Coleman Gas Stove | Portable Bottletop Propane Camp Stove

Last updated date: August 21, 2019

DWYM Score

8.9

Coleman Gas Stove | Portable Bottletop Propane Camp Stove

Why Trust DWYM?

DWYM is your trusted product review source. Along with our in-house experts, our team analyzes thousands of product reviews from the most trusted websites. We then create one easy-to-understand review. Learn more.

Don't Waste Your Money Seal of Approval
Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in the category.
Show Contents

We looked at the top Camping Stoves and dug through the reviews from some of the most popular review sites. Through this analysis, we've determined the best Camping Stove you should buy.

Update as March 18, 2021:
Checkout The Best Camping Stove for a detailed review of all the top camping stoves.

Overall Take


In our analysis of 111 expert reviews, the Coleman Portable Propane Camp Stove placed 13th when we looked at the top 15 products in the category. For the full ranking, see below.

From The Manufacturer

When you’re looking for a compact stove to take on the trail, pack the Coleman Bottle Top Propane Stove. The cooking surface fits an 8-in. pan above a fully adjustable burner that delivers up to 10,000 BTUs of cooking power. The PerfectFlow technology will keep the heat steady, and you'll use less fuel too thanks to the Perfectheat technology. Wind baffles help shield your flame from the wind so the most heat possible goes into making your meal. When you’re ready to leave camp, the burner and base easily separate from the propane bottle for compact packing. Need a lightweight outdoor stove for backpacking, hunting, or camping? Look no further than the Coleman Portable Bottle-Top Propane Stove, which fits up to an 8-inch pan above a fully adjustable burner for precise temperature control and up to 10,000 BTUs of cooking power. Brew coffee, heat up hot dogs, and so on, knowing you can enjoy up to 2.5 hours of cooking on just one 16.4 oz. propane cylinder (sold separately). PerfectFlow technology keeps that heat steady, even in extreme conditions, and a large base offers stability for easy stirring. When it’s time to break down the campsite and fit all your gear into a crowded pack, you’ll be relieved to know that the burner and base separate from the propane cylinder for truly compact packing. Rest assured your ultra-portable stove comes with a 3-year limited warranty. The Coleman 5431A700 One-burner Propane Stove is an easy-to-use portable stove that should meet almost any camp cooking need. The PerfectFlow regulator provides consistent cooking performance by producing a steady fuel stream, even in cold weather, high altitudes, or when fuel is low. Equipped with one 10,000 BTU burner, this fully adjustable stove will last for 2.2 hours on high or up to nine hours on low. The pot supports help shield your cooking flame from the wind, while the large eight-inch burner bowl should fit most any pot. This Coleman one-burner stove can boil a quart of water in just four minutes! This stove operates on one 16.4-ounce cylinder of Coleman propane (not included).

Expert Reviews

Expert Summarized Score

8.9
11 expert reviews

User Summarized Score

9.0
1,148 user reviews

What experts liked

For an emergency or tailgate party, it is an excellent little propane cylinder stove. The top is well made stainless steel with wind baffles, works well as a side stove top. Very impressed with the construction and the versatility of this cylinder stove. It is easy to set up and store away,
- New York Mag
April 18, 2019 | Full review
An extra-wide base minimizes the occurrence of wobbling, making it a great choice for stirring and sauteing.
- Wiki EZ Vid
March 21, 2018 | Full review
Despite its efficient size, it can fit an eight-inch pan on the fully adjustable burner, which produces up to 10,000 BTUs of cooking power.
- Trip Savvy
March 3, 2019 | Full review
Flame control is remarkably easy with this stove, just twist that large plastic knob all the way open for a roaring 10,000-BTU output or dial it back for hours of simmering. And thanks to the deep bowl shape and generous wind baffles, this stove will maintain a consistent burn in all but the most powerful gusts of wind.
- Business Insider
May 23, 2019 | Full review
Has an adjustable burner. Durable circular pot stands instead of individual folding arms. Compatible with Coleman 16.4 oz. propane cylinder. Takes about 3 minutes to boil 500ml of water.
- Independent Wolf
April 28, 2019 | Full review
This stove is highly fuel efficient - giving you quite of bit of cooking time off of one propane canister. Rated great for long lifespan and solid durability. Is compatible with Coleman’s standard propane canisters which are one of the cheaper options in camp stove fuel.
- Heavy
March 28, 2019 | Full review
Uses PerfectHeat and PerfectFlow technologies for efficient and even cooking. Adjustable burner. Screws onto a propane canister, and provides 10,000 BTUs of cooking power. Baffles offer protection from the wind. Weight of the stove and canister is just under 3 1/2 lb. Comes with a carry box. Boils a quart of water in 4 minutes.
- BestReviews
July 1, 2019 | Full review
The burner can be adjusted and fits an 8in pan easily. The stove runs on the 16.4oz Coleman propane bottle and both the burner and base can be separated from the fuel bottle. It also has wind baffles for cooking in windy areas.
- All Camping Stuff
September 28, 2015 | Full review
Performance-wise this is impressive; the burner can put out 10,000 BTU at full power, and it’s also easy to adjust the output.
- Wilderness Today
Another benefit of this stove is that it is easy to assemble. The base, which helps to create a sturdier working surface, contains the propane tank (that forms the body) and the burner attaches on top of that.
- Camping AXS
It is so high performance for a small size burner.
- Best Home Shopping
March 1, 2018 | Full review

