Coffee Gator Pour Over Coffee Maker

Last updated date: January 22, 2020

DWYM Score
9.7

Coffee Gator Pour Over Coffee Maker

Why Trust The DWYM Score?

DWYM is your trusted product review source. Along with our in-house experts, our team analyzes thousands of product reviews from the most trusted websites. We then create one easy-to-understand score. Learn more.

Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in the category.

We looked at the top Pour Over Makers and dug through the reviews from some of the most popular review sites. Through this analysis, we've determined the best Pour Over Maker you should buy.

Overall Take

Laser-cut steel keeps coffee grounds out of your cup in the Coffee Gator Pour Over Coffee Maker. However, that means you'll lose some of the oils that other pour over coffee makers preserve. This carafe is designed to accommodate households that only need to make one or two cups of coffee at a time. You'll also get a rubber handle that keeps your hand safe from the hot glass, which we found to be incredibly handy during our testing. In our analysis of 119 expert reviews, the Coffee Gator Coffee Gator Pour Over Coffee Maker with Permanent Filter placed 1st when we looked at the top 9 products in the category. For the full ranking, see below.

Editor's Note October 3, 2019:
Checkout The Best Pour Over Maker for a detailed review of all the top pour over makers.

Expert Summarized Score
8.8
16 expert reviews
User Summarized Score
9.2
2,963 user reviews
Our Favorite Video Reviews
What experts liked
Makes good-tasting coffee for a reasonable price. No need to use your own filters since it's outfitted with a reusable one of its own. It's also easy to clean.
- BestReviews
September 11, 2019 | Full review
On the plus side, Gator is quite easy to clean and put together, especially because of the thermometer that allows you to do other things around the kitchen while you wait for the coffee.
- Kitchen Byte
Nonetheless, it’s a highly effective brewer. The cone filter is a permanent addition, a laser-cut, surgical-grade stainless-steel micro-mesh filter (you can always pop in a paper filter as well if you’d prefer) with little rubber handle so you don’t burn yourself when removing it. There’s no silt in your coffee either way.
- Coffee Dorks
Another sterling example of a paperless brewing system, the Coffee Gator is a combined carafe and filter at a competitive price point that will set off any minimalist kitchen a treat.
- Fourth Estate Coffee
If you’re new to the pour-over method, you’ll get a handy recipe book thrown in to get those creative juices flowing. It’s also a beginner-friendly coffee maker so you don’t need to be a barista to get the most from the Coffee Gator.
- Prince La
March 1, 2019 | Full review
Unlike other coffee makers, the Coffee Gator best hand drip coffeemaker comes with a laser cut steel filter that you can use again and again, and it is able to retain the delicious flavors and oils that gives every coffee a delightful taste.
- Love My Coffee Cup
July 13, 2016 | Full review
It is best suited for people who don’t mind one cup per brewing.
- Fried Coffee
The washable and reusable stainless steel filter that it comes with is able to retain the oils and the natural flavor of the grounds perfectly.
- Product Reviews
June 11, 2019 | Full review
I loved the design mainly, and the design is also standard which easily match all decors.
- Coffee Maker
January 10, 2019 | Full review
The whole process is extremely simple and takes no time at all to actually get a great blended coffee.
- Tech Nuovo
June 27, 2017 | Full review
I really like the kettle, especially the built-in temp gauge in the lid. The precise spout was also such an improvement over the makeshift pitchers I had been using, that this will definitely become my go-to for anything pourover.
- I Need Coffee
May 23, 2016 | Full review
The company wants you satisfied so it has added a money back warranty to this product. No hassles with their warranty either.
- Why Not Coffee
January 27, 2018 | Full review
The filter used is metallic, made from dual layer of micro-mesh, laser cut steel. It is pretty well constructed, though obviously don’t expect the glass carafe to survive falls.
- Coffee Urban
You will be pleased to know that the filter is very easy to clean and it’s unlikely to clog. This is something not many models can boast with. As well as, it’s impossible for coffee sediments to pass through.
- Coffeein Blog
The coffee maker is also one of the easiest to use on our list, and even beginners should have an easy time when making coffee on the go.
- Coffee Gear X
The stainless steel filter is one of the best things about this brewer. There are none of the unwanted flavors you can get with paper versions. You won’t have to buy replacements. And its kind to the environment.
- AG Ferrari
June 12, 2019 | Full review
What experts didn't like
Very fragile glass construction that loses heat rapidly. Small size isn't suitable for serving larger groups.
- BestReviews
September 11, 2019 | Full review
The main drawbacks are the fact the glass carafe could break if you drop it and you need to pre-warm the water if you want a really hot cup of coffee in the morning (and I know I do).
- Kitchen Byte
This is very important as the exposed stainless-steel mesh has no heat retaining properties whatsoever. One solution is to increase the water temperature, but that scorches your coffee
- Coffee Dorks
Not cut out for batch brewing as this dripper makes just 1 or 2 cups
- Fourth Estate Coffee
Only one cup can be brewed in one go
- Fried Coffee
You may get some trouble with cleaning the filter. The coffee ground takes more time for drying, and so this could make it hard for you with the cleaning purpose.
- Coffee Maker
January 10, 2019 | Full review
While it makes a great cup of hot coffee, this pour over pot is not good for cold coffee brews.
- Why Not Coffee
January 27, 2018 | Full review
It can’t handle a large amount of coffee
- Coffeein Blog
Although the glass carafe can be quite delicate, this should not stop you from carrying your pour over coffee maker when traveling as a little extra precaution and care is all you need.
- Coffee Gear X
It’s pour-over – so it will take a bit of time to brew
- AG Ferrari
June 12, 2019 | Full review

