWYM Score
8.6

Why Trust The DWYM Score?

DWYM is your trusted product review source. Along with our in-house experts, our team analyzes thousands of product reviews from the most trusted websites. We then create one easy-to-understand score. Learn more.

Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in the category.

We looked at the top 1 Convertible Car Seats and dug through the reviews from 9 of the most popular review sites including The Bump, Lucie's List, BestReviews, New York Times Wirecutter, Consumer Reports, Car Seat Blog, Best Car Seat Hub and more. Through this analysis, we've determined the best Convertible Car Seat you should buy.

Overall Take

Accommodating kids from 4 to 120 pounds for up to 10 years of use, the Graco 4Ever is perfect for anyone who really only wants to buy one car seat. As far as safety goes, it has a steel frame and easy-to-use harness that doesn't need rethreading. Plus, your child will love the double cup holders. In our analysis of 98 expert reviews, the Graco Graco 4Ever placed 3rd when we looked at the top 13 products in the category. For the full ranking, see below.

Editor's Note May 17, 2019:
Checkout The Best Convertible Car Seat for a detailed review of all the top convertible car seats.

Expert Summarized Score
8.2
9 expert reviews
User Summarized Score
9.6
5,564 user reviews
Our Favorite Video Reviews
What experts liked
The name says it all. This best car set for toddlers can be used from birth until your kid is 120 pounds! Parents also boast about the steel frame, energy-absorbing padding, a great harness system and two cup holders for extra long trips. It is literally the only car seat you’ll need.
- The Bump
While I was skeptical when these seats first came out, I do believe they could (in theory) be the only seat you’ll ever need. I say “in theory” because, as a practical matter, car seats just get… really gross and… gnarly over time. I am one of those people who enjoys getting new car seats every few years (maybe I’m really bad at cleaning them, I dunno), but if you’re a “one and done” type of consumer, then YES, you could enjoy this seat for a very, very long time.
- Lucie's List
Largest weight range available (4 to 120 pounds), A true 4in1 convertible car seat that converts to belt-positioning and backless booster car seats, No-rethread harness, Side impact protection, Steel-reinforced frame, EPS energy-absorbing foam, Superior crash test performance, Approved for air travel, Comfortable, Cup-holders, Easy adjustments, Modern LATCH connectors.
- Mommy Hood 101
A sturdy, versatile seat that converts to fit children from 4 to 120 pounds. Has 6 comfortable reclining positions and is easy to install and adjust.
- BestReviews
Based on its outside accolades, we do think this seat is likely a good choice for people who want a single seat to see a child though the car seat years.
- New York Times Wirecutter
Highs: Easy harness-height adjustment from front of seat without re-threading or removing seat. - Adjustable crotch strap.
- Consumer Reports
No-rethread harness with tall height limits. Installs easily with LATCH or seatbelt. Relatively compact for rear-facing. Fits small babies well. Converts easily to high-back and backless booster mode. Easy-to-remove cover. Harness doesn’t need to be removed for booster use. Can use LATCH in high-back booster mode. Instruction manual is clear and well written 10 year lifespan before expiration. Can accommodate all children under 40 lbs. rear-facing.
- Car Seat Blog
One car seat that’ll work from birth to (really) big kid? Yes, please! The Graco 4Ever starts out as an infant rear-facing seat that can be used when your baby is just four pounds.
- Baby List
January 2, 2018 | Full review
Easy installation. Easy converting between modes. Wide weight range. Allows extended rear-facing. 2 removable (solid bottom) cup holders. No-rethread harness that doesn’t need to be removed in booster mode. LATCH available for booster mode (up to 42 pounds). Easy seat belt installation. Proven crash safety record. 3-part cover for easy removal and washing.
- Best Car Seat Hub
What experts didn't like
Big and heavy, Adjustments get sticky over time, Pricey (about $250-300), Jack of all trades but master of none.
- Mommy Hood 101
It is expensive.
- BestReviews
Lows: Can be difficult to securely install forward-facing with a seat belt. - The use of some forward-facing recline positions are limited by child weight.
- Consumer Reports
Lacks a lockoff device for installations with seatbelt. Sometimes tricky to tighten harness when rear-facing. Somewhat twisty straps. Made in China.
- Car Seat Blog
This car seat can be difficult to install. But, once you do, it’ll be there for a very long time.
- Baby List
January 2, 2018 | Full review
Headrest rattles. Bulky, especially in rear-facing mode. Fabric not very breathable. Harness can be tricky to tighten. Harness not removable for easy cleaning. At full height, can block rear visibility somewhat.
- Best Car Seat Hub

