Don't Waste Your Money is supported by our readers. When you purchase an item through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

The Best Tool Box

Last updated on June 23, 2020

We looked at the top 10 Tool Boxes and dug through the reviews from 55 of the most popular review sites including All Listings, Storables, Car Bibles, Twice Partner, Tool Belt Guru, In Stash and more. The result is a ranking of the best Tool Boxes.

Best Tool Box

Why Trust The DWYM Score?

DWYM is focused on helping you make the best purchasing decision. Our team of experts spends hundreds of hours analyzing, testing, and researching products so you don't have to.Learn more.

Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in a category.

Our Picks For The Top Tool Boxes

Show Contents
Our Take
Experts Included
Pros
Cons
  The Best Overall

DEWALT DWST17814 Tstak Long Handle Tool Box

DEWALT

DWST17814 Tstak Long Handle Tool Box

Overall Take

Extra-Large VolumeIf you're more than just a hobbyist, you'll need this tool box, which has an extra-large volume.

Experts Included
DWYM Tools Experts plus BestReviews, Top Great Pro, A Top Daily, The Drive, Sweet Home Spot, Choose the Best Toolbox and 5 more. Along with user reviews from Amazon.
Pros
" Relatively lightweight with great durability. Useful organizer included for small items. Comfortable handle. Stackable design can be combined with other TSTAK units."
Cons
"Plastic is more prone to cuts and holes from sharp tools. The hardware holding the latches can strip over time. A handcart is required to transport three or more stacked tool chests."

Plano 651-010 Tool Box With Tray

Plano

651-010 Tool Box With Tray

Overall Take

Traditional OrganizerTraditional is the best word to describe this smaller-sized tool box, which comes with a lift out tray.

Experts Included
DWYM Tools Experts plus Easy Trip Guides. Along with user reviews from Amazon and Home Depot.
Pros
" This 20-inch toolbox has bulk storage space to store plenty of large tools. Plus, it has a pair of the removable tray to easily access the tools inside the tool chest."

Akro-Mils 09514 ProBox Plastic Removable Tray Tool Box

Akro-Mils

ProBox Plastic Tool Box

Overall Take

Removable TrayThis tool box with removable tray is available in either clear or classic red.

Experts Included
DWYM Tools Experts plus Motor Day, Electronics Hub, In Stash, Choose the Best Toolbox. Along with user reviews from Amazon.
Pros
" The large plastic handle is designed to be comfortable to carry, an important consideration if you plan to keep heavy tools in your box."
Cons
"Could have had a bit more compartments or shelves for the price"
  The Best Value

WORKPRO Wide Mouth & Waterproof Molded Base Tool Box

WORKPRO

Wide Mouth & Waterproof Tool Box

Overall Take

Adjustable Shoulder StrapIf you're searching for a portable tool box made of fabric, this model with its adjustable shoulder strap is an excellent choice.

Experts Included
DWYM Tools Experts plus AskMen, Auto Guide, Car Bibles, Motor Day, HVAC Training 101, Architecture Lab and 5 more. Along with user reviews from Amazon.
Pros
" The tool bag is constructed from polyester fabric, and includes eight inside pockets, 13 exterior pockets and eight belt loops, and a generous interior to hold larger tools."
Cons
"Inside pockets are too shallow and floppy."
Don't just take for granted what one reviewer says. Along with our own experts, DWYM analyzes the top expert reviews of the leading products and generates a score you can actually trust.
17

Products Considered

We identified the majority of the tool boxes available to purchase.
10

Products Analyzed

We then selected the leading and most popular products for our team to review.

View All Product Rankings

55

Expert Reviews Included

In addition to our expert reviews, we also incorporate feedback and analysis of some of the most respected sources including: All Listings, Storables, Car Bibles, Twice Partner, Tool Belt Guru.

19,707

User Opinions Analyzed

We also incorporate user reviews from the leading retailers including Amazon, Home Depot, Walmart and 4 others.

