ATD Tools 5184 Oil Drain Pan

Last updated date: July 6, 2020

DWYM Score
9.5

ATD Tools 5184 Oil Drain Pan

Why Trust The DWYM Score?

DWYM is your trusted product review source. Along with our in-house experts, our team analyzes thousands of product reviews from the most trusted websites. We then create one easy-to-understand score. Learn more.

Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in the category.

We looked at the top Oil Drain Pans and dug through the reviews from some of the most popular review sites. Through this analysis, we've determined the best Oil Drain Pan you should buy.

Overall Take

You can avoid spills and splashes with the well-designed anti-splash lip. This oil drain pan also has a large spout so it’s easy to pour out the liquid. The molded handles make it simple to control the pan when it’s full. In our analysis of 65 expert reviews, the ATD Tools ATD Tools 5184 Oil Drain Pan placed 2nd when we looked at the top 10 products in the category. For the full ranking, see below.

Editor's Note July 6, 2020:
Checkout The Best Oil Drain Pan for a detailed review of all the top oil drain pans.

Expert Summarized Score
9.1
13 expert reviews
User Summarized Score
9.6
849 user reviews
Our Favorite Video Reviews
What experts liked
Prevents spills. Holds a lot of oil. Thick and rigid pan. Spout makes it easy to stick the oil back in the containers for recycling. Wide top. Minimal splashing.
- BestReviews
Every aspect of the pan is designed to collect oil. The inside is grooved to help prevent splashing while funneling the oil towards the middle. Plus, an anti-splash lip helps prevent spills when sliding the full pan out from underneath the car.
- DigMyRide
It is an easy to clean and carry drain pan that offers a generous 4.5-gallon capacity to ensure you can drain oil without stopping to empty it.
- Car Care Total
This pan has a wide mouth for easy pouring. It also has a molded handle which makes it highly portable and easy to pick up, move, and store. The lip makes it quite easy to pour without having to worry as much about spillage.
- Garage Chief
With this pan, you’ll enjoy using this model for a decent time. It has a construction from high-grade polyethylene. The material is not only rugged, but it can also resist chemicals.
- Auto Quarterly
At only 6 inches tall, it will fit under any vehicle, and it can still handle over 4 gallons of oil. ATD Tools have helped prevent any spills with an anti-splash lip all around the draining pan. This is regarded as one of the most efficient on the market at avoiding spills.
- Mechanic Scout
What we like the most of this pan is its spout that is big enough to pour down the oil comfortably. Many customers are satisfied with the performance of this product.
- 10ATop
Lightweight design to easily move the pan around underneath your car. Has a spout to minimize spilling used oil, a large mouth for easy collection, and handles to help with transport.
- The Drive
Undoubtedly the best drain pan in our review. This black 4-1/2 gallon drain pan features a large spout for easy pouring. The molded handle makes carrying, pouring and storing extremely easy. Its anti-splash lip helps prevent spilling when carrying or pouring.
- XL Race Parts
Packs a large capacity oil drain featuring 30 quart which is about 7.6 gallons of fluid when full. The anti-splash lip on the other hand helps ensure all your fluids stay within the drain pan. For easy disposal and pouring of liquids, it features a large spout on one end so that you can use it without a funnel and won’t have to worry about unnecessary spills.
- Sisters Grimm
Pretty ergonomic in shape, has two handles that will make carrying it easier, and has a ergonomic design special anti-spill lid filled linseed oil with liquid to add weight. It is 6” deep and measures 15” in diameter. It also comes with a spout which makes pouring easier and less messy.
- Car Part Helper
The model comes with a large spout important for easy pouring of the oil into a container. You still an anti-splash lip that contains the fluid to remain in the oil pan. There are also handles that you could use for carrying, pouring and storing of the oil.
- I Love Engineering
What experts didn't like
When emptying this model, you must be careful with the spout side of the drain to not empty too quickly and spill.
- BestReviews
Not suitable for transporting oil.
- DigMyRide
There is no lid on this oil drain pan, and so it will not be very convenient for storing the oil.
- Car Care Total
A plastic pan, so not the most durable on the market.
- Garage Chief
It is easy to knock over and spill oil since it does not have a lid.
- Auto Quarterly
There's no lid or cover with this oil drain pan, so it's not ideal if you need to transport the waste oil any great distance.
- Mechanic Scout
It comes without a lid that could help to save the extracted oil for recycling purposes.
- 10ATop
There is no lid which can make transporting used oil tricky. If the drain pan is full some oil can come out through spout if jostled.
- The Drive
Not recommended for transporting oil. The pouring spout might need a bigger lip above it.
- Sisters Grimm
While an average capacity for an oil drain pan molded hands is 5 gallons, this one will hold up to 4.5 gallons only.
- Car Part Helper
It lacks a strong construction.
- I Love Engineering

From The Manufacturer

This black 4-1/2 gallon drain pan features a large spout for easy pouring. The molded handle makes carrying, pouring and storing extremely easy. It's anti-splash lip helps prevent spilling when carrying or pouring. This drain pan is 6 inch deep and has a 15.25 inch diameter.