From The Manufacturer

More smiles per cup. Baristas agree, pour over brewing unlocks the full potential of coffee. This drip kit is the easiest way to get there. Prepare your taste buds for a flavor fiesta that will leave you grinning like a possum eating a sweet potato. Get more from your beans. Coffee travels long and far and has the capacity to make you extremely happy. This 14 oz pour over coffee dripper with 100% BPA-free carafe means maximum flavor and minimal effort. Save time, hassle and the planet. Single-use filters are history. They cost money, strip flavor, create waste and damage the environment. This laser-cut stainless steel mesh filter ensures flavor ends up on your lips - not in the trash. Everything you want - nothing you don’t. Forget all those nasty dregs getting into your brew. Prepare your senses for a fragrant, naturally sweeter, coffee house-standard brew in your own home. Why risk disappointment? Unlike the competition, we never compromise on quality or service. Our feedback shows we know coffee - our 100% satisfaction promise proves we care about your personal happiness. Choose Gator today for dream coffee tomorrow

Overall Product Rankings

Coffee Gator Pour Over Coffee Maker
1. Coffee Gator Pour Over Coffee Maker
Overall Score: 9.7
Expert Reviews: 16
Bodum Pour Over Coffee Maker With Permanent Filter
2. Bodum Pour Over Coffee Maker With Permanent Filter
Overall Score: 9.6
Expert Reviews: 20
OXO BREW Pour Over Coffee Dripper, Single Serve
3. OXO BREW Pour Over Coffee Dripper, Single Serve
Overall Score: 9.4
Expert Reviews: 5
Chemex Classic Series Glass Pour-Over Coffee Maker, 8 Cup
5. Chemex Classic Series Glass Pour-Over Coffee Maker, 8 Cup
Overall Score: 9.1
Expert Reviews: 12
Coffee Gator Pour Over Kettle
6. Coffee Gator Pour Over Kettle
Overall Score: 8.9
Expert Reviews: 13
E-PRANCE Pour Over Coffee Filter Cone
7. E-PRANCE Pour Over Coffee Filter Cone
Overall Score: 8.7
Expert Reviews: 3
Melitta Pour-Over Coffee Brewer, 6 Cup
8. Melitta Pour-Over Coffee Brewer, 6 Cup
Overall Score: 8.7
Expert Reviews: 8

An Overview On Pour Over Makers

Although single-cup coffeemakers and drip brewers may be unrivaled for convenience, they can’t quite get around the fact that flavor is typically lost through the brewing process. For that reason, true coffee connoisseurs have fallen in love with pour over coffeemaking in recent years. Traditionally, pour over coffeemaking was too complicated, requiring special equipment and plenty of patience. However, manufacturers have come up with tools that give you great flavor without all the work.

Kristin Forte/Simplemost Media

One of the reasons the pour over method is so useful is that it doesn’t always require paper filters, which trap some of the natural oils in coffee along with the grounds. So you’ll find that the pour over coffeemakers on the market today try to honor that, with many offering stainless steel reusable filters that are both good for the environment and great for preserving flavor.

Paperless filtering helps keep natural oils from coffee, leading to a richer flavor. However, you may find that without that excess filtration, you get some grounds in your coffee. Coffeemakers with microfiber paper and narrow openings can help ensure your cup is as clean as possible, but be aware this can dull the taste.

