Don't Waste Your Money is supported by our readers. When you purchase an item through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

The Best Pickle Candy

Last updated on March 20, 2020

We looked at the top 5 Pickle Candies and dug through the reviews from 4 of the most popular review sites including Elite Daily, Wide Open Eats, The Kitchn, Wichita By E.B. and more. The result is a ranking of the best Pickle Candies.

Why Trust The DWYM Score?

DWYM is focused on helping you make the best purchasing decision. Our team of experts spends hundreds of hours analyzing, testing, and researching products so you don't have to.Learn more.

Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in a category.

Our Picks For The Top Pickle Candies

Show Contents
Our Take
Experts Included
Pros
Cons
  The Best Overall

Archie McPhee Pickle Candy in Tin

Archie McPhee

Pickle Candy in Tin

Overall Take

Subtle Pickle TasteYou'll get a light, subtle pickle taste with the hard candies in the Archie McPhee Pickle Candy in Tin.

Experts Included
DWYM Food Experts plus Wichita By E.B.. Along with user reviews from Amazon.
Pros
" Each hard candy tasted like a pickle flavored candy cane. My niece was really surprised how much it tasted like a pickle. It had a very light pickle flavor to it that wasn’t overpowering. This was some candy we could..."
  The Best Value

Archie McPhee Pickle Candy Canes

Archie McPhee

Pickle Candy Canes

Overall Take

Fun Christmas GiftWith six per box, the Archie McPhee Pickle Candy Canes make a fun replacement for standard candy canes at Christmas.

Experts Included
DWYM Food Experts plus The Kitchn. Along with user reviews from Amazon and Walmart.
Pros
" My initial thought was that they tasted just like the brining seasoning in pickle juice."

Pickle Addicts Pickle Candy Sampler Gift Pack

Pickle Addicts

Pickle Candy Sampler Gift Pack

Overall Take

Candy, Mints and LollipopsThe candy, mints and lollipops included in the Pickle Addicts Pickle Candy Sampler Gift Pack give you a chance to try out a variety.

Experts Included
DWYM Food Experts plus Wide Open Eats. Along with user reviews from Amazon.
Pros
" This is a great gift idea for the pickle lover, even if it's just a gag gift. After all, what could be better than hard candies in pickle flavors? If you love pickles, probably nothing."

Accoutrements Dill Pickle Flavored Mints

Accoutrements

Dill Pickle Flavored Mints

Overall Take

Great On the GoAccoutrements Dill Pickle Flavored Mints come in a fun tin that's handy to take with you.

Experts Included
DWYM Food Experts plus Elite Daily. Along with user reviews from Amazon.
Pros
" If you're constantly craving that dill pickle flavor, you can try the dill-flavored mints from Accoutrements. They are great if you just gotta have that pickle flavor in a handy tin when you're on the go."
Don't just take for granted what one reviewer says. Along with our own experts, DWYM analyzes the top expert reviews of the leading products and generates a score you can actually trust.
12

Products Considered

We identified the majority of the pickle candies available to purchase.
5

Products Analyzed

We then selected the leading and most popular products for our team to review.

View All Product Rankings

4

Expert Reviews Included

In addition to our expert reviews, we also incorporate feedback and analysis of some of the most respected sources including: Elite Daily, Wide Open Eats, The Kitchn and Wichita By E.B..

3,018

User Opinions Analyzed

We also incorporate user reviews from the leading retailers including Amazon, Walmart.

Our experts reviewed the top 5 Pickle Candies and also dug through the reviews from 4 of the most popular review sites including Elite Daily, Wide Open Eats, The Kitchn, Wichita By E.B. and more. The result is a ranking of the best of the best Pickle Candies.

DWYM is your trusted roduct review source. Our team reviews thousands of product reviews from the trusted top experts and combines them into one easy-to-understand score. Learn more.

Look for the DWYM seal for products that are the best in their category.

The Best Overall

Archie McPhee Pickle Candy in Tin

Our Expert Score
0.0
1 expert reviews
User Summarized Score
7.2
146 user reviews
Our Take

Enjoy, a light, subtle pickle taste similar to a hamburger pickle with the Archie McPhee Pickle Candy in Tin. You'll get a pack of two tins, each filled with individually wrapped hard candies.

What other experts liked
Each hard candy tasted like a pickle flavored candy cane. My niece was really surprised how much it tasted like a pickle. It had a very light pickle flavor to it that wasn’t overpowering. This was some candy we could...
- Wichita By E.B.
What other experts didn't like
Our only gripe was the price tag of nearly $8.
- Wichita By E.B.

The Best Bang For Your Buck

Archie McPhee Pickle Candy Canes

Our Expert Score
10.0
1 expert reviews
User Summarized Score
7.2
895 user reviews
Our Take

Candy canes aren't just for the holiday season. The Archie McPhee Pickle Candy Canes provide a sweet, light pickle flavor comparable to the brining seasoning found in pickle juice. You'll get six per box, with options for multiple-pack purchases available. The bright green color make it a great replacement for more traditional mint-flavored candy canes.

