Apple Watch 4

Last updated date: July 19, 2019

DWYM Score
9.0

Why Trust The DWYM Score?

DWYM is your trusted product review source. Along with our in-house experts, our team analyzes thousands of product reviews from the most trusted websites. We then create one easy-to-understand score. Learn more.

Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in the category.

We looked at the top 1 Smartwatches and dug through the reviews from 13 of the most popular review sites including Tom's Guide, Digital Trends, The Verge, Tech Radar, Trusted Reviews, CNET, Consumer Reports, Engadget, ZD Net, PG Magazine - SE Asia, T3, Mashable, Wired UK and more. Through this analysis, we've determined the best Smartwatch you should buy.

Overall Take

Although it boasts the highest cost, the Apple Watch Series 4 has all the bells and whistles, including Raise to Speak Siri and a less bulky screen. An Apple Watch will also give you a fuller selection of apps than watches that run on other operating systems. In our analysis of 177 expert reviews, the Apple Apple Watch 4 placed 1st when we looked at the top 16 products in the category. For the full ranking, see below.

Editor's Note August 1, 2019:
Checkout The Best Smartwatch for a detailed review of all the top smartwatches.

Expert Summarized Score
8.8
13 expert reviews
User Summarized Score
8.4
9 user reviews
Our Favorite Video Reviews
What experts liked
Big, beautiful display. Advanced health sensors. Faster processing power. Useful Raise to Speak Siri
- Tom's Guide
November 13, 2018 | Full review
Great design and build quality. Excellent, user-friendly software. Comprehensive, motivational health and fitness features. Can replace your phone for a short time. Plenty of colors, straps, and third-party accessories
- Digital Trends
October 5, 2018 | Full review
Great battery life. Huge, beautiful screen. Health-tracking features, not just fitness
- The Verge
September 19, 2018 | Full review
The design alone is a big upgrade, with the screen offering far more visibility, and while the health benefits are only going to help a subset of users, they're welcome and show the direction Apple is heading.
- Tech Radar
September 25, 2018 | Full review
Feels great to wear. Screen is gorgeous. Huge amount of strap options. Fantastic array of fitness and health features. It motivates you so well to be active
- Trusted Reviews
October 22, 2018 | Full review
The Apple Watch Series 4 offers a larger, crisp display that shows more with less bezel, superfast speed and a louder speaker. It adds high and low heart-rate detection, fall detection with SOS trigger, and (eventually) FDA-cleared EKG for more detailed heart readings.
- CNET
October 19, 2018 | Full review
The watch face is not only bigger but also flatter, making it less bulky. And, thanks to sleeker bezels, there's no big, black border surrounding the enlarged display. And, like earlier models, the Apple Watch Series 4 is a champ when it comes to readability in bright and low-light situations.
- Consumer Reports
October 23, 2018 | Full review
Bigger and improved screen. Long battery life. Much-improved performance. Accurate step tracking. Walkie-Talkie conversations are a blast. New heart features could save lives. Talking to Siri is easier.
- Engadget
September 27, 2018 | Full review
Expanded viewable area. Light weight. Solid battery life. Gorgeous display with stunning animations for watch faces.
- ZD Net
September 27, 2018 | Full review
Large screen. Good call quality. ECG capability. Fall detection. WatchOS 5 brings numerous improvements. Stylish.
- PG Magazine - SE Asia
Big, bright screen. Good battery life. Impressive health features. Better fit in thinner body
- T3
Bigger, higher-resolution displays. Compatible with all old Apple Watch bands. Increasingly advanced health and fitness tracking. Super fast and smooth performance. Satisfying haptic feedback in Digital Crown. Walkie Talkie app is awesome. Excellent battery life
- Mashable
Superb Watch calls, better specs; improved design
- Wired UK
October 21, 2018 | Full review
What experts didn't like
ECG app not available at launch. Expensive
- Tom's Guide
November 13, 2018 | Full review
The Apple Watch’s battery capacity is unknown, but Apple says it will last for around 18 hours before it needs a recharge using the included magnetic charging disk. The quoted time is on the conservative side, depending on your use. If you’re using GPS, fitness tracking, or cellular, then 18 hours is at the top end, but with only notifications and turning it off overnight, we could almost reach 24 hours. Not great, but we’ve seen worse.
- Digital Trends
October 5, 2018 | Full review
Siri is still unreliable. No always-on screen option. Complication options can be confusing
- The Verge
September 19, 2018 | Full review
If it had better battery life, and thus able to track sleep, the Watch 4 could have been the perfect smartwatch.
- Tech Radar
September 25, 2018 | Full review
It won’t last multiple days without needing a charge. Still won’t track sleep natively. No always-on display is irritating.
- Trusted Reviews
October 22, 2018 | Full review
Starting prices are higher than last year. Battery life still won't last past two days. Watch face options are still very limited in choice and function. Only works with iPhones.
- CNET
October 19, 2018 | Full review
People who wear reading glasses might still have trouble reading the display without them.
- Consumer Reports
October 23, 2018 | Full review
More expensive than ever. Transferring LTE service can be tricky. ECG feature isn't ready yet. Some watch faces feel like information overload. Rival watches have even better battery life.
- Engadget
September 27, 2018 | Full review
No advanced sleep tracking. No always-on display option. No support for third party watch faces. Swipe to switch watch faces is annoying.
- ZD Net
September 27, 2018 | Full review
Expensive. Battery life remains unchanged. No built-in sleep tracking.
- PG Magazine - SE Asia
Running data still behind Garmin. New flush side button is harder to press
- T3
Lacks sleep tracking, commonplace in other wearables. Still no always-on clock. Super pricey
- Mashable
No native sleep detection; auto-detection for walking comes in too late
- Wired UK
October 21, 2018 | Full review