Our experts reviewed the top 10 Tool Boxes and also dug through the reviews from 55 of the most popular review sites including All Listings, Storables, Car Bibles, Twice Partner, Tool Belt Guru, In Stash and more. The result is a ranking of the best of the best Tool Boxes.

DWYM is your trusted roduct review source. Our team reviews thousands of product reviews from the trusted top experts and combines them into one easy-to-understand score. Learn more.

Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in their category.

The Best Overall

DEWALT DWST17814 Tstak Long Handle Tool Box

Our Expert Score
9.6
11 expert reviews
User Summarized Score
9.2
3,928 user reviews
Our Take

This heavy-duty tool box comes with a long handle that is both functional and comfortable to hold. In addition to the main compartment, this tool box has an upper organizer with dividers to keep smaller tools from becoming lost. If you purchase more than one of these tool boxes, you'll find they are designed to stack neatly on top of each other.

What other experts liked
Relatively lightweight with great durability. Useful organizer included for small items. Comfortable handle. Stackable design can be combined with other TSTAK units.
- BestReviews
All factors considered, this toolbox kit is suited for carrying larger kinds of tools. Example of these are the saws, dividers, spanners, drills, bits, and bolts. This is due to its extra-large volume.
- Top Great Pro
The box is made of top quality materials that are highly resistant to cracks and rust to ensure that the lifetime lasts longer.
- A Top Daily
TSAK tool chests are stackable and use metal latches to keep them locked in place. The storage drawers are customizable to fit your needs. The handle is designed for both grip and stability.
- The Drive
This toolbox features heavy duty handles, a handle with extended arm length, a 3.7 gal capacity and removable cups.
- Just Best 10
Removable tray for quick access to tools that you use the most
- Sweet Home Spot
Comes with a deep handle for easy portability
- Choose the Best Toolbox
Many users won’t notice, but the Dewalt DWST1784 TSTAK Toolbox also has built-in side latches that allow other TSTAK modules to be attached to it.
- Do-It-Yourself Blog
Dewalt has many great toolboxes, this one stands out because of its deep storage capacity and the long handle that makes it sturdy and user-friendly. If your tools are big this is a great choice.
- Autozik
Tons of storage space. Enough room for more than 30 of my tools and my Black and Decker drill and charger.
- The Walking Dad Blog
The handle is very long and comfortable to use.
- Easy Trip Guides
What other experts didn't like
Lid hinges have been known to break, though not often. Some distortion under heavy load.
- BestReviews
Plastic is more prone to cuts and holes from sharp tools. The hardware holding the latches can strip over time. A handcart is required to transport three or more stacked tool chests.
- The Drive
A Little Heavy When Fully Loaded
- Sweet Home Spot
Some customers complain that the hinges aren’t very durable
- Choose the Best Toolbox
Plastic material might deform with heavy loads
- Do-It-Yourself Blog
There are no internal dividers and the tools can end up in a heap, when on the move
- Autozik
The top compartment could be bigger. It does not span the entire length of the tool box which eliminates extra space I could have had to store more of my drill bits, etc.
- The Walking Dad Blog
It is made of plastic and seems a bit brittle.
- Easy Trip Guides

The Best Bang For Your Buck

WORKPRO Wide Mouth & Waterproof Molded Base Tool Box

Our Expert Score
10.0
11 expert reviews
User Summarized Score
9.4
1,503 user reviews
Our Take

Constructed from a 600D polyester fabric, this tool box is comfortable to carry. It even comes with an adjustable shoulder strap. Users will appreciate that the bag has a wide mouth, waterproof base, and 21 total pockets for storing a wide range of tools.

