Graco 04530-21F Storkcraft Benton 4-In-1 Convertible Crib

Last updated date: July 28, 2020

DWYM Score

8.7

Graco 04530-21F Storkcraft Benton 4-In-1 Convertible Crib

Why Trust DWYM?

DWYM is your trusted product review source. Along with our in-house experts, our team analyzes thousands of product reviews from the most trusted websites. We then create one easy-to-understand review. Learn more.

Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in the category.
Show Contents

We looked at the top Cribs and dug through the reviews from some of the most popular review sites. Through this analysis, we've determined the best Crib you should buy.

Editor's Note August 5, 2020:
Checkout The Best Crib for a detailed review of all the top cribs.

Overall Take


In our analysis of 220 expert reviews, the Graco Graco 04530-21F Storkcraft Benton 4-In-1 Convertible Crib placed 9th when we looked at the top 14 products in the category. For the full ranking, see below.

From The Manufacturer

Designed for many years of use, the Graco Benton 4-in-1 Convertible Crib can easily convert from a crib to a toddler bed, daybed and full-size bed with headboard, and features a three-position adjustable mattress support base (optional Graco Toddler Guardrail, Graco Full-Size Conversion Kit, and mattress sold separately). Like all Graco cribs, the Benton is certified by the Juvenile Products Manufacturers Association (JPMA) and is meticulously tested to meet or exceed all applicable Consumer Products Safety Commission (CPSC) and American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) safety standards to ensure the safest sleeping environment for your child. Size: Length (56.7 inches); Width (29.8 inches); Height (42 inches); Weight (41 pounds); Maximum child height for crib stage (35 inches); Maximum recommended weight limit for toddler bed and daybed stage (50 pounds). Graco cribs are exclusively manufactured by Storkcraft. For over 70 years, Storkcraft has been manufacturing quality furniture for infants, toddlers, kids, and teens. Compare Storkcraft’

Expert Reviews

Expert Summarized Score

8.5
13 expert reviews

User Summarized Score

9.0
1,470 user reviews

What experts liked

Three positions adjustable mattress height makes it compatible with your baby.
- Kidz Geek
This crib has different height adjustments so you can lower the mattress as your baby starts to grow and learns to stand and pull up on the side of the crib.
- BoosterWP Reviews
October 17, 2019 | Full review
Fully certified and best suited for a newborn, the mattress can be adjusted to 3 different levels and the crib can be converted to a toddler bed, daybed and full sized bed.
- Travel Crib Reviews
The baby crib features three adjustable mattress positions, and can be converted into a toddler bed, daybed, and full-size bed with a beautifully designed headboard and footboard.
- Net Parents
The crib has three adjustable mattresses. The crib can support other mattresses designed for babies or toddlers, such as baby foam mattresses.
- Little One Mag
There is a three position, mattress height adjustment setting for even more convenience.
- Adversify
This convertible crib can be used on kids as early as newborn phase. You can take advantage of the four levels of mattress height so you will not have a problem getting your baby in and out of the crib during the first few months. As they start becoming mobile and learn to move around, you can lower the mattress height until the bottom most part and prevent them from climbing out and falling off of the crib.
- Parents Need To Know
With the Graco Benton, you get a sturdy, solidly constructed bed for your baby that won’t put a huge hole in your pocket.
- A Web To Know
This crib not only meets federal safety regulations, it also adheres to the Juvenile Products Manufacturers Association (JPMA) standards.
- Parenting Pod
The bed has 5 conversion options. It can be a crib, toddler bed, day bed, and full-sized bed. The full-sized bed comes with the two options of either having a footboard or not. It also has an adjustable mattress.
- Best Mom Products
October 25, 2017 | Full review
The mattress can adjust in three positions depending on your child heights
- Best Care Life Reviews
This bed meets all standards and is JPMA certified, so you won’t have to worry about the safety of your little one in this bed.
- top9rated
It meets or exceeds all standards of ASTM International and U.S. CPSC safety standards. It is also JPMA certified. All the finishes are non-toxic and the crib is lead and phthalate free.
- Better Sleep Baby

What experts didn't like

Some of the parents reported that the baby’s leg sometimes get caught between the slats.
- Kidz Geek
It is very sturdy, but in use the paint can chip which reduces its life a bit.
- Travel Crib Reviews
Conversion kid not included and has to be purchased separately
- Net Parents
No wheels for quick transport
- Little One Mag
There were some complaints about parts missing during assembly.
- Adversify
Perhaps the only downside to this one is that it has very little space underneath to tuck any items in so the bottom is not ideal for storage. You might want to get a separate dresser which you can put at the side instead.
- Parents Need To Know
Does not include a toddler rail
- A Web To Know
You’ll need to purchase a bed frame for the larger beds.
- Parenting Pod
The crib does not come with a toddler rail or a day bed rail. Those pieces can be bought separately.
- Best Mom Products
October 25, 2017 | Full review
Adjustable mattress sold separately.
- Best Care Life Reviews
Conversions require additional parts to be purchased, and this crib does not come with the mattress, so those will be additional expenses.
- top9rated
Sometimes crib arrived broken.
- Better Sleep Baby