What experts didn't like

Control knob is finicky
- Wiki EZ Vid
March 21, 2018 | Full review
Very heavy and bulky.
- Business Insider
May 23, 2019 | Full review
Not as light or compact as other portable canister stoves.
- Independent Wolf
April 28, 2019 | Full review
Fairly heavy to backpack with. The platform for the canister takes up a considerable amount of space if trying to pack light. A bit outdatted considering all the new stoves on the market - but sometimes old is best.
- Heavy
March 28, 2019 | Full review
Some reports of quality issues involving the plastic parts (break easily) and the screw threads (poor meal, strips easily). Flame contol is not great; can't adjust it low enough to prevent burning.
- BestReviews
July 1, 2019 | Full review
Doesn’t have a friction light.
- All Camping Stuff
September 28, 2015 | Full review
Apparently, the low setting does not go low enough for simmering purposes (e.g. for cooking rice) and you have a risk of burning your food in such situations.
- Camping AXS

Our Expert Consultant

Shawna Newman 
Camping And Outdoor Expert

Shawna Newman is the editor-in-chief of Active Weekender, a website that provides resources — from gear recommendations to beginner tips — to people looking to plan outdoor adventures. Her favorite outdoor activity is hiking, and she is on a quest to visit every national park in the U.S.

 

An Overview On Camping Stoves

Spending a few days in the great outdoors can be refreshing. But it comes with one big challenge: food. Chances are, you can’t have steaks and burgers delivered to your campsite, so you’ll need to find a way to make the food you want yourself.

There are numerous factors to consider when you’re shopping for a camping stove. One of the most important is your fuel source. Choose this based on the type of camping and camp cooking you’re going to do.

“Your options are canister stoves, liquid fuel stoves (i.e. gas) or alternative fuel stoves,” says outdoor and camping expert Shawna Newman, editor-in-chief of Active Weekender. “Canister stoves are great if you’re concerned about weight. Liquid fuel stoves are ideal if you know you’re going to be on uneven ground and need the most stable type of camp stove. Alternative fuel stoves, like wood-burning and tablet stoves, are not great for traditional camping because they don’t perform as well.”

Many camping stoves run on propane, which is a handy option. Butane can be another option, but it doesn’t do as well in cold weather, so make sure you have a backup option if you’re planning to use it during the winter months.

Portability is a top consideration in any camping stove. If you’re hiking, you’ll need a stove that will fit snugly into your pack, while campers can get away with something a little bigger, as long as it can slide into the back of your vehicle. Keep in mind how you’ll be using it and whether you can sacrifice cooking surface area for a smaller, easier-to-carry unit.

Cooking capacity is very important when you’re in the market for a new camping stove. Some more portable stoves are designed to cook for one, which may mean you’ll be able to make your morning coffee and meals just for you on it, but if you’re cooking for more people, a camping stove with more capacity may be in order. Canister stoves can’t support the weight of larger pots, so you may want to use a liquid fuel stove if you have more people to cook for.

If you don’t feel like traveling with matches, you may want to consider a cooking stove that ignites automatically. While camping stoves have traditionally required a little extra help to start up, some newer models have auto-ignition. If this is important to you, factor that into your decision.

Safety is always important when you’re dealing with a cooking appliance. Since cooking stoves typically rely on disposable propane bottles, it’s important to carefully check for propane leaks before you start your stove up. This will help keep you and your fellow campers safe.

Ultimately, though, camp stoves can offer added convenience and safety compared with other options and can be a great choice for families.

“Cooking over a campfire can be done, but it’s not the best way to serve up a tasty camp meal,” Newman explains. “It can even be dangerous if you’re camping with children. Bringing along a camp stove means that you can eat just as well at the campsite as you do at home.”

Just be sure to follow both the stove instructions as well as any rules that apply to your campsite.

“Remember to never use your camp stove in the tent or any other enclosed space, because it’s a fire risk, and you also risk carbon monoxide poisoning,” Newman says.

The Camping Stove Buying Guide

  • Your first question will likely be just how much power your camping stove should have. It probably won’t be your full-time cooking appliance, but it will need to get you through entire weekends or vacation weeks. The Camp Chef is among the most powerful camping stoves you can buy, putting out an impressive 60,000 BTUs through its two burners. However, you’ll sacrifice portability for that cooking power, so you may want to consider a unit that is portable but provides 11,000 BTUs.
  • Look for a unique appliance that is designed to make foods and beverages for one person quickly. You can heat up a cup of coffee or rehydrate freeze-dried meals using the ultraportable device, which is designed specifically for outdoor adventurers.
  • Among camping stove options, some compact options are designed with everything fitting into a single large cup. They may provide an insulated cozy and a lid that operates as both a pour hole and a strainer, and a cooking pot that can serve as a mug, measuring cup and a bowl.
  • The Gas One Portable Propane Butane Camping Stove is also portable, weighing only 3.1 pounds. It also comes with a free carrying case to make it easy to take on the go with you. Although some models aren’t the most compact, they are often fairly slim and easy to pack, weighing only 11 or 12 pounds. Other stoves are definitely designed for those with plenty of storage space in their camping vehicles, weighing 36 pounds and packing quite a bit of bulk.
  • Autoignition is a top feature, keeping you from having to strike a match or carry a lighter around with you. The Gas One Portable Butane Camping Stove has an exclusive type of electric ignition that lets you start it up with the twist of a knob.