Kristin Forte/Simplemost Media

If you’ve never used a pour over coffeemaker before, you’re understandably concerned about the learning curve. Some coffeemakers come with recipe books, but you can also easily find instructions online, including videos that walk you through it. It may take a bit of a learning curve, but it will be well worth it in the end.

Before you buy, consider the capacity you’ll want. Pour over coffee isn’t meant to be like that pot of coffee you make at seven a.m. that takes you all the way through lunch. Instead, it’s intended to make only enough for the cup you’re presently drinking. However, if you have two or more coffee drinkers in the house, it may be well worth getting a higher-capacity coffeemaker. Otherwise, you’ll have to heat water up separately for each person. Since pour over coffeemakers don’t have a way to stay warm in between cups, you’ll need to use each batch relatively quickly after heating the water up.

Kristin Forte/Simplemost Media

DWYM Fun Fact

Modern coffee lovers owe thanks to a German entrepreneur named Amalie Auguste Melitta Bentz, who was instrumental in a couple of major inventions that led to the way the hot beverage tastes today. In 1908, Melitta was unhappy with the flavor of the coffee coming from her percolator and began experimenting with other ways to brew. She discovered when she poured coffee through blotting paper from her son’s schoolbook, the taste improved. This was the beginning of the pour over method that led to Melitta Pour Over Coffemakers hitting the market in the 1930s. Melitta coffeemakers are still sold today, but Melitta is best known as the inventor of the coffee filter, which is even more widely in use.

The Pour Over Maker Buying Guide

  • The most important feature any pour over coffeemaker can have is taste. The nonporous glass in the Chemex Classic Glass Pour Over Coffeemaker keeps chemicals from the container from seeping into your coffee, ensuring a pure experience.
  • Another factor affecting coffee taste is filtration. The paper coffee filters typically used when brewing have a bad habit of absorbing the oils in the coffee, dulling the flavor. Many pour over coffeemakers feature reusable stainless steel filters that not only keep you from having to buy paper filters, but they allow for a richer flavor experience.
  • The Coffee Gator Pour Over Coffee Maker With Filter is made from laser-cut steel that makes it impossible for small particles to pass through. If you prefer paper filters, you’ll want to consider the Chemex Classic Glass Pour Over Coffeemaker, which requires separately purchased Chemex bonded filters. These filters use microfine paper that catches even the smallest coffee grounds to provide a truly clean cup of coffee. These filters are a bit pricey, so make sure you factor that in if you’re comparing prices. However, the trade-off of having a particle-free cup of coffee is that you’ll lose those natural oils that looser filters allow through.
  • Capacity is an important consideration. If you’re only planning to make one or two cups of coffee a day, the Coffee Gator Pour Over Coffee Maker With Filter or OXO BREW Pour Over Coffee Dripper will work fine. However, if you need to make more cups at a time, consider the Chemex Classic Glass Pour Over Coffeemaker, which comes in either 3, 6, 8 or 10-cup models. The Bodum Pour Over Coffee Maker with Filter comes in 17, 34 or 51-ounce versions.
  • One feature you may not think about with pour over coffee is how warm it will stay once you’ve poured your first cup. This is especially important if you’re investing in a coffeemaker with a capacity that goes beyond one cup. There is no function that keeps pour over coffeemakers warm when not in use, so larger-capacity models may not be very useful unless you’re making coffee for multiple people at once.
  • Some pour over coffeemakers are plastic, while others are made from glass. The biggest benefit of plastic-based coffeemakers is that they’re more durable than glass usually is. The OXO BREW Pour Over Coffee Dripper is plastic, while the Coffee Gator Pour Over Coffee Maker With Filter is made from glass and therefore not as likely to survive a drop. But you do sacrifice taste with plastic, as water heated in plastic can taste slightly contaminated. To overcome this limitation while also being somewhat durable, the Chemex Classic Glass Pour Over Coffeemaker and Bodum Pour Over Coffee Maker with Filter are both made from borosilicate glass, which is thick enough that it can take the heat and handle gentle drops. It’s important to note that this doesn’t make them completely shatter-resistant, just more so than coffeemakers made from thinner types of glass.
  • Safety is another consideration if you choose glass over plastic. Glass can more easily transfer heat to your hands. To compensate for that, the Chemex Classic Glass Pour Over Coffeemaker and Bodum Pour Over Coffee Maker with Filter have a collar around the middle of each carafe that you can use when picking it up. The Coffee Gator Pour Over Coffee Maker With Filter keeps you safe with a rubber handle. You’ll still need to be careful where you grab any time you have heated liquids inside glass.