Calphalon Aluminum Nonstick Square Grill Pan

Last updated date: December 21, 2020

DWYM Score

8.6

Calphalon Aluminum Nonstick Square Grill Pan

Why Trust DWYM?

DWYM is your trusted product review source. Along with our in-house experts, our team analyzes thousands of product reviews from the most trusted websites. We then create one easy-to-understand review. Learn more.

Don't Waste Your Money Seal of Approval
Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in the category.
Show Contents

We looked at the top Grill Pans and dug through the reviews from some of the most popular review sites. Through this analysis, we've determined the best Grill Pan you should buy.

Update as December 21, 2020:
Checkout The Best Grill Pan for a detailed review of all the top grill pans.

Overall Take

Grill masters will love the three layers of nonstick coating on this grill pan, which means foods release with ease. The pan's ridges are deep to provide the perfect grill marks and to trap juices for easy clean up later. The company believes in its product so much that it provides a lifetime warranty. During our testing, this grill pan cooked the veggies quickly and evenly, without smoking. It was also lightweight and was very easy to clean.


In our analysis of 59 expert reviews, the Calphalon Aluminum Nonstick Square Grill Pan placed 9th when we looked at the top 10 products in the category. For the full ranking, see below.

From The Manufacturer

Featuring a hard anodized exterior and nonstick interior. Calphalon ContemporaryNonstick combines durability and performance with fast clean up and easy low fat cooking.. Heavy gauge aluminum construction ensures even heating and is hard anodized for durability. It also makes it dishwasher safe. Interior includes three layers of nonstick coating – two layers provide durability and the third layer offers easy release performance. The long, brushed stainless steel handles are designed to stay cool on the stovetop. Pans and covers are also oven safe, making it ideal for finishing a gourmet dish. Deep ridges add authentic grill flavor to meats and browns evenly while locking in juices. And it’s large enough to accommodate extra servings. The nonstick surface means you can cook healthier using less fat, with effortless cleanup. Comes with Calphalon's full lifetime warranty.

Expert Reviews

Expert Summarized Score

8.0
10 expert reviews

User Summarized Score

9.4
630 user reviews

What experts liked

11 inch size makes this pan fall in the above average size section which is good thing since now you have more space for grilling.
- Food Shark Marfa
It is made of heavy-gauge aluminum for even heating and the body is hard anodized for durability. It is also dishwasher safe for easy cleanup.
- Cookware Stuffs
March 5, 2019 | Full review
While it is designed to cook food evenly, it also ensures that the food retains its juices.
- All Kitchen Pro
This product is PFOE free. Without the inclusion of harmful chemicals, your grilled meals will always be safe to eat. And, being oven safe up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit, you also get flexibility of use.
- Chef's Resource
The long, brushed stainless steel handles of the pan are designed to stay cool on the stovetop. Pans and covers are also oven safe which makes it ideal for finishing a gourmet dish.
- My Classy Kitchen
Heavy gauge aluminum construction ensures even heating and is hard anodized for durability. It also makes it dishwasher safe.
- Grills Zone
The heavy-gauge aluminum construction allows for even heat distribution when cooking. This will, therefore, make the cooking elementary and faster.
- All the Best Review
March 16, 2019 | Full review
The good thing about this product is you can clean this in your dishwasher. In order to protect your hands while handling this cookware the handle of this pan is made of a long stainless steel material.
- Broad Review
I love the long brushed stainless steel handle that surprisingly stays cool over the stovetop. Both the pan and the cover are oven-safe too thus enabling me to make my favorite gourmet recipes.
- JosephineDC
3 layered non stick coating for durability and easy release of food. Accommodates more than one serving and can be used to cook different items together.
- All About Grill
August 7, 2018 | Full review

What experts didn't like

Not dishwasher compatible as advertised. It is not scratch resistant. Not metal utensil safe.
- Chef's Resource
Some might find the handle too long for their arm
- JosephineDC
The ridges are not high enough which may result in food being cooked in extra fat.
- All About Grill
August 7, 2018 | Full review

Our Expert Consultant

Julie Chernoff
Culinary Expert

Julie Chernoff is a long-time member of Les Dames d’Escoffier (past president of the Chicago Chapter, and current co-chair of the LDEI Legacy Awards Committee), the Association of Food Journalists (AFJ) and the International Association of Culinary Professionals.