Our Expert Consultant

Kate Desmond 
Parenting Pro and Safe-Sleep Expert

Kate Desmond is a writer and infant safe-sleep expert. She has spent the last eight years working as the marketing director for Charlie’s Kids Foundation, a nonprofit that aims to educate families about SIDS and safe sleep. In that role, she travels around the country learning and educating caregivers and providers on the latest and greatest safe-sleep information to prevent infant death.

As mom to two elementary-aged daughters, she spends hours researching the best and safest products for her own kids. She is quick to get in the weeds with other mamas, and uses humor to cope with parenting woes from potty-training to teaching kids to read. She writes about the ups and downs of parenting on her blog.

An Overview On Cribs

The biggest purchase you’ll make after finding out you’re about to become a parent is a crib.

As the days roll closer to bringing your baby home, you will want to prepare in so many ways. There is quite a bit of design effort put into cribs, and they are drastically different between companies. However, finding the best crib is not just a matter of personal style but also of safety. Discover what the experts are saying along with all the safety features to consider when shopping for that perfect crib for your little love.

Safety first when it comes to researching the best baby crib. Several safety features are required of manufacturers to include when designing a crib. These standards are set by the government based on past recalls and baby sleep studies. Manufacturers must abide by the standards or their product cannot be sold in stores.

To name a few safety standards: There cannot be a bigger gap than 2 3/8 inch between slats and corner posts as it has been determined that any bigger can cause entrapment issues for baby. The corner posts should not be higher than 1/16 inch above the end panels. All hardware should be set in securely without sharp screws or nail heads sticking out. Older, used cribs may pose the risk of lead paint so it is highly recommended to either get a lead test or just skip using an old crib. The mattress needs to be a tight fit so baby can’t get caught between the mattress and the slats. (When in the store looking at cribs, do the two-finger test: If you can fit two fingers side-by-side between the mattress and the slats, you need a bigger mattress than what they’ve got in there). Keep the baby’s crib free from all stuffed animals, bumpers and loose-fitting blankets and sheets.

Kate Desmond, a writer and infant safe-sleep expert as well as mom to two young daughters, has spent an enormous amount of time researching the safest and best products for her kids.

“The most important thing to consider when purchasing your baby’s crib is safety,” she says. “Remember, drop-side cribs are no longer deemed safe, so this is a great reason to say no to heirlooms from your mother-in-law. Mattresses are sold independently of cribs so be sure to select one that fits, leaving no gaps, and cover only with a tight-fitting crib sheet. Remember to keep the crib empty of all blankets, pillows and stuffed animals. Babies under one year of age sleep safest alone, on their back, in their crib.”

After learning the safety regulations and hearing from an expert, you know what to look for and can go shopping. One last thing to consider is the size and style of your nursery as this will determine the crib you buy. If you are tight on space, you can consider a combination crib and changing table in one, like the Delta Children Emery Deluxe 6-In-1 Convertible Crib, Babyletto Hudson 3-In-1 Toddler Convertible Crib, Graco Storkcraft Benton 4-In-1 Convertible Crib or the Dream On Me Aden 4-In-1 Convertible Mini Crib.

All of these cribs will be a beautiful addition to a darling nursery of any style.

The Crib Buying Guide

  • The safest cribs are usually the simplest. Find a crib that doesn’t have drop sides or fancy bed knobs on the corners.
  • Buying new is best because it is more likely that it is up to safety standards.
  • Bring a ruler with you to measure the spaces between the slats when you shop.
  • Baby crib mattresses are also an item to buy new. Many have been recalled for being too soft. Also, when you buy new, you can buy one that fits super snug into your crib with no spaces on any side.
  • Put tight-fitting sheets on your crib.
  • “Most modern cribs require some assembly,” says Desmond, “Just make sure you follow the directions and ask an expert for help when needed.”
  • For the mother’s healing and safety as well as the baby’s safety, you should pay attention to the level of height of the crib mattress. Most cribs have three levels to help parents reach the baby in the early stages but keep a growing baby safe from climbing out later on in their development.
  • Immediately stop using a crib if you notice baby attempting to climb out.