From The Manufacturer

GLONASS, Galileo, and QZSS, Barometric altimeter, Optical heart sensor, Electrical heart sensor, Improved accelerometer up to 32 g‑forces, Improved gyroscope, Ambient light sensor, LTPO OLED Retina display with Force Touch (1000 nits), Digital Crown with haptic feedback, Louder speaker, Ion-X strengthened glass, Sapphire crystal and ceramic back

Overall Product Rankings

1. Apple Watch 4
Overall Score: 9.0
Expert Reviews: 13
2. Samsung Gear 3
Overall Score: 8.8
Expert Reviews: 7
3. ASUS Zenwatch 2
Overall Score: 8.7
Expert Reviews: 9
4. Apple Watch Series 3
Overall Score: 8.5
Expert Reviews: 10
5. Huawei
Overall Score: 8.2
Expert Reviews: 11
6. Scinex SW20 Smartwatch
Overall Score: 8.1
Expert Reviews: 12
7. TicWatch S Smartwatch
Overall Score: 8.1
Expert Reviews: 6
8. Fitbit Versa
Overall Score: 8.1
Expert Reviews: 12
9. Garmin 3
Overall Score: 7.9
Expert Reviews: 8
10. Fitbit Versa
Overall Score: 7.8
Expert Reviews: 12
11. TicWatch E Bluetooth Smartwatch
Overall Score: 7.8
Expert Reviews: 4
12. Samsung Galaxy Smartwatch
Overall Score: 7.6
Expert Reviews: 9
13. TicWatch Pro Bluetooth Smartwatch
Overall Score: 7.5
Expert Reviews: 7
14. Samsung Gear 2
Overall Score: 7.5
Expert Reviews: 10
15. SUNETLINK Bluteooth Smartwatch With Camera
Overall Score: 7.3
Expert Reviews: 2
16. Motorola Moto 360 Smartwatch
Overall Score: 7.1
Expert Reviews: 26

An Overview On Smartwatches

Watches have gone well beyond merely telling the time. You can read incoming texts and emails, monitor your health stats and even make and receive phone calls, all from the device on your wrist. But there’s more than one smartwatch player in town, and the choices can be overwhelming.

Chances are, one of the top deciding factors when choosing a smartwatch is the type of smartphone you own. If you have an iPhone, you’ll find the best compatibility in an Apple Watch. If, on the other hand, you own an Android-based smartphone, an Android-based watch like the Samsung S3 may be a better choice. While most watches can pair with other operating systems, you’ll get the most out of one with the same operating system as your phone.

Then there’s the Fitbit line of fitness trackers. Once merely designed to measure the steps you take each day, these wearables have gotten much more sophisticated over time. Models like the Fitbit Versa have a few of the same features as the iOS- and Android-based watches, offering functions like texting and contactless payment.

Your choice of smartwatch will probably be driven by your needs. If you just need health tracking, for instance, you may not get enough out of the other features to make it worth the extra expense. However, the price variations are minimal — especially if you’re open to an older model, like the Apple Watch Series 3, rather than needing to have the latest and greatest.

With smartwatches, many features are driven by the available apps. You can play games on both Apple and Samsung watches, for instance, but you’re limited by the apps that have been created for those versions. The Apple Watch is by far the top choice in this arena since third-party developers are lining up to make apps that work with the technology. Before you buy, make sure the apps you want are available for whichever watch you’re considering.

After searching the app store, you’ll also want to consider the look and feel of each of the watches. The Samsung Gear S3 has a more traditional watch look, but you may find more bands you like in the Apple Watch. Since the faces of both types of watches are customizable, you’re sure to find a look that works with your own unique tastes.

DYWM Fun Fact

Like other wearables, smartwatches are expected to continue to expand their functionality in the coming years. The field of medicine has especially been interested in the technology, wanting to move beyond heart rate and step tracking to keep patients healthy. Wearables can already help wearers track their menstrual cycles to know when they’re ovulating, as well as tracking moods to help with stress. But medical professionals hope to eventually refine the technology to monitor glucose levels and warn wearers when there might be a heart-related health issue. Smartwatches can also be built to sense when you’re driving and reduce notifications. Apple is reportedly also looking at ways that users could use hand gestures to control their watches, which will effectively reduce the current reliance on voice commands.

