Baby Jogger City Select Lux Second Seat

Last updated date: April 2, 2019

Review Melt Score

Why Trust The Review Melt Score?

Review Melt is the #1 product review aggregator. Our team analyzes thousands of product reviews from the most trusted websites. We then "melt" them into one easy-to-understand score. Learn more.

Look for the Review Melt seal for products that are the best in the category.

We looked at the top 1 Strollers and dug through the reviews from 4 of the most popular review sites including Lucie's List, Little Baby Gear, Who Loves Babies, Also Mom and more. Through this analysis, we've determined the best Stroller you should buy.

Overall Take

In our analysis of 55 expert reviews, the Baby Jogger Baby Jogger City Select Lux Second Seat placed 6th when we looked at the top 10 products in the category. For the full ranking, see below.

Editor's Note April 19, 2019:
Checkout The Best Stroller for a detailed review of all the top strollers.

Expert Summarized Score
4 expert reviews
User Summarized Score
58 user reviews
Our Favorite Video Reviews
What experts liked
The regular City Select is the roomiest convertible on the market and has two identical seats that each hold up to 45 lbs.
- Lucie's List
This stroller has decelerating brake and parking brake in one, within reach. Locking and unlocking is very easy, but an older child won’t be able to do this when sitting on a bench seat.
- Little Baby Gear
The canopy has a 3-part fold and is adjustable for different head heights to accommodate taller kids. The sun shade comes with UV+50 Sun protection and provides adequate coverage on hot sunny days, preventing the Sun from blaring down on the children’s face or hurting their sensitive eyes.
- Who Loves Babies
The City Select Lux has an easily adjustable footrest and reclines super deep with the push of a button; however, due to the molded bucket seat, the Lux will never recline completely flat.
- Also Mom
What experts didn't like
A downside to the roominess is the loss of maneuverability. Because the stroller is so lonnnnng, it’s harder to steer and maneuver, especially if you’re dealing with any kind of hills.
- Lucie's List
Handlebar might be too high for short parents; it’s better for average and tall people
- Little Baby Gear
LUX still does not self-stand after folding so you either have to hold it with a hand or lay it totally flat.
- Who Loves Babies
To attach the harness, you must first link up each shoulder strap to its waist strap counterpart, then buckle those pieces into the crotch strap. It's an extra step we'd rather not have to think about while buckling in a squirmy toddler.
- Also Mom

From The Manufacturer

The City Select LUX convertible stroller, with second seat kit, goes from a single to double, so your growing family is always ready for any adventure. It has the most riding options of any single to double stroller, with over 20 configurations. That's over 25% more than City Select! Add the bench seat so your older child can hop a ride. Or, add an infant car seat, pram, or second seat to accommodate up to two children. Folding stroller is 30% smaller and automatically locks, so it's even easier to carry. All-wheel suspension and a decelerating hand brake provide increased comfort and control for this all terrain stroller.

Overall Product Rankings

1. Britax B-Lively Lightweight Stroller
Overall Score: 9.3
Expert Reviews: 3
2. BOB Revolution Flex 3.0 Jogging Stroller
Overall Score: 9.0
Expert Reviews: 5
Overall Score: 9.0
Expert Reviews: 5
4. Baby Jogger 2016 City Mini 3W Single Stroller
Overall Score: 8.8
Expert Reviews: 5
5. UPPAbaby Cruz Stroller
Overall Score: 8.7
Expert Reviews: 10
6. Baby Jogger City Select Lux Second Seat
Overall Score: 8.4
Expert Reviews: 4
7. Graco Roomfor2 Stroller
Overall Score: 8.2
Expert Reviews: 5
8. Baby Trend Expedition LX Travel System
Overall Score: 8.1
Expert Reviews: 4
9. Britax 2017 B-Agile Lightweight Stroller
Overall Score: 7.8
Expert Reviews: 6
10. Kolcraft Cloud Plus Lightweight Stroller
Overall Score: 7.3
Expert Reviews: 4

An Overview On Strollers

Like anything involving your kids, buying a stroller is a lot more complicated than it should be. You’ll want something that fits both your car trunk and your budget, but that’s just the beginning of factors to consider — and the constant upgrades, innovations and recalls from the stroller industry don’t make things any simpler. The important thing is to know what basic kind of stroller will suit your needs, and the questions narrow down from there.

In the beginning, strollers were a one-piece affair: Take the baby out of the car seat, put them in the stroller and walk. While some traditional strollers still sport that self-contained design, the default these days is the broad category of a car seat carrier. In this case, you have a car seat that’s secured to your car by a base. The car seat lifts out of the base and can be locked directly into the stroller. Some face forward, some face back, but most have the option to do either one. Some strollers have the option to install a car seat for infants (sometimes with adapters), but still have an integral seat to accommodate larger toddlers.

Jogging strollers can also incorporate car seats, and they’re popular with active parents in both rural or urban settings. This smaller design usually has three wheels for quicker maneuverability. Their tires are suited to the environment, and sometimes can be switched out. There are knobby ones for off-road areas, and the BOB Revolution Flex 3.0 has inflated tires with a tight grip for mommy marathons along asphalt or indoor floors. In most cases, these strollers aren’t recommended for children under 6 months.