Chernoff is the dining editor of Better, a lifestyle website and print magazine. Her journalism started in the test kitchens of Weight Watchers Magazine. She holds a BA in English from Yale University and is a graduate of the California Culinary Academy. She has spent the last few decades styling, photographing, teaching, developing recipes, editing, thinking and writing about food.

An Overview On Grill Pans

Grill pans are an excellent cooking tool that will help you get the sear you’re looking for, even if you need to prepare a meal indoors. In fact, our resident culinary expert and the co-chair of the International Association of Culinary Professionals Julie Chernoff says: “Grill pans are just the thing when it’s too cold or rainy to head out to your outdoor grill, or if you just have a small amount to grill.”

Simplemost Media

Did you know that one of the first known meals cooked barbecue-style was mammoth ribs? It’s true! Archaeologists actually uncovered an old cooking pit back in 2009. While it’s safe to say you won’t be grilling mammoth for your family, you’ll most likely be preparing some kind of meat as the main course for your meal.

When you begin your search for the best grill pan, take a look at the materials used for construction.

“I prefer cast iron grill pans, as they retain heat better than stainless steel, and although heavier than stainless, are far better at mimicking the classic grill grates in terms of grill marks on your meats and veggies,” says Chernoff.

Simplemost Media

The Lodge Pro-Grid Cast Iron Reversible Grill/Griddle is an excellent choice, as it features a grill on one side and a griddle on the other. It’s also pre-seasoned and able to distribute heat evenly across the pan.

Another option is a grill pan made using a heavy gauge aluminum, like the Calphalon Aluminum Nonstick Square Grill Pan. When you go this route, you’ll need to make sure the pan has a nonstick coating. The Calphalon has not one, but three layers of nonstick coating. You won’t have any trouble with food sticking to the pan with this model.

Next, you’ll want to consider the pan’s shape.

“As far as shape, I recommend the square or rectangular grill pan, as they have more surface area than a round or oval pan,” says Chernoff.

Simplemost Media

She goes on to point out that “the larger rectangular pans will cover two burners.” That makes them an excellent choice when cooking for a big family.

According to Chernoff, “the smaller, one-burner grill pans will have a handle, and the longer, the better. Those pans get hot and stay hot! This will, of course, make the pan heavier, so you will need a helper handle on the opposite side of the pan from the long handle, to make it easier to maneuver.” In addition to a long handle, Chernoff recommends choosing a pan with “nice deep ridges that will keep your food out of the grease that drips off during cooking.” The Cuisinart Chef’s Classic 12-Inch Round Grill Pan has a tapered drip-free rim that makes it a cinch to collect and pour out drippings.

Of course, there are also grill pans out there that are meant to be used just once. The disposable Weber Small Aluminum Drip Pans, for example, can be used with select grills to catch drippings, or used to prepare veggies or casseroles for a family picnic.

The Grill Pan Buying Guide

  • Review any guarantees or warranties offered by the company. You may be pleasantly surprised to discover that some models actually come with a lifetime warranty.
  • Make sure the grill pan you’re interested in fits your needs. Can it be used indoors on an oven, a grill or a stove? Can it be used outdoors on a grill or over a campfire?
  • Check to see if the grill pan is dishwasher safe. Some models are and some aren’t. Those that must be washed by hand are easier to clean if they have been given time to soak in a dishpan of hot soapy water. Should you have any tough stuck-on foods to contend with, use baking soda and a non-abrasive sponge to remove them.
  • Look to see whether your grill pan can be used with an induction cooktop. Some models aren’t compatible with induction cooking.
  • Certain grill pans are not safe for use with metal utensils, as they may pull up the nonstick surface or causes scratches. It’s best to stick with wooden or plastic utensils.
  • Check to make sure the product is PFOE free. You don’t want to chance harmful chemicals leaking into your grilled meals and veggies.
  • Always review the maximum temperature the pan can be exposed to, as higher heats may cause the grill pans to crack. Many will list that they are oven safe up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit on their product packaging.
  • Consider grill pans that come with a weighted press. This will allow you to cook bacon evenly or make a delicious panini sandwich.
  • When it comes to price, you must take into consideration the material used to construct the pan, as well as the pan’s size. The Lodge Pro-Grid Cast Iron Reversible Grill/Griddle is priced higher than the Cuisinart Chef’s Classic 12-Inch Round Grill Pan and the Calphalon Aluminum Nonstick Square Grill Pan, as they are made out of aluminum and it is made out of a more durable cast iron. The Lodge grill pan also spans the length of two burners. On the lower end of the price range, you have the Weber Small Aluminum Drip Pans, which are made for one-time use only.