What other experts liked
The tool bag is constructed from polyester fabric, and includes eight inside pockets, 13 exterior pockets and eight belt loops, and a generous interior to hold larger tools.
- AskMen
The wide open mouth design on this tool bag is reinforced with an internal metal frame and a top double-pull zipper for easy access.
- Auto Guide
This bag can happily swallow up big tools whilst it also boasts a very tough construction, complete with a rigid and waterproof plastic base.
- Car Bibles
The internal metal frame of this 16″, wide mouth bags means you can instantly locate the right tool for each job.
- Motor Day
Waterproof and fall-resistant to protect your tools.
- HVAC Training 101
It has been engineered with high-quality 500D polyester fabric. The rubber foam bottom keeps the bag sturdy and protects the tools from hard falls.
- Architecture Lab
As for where to put your tools, there are 8-inner pockets, along with 13 external pockets.
- Techno Buffalo
It also has a handy shoulder-strap because WORKPRO understands that sometimes you gotta go hands-free, especially when those hands are on the job.
- BroBible
It has an adjustable strap.
- Electrical Tools World
The bag has a rigid waterproof plastic base.
- Contractors Zone
The zipper system has been installed in such a way that you can easily put items in and out of the tool bag. The double pull zipper makes it a strong one.
- Tool Belt Guru
What other experts didn't like
Inside pockets are too shallow and floppy.
- HVAC Training 101
It is not designed for heavy duty use.
- Electrical Tools World
Some reviewers have complained that the bag is far too small.
- Contractors Zone
It lacks suitable pockets for carrying small items
- Tool Belt Guru

Overall Product Rankings

DEWALT DWST17814 Tstak Long Handle Tool Box

1. DEWALT DWST17814 Tstak Long Handle Tool Box

Overall Score: 9.8
Reviews Included: 13

Plano 651-010 Tool Box With Tray

2. Plano 651-010 Tool Box With Tray

Overall Score: 9.6
Reviews Included: 3

Akro-Mils 09514 ProBox Plastic Removable Tray Tool Box

3. Akro-Mils 09514 ProBox Plastic Removable Tray Tool Box

Overall Score: 9.4
Reviews Included: 5

JEGS 81400 3-Drawer Professional Tool Box

4. JEGS 81400 3-Drawer Professional Tool Box

Overall Score: 9.1
Reviews Included: 10

WORKPRO Wide Mouth & Waterproof Molded Base Tool Box

5. WORKPRO Wide Mouth & Waterproof Molded Base Tool Box

Overall Score: 9.0
Reviews Included: 14

Apollo Tools DT5010P Heavy-Duty Steel Chest Tool Box

6. Apollo Tools DT5010P Heavy-Duty Steel Chest Tool Box

Overall Score: 8.8
Reviews Included: 2

GEARWRENCH 83151 Steel Tool Box

9. GEARWRENCH 83151 Steel Tool Box

Overall Score: 8.4
Reviews Included: 8

Our Tool Box Findings

DEWALT DWST17814 Tstak Long Handle Tool Box

What We Liked: This heavy-duty tool box comes with a long handle that is both functional and comfortable to hold. In addition to the main compartment, this tool box has an upper organizer with dividers to keep smaller tools from becoming lost. If you purchase more than one of these tool boxes, you’ll find they are designed to stack neatly on top of each other.

Plano 651-010 Tool Box With Tray

What We Liked: Although this tool box is on the smaller size, it’s still made from a heavy-duty plastic. The chest has two secure latches and a handle that folds down when not in use. Inside, you’ll find a lift out tray and plenty of space to store your most essential tools.

Akro-Mils 09514 ProBox Plastic Removable Tray Tool Box

What We Liked: While this tool box works well to organize and store your screwdrivers, measuring tape and hammer, it can also be used for a variety of other purposes. The box can store everything from craft supplies to first aid items. The removable tray with handle is a nice touch, as is the inclusion of the oversized padlock eye.

JEGS 81400 3-Drawer Professional Tool Box

What We Liked: You’ll love this tool box’s black powder coat finish and heavy-duty steel construction. It comes with three drawers and an extra storage shelf under the handle. The included handle makes the unit portable, while the lock and key add to the protection of your tools.