From The Manufacturer

The Graco 4Ever 4-in-1 Car Seat, in Cougar, gives you 10 years with one car seat. It's comfortable for your child and convenient for you as it transitions from rear-facing car seat in a 5-point harness for your infant(4-40 lbs.) to forward-facing car seat with a 5-point harness (20-65 lbs.) to high-back belt-positioning booster (30-100 lbs.) to backless belt-positioning booster (40-120 lbs.). For a proper fit, the Simply Safe Adjust Harness System and 10-position headrest lets you easily adjust the harness and headrest together, on the spot, with no rethreading. The 6-position recline keeps your child comfortable, while the InRight LATCH system with 1-second attachment makes installation easy. It's the only convertible car seat that truly goes from infant car seat to booster seat!

Overall Product Rankings

1. Britax Marathon ClickTight
Overall Score: 8.9
Expert Reviews: 8
2. Graco Extend2Fit
Overall Score: 8.6
Expert Reviews: 6
3. Graco 4Ever
Overall Score: 8.6
Expert Reviews: 9
4. Chico NextFit Zip
Overall Score: 8.5
Expert Reviews: 8
5. Britax Advocate ClickTight
Overall Score: 8.5
Expert Reviews: 7
6. Britax Boulevard ClickTight
Overall Score: 8.5
Expert Reviews: 8
7. Graco Contender 65
Overall Score: 8.4
Expert Reviews: 7
8. Evenflo Titan
Overall Score: 8.3
Expert Reviews: 3
9. Evenflo Tribute LX
Overall Score: 8.1
Expert Reviews: 7
10. Evenflo Sure Ride
Overall Score: 8.1
Expert Reviews: 6
11. Maxi-Cosi Pria 85
Overall Score: 7.6
Expert Reviews: 4
12. Peg Perego Primo Convertible
Overall Score: 7.5
Expert Reviews: 7
13. Clek Fllo
Overall Score: 6.7
Expert Reviews: 8

An Overview On Convertible Car Seats

Maybe your baby has outgrown his or her infant car seat. Or perhaps you don’t like the idea of having to buy several different types of seats or boosters. Either way, it feels like the time to consider purchasing a convertible car seat.

All children ages 8 and younger — depending on their height and weight — are generally required by law to use some form of car seat or booster. You are probably familiar with the infant car seat, also called the bucket or pumpkin seat. It’s a rear-facing seat that is detachable and clicks into a base that stays in the car. Infant car seats typically have a carrying handle, may have an adjustable shade and can usually be used with a stroller.

It is hard to beat the convenience factor of the infant car seat for taking a sleeping baby in and out of the car easily — and for transporting them in general.  But they are generally only considered safe until your child is 35-40 pounds at most. Hence, the convertible car seat, which typically starts as a rear-facing car seat up to around 40 pounds, and in some cases, can then convert to a front-facing toddler seat and, later, to a booster seat around 120 pounds. Just remember, convertible car seats are bulkier, heavier and are typically meant to remain in the car. This means you will need to consider having a separate stroller or baby carrier when your child is young.

Convertible car seats attach to the car using either a LATCH (lower anchors and tethers for children) system, which is part of your car, a seatbelt or a combination of the two. The Britax Marathon, for example, uses their ClickTight installation system, which allows you to simply use a seatbelt to secure the seat (although using the built-in tether latch in your car is also recommended).

From a safety perspective, each convertible car seat uses different materials and construction to bolster safety. The Graco 4Ever and Britax Marathon car seat both feature a steel-reinforced frame. Convertible car seats also typically have a 5-point harness system that can be adjusted in various ways as your child grows.

Most importantly, convertible car seats allow kids to be rear-facing for longer and can accommodate children of various sizes. The National Highway Traffic Saftey Administration advises keeping a child rear-facing and in a car seat in general as long as possible, based on height and weight requirements for the seat. Car seats like the Graco Extend2Fit, for example, are being built to allow rear-facing for up to 50 pounds and include an extendable panel that provides more leg room. This combination of safety and maximized comfort is truly only available with convertible car seats.

Cost is an obvious final deciding factor for purchasing a convertible car seat. Instead of purchasing three or even four separate car seats and a booster, you are able to use one unit throughout childhood. This also lessens the impact on the environment since car seats expire and are only partially recyclable. While convertible car seats can be on the pricey side, you will hopefully only be shelling out money for them once or twice, depending on whether you have multiple drivers or caregivers.

DYWM Fun Fact

The very first car seats were created in the 1930s with the sole purpose of keeping kids from moving around in the car. In the 1970s, the NHTSA began to put regulations in place. The first laws requiring parents to use car seats for children under a certain age weren’t passed until 1985. We’ve certainly come a long way!

