Don't Waste Your Money is supported by our readers. When you purchase an item through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

The Best Plastic Post Earrings For Sensitive Ears - 2022

Last updated on May 27, 2022

Why Trust The DWYM Score?

DWYM is focused on helping you make the best purchasing decision. Our team of experts spends hundreds of hours analyzing, testing, and researching products so you don't have to.Learn more.

Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in a category.

Our Picks For The Top

Show Contents
Our Take
  Top Pick

Jstyle Assorted Shapes Rhinestone Stud Plastic Post Earrings, 12-Pairs

Don't Waste Your Money Seal of Approval

Jstyle

Assorted Shapes Rhinestone Stud Plastic Post Earrings, 12-Pairs

Overall Take

Great GiftThe included black pouch makes this set perfect for gifting.

  Runner Up

DesignedDazzle Silicone Backs Plastic Post Earrings, 18-Pairs

DesignedDazzle

Silicone Backs Plastic Post Earrings, 18-Pairs

Overall Take

Great for Little EarsInfants, toddlers and older children will love these earrings, which are small with studs that can be trimmed to fit.

  We Also Like

minihope Animals & Foods Shaped Plastic Post Earrings, 30-Pairs

minihope

Animals & Foods Shaped Plastic Post Earrings, 30-Pairs

Overall Take

Fun DesignsThe kid-friendly designs of these earrings feature plenty of fun shapes, from desserts to animals.

  Strong Contender

Pretty Smart Succulent Design Hypoallergenic Plastic Post Earrings

Pretty Smart

Succulent Design Hypoallergenic Plastic Post Earrings

Overall Take

Classy and ElegantA simple but colorful floral design makes this pair of earrings an elegant option for those who can’t wear metals.

Guide written by Stephanie Faris
Last updated on May 27, 2022

Metal allergies aren’t all that rare, with studies showing that about 17 percent of women and 3 percent of men are allergic to nickel. Another 1 to 2 percent are allergic to either cobalt or chromium, with some allergic to both.

The problem is nickel and chromium are in a substantial portion of the jewelry that’s marketed to women and children. With 17 percent of women allergic to nickel, that has opened a big market for jewelers, who offer hypoallergenic options to consumers. Some parents seek out these options for children. Infants and toddlers can be especially sensitive, and parents may prefer an alternative to the metals traditionally found in earrings.

Plastic posts can be a great way to wear the jewelry you want without worrying about the skin becoming irritated or your body being exposed to certain metals. The best thing about plastic posts is that usually, nobody else will even know they aren’t metal. They’ll have earring backs, as metal earrings do, and you can find them in a variety of decorations.

Parents have plenty of options when it comes to plastic post earrings for their children. Some feature small jewels, while others have kid-friendly embellishments to let children express their unique likes. If your child doesn’t yet have pierced ears, speak to the professional who will be doing the piercing to find out how you can use a safe post option for your child’s first pair of earrings.

For some, though, medical-grade earrings are the best option. These earrings are designed specifically for those suffering from metal allergies. You can purchase those online or get a recommendation from your dermatologist or allergy specialist for earrings that address your specific allergy.

The Best

1
  Top Pick

Jstyle Assorted Shapes Rhinestone Stud Plastic Post Earrings, 12-Pairs

You’ll get 12 pairs of earrings in various shapes, including hearts, stars, triangles, squares, round and flowers. Each earring features a plastic post made from quality acrylic that’s both hypoallergenic and durable. The jewels are white rhinestones to provide plenty of sparkle.

Features


Specifications

Brand
Jstyle
Model
2
  Runner Up

DesignedDazzle Silicone Backs Plastic Post Earrings, 18-Pairs

You’ll get a plastic box packed with earrings, each with nylon studs. Each stud features a 1/8-inch diameter crystal and silicone earring backs. You can shorten the nylon posts with scissors, then filed with a nail file to smooth the end.

Features


Specifications

Brand
DesignedDazzle
Model
3
  We Also Like

minihope Animals & Foods Shaped Plastic Post Earrings, 30-Pairs

You’ll get 30 different pairs of earrings in this set, with whimsical designs including foods and animals. The earrings come in an attractive package that makes it ready for gifting. The post is made from hard, food-grade plastic for a hypoallergenic but durable alternative to traditional earring posts.