WORKPRO Wide Mouth & Waterproof Molded Base Tool Box

What We Liked: Constructed from a 600D polyester fabric, this tool box is comfortable to carry. It even comes with an adjustable shoulder strap. Users will appreciate that the bag has a wide mouth, waterproof base, and 21 total pockets for storing a wide range of tools.

Our Tool Box Buying Guide

No garage is complete without a tool box. This handy device keeps important tools at the ready, should your sink spring a leak or your car need an oil change. While a good set of tools may cost you a little money up front, you’ll save thousands of dollars over the years by not having to pay a professional, as labor costs are often much more than the price of any necessary parts.

Keep in mind the number of tools you need to store as you search the available tool boxes on the market. You’ll find tool boxes come in a variety of sizes with a number of different storage compartments. One model may have three drawers and a shelf underneath the handle, while another comes built with 21 pockets and eight belts.

Look at the construction material next, as you don’t want to invest your money in a tool box that won’t stand the test of time. A 600D polyester fabric that is waterproof and abrasion-resistant is a good choice if you’re looking for a portable bag. 16-gauge steel with a black powder coat finish is more ideal if you want a tool chest that is going to remain in one spot in your garage.

Check to see if the tool box comes with any special safety features. This is especially important if you take your tool box to a job site every day. You may come across a model with a steel latch with an oversized padlock eye, which can be secured using either a zip tie or a padlock, or a model that has a keyed lock with two keys.

Consider any extra features that add value to the tool box. For example, a tool bag with adjustable shoulder straps makes carrying the bag much easier, while a box with an inner tray that has a handle in the center lets you quickly move a few essential tools around without having to lift the entire chest. Some tool boxes can even be used for other purposes, such as storing craft supplies or making a first aid kit.

DWYM Fun Fact

One of the most interesting and well-designed tool boxes of all times was created by H.O. Studley in the 19th century. The case itself was constructed from an attractive mahogany rosewood with ebony and mother-of-pearl accents. It was able to hold an astounding 300 tools in its various hidden compartments and flip-up trays. With a weight of 72 pounds when empty, this tool box certainly wasn’t portable. Still, it is considered a work of art and even spent time on display at the Smithsonian Institute’s National Museum of American History.

The Tool Box Tips and Advice

  • If you opt for a few stackable tool chests, you can transport them all at once if you purchase a handcart separately. Otherwise, you’ll need to carry each tool box one at a time.
  • Pay attention to the weight of the items you load in the tool box, you don’t want to make the box so heavy that you can’t carry it.
  • Consider adding a foam liner to the drawers in your tool box. Start off tracing each tool over the liner where you want it to go. Cut the shapes and out install the liner. Set each tool in its designated place. The tools will now be surrounded by foam, which will not only protect the tools, but also keep them from sliding around the tool box during transport.
  • When organizing your tool box, it’s helpful if you keep similar items grouped together. Then when you need a specific tool, you won’t have to spend unnecessary time hunting for it.
  • Keep your tool box clean. You can wipe it down with grease-fighting dish soap and some hot water, as long as you dry it thoroughly afterward to prevent any rust from forming on the metal parts. If one area is extremely oily, you can use a bit of paint thinner to get it up.
  • Size, design and construction material all play a role in the overall price of a tool box. The Plano 651-010 Tool Box With Tray and the Akro-Mils ProBox Plastic Tool Box are more basic models, and therefore among the most affordable tool boxes. You’ll pay a moderate price for the DEWALT DWST17814 Tstak Long Handle Tool Box with the highest price tag going to the JEGS 81400 3-Drawer Professional Tool Box.

About The Author

Alicia Bodine
Alicia Bodine 

Alicia Bodine is a New Jersey-based writer specializing in finance. With more than 15 years of experience, her work has appeared on leading financial publications. She's also a certified Ramsey Solutions Master Financial Coach.