Dr. Scholl’s Men’s Dual Strap Shoe

Last updated date: December 13, 2019

DWYM Score

8.6

Dr. Scholl’s Men’s Dual Strap Shoe

Why Trust DWYM?

DWYM is your trusted product review source. Along with our in-house experts, our team analyzes thousands of product reviews from the most trusted websites. We then create one easy-to-understand review. Learn more.

Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in the category.
Show Contents

We looked at the top Men's Senior Shoes and dug through the reviews from some of the most popular review sites. Through this analysis, we've determined the best Men's Senior Shoe you should buy.

Editor's Note December 17, 2019:
Checkout The Best Men’s Senior Shoes for a detailed review of all the top men's senior shoes.

Overall Take

The Dr. Scholl's Men's Dual Strap Shoe boasts solid construction for a budget piece of footwear. They are made to fit comfortably around a variety of conditions thanks to the rounded toe area. Velcro fasteners make them as easy to remove as they are to slip on.


In our analysis of 42 expert reviews, the Dr. Scholl's Dr. Scholl's Men's Dual Strap Shoe placed 4th when we looked at the top 5 products in the category. For the full ranking, see below.

From The Manufacturer

Mesh and faux leather Mesh and faux leather Dual strap closures Air-Pillo gel insoles Thick rubber outsoles

Expert Reviews

Expert Summarized Score

8.6
3 expert reviews

User Summarized Score

8.5
1,012 user reviews

What experts liked

Softly rounded toe has ample room for a variety of foot conditions
- Sportsly
Their easy to use Velcro closures make for easy on and off wearability, while their mesh detailing keeps feet cool and dry all day long
- WalkJogRun
These shoes are well-made and attractive, also less expensive than many similar shoes.
- Branded Girls

What experts didn't like

Velcro straps are too long and overhang when fastened
- Sportsly
Less stylish than others
- WalkJogRun
These shoes appear to be constructed of man-made plastic material only which causes feet to sweat profusely.
- Branded Girls

Overall Product Rankings

An Overview On Men's Senior Shoes

If there’s anything that seniors should consider investing in, a new pair of shoes is near the top of the list. Those old loafers might be comfortable, but aging (and possibly unsteady) feet come with a whole new set of needs.

Whether you’re buying a pair of shoes designed for seniors or toddlers, one priority remains number one: The size. If anything, that’s more important for seniors. Don’t assume your old shoe size will always stay the same, especially if you have developed conditions like edema, bunions or arthritis that can alter the shape of the toes and foot. Tight shoes, of course, will be painful, but make sure that you don’t pick anything too loose, either. Feet that slide around inside the shoe are more prone to lose their balance.

The factor that most shoe buyers consider next is the feel of the sole, and that warrants an important note. No matter how good they feel after a short “breaking in” pace around the room, be wary of midsoles that are too soft. Any professional runner can tell you that when stability is paramount, you want to be able to feel the ground. Go with a shoe that’s comfortable enough to reduce the impact on sore joints, but still has a structure that allows you to feel your steps.

As for the back of the foot, stay away from shoes that unduly raise or overly cushion your heel. They tend to be bad for your posture and therefore your gait. It goes without saying for most senior shoes, but make sure the back of the heel is closed. Open heeled, “slipper” type shoes will cause the same balance problems that any ill-fitting shoe would. In fact, a higher back on the shoe can help offer extra support.

As far as the tread goes, you might think that the shoe with the most ground-hugging design might be the best. Don’t go with anything too extreme, though. Too much tread can be as much of a stumble risk as worn-out shoes with little or no tread. There’s a sweet spot to look for, and shoes that are designated as “slip-resistant” usually hit near that mark.

As for the rest of the shoe, the material should be light and breathable. Tired feet get sweaty, and sweaty feet aren’t just uncomfortable — they’re more prone to slipping. The shuffle-step is an all too common gait among the elderly, and it can be alleviated by getting shoes that aren’t too heavy.

Older shoe buyers might assume that Velcro fasteners were invented to appease tweens who were too lazy to tie their shoes, but they can be a real lifesaver for seniors. Even if you’re capable enough to tie your shoes now, go ahead and choose Velcro over ties (which most senior shoes have anyway). You may thank yourself later on.

Finally, don’t underestimate the importance of style. Just because your shoe is geared toward an older lifestyle doesn’t mean it has to look like a relic. Comfort is paramount, but there are plenty of senior shoes out there that are indistinguishable from everyday workwear or casual walking shoes.

The Men's Senior Shoe Buying Guide

  • When we pick a pair of shoes, most of us are used to that awkward couple of walks around the block, otherwise known as “breaking them in.” That might be standard practice for dress shoes or some types of sneakers, but you shouldn’t have to do it for senior shoes. In fact, it can be dangerous. Discomfort can cause you to shift your gait, and that can result in falls or aggravation of any foot conditions you may have. Good senior shoes are designed with large width in the toe and other features to accommodate a wider range of sizes and shapes. If they don’t feel right when you first put them on, try another.
  • Another tip when you’re sizing up shoes for the first time: Remember to bring your insoles. Thicker insoles can take away a significant amount of space inside the shoe, so make sure you account for that right off the bat.
  • It’s not a common practice, but just in case you were planning on saving a few bucks: Don’t do it by purchasing old shoes or accepting hand-me-downs. Worn tread means a much higher chance of slippage. Along those same lines, make sure that you check old shoes periodically to make sure their tread still has a few grooves left. They may be comfy, but slick bottoms can make unfamiliar terrain even more problematic.
  • If you’re having particular problems walking, you might have heard that orthotics are the solution. They certainly can be, though they are most effective when prescribed by a foot doctor for a specific medical condition or irregularity in the gait. Over-the-counter orthotics are also an option, although you should still get a diagnosis to determine whether a simple one might help. In either case, make sure as with insoles that you take them into account when trying on new shoes.
  • Finally, a word about taking those shoes off. Around the house, seniors with particular mobility issues might want to keep some stability by investing in grip socks. Those are socks with tiny rubber patterns on the bottom, designed to help you stay free of slips around the house (which is where most falls happen, after all).