Columbia Men’s Watertight II Jacket

Last updated date: May 10, 2021

DWYM Score

8.8

Columbia Men’s Watertight II Jacket

Why Trust DWYM?

DWYM is your trusted product review source. Along with our in-house experts, our team analyzes thousands of product reviews from the most trusted websites. We then create one easy-to-understand review. Learn more.

Don't Waste Your Money Seal of Approval
Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in the category.
Show Contents

We looked at the top Men's Rain Jacket and dug through the reviews from some of the most popular review sites. Through this analysis, we've determined the best Men's Rain Jackets you should buy.

Editor's Note May 14, 2021:
Checkout The Best Men’s Rain Jacket for a detailed review of all the top men's rain jacket.

Overall Take

This portable jacket can be folded into one of its own pockets which serves as a handy case. Once you get it on, it provides ample protection from sudden downpours or extended drizzles. The lightweight construction allows it to be worn all day.


In our analysis of 25 expert reviews, the Columbia Columbia Men's Watertight II Jacket placed 3rd when we looked at the top 9 products in the category. For the full ranking, see below.

From The Manufacturer

Shell: 100% Nylon; Lining: 100% Polyester. Imported. Zipper closure. Machine Wash. ADVANCED TECHNOLOGY: Columbia Men's Watertight II Jacket is crafted of a waterproof nylon shell durable enough to withstand anything from drizzle to downpour at a moment's notice. HANDY FEATURES: This rain jacket features an abrasion resistant chin guard, two zippered side pockets, elastic cuffs, and an elastic hem. COMFORT & WARMTH: Crafted of a waterproof 100% nylon shell, this rain jacket is lightweight while remaining protective. It also packs into your hand pocket. SNUG FIT: Elastic details and a zippered closure provide a snug, yet comfortable fit that allows for movement. OMNI-SHIELD - Go ahead, try and get dirty. Omni-Shield helps you stay clean and dry by resisting the absorption of liquids. Unlike most fabrics that absorb moisture, Omni-Shield repels moisture and dries quickly—avoiding stains and keeping you clean.

Expert Reviews

Expert Summarized Score

7.0
5 expert reviews

User Summarized Score

9.4
15,914 user reviews

What experts liked

Ultra-lightweight protection provided by full seam sealing and Omni-tech fabric. Jacket folds into itself for easy storage and packing.
- BestReviews
Our favorite of the more budget-oriented models on the market. It fits well, looks sharp, provides good mobility, and — most importantly — will keep you dry. The Watertight II is built for the budget-conscious and is a perfect everyday option for short hikes, drizzly early morning dog walks, and yard work. It's light enough for longer hikes and backpacking trips.
- Outdoor Gear Lab
Its approachable price, durable construction, and extended range of sizes make it a staple for casual outings, commuting, and the occasional rainy-day hike.
- Switchback Travel
A great little jacket that I think is perfect for a beginner hiker. The main reason for that statement is it's simple but effective functionality for a very reasonable price. It will double up nicely to be worn about the city and has all the basic features I would expect from a rain jacket. If you're just starting out or if you are an intermittent hiker, this could be the jacket for you.
- Cool Hiking Gear
You have three external zippered pockets (two at sides and one on the chest) and an internal pocket. The outer pockets are with storm flaps, and the same is with the front zipper. This is a clever design: the jacket can be packed in its own internal pocket.
- Mountains for Everybody

What experts didn't like

Runs a little large. Many consumers would prefer a removable hood.
- BestReviews
The DWR will need maintenance over time. After a few hikes, areas that are vulnerable to wear — primarily the forearms and shoulders — were losing their DWR and beginning to wet out.
- Outdoor Gear Lab
The jacket isn’t a standout in wet-weather performance—you’ll need to spend up for that. During heavy bouts of rain, the jacket eventually soaked through at the seams.
- Switchback Travel
No Napoleon breast pocket.
- Cool Hiking Gear
There are no pit zips. Not Ripstop.
- Mountains for Everybody

An Overview On Men's Rain Jacket

If you spend a lot of time outdoors, there are some lessons you learn pretty fast. Case in point: The first time you spend in a real downpour without a good rain jacket will probably be the last one. Your regular jacket might do for a light drizzle, but it takes a whole different level of fabric to keep your inner clothing dry in driving rain.

So what distinguishes a real rain jacket from a flimsy windbreaker? First and foremost, it’s the waterproofing. Jackets from a reliable brand that are certified as waterproof should stay dry inside no matter what the weather is like outside. If a jacket says it’s water-resistant, it means just that: Resistant to water, but not 100% effective against it.

So how do garment makers ensure that their jackets are waterproof? There are many different materials and treatments involved, but one big factor is the outer coating. No matter what the underlying fabric is, most rain jackets have a chemical “shell” that does the heavy lifting when it comes to blocking the rain. This might be a laminate, which is a glued-on layer of polyurethane. It might also be a membrane, which is a spray-on treatment. Generally speaking, laminate coatings will protect better and last longer, while membrane treatments are slightly lighter and cheaper.

Most all rain jackets are layered, but you don’t necessarily want to shell out more money for the one that has the most. If your jacket has two layers, it’s probably designed for light outdoor work. It may not be the best for heavy protection, but it also won’t be as bulky. These jackets also tend to make less of the trademark “swish” noise that rain jackets have. And depending on the construction, they will be sturdy for the price.

There are 2.5 layer jackets, and that half-layer is actually an extra coating that’s been laid down between the inner and outer fabric. These tend to be lighter and a bit more breathable for extended use.

Then there are 3-layer jackets, which are made for the true outdoorsman. This is where you will usually find advanced membranes like Gore-Tex on top of insulted materials. Definitely more expensive, but worth it if you’re spending a lot of time working in stormy weather.

Heavy rain tends to come with wind, so you may want to pay a little extra for windproofing features. These can include drawcords on the hood and waist to prevent rain and wind from getting in through the cracks. Details make a lot of difference on rain jackets. Waterproofing might keep you dry, but it won’t do your phone much good if the pocket zippers aren’t sealed. Some rain jackets also come with a pocket that folds out into a bag for the jacket, allowing you to pack it more easily on long trips.

The Men's Rain Jackets Buying Guide

Testing the waterproofing on your rain jacket is pretty easy, once you get it home. Simply spray a bit of water onto it and make sure that it beads up and rolls off.

If it fails to repel water over time, a simple cleaning can do a lot of good. Make sure that you follow washing instructions for your gear, and keep in mind that the water-repellent coating on most jackets will need to be dried on low or medium heat.