What other experts liked
My initial thought was that they tasted just like the brining seasoning in pickle juice.
- The Kitchn
What other experts didn't like
If you really enjoy pickled-flavored things, they might be a little disappointing. Nobody particularly enjoyed them.
- The Kitchn

Overall Product Rankings

Archie McPhee Pickle Candy in Tin

1. Archie McPhee Pickle Candy in Tin

Overall Score: 9.5
Reviews Included: 2

Archie McPhee Pickle Candy Canes

2. Archie McPhee Pickle Candy Canes

Overall Score: 9.1
Reviews Included: 4

Pickle Addicts Pickle Candy Sampler Gift Pack

3. Pickle Addicts Pickle Candy Sampler Gift Pack

Overall Score: 8.9
Reviews Included: 3

Accoutrements Dill Pickle Flavored Mints

4. Accoutrements Dill Pickle Flavored Mints

Overall Score: 6.2
Reviews Included: 2

CHOCOLATE STORYBOOK Pickle Cotton Candy

5. CHOCOLATE STORYBOOK Pickle Cotton Candy

Overall Score: 5.6
Reviews Included: 1

Our Pickle Candy Findings

Archie McPhee Pickle Candy in Tin

Best Overall

What We Liked: Enjoy, a light, subtle pickle taste similar to a hamburger pickle with the Archie McPhee Pickle Candy in Tin. You’ll get a pack of two tins, each filled with individually wrapped hard candies.

Simplemost Media

Archie McPhee Pickle Candy Canes

Best Candy Cane

What We Liked: Candy canes aren’t just for the holiday season. The Archie McPhee Pickle Candy Canes provide a sweet, light pickle flavor comparable to the brining seasoning found in pickle juice. You’ll get six per box, with options for multiple-pack purchases available. The bright green color make it a great replacement for more traditional mint-flavored candy canes.

Simplemost Media

Accoutrements Dill Pickle Flavored Mints

Best Mint

What We Liked: They may not freshen your breath, but Accoutrements Dill Pickle Flavored Mints are a tasty treat you can take everywhere with you. The fun round tin makes it fun to show off or give as a gag gift. You can choose from a pack of 2, 3 or 4, with about 100 mints per tin.

Simplemost Media

CHOCOLATE STORYBOOK Pickle Cotton Candy

What We Liked: One tub of CHOCOLATE STORYBOOK Pickle Cotton Candy has only 140 calories, making it a great guilt-free snack. This is one of many flavors offered by Chocolate Storybook, a company that has specialized in flavored cotton candy since 1986. You’ll get 1.2 ounces of hand-spun cotton candy that tastes more like pickles than many competing products.

Simplemost Media

Our Pickle Candy Buying Guide

Pickles may not be for everyone, but like bacon, those who love them are passionate. So passionate, in fact, that manufacturers have found a market for pickle-flavored products like mints, hard candy, lollipops, candy canes and cotton candy. Many were initially introduced to pickle-flavored candy through candy canes, in fact, as the festive green-and-white colors make them a great holiday gift.

Simplemost Media

But even if you aren’t a pickle enthusiast, someone on your gift list probably is. That makes pickle-flavored candy a great gag gift or stocking stuffer. Some candies taste more like pickles than others, though, with many reinventing the concept by providing a sweetened version of pickles.

Simplemost Media

Obviously, the candy won’t freshen your breath. Quite the opposite. That can be deceptive, especially if you’re buying one of the mint options. They even come in mint tins, similar to what you get with Altoids. The tin concept lets you easily carry it in your purse, bag or pocket, or give it as a gift if you choose.

Simplemost Media

If you haven’t tried pickle candy before, you may want to start out slowly, purchasing a smaller quantity to see if you like it. You may prefer your pickle flavor in cotton candy or candy canes instead of hard candies, for instance. Some find certain versions much more palatable than others.

DWYM Fun Fact

If you like pickles, you’re in good company. The food is mentioned in the Bible, and Cleopatra is said to have eaten them to stay beautiful. In fact, throughout history, many people have believed pickles are the key to good health, helping maintain the body’s natural balance. Queen Elizabeth I, Thomas Jefferson, Fran Drescher and Ed Koch also reportedly love pickles. Some people take a unique twist on the snack, including Elvis Presley, who had a fondness for fried pickles. He wasn’t the only one who liked to shake things up. In parts of Mississippi, people soak pickles in Kool-Aid to give them a unique flavor.

If you can’t decide whether pickles, made from cucumbers, are a fruit or vegetable, you aren’t alone. In fact, it took a Supreme Court ruling to decide that they are a fruit.

The Pickle Candy Tips and Advice

  • When it comes to pickle flavoring, less can be more. It can help to go into it with the expectation that you’ll be enjoying a subtle pickle flavor rather than expecting the experience to be similar to removing a pickle straight from a jar.
  • Once you’ve found an option you like, consider buying in multipacks to save money.
  • Pay close attention to quantities before you order. You’ll find candy canes come in small quantities but multiple packs, for instance.
  • If you’re looking for kosher or gluten-free options, you’ll need to look for a candy designed for special diets.
  • Although pickle-flavored candy can last a while, if you aren’t going to be eating it soon, store it in a cool, dry place away from light to keep it fresh as long as possible.
  • In addition to gag gifts and stocking stuffers, pickle-flavored candy can make great party favors. This is especially true of pickle-flavored cotton candy.
  • Companies that manufacturer pickle-flavored items often have other flavors available, so look around to see what other unique tastes you can try.
  • Some pickle-flavored candies come in a tin that makes them portable. Still others are individually wrapped. That gives you the option to ensure you always have some of your favorite treats on hand, whether you’re at the office or traveling.

About The Author

Avatar
Stephanie Faris 

Stephanie Faris is a novelist and business writer whose work has appeared on numerous blogs. She worked for the State of Tennessee for 19 years, the latter six of which were spent as a supervisor. She has written content for entrepreneurs and marketing firms since 2011. In addition to her online content, she is also the author of eight novels for Simon & Schuster, including the Piper Morgan chapter book series.