Features


Specifications

Brand
minihope
Model
4
  Strong Contender

Pretty Smart Succulent Design Hypoallergenic Plastic Post Earrings

Available in a variety of colors, this pair of floral earrings is great to give as a gift or buy for yourself. The design is free from metals and BPA for a safe alternative to traditional metal earrings. The earrings arrive in a gift box with extra rubber backs included.

Features


Specifications

Brand
Pretty Smart
Model
5
  Also Great

AKOAK DIY Jewelry Hook Findings Plastic Post Earrings, 25-Pairs

You’ll get 50 plastic earring hooks in this set, each ready to be attached to a jewel or other decorative item. The hooks are transparent so they won’t show as much as a metal hook. It’s the perfect option for do-it-yourselfers or crafters.

Features


Specifications

Brand
AKOAK
Model

Our Buying Guide

Metal allergies aren’t all that rare, with studies showing that about 17 percent of women and 3 percent of men are allergic to nickel. Another 1 to 2 percent are allergic to either cobalt or chromium, with some allergic to both.

The problem is nickel and chromium are in a substantial portion of the jewelry that’s marketed to women and children. With 17 percent of women allergic to nickel, that has opened a big market for jewelers, who offer hypoallergenic options to consumers. Some parents seek out these options for children. Infants and toddlers can be especially sensitive, and parents may prefer an alternative to the metals traditionally found in earrings.

Plastic posts can be a great way to wear the jewelry you want without worrying about the skin becoming irritated or your body being exposed to certain metals. The best thing about plastic posts is that usually, nobody else will even know they aren’t metal. They’ll have earring backs, as metal earrings do, and you can find them in a variety of decorations.

Parents have plenty of options when it comes to plastic post earrings for their children. Some feature small jewels, while others have kid-friendly embellishments to let children express their unique likes. If your child doesn’t yet have pierced ears, speak to the professional who will be doing the piercing to find out how you can use a safe post option for your child’s first pair of earrings.

For some, though, medical-grade earrings are the best option. These earrings are designed specifically for those suffering from metal allergies. You can purchase those online or get a recommendation from your dermatologist or allergy specialist for earrings that address your specific allergy.

DWYM Fun Fact

Do you have metal allergies? With jewelry, an allergic reaction typically isn’t as extreme as a food allergy. In fact, you might wear metal jewelry most of your life, only to suddenly develop a sensitivity out of the blue.

With nickel allergies, in particular, symptoms usually start 12 to 48 hours after contact with the metal. You may simply notice the patch of skin the jewelry touched is red or irritated. You might find you’re scratching it and still not getting relief. For some people, blisters even appear as a result. These allergic reactions are typically harmless if you stop contact with the metal quickly, but if left unchecked, over time, the area can become infected, leading to bigger problems than simple irritation.

The Tips and Advice

  • If you wear body jewelry, you can find earrings with plastic posts for each need. Make sure you buy one with the right-sized post for your use.
  • Crafters might want to create their own look. You can buy your own parts to build the earrings you want. There are plastic hooks, as well as plastic posts and backs that you can attach to the decorative part of the earring.
  • Not all plastic is hypoallergenic. Look for that in the description if you’re concerned. The first time you wear your new plastic posts, keep an eye on the area around the earring to make sure you aren’t having a reaction. Remove them as soon as possible if you start to suffer irritation.
  • Plastic can tend to be less durable than metal. Make sure you go for a pair of earrings with posts made from top-quality plastic.
  • If you’re buying earrings as gifts, you can find some that are packaged for gifting. Some children’s options have fun, whimsical packaging that will take the gift to the next level.
  • Pay attention to the backs of the earrings you buy. Some are higher quality than others. You’ll likely also want the backs to be plastic.
  • Most plastic earrings are made to be costume jewelry. If you have sensitivities but want genuine diamonds, you might want to look into earrings with medical-grade posts.
  • With some plastic post earrings, the post can be trimmed to fit younger ears. If you have an infant or toddler you’re fitting, pay attention to whether you can customize them in this way.
  • You can find earrings sold in sets that will give you different pairs to wear for different occasions. These can be especially fun for children.
  • Some consumers are concerned about BPA, which can be found in some plastics. If this is a worry for you, look for earrings with posts that are BPA free.

About The Author

Stephanie Faris 

Stephanie Faris is a novelist and professional writer. She's also a wife and stepmom who lives in the Nashville, Tennessee, area. She has a passion for fashion and has been able to used that passion to write content for a variety of sites. She also writes books for young children, including the Piper Morgan series of chapter books published by Simon & Schuster's Aladdin imprint.