The Smartwatch Buying Guide

  • You’ll be wearing your watch every day, so appearance is important. Taste plays a big part in this, but Apple Watches have a very basic look. The Samsung Gear S3 looks the most like a traditional watch. With Apple’s watches and the Samsung Gear S3, though, you can change out the digital watch face to suit your mood — or to match your outfit.
  • The Apple Watch, Samsung Gear S3 and the Fitbit Versa all build in advanced fitness tracking, although this is one area where Fitbit outdoes all others. You’ll get accuracy and more information with a dedicated fitness band. Samsung’s tracking is the least accurate of the three watch groups.
  • If you choose a watch with cellular built-in, you’ll be able to accept and make calls and texts even when you’re away from your phone. You’ll have to pay an additional monthly fee for that, though, in addition to paying more for the watch. Only the Apple Watch Series 3 and 4 and the Samsung Gear S3 have this feature. To use this phone capability, you’ll need to have a device that’s compatible with the watch you choose, which means a phone with iOS for the Apple Watch or an Android-based one for the Samsung watch.
  • In addition to phone functionality, you’ll also need the right smartphone to take full advantage of the Apple or Samsung watch’s features. The Fitbit can sync with either iOS or Android, allowing you to accept texts and connect to the Fitbit app.
  • When you put your smartwatch on, you want it to run on battery power for at least the entire workday. The Apple Watch Series 3 or 4 will run for up to 18 hours on a charge. Both the Samsung Gear S3 and the Fitbit Versa promise battery life of up to four days, but this will vary depending on use.
  • If you own a smartphone, you’re probably already aware of the apps that are available for your operating system. The same situation will apply to your smartwatch. Apple has far more apps than Samsung, although both manufacturers suffer from a shortage of apps specific to smartwatches. Fitbit’s bands are even more limited, with these bands primarily used to track health data.
  • Since you’re wearing it on your wrist every day, it’s important to find a band that won’t weigh you down. Apple’s smartwatches are the lightest, with the Series 3 weighing 1.12 ounces and the Series 4 weighing 1.69 ounces. Samsung’s Gear S3 weighs slightly more, at 2.24 ounces, while the Fitbit Versa weighs 5.1 ounces.
  • In addition to weight, it’s also important to consider how much real estate the watch will take up on your wrist. The Apple Watch is available in two sizes, 40 mm and 44 mm, so you can choose the size that works best with your wrist. The display area of the Gear S3 is smaller, totaling only 33 mm, or 1.3 inches.
  • One popular feature of today’s smartwatches is the ability to pay at the register without taking out your wallet. All of the watches have payment built-in. You’ll just need to add your credit card before you start shopping. There are benefits to Samsung Pay, though, including wider acceptance and the ability to earn points through shopping. With Fitbit Pay, you’ll have a tough time finding a place that accepts it, so it might be best to go with the other watches if that’s important to you.
  • With limited screen space, voice control is essential in a smartwatch. Apple Watch builds in Siri, while Android watches use the Google Assistant. One plus in Apple Watch’s favor is that you can activate Siri through Raise to Speak, as long as you set it up in settings. The Fitbit does not have voice control.
  • Previously, active smartwatch wearers were disappointed that they couldn’t track their activity while swimming. Newer watch models correct that, but you’ll need to keep an eye on their limits. The Gear S3 is designed to be submerged in up to 1.5 meters for only 30 minutes or less. The Fitbit Versa and Apple Watch Series 3 and 4 are limited to up to 50 meters with no time constraint mentioned.
  • No matter which band you choose, you’ll still have to charge it at least every few days. Apple watches use a magnetic charging cable that’s easy to connect. The Gear S3 and Fitbit Versa use a charging dock that you rest your watch on when you’re ready to charge.
  • Sleep tracking can provide valuable information, and the Fitbit Versa excels in this area. The Apple Watch still can’t track this without an additional app, but you can download apps to help with that. The Samsung Gear S3 provides better sleep tracking, but you’ll still only see how long you slept, not how many hours you spent in light, deep and REM sleep.
  • When you’re tracking your heart rate and sleep, you likely don’t want to be without your watch for long. The Apple Watch and Fitbit Versa take up to two hours to charge to 100 percent, while the Samsung Gear S3 is just over that, at 127 minutes.
  • The band is an important part of the look and feel of your watch. The bad news is, each smartwatch comes with a similar-looking plain black band. But the good news is that there’s no shortage of bands available for purchase for each watch type, both from the manufacturer and third-party resellers. Look around at your options before you make a decision.
  • If you plan to stream music from your watch, Apple or Samsung watches will be the best option, since the Fitbit Versa requires you to manually transfer music in a multistep process.
  • Though smartwatches can range widely in price, you’re sure to find a model that fits your specific needs and your budget.