Overall Product Rankings

Lumax LX-1632 Drainmaster Oil Drain Pan
1. Lumax LX-1632 Drainmaster Oil Drain Pan
Overall Score: 9.7
Expert Reviews: 12
ATD Tools 5184 Oil Drain Pan
2. ATD Tools 5184 Oil Drain Pan
Overall Score: 9.5
Expert Reviews: 13
Capri Tools CP21024 Oil Drain Pan
3. Capri Tools CP21024 Oil Drain Pan
Overall Score: 9.2
Expert Reviews: 5
Neiko 20762A Anti Splash Oil Drain Pan
4. Neiko 20762A Anti Splash Oil Drain Pan
Overall Score: 9.0
Expert Reviews: 1
Lisle 17892 Transmission Oil Drain Pan
6. Lisle 17892 Transmission Oil Drain Pan
Overall Score: 8.9
Expert Reviews: 1
Motivx Tools Engine Oil Drain Pan
7. Motivx Tools Engine Oil Drain Pan
Overall Score: 8.7
Expert Reviews: 8
WirthCo 32953 Funnel King Oil Drain Pan
8. WirthCo 32953 Funnel King Oil Drain Pan
Overall Score: 8.6
Expert Reviews: 1
Custom Accessories 31118 Oil Drain Pan
9. Custom Accessories 31118 Oil Drain Pan
Overall Score: 8.2
Expert Reviews: 5

An Overview On Oil Drain Pans

Have you ever tried to drain the oil from your vehicle and ended up with a big, sloppy mess all over your garage floor? What you need is an oil drain pan. While it looks like a fancy bucket, what it does is prevent the oil from spilling and splattering all over the place while you drain it from your car. If you want to avoid spilling oil everywhere and not have to clean up a stubborn mess, invest in an oil drain pan you can use over and over again.

Depending on how big your automobile’s engine is, you’ll need to drain out somewhere between five and eight quarts of oil. That is a lot of fluid. If the worst happens and it spills all over your garage floor, it’s going to take you days to clean it up and you’ll need to get some harsh chemical cleaners. You will never get all of the spilled oil out of your concrete driveway and will be left with a large stain, too. When it comes to cars, it’s important to use job-specific tools so you can get the task done right and avoid a headache.

Oil changes are a necessary maintenance activity that is required to keep your car running well. Frequent oil changes ensure your engine runs smoothly, and they also help to increase overall performance, extend the lifespan of your engine and lower your fuel consumption. It’s not a task you can avoid, and using an oil drain pan makes it much easier. Draining oil from your engine can be difficult, but having the right tools ensures you’re getting the job done faster and with less mess.

DWYM Fun Fact

Storing your oil drain pans can be a problem because they often get covered in oil, and lots of dirt and dust can then stick to the oil. In order to store your oil drain pans without making a mess, consider hanging the empty oil drain pan vertically so that you can drain out any remaining oil carefully into another container drip by drip. If you don’t have space to hang it up, you can place the oil drain pan standing up in another large container so that the final drips can drain out. Once all of the oil has come out of the pan, you can wipe it down and then store it in your garage, without worrying about it dust particles getting stuck to it.

The Oil Drain Pan Buying Guide

  • When you’re looking for an oil drain pan, size is one of the most important factors to consider. You want to ensure that you can empty all of the oil in one go, so look for a pan that accommodates your vehicle. Keep in mind how far your car is off the ground. Bigger pans with higher profiles will be difficult to slide under your car if it’s been lowered.
  • Handles are something you cannot underestimate. It’s very difficult to maneuver and carry a full oil drain pan with six quarts of oil. Choose an oil drain pan that has two handles that are placed conveniently for your needs.
  • When it comes to the material of the oil drain pan, opt for a sturdy product made from tough polyethylene material. This will provide you with long-lasting durability. Just keep in mind that heavier oil drain pans will be more difficult to carry once they are full.
  • If you want to avoid the mess of funneling and pouring the oil from the pan, go with an oil drain pan that comes with a lid. You can then store the oil directly in the pan without having to move it to another container. You can just empty the oil into the pan, put on the lid and then take it away. However, if you need to change the oil in several vehicles at once, then it might be best to use an oil drain pan that’s not also a storage container.
  • Consider how easy it is to pour the oil out of the drip pan. Look for one that has multiple spouts in strategic places. This will help you avoid spills and messes.