Did you know that car seats expire? While they don’t necessarily spoil like old milk, they do become less safe due to a variety of factors. Materials like plastic can become brittle due to constant exposure to heat, cold and sun in your car, metal parts can rust and other parts could go missing or be discontinued. Everyone’s car seat looks a little battered from everyday use. Even so, hairline cracks or reduced elasticity in the straps might be harder to notice, but can really matter in a crash. Because the No. 1 concern for car seats is safety, you should always check a seat’s expiration date before buying or resuing. You can typically find this information on the car seat itself, in the manual or through the manufacturer. Most car seats expire in 5-10 years, and convertible car seats tend to fall somewhere on the higher end of that range. But what do you do with an expired car seat? Unfortunately, the best thing to do is completely dismantle it and recycle the plastic parts so that no one tries to reuse it. If you don’t want to go through all that trouble, try a car seat trade-in event at a local store that sells baby gear.

The Convertible Car Seat Buying Guide

  • You will need a car seat starting on the first day you drive your bundle of joy home. All 50 states have laws requiring the use of a car seat until your child is at least 7 years old. Also, most states require the use of a booster seat until your child is a certain weight and height (usually between the age of 8 and 10). Since you will need some form of car seat or booster for a large portion of your son or daughter’s childhood, it’s not a bad idea to consider convertible car seats since they last longer. Some, like the Graco 4Ever car seat, boast up to 10 years of use.
  • Anyone who has seen how gross a car seat can get knows how important it is to take into account how easy it is to clean. Many car seats come fitted with covers that you can’t remove and can only spot clean. Ideally, all fabric should be able to be removed for cleaning. Better yet, look for machine washable covers.
  • It may seem minor, but when buying a car seat, consider whether or not a cup holder is important to you. Sometimes it’s better to have at least one so you aren’t distracted by handing your child water or a snack while driving. On the other hand, you may want to keep food and drink away from the seat. The Graco 4Ever and Graco Extend2Fit car seats both have two cup holders. The EvenfloTribute LX has one, while the Britax Marathon has none.
  • Lugging a car seat around is no fun for anyone. If you plan to switch your car seat between cars a lot or will be taking it with you while traveling frequently, you’ll want to consider the overall weight. For instance, the Britax Marathon car seat weighs in at 28.4 pounds, while the Evenflo Tribute LX is only 9.1 pounds.
  • Even if you think you’re an old pro at installing a car seat, it may be worth getting it checked out after the first time you do it. Car seat designs change from year to year and each model can be a little different. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration offers locations where you can have your car seat and installation expertly inspected.
  • The straps of a car seat should always be snug, even if your child protests. You should only be able to fit one finger between the strap and your child’s shoulder and you should not be able to pinch any excess harness fabric between your fingers. Also make sure not to put your child in a car seat wearing a bulky coat, which could require you to make the straps looser than is safe.
  • In addition to the straps being too loose, another common mistake many parents make is placing the chest clip — sometimes called the retainer clip — too low or too high, which is actually a pretty serious safety concern. If it’s placed too high, it could cause choking or a neck injury. When placed too low, your child could be ejected from the seat in the event of an accident. The ideal placement of the clip is the middle of the sternum, lined up with the top of the child’s armpits. It’s worth reminding grandparents or other caregivers of this placement as well.
  • According to the American Academy of Pediatrics and theNational Highway Traffic Safety Administration, a car seat should be installed facing the rear until your child turns 4 or outgrows the seat (based on the individual seat’s safety requirements for height and weight). Even if your child’s legs look cramped, they are still safer facing backward. The Graco 4Ever, Britax Marathon and Graco Extend2Fit are all car seats designed with rear-facing placement in mind and offer a little more space for taller kids.
  • It’s important that you use the LATCH system (lower anchors and tethers for children) in your car that your car seat is designed to work with. All cars manufactured after 2003 are required by the U.S. government to have at least two seats with lower anchors — usually positioned near the seat belts — and three spots with tether anchors, typically behind the headrests or seats. Even if your car seat model uses a seatbelt rather than the lower anchors — like the Britax Marathon — you should still use the tether when the car seat is front-facing.
  • Consider including “in case of emergency” information on your car seat for EMTs or other first responders. In the event that a parent or caregiver is injured or can’t talk, having the child’s name, contact information, allergies, medical conditions and pediatrician listed on the car seat can be a lifesaver. Simply attach a luggage tag with the necessary details or tape a note card securely to the seat in an easy-to-find area.