Then there’s the lightweight, or umbrella stroller. Small both in profile and price, these are the ultimate in portability. A good umbrella stroller can weigh as little as ten pounds, folds up quickly and should fit into just about any car. Most of them can also use a car seat, but bear in mind they are not generally good for newborns, especially if you’re simply using the integrated seat.

There’s a lot of variation among all these types, and we’ve recently begun to see car seats that incorporate the entire stroller, wheels and all, into the base. A popular if more expensive option is a “travel system” that gives you a car seat and base along with a compatible stroller. Others like the UPPAbaby Vista have a bassinet as their default carrier. If there’s a common selling point among modern strollers, it’s adaptability. A carrier that might be perfect for you one year is going to be useless the next, unless it can change to handle your rapidly growing child.

You’ll want your stroller to get you from point A to B easily, but also safely. The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission has a raft of new federal requirements that strengthen the standards on things like non-pinching hinges, latch mechanisms, seat belts and detachable wheels. If reliability is a key concern, definitely look for strollers made after those standards were enacted in September 2015. You can also look for certification by the JMPA (Juvenile Products Manufacturers Association), which ensures that products for children meet those federal guidelines as well as their own.

Strollers of any type can vary widely in weight, from 10 pounds on umbrella models up to 30 pounds or more. And that’s just the beginning of the variety: Bells and whistles these days might include bench seats so that larger kids can ride upright, extensive compartment space and cup holders for parents, baby or both. But don’t sweat the small stuff to begin with. The best thing is to first determine if it will fit your child and car, then explore your perks from there.

Review Melt Fun Fact

Need a little motivation to keep exercising? Dianna Chivakos of Massachusetts set a world record for the fastest marathon while pushing a jogging stroller in October 2017. The time? Just over 3 hours and 10 minutes. The stroller? A BOB Revolution. The wingman? Dianna’s three year old son Evan, who apparently went the entire 26.2 miles without a fuss thanks to his iPhone and games.

The Stroller Buying Guide

  • The seat is the first thing you’ll want to consider when buying a stroller. If it’s a self-contained, traditional type, simply check the specs to see what the carrying capacity is, usually listed by age or weight range. If it’s a car seat carrier, you’ll want to make sure that it can accommodate the brand and model of car seat you already own – unless you’re buying an all-in-one travel system. Most strollers are only compatible with car seats made by their company, but some do allow other brands to be mounted — usually with an adapter, which you may have to buy separately.
  • Weight of the stroller is also a big concern, especially for the elderly, those with bad backs or mothers dealing with the aftermath of a C-section. You can usually find the weight listed prominently on the product specs, but heads up if the stroller doesn’t come with a car seat included. That car seat is going to add a significant amount of pounds.
  • More than likely, the stroller’s method of assembly and disassembly is going to make you love it or hate it. Is it able to fold up quickly and easily? A lot of engineering goes into the best selling strollers, so much so that they seem like origami creations when in use. Some will tout “one-handed” folding, which may not necessarily translate to “easier,” but can certainly be a plus when it works well. If you can’t try out the stroller first-hand, check online for a video that shows how it breaks down.
  • If you plan on keeping your stroller for the long haul, adaptability is going to be a main selling point. You may save money on a quick and sporty umbrella carrier, but it won’t be much use after your child outgrows the only car seat that fits on it. There’s a lot to be said for a fully integrated seat with adjustable seat belts that can be moved as your child grows.
  • Got a small car? That probably does more to limit your options than anything else. Be sure to measure the space that your stroller will be fitting into when folded, whether that’s a trunk or a closet. Some strollers will even stand upright when disassembled, which can help with indoor storage.
  • Safety should always be a main concern, no matter what type you get. The frame should definitely be made of durable materials, and the buckles situated or padded so that they don’t pinch tiny fingers. In general, when it comes to harnesses, a five-point restraint system is the gold standard. There are federal specifications on strollers that have been upgraded since 2015, so models made after that year may be better constructed. You can also look for certification by the JPMA, an industry group that sets their own exacting standards.
  • Next, let’s kick the tires. Some parents enjoy the three-wheel feel of most jogging strollers, while others prefer the relative stability of a four-wheel setup. Bigger wheels will give you a better ride on uneven surfaces either way. As for the actual tire, most are made out of plastic and rubber — although some jogging strollers may sport actual inflatable tires. That can definitely result in a smooth ride, but bear in mind you will have to keep them inflated just like any car tire. Many strollers feature detachable wheels, either to give you the option of different tire styles or to make the product smaller when not in use. Either way, double check that the wheels are securely fastened before you roll out.
  • Storage is going to be another key concern for busy parents, or those who like long walks. The primary spot for diaper bags or other light luggage is under the seat, so make sure there’s enough room there for whatever you’re likely to carry. Whatever you do, don’t hang heavy items from the handlebars. Too much weight can tip the stroller. If a stroller has a cup holder, that’s another big plus. Some even have a second one for baby right there on a tray, and deluxe models might even feature insulated holders to keep that milk or juice cold for the jog home.
  • Especially short or tall parents, do yourself a favor and check that the handlebars are positioned at a comfortable height. On many models, they will be adjustable, but it’s not a given. Bending over too far to push a heavy stroller can be harder than just carrying a child around.
  • When you get that stroller home, you may want to breathe a sigh of relief and check out after you’ve gotten through the assembly. Do yourself a favor and keep reading. There’s typically an option to register your stroller. Sign yourself up and you can get notified in case of a recall.